Ati Maharathi Danver Karna update 1st post/ DT nt pg 14

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Sabhayata

@Sabhayata

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#21

Paanchali

Karan's story is no doubt tragic but Karan also did adharam on several occassions like when he insulted druapadi and when he killed abhimanyu.Both of these were unfair.if he didnt do either of these things Arjun wouldnt have killed him unfairly

Quote

sravanthi vangala

@sravss

Voyager

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#22

Like most of them here even I have a soft feeling towards Karn, feel bad for him and even cry for him.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

TheWatcher

@TheWatcher

Voyager

Posted: 12 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: Sabhayata
Paanchali
Karan's story is no doubt tragic but Karan also did adharam on several occassions like when he insulted druapadi and when he killed abhimanyu.Both of these were unfair.if he didnt do either of these things Arjun wouldnt have killed him unfairly

Ya he did adharma at those two points ,dont forget the fact that draupadi always insulted karna its not like karna hated draupadi from the beginning draupadi was the first one to humiliate karna in her swyamvar i am not saying that KARNA did the right thing by calling draupadi a wh**e it was not acceptable, but i hate the fact that everyone blames only karna for that, draupadi invoked the revenge fire in him, and about the abhimanyu killing when abhimanyu was killed drona was the commander when karna became the commander he said when i wasn't the commander i simply had to follow orders but when i am the commander everyone will follow the war rules.

Dont get me wrong that karna was right every time he DID two mistakes that's why he paid with his life.

Quote

mysterieux

@mysterieux

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#24

The actor has done a wonderful job!!! I do also like the character because he was daan veer- he would give from his right hand and from his left- and illfated hero and thats why he is remebered even today for the good.

Like all characters in Mahabhart Karan was flawed - he made mistakes and he paid the price - he was brave maybe better than Arjun thats arguable - I think they both and even Eklavya were really good --

Karan and Arjun were sons of Gods Eklavya was not. Karan had a protective shield and earinga Arjun and Eklavya did not.if they competed together any one of them could have won because they would have to play fair and on equal footing.

Karan is the most sympathized character in Mahabhart because he mother abandoned him...she did her reasons which were valid, her fear was valid but he suffered the consequences so when his mother asked him to choose his brother over his friend he did not and he suffered the consequences... he stood by his friend that shows him to be a great friend but he watched his friend do wrong and still stood by him and he suffered consequences. He was daan veer so when his mother asked him to give up his advantage he did because he knew that then he and Arjun would be on equal footing and he could beat Arjun with his archery prowess and prove he was superior and he gave up his advantage and he suffered the consequences and that day when he lost ...everything worked against him..poor guy.

That is the essence of Mahabharat that life is all about choices and its consequences.

Karavas had a choice they choose wrong and went to war and lost it all. Panndavas played fair for the most part but they also made wrong choices for which they to suffered the consequences - Arjun lost his son in the war...he sufffered for having killed his grandsire whom he loved very dearly...even Shri Krishna suffered the curse ...they all paid the price...thats just life...you make choices and live with the consequences.

Sorry for the looong post...got carried away😳

Edited by mysterieux - 12 years ago

Quote

582445

Hibernated

Posted: 12 years ago

#25

nice post .. I believe Karna with his all qualities the greatest character in Mahabharat .. he was definitely the best archer of Mahabharat .. without help of fortune and any God he made it to the top .. but he is best not only because he was greatest archer or he was daanveer he is the bravest coz he fought with misfortune throughout whole life and no matters how his ill fate tried to defeat him he defeated it with his greatness .. it is not he cudn't be lucky .. Kunti herself offered him the crown .. asked him to join pandava's side and as the oldest she assured only he will get the crown but Karna didn't get allured .. he chose his friend over crown, his "dharama" over power .. what can be better lesson than the lesson of friendship and loyalty ..

yes he was flawed in just one place of mahabharat that too in a way what seems like it was a forced stain on his character .. I have my personal theory on it anyway I won't bring that here

For me KAARNA is the true hero, ultimate winner, one Mrityunjai who even after his death remain mrityunjai .. one who was so much strong with "Dharma" that even God had to take path of "Adharma" [killing a nirashtra is Adharma as per our religion] to take him down ..

he is the ultimate winner who won our respect love sympathy n tears .. I proudly say yes I believe HE is the greatest in Mahabharat .. and best ever fictional characterization of worldwide literature

Edited by SayaneeH.Lecter - 12 years ago

Quote

Savi_S

@Savi_S

Voyager

Posted: 12 years ago

#26

same here dear...
karn always make me emotional...
thats fate which got him in place where he bacame enemy of his own brothers...

Quote

582445

Hibernated

Posted: 12 years ago

#27

Originally posted by: TheWatcher

Ya he did adharma at those two points ,dont forget the fact that draupadi always insulted karna its not like karna hated draupadi from the beginning draupadi was the first one to humiliate karna in her swyamvar i am not saying that KARNA did the right thing by calling draupadi a wh**e it was not acceptable, but i hate the fact that everyone blames only karna for that, draupadi invoked the revenge fire in him, and about the abhimanyu killing when abhimanyu was killed drona was the commander when karna became the commander he said when i wasn't the commander i simply had to follow orders but when i am the commander everyone will follow the war rules.

Dont get me wrong that karna was right every time he DID two mistakes that's why he paid with his life.

Karna's behavior in that very incidents is not really karna alike .. I think it was somehow forced .. anyway about that "wh**e" comment .. as per HINDUISM it was said then that one woman can have physical relationship with 4 men .. one who does more is a wh**e .. so technically Karna was not wrong ..

@Sabhayata if you think karna committed sin by telling those words to Paanchali then what about Yudhisthir .. a man who can bet and sell his wife in gambling isn't it a bigger sin?? how will you justify it?? if a woman has 5 husbands and still she is disgraced wide open who is at fault?? isn't it Pandavas .. don't forget at that moment to Karna n kauravas panchali was der slave but to Pandavas it was about their wife .. if Arjun did protest against his brother's decision I wud have appreciated .. Arjun did nothing there .. and you call him he did justice killing karna ?? think with logic dear ..

Edited by SayaneeH.Lecter - 12 years ago

Quote

maya_sm

@maya_sm

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

#28

can someone tell me plz what is real name of child actor karan in mahabharat? i have seen him in Latest Rin Yellow Fighters ad with Ritvik Sahore.

Edited by mmurdeshwar - 12 years ago

Quote

Sabhayata

@Sabhayata

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#29

The watcher and sayaneeh

Dont get me wrong.Of course what happened to panchali pandvas,ARjun and panchali herself is to be blamed for it no doubt but that doesnt make Karan's sin any lesser.Two wrongs dont make a right.What panchali did to karan was wrong but what karan did to panchali was also wrong and so was killing abhimnayu commander or no commander he killed abhimanyu by using unfair means

Yes karan's life is no doubt tragic but his death he isnt tragic he killed a young boy by using unfair menas hence he died unfairly.Arjun wasnt perfect either,he also made many mistakes in his life but killing Karan using unfair means wasnt one of them.That is my POV

Edited by Sabhayata - 12 years ago

Quote

--Royal--

@--Royal--

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#30

Originally posted by: Sabhayata
The watcher and sayaneeh
Dont get me wrong.Of course what happened to panchali pandvas,ARjun and panchali herself is to be blamed for it no doubt but that doesnt make Karan's sin any lesser.Two wrongs dont make a right.What panchali did to karan was wrong but what karan did to panchali was also wrong and so was killing abhimnayu commander or no commander he killed abhimanyu by using unfair means

Yes karan's life is no doubt tragic but his death he isnt tragic he killed a young boyby using unfair menas hence he died unfairly.Arjun wasnt perfect either,healso made many mistakes in his lifebut killing Karan using unfair means wasnt one of them.That is my POV

Agree 👍🏼

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 ... 15

Ati Maharathi Danver Karna update 1st post/ DT nt pg 14 - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics