Phalguni Bhabhi ki JAI HO!!!!!! *edited* - Page 9

I think Dialogue are nt Clearly Written...
Saaf saaf likhna chahiye tha clear too cut...

Audience Aise chize jada dyaan se dekhti hai

She was too boring..dont like her lecture

Originally posted by: Valar.Morghulis

<font color="#CC0033"><font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">
Sana ... as I said.. it may have happened that this 'revenge' was no longer in her to-do list... as that list has been occupied with dozens of house chores and regressive traditions that she has to follow as a widow..

Maybe she was living in the present... maybe she was being a little selfish.. a little human... she was into that marriage for a couple of months.. but she has lived as a widow for 13 years... her loyalties may have shifted a little.. more to herself than to her deceased husband... she may have made peace with husband's death... see I am not defending her.. this is her first scene that I saw properly where she got to talk... I do not know about her character.. so I cannot judge her...

It may bring her some peace ... but it cannot bring her happiness, Sana. Big difference there. Hence, no reason to celebrate.

I think I am sounding like a broken recorder...forget it. 😆

She is not worth it. Itna toh main ne JM aur Raja ko bhi explain nahin kia.. 😆 Woh chhoro.. shayad RK ko bhi I didn't explain this much.😆

P.S. I am not talking about Raja in this post.. nor am I pointing fingers at him.
</font></font>

ok fir falguni bhabi ko goli maro...oops goli maro see the effect of Raja on me 😳 🤣

Originally posted by: -Evil-Defiance-

And darling I clearly pointed it out that this is NOT how a village works 😆...seriously now ur idea of how a village is run is making me smile😆

She did speak about killing right...revenge, killing...ek hi baar hai for this particular village...I will be more specific next time for so that u can grasp it 😛😆...we dont know...capital punishment ya life imprisonment ...kuch bhi ho sakhta hai (😛) ...and yes she is only thinking from her widowed and tortured POV so she cannot feel glad that Raja will be relieved to have this measure of sartisfaction ( or so he thinks now 😛)...and Raja is thinking from his violence-prone POV so he cannot see that he has bothered to only complete his own promise and not actually get proper justice and compensation for the torture Faguni has suffered for yrs.

Kyun bhai...every action has an equal and opposite reaction...Faguni ka reaction discuss karna hai toh invariable Raja ki action will come into discussion😛...Its my POV and I found her reference to someone becoming another widow as a clear reference to this kill- and -widow cycle ...aapki na ho...meri hai...main toh bolungi 😛

When did Faguni mention JM ? Am I missing something.😕 When did I mention JM in our chat ? 😕

See the point here is about Faguni not being happy with the punishment...toh pehle we must ask why is a crime punished ? I believe it is to either make the criminal repent and turn over a new leaf or when the crime is excessive ...to make an example for society that such crimes are always end in bad endings.

Here the punishment Raja has given the man has neither made him repent and nor has it served as an example to warn others...it has only continued the past bloodbath. Ab Raja ne ki hai, kal koi aur karega...and acc to Faguni, in their women oppressed village, only women will suffer from their men's actions. Toh bas, she is not happy and ready to celebrate such a type of punishment. Unki marzi 😆


EDT - Bohot raat ho gayi...if u reply and I am not awake..dont take any offense..I will reply tomorrow...nice to have a healthy debate...warna most of the time forum is at war these days 😆

agree with u Ankita. Before criticing Phalguni we should first understand where she is coming from. At the cost of repeating myself I am saying we are all a product of our environments.

Phalguni obviously married and widowed at a very young age. How much time do u think she spent with her husband? Plus it must have been an arranged match.

13 long years have passed since her husband's death. What would be fore front in her mind- justice for a husband she knew for a short time or her 13 long years of pain - pain which has no chances if ever being reduced?

We say that she is not in favour if justice - my question is what justice? When has the world ever been just to her. Today also raja ia all concerned about justice for a dead brother but is unfeeling toward's the same brothet's living wife?

In such a scenario how is she wrong if she wants to save another woman from the same hell?

Originally posted by: _Mojo.Jojo_

According to Phalguni bhabhi, all the criminals and murderers should be set free. No one should ever be punished.👏👏

REASON - Their wives will become widows😭

Then I guess all the rapists and murderers should have wives so that they never get punished👏👍🏼

There should be no phaansi ki saza also. After they kill someone or commit a major crime like rape, they should be sunaoed a bhashan and let them go👍🏼

I am with you Phalguni Bhabhi👍🏼

Edited!

Why do we in our country ask the court to hang the rapists till death? The victim won't ever get her izzat back na. Then why? We should let them roam freely too afterall they have a family and ofcourse like our politician ji recently said, "Ladke hain, galti ho jaati hai"🤢

Originally posted by: -Evil-Defiance-

And darling I clearly pointed it out that this is NOT how a village works 😆...seriously now ur idea of how a village is run is making me smile😆

She did speak about killing right...revenge, killing...ek hi baar hai for this particular village...I will be more specific next time for so that u can grasp it 😛😆...we dont know...capital punishment ya life imprisonment ...kuch bhi ho sakhta hai (😛) ...and yes she is only thinking from her widowed and tortured POV so she cannot feel glad that Raja will be relieved to have this measure of sartisfaction ( or so he thinks now 😛)...and Raja is thinking from his violence-prone POV so he cannot see that he has bothered to only complete his own promise and not actually get proper justice and compensation for the torture Faguni has suffered for yrs.

Kyun bhai...every action has an equal and opposite reaction...Faguni ka reaction discuss karna hai toh invariable Raja ki action will come into discussion😛...Its my POV and I found her reference to someone becoming another widow as a clear reference to this kill- and -widow cycle ...aapki na ho...meri hai...main toh bolungi 😛

When did Faguni mention JM ? Am I missing something.😕 When did I mention JM in our chat ? 😕

See the point here is about Faguni not being happy with the punishment...toh pehle we must ask why is a crime punished ? I believe it is to either make the criminal repent and turn over a new leaf or when the crime is excessive ...to make an example for society that such crimes are always end in bad endings.

Here the punishment Raja has given the man has neither made him repent and nor has it served as an example to warn others...it has only continued the past bloodbath. Ab Raja ne ki hai, kal koi aur karega...and acc to Faguni, in their women oppressed village, only women will suffer from their men's actions. Toh bas, she is not happy and ready to celebrate such a type of punishment. Unki marzi 😆


EDT - Bohot raat ho gayi...if u reply and I am not awake..dont take any offense..I will reply tomorrow...nice to have a healthy debate...warna most of the time forum is at war these days 😆

ok.. just sharing my POV..

Originally posted by: zoya_naziya

ok.. just sharing my POV..

The Cvs, neither did they endorse violence through Raja nor were they preaching through JM n Falguni Bhabhi..

All that they did was give credibility to both sides of the argument..

Falguni Bhabhi considers it a futile exercise as nothing is ever going to change for her.. She will still be treated like dirt..

Raja sees that 3 non-violent, peace loving people in a village where violence and an eye for an eye, is the order of the day, were mercilessly killed , hence he doesn't see what is wrong in it cuz it is about survival of the fittest n he thinks if being a jaanwar would ensure that, he'd rather stay a jaanwar..

JM says the only way out is to move out to a peace-loving area..which is true, cuz the mindset of an entire village cannot be changed. This has been going on for generations.

Honestly if you ask me, nobody is entirely right and nobody is entirely wrong... cuz there are lot of regions in the world which are affected by terrorism, violence, and various other hard-hitting issues... Citizens of those countries do not leave their land just cuz the condition of their environment is bad.. they adapt to their environment and live, and people who have the resources and feel stifled move out of the place and make a living elsewhere... It is all about individual perception...

And since it is fiction, I see there is believable conflict between all the characters.. And I can justify every characters actions(raja,jm, falguni, bhanu,agni) as of now keeping their POV in mind.. so am a happy viewer.

phalguni bhabhi ki jai ho🤣 lekin is as ko khulla mat chodo😭😆 isne dekho mb ka kya haal kar dia hai but i am liking raja aka vd😎 raja is a smoth criminal😆

Originally posted by: EvIlNeSs_RoCkZ

u r talking as if u r the only expert in knowing villages and everyone else is a fool...we already saw in the first epi of village how that woman came crying to Tauji that her hubby beats her and he decided on it...its clear that family is powerful n they decide the punishment...n Raja too clearly told Madhu that in this village they r the Government and village runs on them...so don't consider u r know it all, we r talking abt this show n not what u think abt villages 😛

ofc there is a diff b/w killing n revenge (pls consult dictionary if both words look same to u 😊)

life imprisonment CUD b but what if it was capital punishment?? 3 innocent ppl k murders k baad capital punishment to banta hai 😆...or if was encountered by police? for a sec forget Raja killed him...then what?..even that wont change Phalguni bhabhi's condition so criminals shud stop being punished bcoz it doesn't change the condition of the victim?? 🤔

if u wanna divert the main topic n only discuss Raja go ahead...don't have to tell me abt it...as I already said Raja did wrong

and where did JM come from in b/w? I didn't even take her name...there is nothing to dicuss abt JM coz we can only discuss abt those char which r consistent...jab thappad padna ho to humanity dikhati hai, snake n kamar bandh scene mein romanchak I mean romantic ho jaati hai aur baki time disgusting looks 😆...Raja's char is violent from the start and its consistent, doesnt change everyday

regarding setting an example to others then Raja killed that guy this news will b spread in whole village...so obviously it serves the purpose of warning others...doesn't it?...women r suppressed there but Raja never made any promise that he will make improvements there

PS: don't come up with long irrelevant essays again...I m very lazy to read ...kuch point ho to u can say it in 2 lines also ...writing essays doesn't make u right 😆

I never even raised the point of villages before...woh toh aap aa gayi with ur "jiski lathi uski bhais" comparison for how uneducated villages run...I simply pointed it out that no lathis or bhais saves them from the law ever ...so now ur switching to this particular village when ur point does not stand valid in reality ? Chalo lets talk about this "fictitious village"...

Ab aap toh sab kuch personally lene mein maahir hai...If u cannot digest u r wrong about a point ...concede karna seekh lijiye...humein aapke know-it-all etc etc whatever jaap se koi farak nahin parta hai.... Kiske kya ideas hai woh toh already proove ho gaye hai . 😆

U said na something about Raja's wife in ur post...so I thought JM kahin mention ki hogi Faguni ne...chhodo...moot point.

The funny thing is here u r trying to determine Faguni's decision and her reasoning without even seeing the entire event from her POV...waah kya logic hai...

Maine toh pehle hi bol diya...uski marzi hai...she found it within herself to make peace with the death of Veer but not of the torture every widow faces in her village...uski POV yehi hai...agar u cannot see the event from her POV before judging her decision, then it makes no sense to discuss a topic based on Faguni . It becomes a redundant discussion with no aim.

As u finally said something right ...no matter what punishment the killer gets Faguni ko koi khushi nahin hogi until her pain is resolved...uski marzi , her pain is more priority to her...

This is too funny...u r debating with me about Faguni;s decision when u clearly refuse to see from Faguni's POV in the first place...I am forced to smile again. 😆 Partiality zindabaad ! 😆

No Raja's actions didnt serve any purpose...village mein all just came to fear Kushwas even more...but in the rest of other village families where there are no Rajas ...this same revenge killing and widow making will go on if they have enemity with someone. 😆 So how did this punishment solve anything? 😆

PS- I do not need ur advice about how long a reply to write...nahin parna to mat paro...ur loss ...because it will only prove ur here to argue and not to have a healthy discussion. 😆