Phalguni Bhabhi ki JAI HO!!!!!! *edited* - Page 7

This post wasnt to judge whether Raja is right or wrong then why is it made an issue here ?? Yes Raja is wrong killing isnt a solution...this topic is abt phalguni bhabhi's lecture over a criminals wife and how the criminal acc to her should not be punished as he has a family and wife😕 lets debate abt it 😆

Originally posted by: EvIlNeSs_RoCkZ

did u really read my post or copy-pasted ur essays? 😕...I seriously doubt it

@red - when did I say its justified and he is right?

3 paras u dedicated only to show Raja was wrong when I CLEARLY said we r not debating on whether Raja was right or wrong

read the post TITLE...its abt Phalguni bhabhi..I never denied she is suffering and she doesn't wanna party fine...I commented on the words she used...had instead of Raja the court had given the culprit hang till death punishment, then too she wud have said the same - what abt family of the victim? 😕

@Neelm - u can keep bowing but we all know abt panchayat n stuff...and taking law in hands in wrong...that was not the purpose of this post to discuss

Kyun bhai...aaphi ne kaha in such villages "jiski laathi uski bhais" ... if u donot want people to think ur defending how the village is run...please be more specific next time

Again...I clearly said...Faguni has had enough of death begets death cycle...did u or did u not understand the part where i outlined how this revenge and rage cycle continues with a clear one para example of Raja's family ?

Clearly Faguni Bhabhi pointed out that now because of Raja , another woman will be a widow...uski marzi hai bhai...she has found it within herself to make peace with her husband's death but she hasnt found it within herself to forgive the people who will keep torturing wodows for their entire life unjustly...and she never said she didnt want the victim punished...she simply pointed it out that the type of punishment Raja has meted out serves no purpose other than continuing this revenge and widow cycle again.
Clearly Faguni is being selfish here for herself...but now dont tell u begrudge her for being a mere human? 😆

And when we speak of Faguni's speech , Raja's actions resulted in tht speech so we do have a need todiscuss them too 😛😆

Originally posted by: -SanaLuvAbhay-

This post wasnt to judge whether Raja is right or wrong then why is it made an issue here ?? Yes Raja is wrong killing isnt a solution...this topic is abt phalguni bhabhi's lecture over a criminals wife and how the criminal acc to her should not be punished as he has a family and wife😕 lets debate abt it 😆

Chalo if Raja would have taken the criminal to court then there too he would have been sentenced to death only and phalguni ji should atleast feel content that her husbands murderer has been punished and her husband must be at peace wherever he is...but nahi as per her reaction she would have said plz leave the murderer as his wife will be widowed then??

I guess this is what chakku wanted to say but sab topic kaha se kaha le gae 😆

Originally posted by: _Mojo.Jojo_

Why do we in our country ask the court to hang the rapists till death? The victim won't ever get her izzat back na. Then why? We should let them roam freely too afterall they have a family and ofcourse like our politician ji recently said, "Ladke hain, galti ho jaati hai"🤢

Originally posted by: -Evil-Defiance-

Kyun bhai...aaphi ne kaha in such villages "jiski laathi uski bhais" ... if u donot want people to think ur defending how the village is run...please be more specific next time

Again...I clearly said...Faguni has had enough of death begets death cycle...did u or did u not understand the part where i outlined how this revenge and rage cycle continues with a clear one para example of Raja's family ?

Clearly Faguni Bhabhi pointed out that now because of Raja , another woman will be a widow...uski marzi hai bhai...she has found it within herself to make peace with her husband's death but she hasnt found it within herself to forgive the people who will keep torturing wodows for their entire life unjustly...and she never said she didnt want the victim punished...she simply pointed it out that the type of punishment Raja has meted out serves no purpose other than continuing this revenge and widow cycle again.
Clearly Faguni is being selfish here for herself...but now dont tell u begrudge her for being a mere human? 😆

And when we speak of Faguni's speech , Raja's actions resulted in tht speech so we do have a need todiscuss them too 😛😆

Originally posted by: EvIlNeSs_RoCkZ

@red - saying smthing n justifying smthing r 2 different things...I SAID that this is how villages work...it doesn't mean I m justifying it and saying it is the right way 🤔...is it???

and again u r talking abt Raja's way of revenge...I never said he was right in killing

@blue - she never talked abt revenge cycle (u did 😛), she only talked abt widow cycle...and like I said even if it was a court case the capital punishment wud have been there n his wife wud becum widow, so that cant b an excuse for any crime...yes she is only thinking abt her sufferings that she wont get anything with it...but Raja is not thinking like her na...for him its his promise is completed so he is happy

@Pink - Raja's action did result in that lecture but u shud discuss what Phalguni bhabhi actually said 😛...and not what u think abt the things she never said or meant like law , revenge cycle n all 😆...she never said Raja did wrong by taking law in his hands but was worried for his wife 😆

And darling I clearly pointed it out that this is NOT how a village works 😆...seriously now ur idea of how a village is run is making me smile😆

She did speak about killing right...revenge, killing...ek hi baar hai for this particular village...I will be more specific next time for so that u can grasp it 😛😆...we dont know...capital punishment ya life imprisonment ...kuch bhi ho sakhta hai (😛) ...and yes she is only thinking from her widowed and tortured POV so she cannot feel glad that Raja will be relieved to have this measure of sartisfaction ( or so he thinks now 😛)...and Raja is thinking from his violence-prone POV so he cannot see that he has bothered to only complete his own promise and not actually get proper justice and compensation for the torture Faguni has suffered for yrs.

Kyun bhai...every action has an equal and opposite reaction...Faguni ka reaction discuss karna hai toh invariable Raja ki action will come into discussion😛...Its my POV and I found her reference to someone becoming another widow as a clear reference to this kill- and -widow cycle ...aapki na ho...meri hai...main toh bolungi 😛

When did Faguni mention JM ? Am I missing something.😕 When did I mention JM in our chat ? 😕

See the point here is about Faguni not being happy with the punishment...toh pehle we must ask why is a crime punished ? I believe it is to either make the criminal repent and turn over a new leaf or when the crime is excessive ...to make an example for society that such crimes are always end in bad endings.

Here the punishment Raja has given the man has neither made him repent and nor has it served as an example to warn others...it has only continued the past bloodbath. Ab Raja ne ki hai, kal koi aur karega...and acc to Faguni, in their women oppressed village, only women will suffer from their men's actions. Toh bas, she is not happy and ready to celebrate such a type of punishment. Unki marzi 😆


EDT - Bohot raat ho gayi...if u reply and I am not awake..dont take any offense..I will reply tomorrow...nice to have a healthy debate...warna most of the time forum is at war these days 😆

Originally posted by: Valar.Morghulis

<font color="#CC0033"><font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Chakku I agree to this that her dialogues could have been better.. but I won't criticize her much.. she did not say that criminals should not be punished. She said there was nothing to celebrate about a death.

She
mentioned the widow because that man's widow is the only person she can
relate to! She only meant that when death... under whatever circumstances
happen.. it doesn't bring happiness and should not be celebrated.. it
always come with a cost. 13 years ago she paid the price.. and now someone else will else pay the price for this death.

When people die in vendetta... it is not just the people who actually die get affected... many lives get destroyed in crossfire. She just said that. She just meant they shouldn't party or celebrate because a man is killed... it is wrong. It is not human.


She further has no reason to celebrate as it is not like anything will change for her... she had
made peace with her husband's death long time back.. it was the
injustice done to her that plagued her existence now! It is never going
to stop.. they will keep calling her jinx and keep treating her that
way.</font></font>

maria but atleast she should have been a bit happy for her dead husbands murderer getting punished but nahi she was worried abt that murderers wife 😆 (i am not saying Raja is right he is completely wrong) but its abt her reaction she would have reacted same if court would have sentenced death to d murderer or she should be atleast happy dat her husbands murderer got punished ya there too she would have asked d judge to not kill him for the sake of his wife?? This is the whole point !!