Deconstructing Rishbala and Sulbala: Who is better - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

72

Views

7.8k

Users

36

Likes

480

Frequent Posters

apolloartemis thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: cardio21

You have me floored! Such. Beautiful way to express urself without offending anyone!👏


I always wanted to make a post about her future with Sultan but didnt want to offend anyone!!
And about RK n Madhu, I think the same.. I know she can hold her ground in front of him, and she is capable of having him wrapped around her little finger(in her own unique way), its worth a try.. She always wins all the little games they have played so far.. 😉

On a funnier note, I think she pushes and hits RK as well.. It's just that she is physically weaker, it doesn't count.. 😆


Thanks! I wanted to write in a way that showed my opinion without fandom coming up in arms. Glad I managed that well😳
These things are something we need to discuss because if not Madhu, then her family will be thinking about it as well! It's all fine and well to think of Sulbala riding off into the sunset, but really? Like I said, the only way to get out of the gang world is either through witness protection, or through a body bag. There was a reason Sultan was training Aryan the way he was.
RK/Madhu are on more equal footing- and there are alike in their craziness. I think, RK understands Madhu in a way Sultan will never be able to.
fairy_stardust thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#22
Very honest and critical analysis! The Sultan and Madhu pairing may look good but given his gangster affiliation it's a dangerous path for them and Aryan. I am not saying RK and Madhu pairing will be any easy...in fact I was surprised that Madhu was "going to" put colors on him after all that happened. This just show that even if she said to Trish in earlier episodes that she will never go back to him, she always will love RK and have a soft spot. Ah, I just hope that Madhu gets the man who respects, trusts and loves her unconditionally.

So let the best man win! keke
apolloartemis thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: ABBY_JERAN

for whom we all r crazy about...dont wanna see him cry like devdas or repent like a bheegi billi...and as they say TIME HEALS everything...they shud shw the rishbala romance after a yr when the revenge injuries bcum vague. ...now cvs shud join rishbala in sum othr way and give Sulbala a chance...given what a HUGE no of fans it has garnered in a month which WONT CHANGE even if RK bcums a Angel...SULBALA fans WILl Always SHIP SULBALA...n we all r fiine with happy ending with rishbala after 2 yrs


Thank you for answering! I suppose my post was more for those fans who have indicated that they adore Sulbala only as an alternative to Risbala- won't name names, or anything😊
To be honest, I don't know if TRP audiences will wait for a year😆 in order to see Rishbala reunited in any way shape or form- this isn't one of Ekta's shows, I don't think the audience has the patience😆
The majority of the complaints I have seen about Rishbala seem to be that Madhu is going back despite the fact that RK has not repented and continues to hurt her- so maybe sentiment will change as he does? Just my opinion though!
Thanks for commenting!
applenpeaches thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#24

AA, Interesting post... 👍🏼 From one Madhu fan to another 👏..

I wish I could offer an intelligent comment on this issue. Cant, since I have watched only two episodes since Sultan's entry. The written updates keeps me updated. So far I havent been tempted to watch any episodes.

About Rishabala, you know how much I was into them. My liking for them had much to do with how they complimented each other in their own crazy ways. I wish the CVs hadnt gone ahead with the humiliation drama. The woman in me refuses to overlook that. So I dont get any pleasure in watching them together now. True, RK hasnt physically abused Madhu, but arent the scars from emotional abuse deeper and likely to pain for longer? Good for Madhu that she has fought back.

Here is to hoping she spends some time in evolving and not go looking for another man or child to take under her wing. *toast*


bria thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#25
I know RK did a lot of mistakes...evn tody radhaji told that his ahankr is his biggiest flaw...Coming to Madhu she is also not perfect..."IS SHE THE SAME GIRL WHO DRAG RK TO JAIL COZ HE ACCIDENTALLY HIT MAKKHI"😡...


She is giving sheltr to a ganster...GOD know how many ppl he killed...and pata nei kitne aryaan jaise massom baccho ki parents ko mar diya...so Madhu also has got flaws in her...

coming back to RISHABALA they a the soul of the show...their luv is different...a new kind of luvstry...and i luv them...and i really hope CVs dissapoint us...
apolloartemis thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: applenpeaches

AA, Interesting post... 👍🏼 From one Madhu fan to another 👏..

I wish I could offer an intelligent comment on this issue. Cant, since I have watched only two episodes since Sultan's entry. The written updates keeps me updated. So far I havent been tempted to watch any episodes.

About Rishabala, you know how much I was into them. My liking for them had much to do with how they complimented each other in their own crazy ways. I wish the CVs hadnt gone ahead with the humiliation drama. The woman in me refuses to overlook that. So I dont get any pleasure in watching them together now. True, RK hasnt physically abused Madhu, but arent the scars from emotional abuse deeper and likely to pain for longer? Good for Madhu that she has fought back.

Here is to hoping she spends some time in evolving and not go looking for another man or child to take under her wing. *toast*



Hi peach!
It is hard to say Madhu belongs with one or the other, but I guess, in the end, for me, the constant physical danger is far more pervasive than the emotional potential danger. Because I don't know RK's strategy yet. I hope they don't go the taunts route again because that will be hard to watch and will make me wish Madhu would book a one way ticket to Mauritius😕
Much as I want her to have some time to herself, she is always going to be caught up in somebody's else's drama.
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: apolloartemis

@AreYaar and @Leela,
Thank you very much for your kind words! You guys write such awesome analysis that is so wonderful that you liked mine!😳



You're welcome, Apollo :-)

I'd like to add that I didn't comment on the Sultan aspect of the analysis for a basic reason that I don't have a grouse with him being a gangster and hence "unworthy" of Madhu...I honestly don't get these arguments about who is "morally" better for Madhu and who can be the perfect husband 50 years into her future...I don't think that is what this show is about at all...I don't think this show is supposed to be about the audience choosing a perfect husband for Madhu...

I prefer RK-Madhu for the simple reason that they make this show entertaining...it's not about chemistry, it's about the WRITING for them...I don't get the complaints regarding the revenge track cuz I thought that was a GENIUS stroke.

For the ppl wanting an instant reuniting of RK-Madhu...what else will be left in the show then? More Sultan type characters to make a khichdi of a love triangle? That is the point at which every show goes downhill and I lose interest anyways.

I'm an RK fan cuz he keeps this show unpredictable and thus entertaining to me atleast...if that is changed and an easy reuniting takes place then there is just saas-bahu drama in the works...the gangster track is just an odd segue that doesn't go with the ESSENCE of the filmworld the show uses as a background.

Sultan would be entertaining if they showed more of his scenes with RK...two strong characters facing off...better than all this chindi gangster-giri going on.


Also, this whole angle of throwing Madhu into a READYMADE family and Mommy role is something that doesn't fit in with the storyline...just my opinion.

As I said in my previous post...RK-Madhu CHALLENGE each other...their power plays are what MAKE this show...otherwise it would be pedestrian stuff.
Secret_Giggle thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#28
Very well written. I really love RK and Madhu.
0-SD-0 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: AreYaar



To me, this gif sorta summarizes their relationship in what was otherwise a light-hearted moment b/w them...



Madhu ungli dikhaayegi toh RK HAS to BEND it😆😆...She's a CHALLENGE that he HAS to win OVER and OVER again...that's his obsession...He can't let her have the last word....

It's a GAME b/w them...RK THRIVES on playing mind games with everyone in his life...but Madhu is the ONLY person who has stood up to him in those games and made the challenge more FUN for him...lol...and in all that only somewhere they've managed to fall passionately in love with each other...so situations change, circumstances change...but inherently the POWER PLAY remains...it will be there in EVERY facet of their relationship whether good or bad...that's how I see them.


That is the essence of their relationship and nothing wrong with that equation when the couple themselves like it that way. Look at your gif. She didn't like his bending of her finger, she turns away, he also turns away, but she looks back at at him again, he too looks back at her --meaning cannot stay away from each other, the game that play, the fun they have at having played and it shows off...they burst off laughing with each other. Its the passion of two loves, its their kind of amorous play, likes wild-cats fighting and still enjoying it.

I once posted a video of lion-lioness fight in the wild as one of Rishbala fight reminded me of it.😆 in the EDT after spending a night and a morning searching for good videos of all kinds of cat fights. 🤣 See that is entertainment as well. Right ? Making me go crazy and searching for lion-fight videos.🤣

Anyways...whatever it is, the power-play between them as it plays out, the offences, the defences, the territorial fights, all generate a lot of entertainment. In the end what is enjoyable even if viewed from a moralising and sermonising perspective is they don't cross the lines institutional abuse and even if that line is crossed, they are available recourses for the perceived victim to invoke in the name of getting justice served. The realists see it, so the realists watching the show understand why the other is not reacting in a normally expected manner (Read Bell's Curve- of statistics - Normal Distribution). Then all of that reaction when seen as falling at the tail ends of curve we know that its just that the victim does not want to go for recourse by himself/herself but will wait for the other to come and enbalm him/her on the wounds.

As viewer than we are just left to express our frustration at abnormality, or exacerbate at the extent of canvas of the game-field they have designed for themselves and we end up watching them as two pitted souls against each other, angry at themselves that how much the other invokes the passion in him or her.

Its a CRAZY show. But to term it as crazy show, we the viewers have to cross the AAG KA DARIYA of SANITY and then we would be able to enjoy the show.

See everyday, in the forum, people wade into this aag ka dariya of realistic expectations to douse themselves in the sea of crazy passion of Rishbala. A dariya will have to finally fall into samunder. Right ?

Edited by 0-SD-0 - 12 years ago
693326 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: apolloartemis


Thank you for answering! I suppose my post was more for those fans who have indicated that they adore Sulbala only as an alternative to Risbala- won't name names, or anything😊
To be honest, I don't know if TRP audiences will wait for a year😆 in order to see Rishbala reunited in any way shape or form- this isn't one of Ekta's shows, I don't think the audience has the patience😆
The majority of the complaints I have seen about Rishbala seem to be that Madhu is going back despite the fact that RK has not repented and continues to hurt her- so maybe sentiment will change as he does? Just my opinion though!
Thanks for commenting!



if balllika badhu can run for ys after yrs...why not our shw...we r no less...n i m not saying this coz im a fan of the shw...if our shw was one of those shws which cant garner trps inspite of being good.then i wont talk abt 2 yrs...

cuming to trp audience...they dont want the leads reunion...the forum people does...they dont hv patience and once reunion happens.they agn start complaining the shw is getting too sweet after the reunion...

trp audience wants entertainment n drama...which isnt poss to b shwn 6 days a weeek month after month...jus revolving one jodi...doesnt matter how the fangrps hate the othr hero n the othr jodi...deep down we all knw both the heroes r needed to keep the spice in tact...to keep the trps in tact

cvs hv milkd rishbala as much as they cud the 1st 8 months

things were getting reptive until sultan n aryan came

the same people craving for rishbala used to bash the rishbala scns even 1 month bk saying its getting boring

so if the rishbala crze is bk

thats also coz of sultan

cuming to waiting for a yr for rishbala

who is telling to wait a yr

cvs rnt fools

they will always link madhu with the 2 heroes this way or that

none of the jodi camps need to wait for their jodi

but strting a rishbala luvstory with eyelocks n bkground music is jus too early

i m not dying for a sulbla romance eithr

both sultan n madhu has bitter past

it will again b too early to mk them fall for each othr

as of now i dont want any luv between any of the jodis

i m luving how cvs r pregressing the track now

cuming to the fans liking sulbala as alternative to rishbala...even i know those fans

n thats why i did say 80% sulbala fans dont like them jus coz rk is evil

the rest 20% falls in the grp u r tking abt

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".