MR's Top 5 performances on the show... - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

33

Views

3.7k

Users

18

Likes

183

Frequent Posters

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: make-believe


Butttt, that is besides the point for this thread, na? You should be able to say at least one or two scenes off the top of your head which impressed you so much that they stick out in memory! :P



LOL yes I know it's besides the point of this thread and I haven't been sticking to the point anyways......sorry😆.....

I know this probably sounds dumb but I really am not able to describe anything in detail like everyone else in here......so I really should shut up now and just read everyone else's views I think :-)

P.S. Keep meaning to tell you but it slips my mind......LOVE the bottom Kala pic in your sig.....wonderfullllllll coloring.
-Fivr- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#22
Lol! Fatty yaar.. I've been on a LTL-old-scenes spree for the past hour and now I'm super nostalgic.. 😍 I miss LTL.. *sigh*

But I'll try and pick my 4 other favorites! I already have one picked!! 😆
droopy_asleep thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#23
Fatty...Yes, the No. 1 scene on my list was the scene during the DP track, it was just amazing....MR was just so perfect in that scene, I had tears in my eyes :)
vahgar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#24

Nice post...........But not fair to stop at 5 scenes :)

I will try to post the ones that I recall from memory........I know if I start to watch a few scenes, it will end up being more than a few....... :)

1. The first one is obviously a tasha scene, For some reason, I like the scene when Nakku comes to return the mangalsutra......he was already standing lost in his thoughts and when Nakku comes and calls him "Saab", and he instinctively says 'Hmm..", at that instant it felt like there was nothing wrong between the 2, it was as if he had responded to the old nakku,and the next second he realizes that Nakku is there and looks up....... It was done so naturally, I keep wondering to this day if MR did an improvisation on that scene, or was it scripted that way. Not a big scene, but somehow its always been one of my favorites.
2. The scene during the DP track........on the sea shore, a drunk dutta talking to baaji....... loved that scene, MR potrayed the emotions of a person who was hurt, angry, sad, lost, frustrated Amazingly. His talk with baaji was very emotional....especially when he says..... he wanted to give Baaji his dad's name, but he was not even aware of his dad till today, his whole identity was changed, was lost. And loved this dialogue, MR has a wonderful voice modulation, "mein teek hai baaji, dekh, dekh, mere paaw zameen par tike hai, saala aaj pairo thale zameen kisak gayi yaar' and especially when baaji says "ghar chal" ,his expression after he asks "Ghar ?" questioningly, with that sarcastic smile...... was amazing......."kya teek hoyga baaji, kya mein waapis ayi saheb ka beta banunga ?" as so childlike yet so painful. and then finally, one of my favorite dialogues , "Chabeez saal baad, mere aankho ke saamne se yeh andhera hata hai," then he points to the dark night and continues "mere saamne tho phir bhi andhera hai" ......We had some wonderful dialogues in that episode. Am surprised that this is not a Tasha scene, but I always thought was one of MR's Best.
3. The first wedding Track....... MR was amazing thru out this track. I know this is a track and not exactly a scene, but will try to get away with it, since it was one continues track even though it lasted almost a month. Loved his acting from the time Nakku enters the house without Supriya until he marries Nakku and takes her to the room........especially after they discover supriya's letter until Baaji gets the nariyal pani wala guy , MR did not have any dialogues....... but his acting was wonderful........he expressed so much thru his eyes and body language. I know Pooja already went thru this scene beautifully,......so will stop here.........
4. After the first wedding, when he comes back all bloodied after killing anna's men, the Tasha scene , like MR's acting in that. where he says that he is not only punishing her, but himself also.
As usual Mishal's dialogue delivery and expressions are awesome thruout the scene....but the best part of the scene when he opens his eyes and finds Nakku standing very close to him, he is surprised and shocked...followed by the very synchronised scene where he gets up and she sits down....followed by some more amzing acting, "mere andar Jhaank kar dekh, Khoon hi khoon reejhtha nazar aayega tujhe......" awesome dialogue delivery......and he realizes that seeing him in pain will be the only thing that will cause her pain, and hence that will be her punishment.
5.Finally......one of my all time favorites, I know this is a very old episode.......The bar scene of tasha after he tells her past of how he became Dutta Bhau.....this was one light hearted scenes where he pulls Nakku's leg.... "sab kuch teri aayi bathathi hai, ya, tu bhi kabhi kuch sochthi hai"....during those days, we hardly got to see Dutta laugh or smile , and in this we have him laughing at Nakku's answer to his "Tu kis mitti ki bani hai Nakku" , "Main, kaali mitti ki".....was refreshing. His hand gestures and facial expression were very subtle and effective here......and the way the scenes ends with his question to Baaji "Ab tu, yoon ruti biwi ki tarah peeche peeche chalega....?" was a nice touch.....But then in an instant he becomes all serious and in Dutta Bhau mode ..........I guess MR is the only actor on TV who can go thru a range of emotions in one scene.........
These are just a few scenes, have not even got to the scenes after second Marriage and the FR..... and the finaly reunion in the temple.........etc etc etc.........
--Lalitha
Pyari_Zahra thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#25
Hmm
Hmmm...
Nope, I just cannot think of just five! 🤔 It's very difficult for me 😆
Very lovely reading everybody else's inputs though 😍 x
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#26
Ok, my mind-block eased up a bit so I can add some thoughts for now I guess.....lol

Following up on the scene Pallo mentioned from the Jagtap track.....I'm just going back on a bit of a nostalgia track and thinking what I felt when I first watched that scene.....those were my early days of REALLY starting to get pulled in by LTL and being taken aback by MR's brilliance as well as the brilliance of the silent moments of communication.....when not a word is spoken and SO much is expressed.

There are two significant moments in that scene.....one when DN are watching Jagtap die as he tells them to leave and tells Dutta to take care of Nakku.....like Pallo mentioned.....just the way Dutta is looking at Jagtap there and SO much is communicated in his eyes.....you get goosebumps.....you FEEL every bit....so tangibly.

But there is a moment after that that touches my heart SO much.....I think someone else mentioned it a few days back too (maybe Ritz did).....yes we have MR's genius in this but I also love this scene as a combined moment of communication b/w DN again without saying a word:

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OWilW15ro8M[/YOUTUBE]

The bit from 0:22 onwards......Nakku trips, Dutta holds her to stabilize her and pulls her back up.....she's exhausted, a despair in her body language, almost unable to stand by herself too....she looks up at the trees surrounding them in the dark night.....Dutta's watching her.....holding her up since she seems ready to collapse any second.....after a moment she looks up at him.....and I always get the sense as if there's a question in her eyes...."why? why did this happen?".....Dutta instantly glances away, looks down.....as if he doesn't have an answer to that question in her eyes.....she keeps on staring at him with that same almost unfathomable emotion in her eyes for a bit.....At 0:57, he kinda gathers himself again and looks back and shakes her for a bit as if to say, "come on Nakku, get a hold of yourself....we have to go"....and they start running again.

It's hardly a 30 or so second bit but I find it SO powerful......Jagtap had just died....emotionally charged moments....yet DN have to run for their lives....there isn't the luxury of time to sit back and absorb all that has happened.....but in these 30 seconds we feel all of it....the way Nakku looks up at Dutta with all that sorrow for Jagtap....Dutta glancing away cuz he can't say anything to console her in that moment....he has no answers....and it isn't the time for it because they have to run....but just those 30 seconds....and how he looks at her and understands what her eyes are saying.....that moment of communication is so touching to me.....brilliant.

That's how I interpret this scene....dunno if it's overimagination.....lol.....I'd made an avi a long time back but stupid tinypic deleted that too....ughhh......lol

Finally, what I love is how this "trip-catch" wasn't turned into a stupid romantic or sappy scenario.....they didn't say a WORD to each other but SO much was communicated.....the soulful connection above everything else as always.

*Edit: And the bit 1:37 onwards specifically for MR's genius as he hears Jagtap's voice echoing around him as he stares at the jungle, the trees around him.......SUCH a fantastic bit....and again there's like an avalanche of emotions that you can see in his eyes, his body language.....but again he gathers himself, takes Nakku's hand purposefully and off they go again.....again moments where no word was spoken b/w them....but the way he looked at her and the way she looked at him....UNDERSTANDING in the purest of senses.
Edited by nureat01 - 14 years ago
Lekz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#27
Friends...this is such an awesome thread.....
Lovely contributions from all....thanks for the post and the additions.....
🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗
It matters when you suddenly get into a depression realising that the show will never be the same again. TaSha will never be the same again....
pbtghosh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#28

pls give me minimum 10 opt. only 5 scenses are very difficult.😔

1. Jana Yogi. --
2. So Gaya Ye Jahan --
3. TASHA's 1st full conversation
4. After 1st marriage full conversation.
5. DSP's reaction after Naku's refusal
N.B. TASHA 1st marriage is all time fev.⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
------
ritun
-Roopa- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#29

When we feel within us the exact emotions of the characters, that is the result of a very good and near perfect acting by the actors. I have tried to pick up the scenes, each of which showed Dutta's different emotions at its best perfectly enacted by Mishal..

Here are the few of my favorite ones..

1st scene: During Sups track, in the dining hall when she again gives the reason of her bad health and walks away, dutta looses his patience. When he is in his room, nakku goes in and starts to give her gyaan trying to explain the reason for sups behavior and stops him from drinking. Dutta completely loosing his patience, targets nakku to pour out his anger with his all time painful words. The peak of his anger, and one of the best scenes where Mishal stood out so convincingly. I was so disturbed when I saw that scene. His every word pierces you with that pain and his anger makes you shudder and it has the same effect even today when I watch it.

March 2nd 2010 - part 4:http://www.upbulk.com/media/video.php?id=111377

March 3rd 2010 - part1: http://www.upbulk.com/media/video.php?id=112384

2nd Scene: When Dutta comes back after his fight with Deshmukh, nakku notices that he is hurt. She follows him and wants to dress his wound. Here Mishal's portrayal of Dutta's pain is so natural and so is his concern about nakku being there and trying to convince her that he can take care of it himself. When she refuses to go, his transition of his emotions from his concern for her to being strict has been bought out so well by Mishal.

March 25th - part 3: http://www.upbulk.com/media/video.php?id=132061

March 25th - part 4 :http://www.upbulk.com/media/video.php?id=132077

March 25th - part 5: http://www.upbulk.com/media/video.php?id=132098

3rd scene: After Sups suicide drama, Dutta is shown lost in thoughts. He is trying to come to a conclusion about supriya and her behavior. Seema also comes in his mind and him switching the light on and off coincides with the past and present and his confusions. When we are overwhelmed with any emotion, it comes out in the form of tears when our closed ones comfort us. When AS comes and comforts him trying to calm his disturbed mind, he rests his head on her lap and tears flows down. One of the best AS-Dutta scene and Mishal was best here.

March 29th - part 1:http://www.upbulk.com/media/video.php?id=135035

March 29th - part 2: http://www.upbulk.com/media/video.php?id=135054

March 29th - part 3: http://www.upbulk.com/media/video.php?id=135074

March 29th - part 4: http://www.upbulk.com/media/video.php?id=135098

4th scene: In the dining hall [after Anna's track], when nakku is serving everyone, dutta wants her to sit with them. Dutta is hurt and confused by nakku's refusal and kala's taunting. But when babi serves him telling that nakku has specially prepared for him, he eats it wholeheartedly. I think this is the only scene that I have seen dutta eating and finishing his plate happily. At the end of it, he feels so content, and tells babi 'nakku ko boliye khana accha tha', pauses and tells 'mera phet bar gaya'.. his expression at the end of it bought tears in my eyes. One of the scenes I have watched countless times and never had enough of it.

August 26th - part 2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_dMHNN1usEY

5th scene: Last but not the least, the proposal scene.

Dutta's acceptance of whatever he had wrong with nakku in the past, asking for the forgiveness and with so much of respect and love asking her hand and his reaction at the end when nakku runs away, were all just awesome. One of the best proposals I have seen on the screen.

Sep 2nd - Part 1: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uVmvhXwjnCM

Sep 2nd- part 2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7hHhPQMedIw&feature=relmfu

Oh..there are many more [both the marriages, dutta's monologue on SR, hospital scene..i can just go on]..

but I want to share this one..the whole karanji wala episode[March 26th] was so hilarious, nakku trying to explain that how much efforts go in preparing karanji and dutta's reaction to her 😆 and dutta going to sups trying to say that karanji she prepared was good and baji outside laughing and enjoying dutta's plight.. 😆

Edited by -Roopa- - 14 years ago
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#30
Oooh Roopa.....lovely list! That dining table scene after the Anna track is one of my favs too and yes the only memory I also have of Dutta eating a full plate of food......LOLLL.....I'd say that scene is an example of how MR made the simplest of lines and simplest of scenes also seem SO profound and so special.....it's such a simple thing....he ate a full meal after many days.....but the love, the gratitude in his words was just SO touching......it's like one of those scenes that make you sighh......A scene like this can easily be taken into overacting territory as well.....but kudos to MR for enacting it with that fine balance as always.....subtle yet SO deep.....that amazing paradox.

At this point in the storyline what I loved was how Dutta had not even once acknowedged or said out loud that he loves Nakku yet every look, every gesture of his expressed that SO beautifully😍.....Words weren't needed.....or rather....they felt small in front of what his eyes, his body language so profoundly expressed otherwise.....I realllyyyyyyy loved this phase.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".