D left Seema at the mercy of ET?

left_forever

@left_forever

Inactive

19

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#31

Zuby if Naku wudnt have been with him he would have prefered to die for Seema but we all knw he cares for Naku more than anythng...u see when Suds said tat Naku will go with him to Hell to help him search DP...he was angry like anythng...tat is Naku to him...its wrong to leave sumone like tis but wat option did he had...there was none..cud he jst say Seema i m not going anywhere let them kill all 3 of us...rather than letting them kill all 3 he chosed to save 2. By running he cud atleast cum later for her but wats the point in giving up and embracing death wen he got a chance to save naku's life

and he must have sensed tat his family back there is in danger who need him..so i dnt thnk he did anythgn wrong....at times life brings us to such point where u have to make a choice(even if it means sacrificng sumone)

4

Reply

Quote

-Carrie-

@-Carrie-

Rocker

27

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#32

Thank u gals for your in-depth explanations.Though like Srush said D running even after hearing Seema's voice made the scene unreal, the circumstances like the danger around him, utter confusion, his weaponless state etc might have clouded his judgement as most of you said. Maybe Kaala will use Seema to lure D back in her trap again. Though I don't for one moment believe Seema will turn negative or a rift will be created between D & his wife because of her.

I think I'll just sulk for a day or two then I'll be alright.It's Patil Saab after all.Unhe jeevan ki dor se baandh liya hai unke zulm aur sitam sar aankhon par!😳

3

Reply

Quote

TheRager

@TheRager

Achiever

47

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#33

Also there is another point...Seema was safer when she was in hiding. Even in his blind state Dutta could have beaten his chicken guards and escaped. But it was Seema's decision to throw herself in danger....ok...ok maybe I am not making sense. Only thing that was obvious yesterday that Dutta would have stayed put and fought if he was alone. But he refused to take a risk with Naku's life. And this is something I wanted to see since ages. So I dont really care what happens to Seema.

6

Reply

Quote

-bharti-

@-bharti-

Dazzler

23

Posted: 14 years ago

#34

Originally posted by: rama_2010
Oh Zuby... Patil saab se naraz ho....
he did not see that seema is in danger... nor did he know chaskar is around (as chaskar were given no dialogues)...... aur abhi woh scene khatam kahan hua.... we will wait n watch tomorrow.

Exactly!

Zuby even thou' u have a point, the circumstances were not in favour of dutta to think nd then decide. He had to make an instant decision. Wait till u see the episode further, hope we dont have to repent later sometime that why was seema not sacrificed.

3

Reply

Quote

mnx12

@mnx12

Channel Moderator

35

+ 15

Posted: 14 years ago

#35

Originally posted by: ZubyDutta
Never in a million years will I accept that D left Seema surrounded by the dozens of armed men while he makes a grand escape with his wife. He will gladly die than let an innocent face the likes of Chaskar & Suds.Especially a young woman.He is a man.A truly principled man.If Cvs wanted to show Seema a martyr there were other ways.A BG could have been pretending to have joined Kala camp while all the time looking out for D & his family.He could have done what Seema did today.Seema could have intercepted a bullet for D. But D making a quick escape? NO! That is not my man. I feel so cheated.
Can someone explain why D was made to act this way today?

well written Zuby, but this reminded me of Jagtap, telling D & N to run & leave the jungle.Jagtap & Seema both wanted to save D & N, the circumstances were extreme, either D & N dies on Jagtap & Seema dies. J & S chose to sacrifice their life for D & N.

1

Reply

Quote

Ankur

@Ankur_1305

Navigator

14

Posted: 14 years ago

#36

Originally posted by: ccolaco
Zuby if Naku wudnt have been with him he would have prefered to die for Seema but we all knw he cares for Naku more than anythng...u see when Suds said tat Naku will go with him to Hell to help him search DP...he was angry like anythng...tat is Naku to him...its wrong to leave sumone like tis but wat option did he had...there was none..cud he jst say Seema i m not going anywhere let them kill all 3 of us...rather than letting them kill all 3 he chosed to save 2. By running he cud atleast cum later for her but wats the point in giving up and embracing death wen he got a chance to save naku's life

and he must have sensed tat his family back there is in danger who need him..so i dnt thnk he did anythgn wrong....at times life brings us to such point where u have to make a choice(even if it means sacrificng sumone)

Hundreds of advancing enemies. A dear friend and fellow soldier lying wounded in front. Back home family, new born child, blind mother and sick father. What should he do?

Prioritize?

Do what Dutta did?

Did he have any more time than Dutta had to take a careful decision?

At least Dutta had a choice to shout at Naku and tell her to leave without saying "saab" so HE, the soldier could stay back and help Seema even if the chance was less than 1 per cent.

That was totally against the grain of the man's character. And yes, we are not saying he is a superman. The soldier in the field is not a superman or God but will not run on his helplessly wounded fellow solider even if the latter was pleading him to run.

Edited by Ankur_1305 - 14 years ago

2

Reply

Quote

-Carrie-

@-Carrie-

Rocker

27

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#37

Hundreds of advancing enemies. A dear friend and fellow soldier lying wounded in front. Back home family, new born child, blind mother and sick father. What should he do?

Prioritize?

Do what Dutta did?

Did he have any more time than Dutta had to take a careful decision?

At least Dutta had a choice to shout at Naku and tell her to leave without saying "saab" so HE, the soldier could stay back and help Seema even if the chance was less than 1 per cent.

That was totally against the grain of the man's character. And yes, we are not saying he is a superman. The soldier in the field is not a superman or God but will not run on his helplessly wounded fellow solider even if the latter was pleading him to run.
@bold: That was exactly the point I was trying to make when I wrote this post. That it's against the nature of this man I love & understand so much to leave his ally to the wolves & run to save his wife. That he loves Nakusha & places her above everything else is without a doubt.But would that also include offering another helpless woman who has been with him thru thick & thin these past days as a sacrificial lamb to keep enemies distracted while he makes sure there is not a scratch on his wife?Somehow its not the man I know. I am not at all worried abt the safety of Seema.It's portrayal of D I care abt.

But all my friends who have made a case defending this action have a solid point that when it;s between Nakku & Seema, Nakku wins hands down for D.That is the point the CVs too tried to make I guess.But they did it at at the expense of tainting the character of an impeccable & inimitable personality like D.

2

Reply

Quote

TheRager

@TheRager

Achiever

47

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#38

I dont think the situation of a soldier and his mate can be compared to Seema and Dutta. Soldiers fight for a greater cause ie their country. Whereas this battle is a lot less noble. Plus if Dutta has a mate then it is Baji. Seema is like one of the villagers who live near the battle field who helped the soldier escape from his enemies. What would the soldier do in such a situation?

4

Reply

Quote

-bharti-

@-bharti-

Dazzler

23

Posted: 14 years ago

#39

This is an endless thing with many ifs and buts. Agreed that dutta does not run leaving another hapless lady in trouble. But look at the tragedy if he had stayed. I understand ur point when u say the CVs could have avoided this dilemna for dutta, why not? let dutta face it. He had to make a decision nd he did the right thing given the circumstances.

3

Reply

Quote

left_forever

@left_forever

Inactive

19

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#40

Originally posted by: kshreya2002
I dont think the situation of a soldier and his mate can be compared to Seema and Dutta. Soldiers fight for a greater cause ie their country. Whereas this battle is a lot less noble. Plus if Dutta has a mate then it is Baji. Seema is like one of the villagers who live near the battle field who helped the soldier escape from his enemies. What would the soldier do in such a situation?

Exactly Ksh

if this point is considered so much then Dutta must have not even left Jagtap at tat time..infact he was not even helpless..he should have never ran along with Naku and shud have fought with Jagtap. But no it doesnt always goes this way

Sometimes decision have to be made in haste. If Dutta had to worry about Seema then first place he shud have asked her to leave him alone and go as his life is full of dangers. He shud have never taken her help...but no he did understnd tat always u cant do as u feel sumtimes u need to thnk of the situation too tat u r in

and Ksh as u said ..yes indeed Seema is like sum other woman in front of Naku and she helped Dutta coz she wanted sumthng in return out of her own selfish motives..if she dies it will be gud for her

i dnt knw how much sense i have made...but i jst feel tat Dutta did take a right decision

Edited by ccolaco - 14 years ago

5

Reply

Quote