Put on Dutta's Pathaani Jooti!

Dancingdoll thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Guys,
I am reading lot of varied posts on Dutta's reaction to Naku's truth and this post is not to contest any point of view because I sincerely feel that everyone has his own taker and feeling that he takes from a scene and none of us have a right to rub the other on his taker for a simple reason that one cannot change other person's feeling and variety is always spice of life...that's what makes this forum spicy!!!
Having said that, I have a simple case study for all of you -
Imagine, you are sitting in your bedroom, day dreaming about your partner (BF/Hubby/Fiance/Potential BF/Fantasiz-able guy)....You recollect your best romantic moment with him, you recollect the sacrifices he has made for you...You recollect the best set of words he crafted only for you....You recollect that one crack in him that made you run and envelope him, make him feel that u are always there for him.....Your eyes well up! You get emotional....
and BOOM! Suddenly a figure walks from the door towards you....You wake up from your trance and look at him, shocked! You cant recognize him! You have never seen that face before...You get scared, "Who is he? What is he doing in my bedroom?"....You reach for the first thing you get your hands on!
And he comes close to you, sighs, look at you longingly, stares in your eyes, serious face and tells you, "I am the one you love"....
What would you do after your initial open mouth expression?....
(Please note that the guy is the same guy you were day dreaming about, either his color has gone through a 180 degree change or he has removed a mask that he always had ON!)
Please be sincere in your answers, put urself in the protaganist's shoes that I have just sketched above, imagine and then see your own reaction in your fantasy, and then answer me!! The reactions would be an interesting thing to analyze here!!
AND GUYS, I WILL PREPARE A COLLAGE OF OUR REACTIONS!!! So, think hard, Imagine yourself actually going through this process and complete that scene for me! Its completely alright if your reaction is different from Dutta's or other member's! its your reaction and it defines the person you are! So, be proud of yourself! šŸ˜›
Love,
DD
Edited by Dancingdoll - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

102

Views

5.5k

Users

25

Likes

203

Frequent Posters

Hessa85 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
i need to think about this, 1 thing I am sure about is that I wouldnt do whatever dutta will probably do next. i would be angry, and hurt and i would probably need space for a while. but honestly if i really loved someone, i would want to believe in the person no matter what. i would WANT for their to be a reason behind hiding something so big. and logically speaking, for someone to hide something so big there HAS to be a reason
prettywoman thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
niki.. tune meri muh ki baat ched di hain..i could nver write as beautifully as u have above.. but this was exactly my thoughts when some could not understand POV. it hurt a bit that some could not understand his love and felt his love was weak.. i know i cannot question their POV and i must respect their POV. but this post will maybe help them better in understanding Dutta's pov for sure.
here is my reply from anotehr thread
dutta is not doing wrong here guys.. poor guy has been lied to by everyone and everyone knew the truth except him.. just put urself in his shoes and think.. if the person u married has a new face only cos of their jhooth, whatever the majhboori, for a person like dutta it is inevitable that he will lash out and that is just what he is doing.. and in some respects what he is saying is true na...kaali nakku mar gayi.. she will never come back.. but slowly he will realise the heart in gori nakku is the same.. pls cut him some slack.. usko itna bada sadma laga hain.. a stranger claims to be nakku and he is expected to believe that?! i really feel for him.. i do feel for nakku too, but she knew the outcomes, didn't she when she hid thr truth.. i am not gonna get into why she hid the truth etc, but at the end of the day, dutta has been betrayed again and for a person whose faith on beautiful faces is so fragile, this must have been the last straw..so let him cleanse his mind after venting out all his anger.. then he will sit down and ponder as always! just hope baaj is not penalised too much!
his love for koel nakku is so deep and strong, that he cant even look at this new face..not cos his love is weak.. in fact he is mourning the loss of his koel nakku.. and it will take some time..

Sophia21 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
I would hurt, angry and confused..
My first reaction would be confused .. then maybe i would push him away and shout.. then when i realise its actually him i would get angry... and maybe walk out...
Then wen i come back to my senses i would want an explanation.. a good one and a proof to back it up ...
I know i should trust the one i love but if he cant trust me enough to show his real face then how am i ment to trust him?
If he gives me a good enough reason then maybe i would forgive him but it would take time to start trusting him again...
Dancingdoll thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Hessa85

i need to think about this, 1 thing I am sure about is that I wouldnt do whatever dutta will probably do next. i would be angry, and hurt and i would probably need space for a while. but honestly if i really loved someone, i would want to believe in the person no matter what. i would WANT for their to be a reason behind hiding something so big. and logically speaking, for someone to hide something so big there HAS to be a reason

hmmm..Interesting...hessa, just complete that scene for me and then in the end, your emotions and thoughts running thru ur mind..... and do remember, imagine a diff guy in front of u....
and yes, I agree, Intention is more important than the action.....but would ur thought on intention Vs Action come in that very moment? In that whole scene or later on? Everyone would have a diff reaction and I am so interested to see that how we all differ frm each other...
I will prepare a collage of our reactions later on!!...
and dont forget, the guy standing in front of u has a diff face!!!///so, imagine a diff face, and pls, not the one whom u might have a crush on!! šŸ˜†šŸ˜†...just arbitary anyone!!
Crystal29 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
I would get very very hurt and then really mad! It would take a lot of time for me to think straight after that. Even if he is explaining, I might just hear him talk but words may not make sense to me..

Also I would not be able to look at his face for a very long time...

About Dutta's reaction...hmm...it is not even done yet...I am waiting to watch the whole thing..till now it is justified in my opinion...he is mad right now..rightly so...it will take a long time for him to calm down...what he does after he calms down is his actual reaction to FR in my opinion...so I will wait.

Forgiving the girl you love for keeping you in dark and not trusting you is in itself a big thing, now if you have to do this to a new face...it is huge!
jani-yeh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
vah re Gabbar kya case study hai...šŸ‘...
whoa-k so i'v jus finished dreamy about me n mr dreamy...šŸ˜...
and in he walks...looking jus as DD said...a complete stranger...šŸ˜²šŸ˜•...
he tries 2 talk 2 me...(n lyk Naku he 2 sounds xactly the same as i'v always knwn him 2 sound)...but the voice is cumin out of a new person...
after the initual shock...i think i wud b angry as hell...😔...and in true angry form...wud start crying...but more than because i was sad...it wud b becuase i was angry...wen im angry i cry...then i would prob throw a few things...
literally anything that came 2 hand...remote...fone...lamp...wateva...i wudnt even think about it...i wud jus reach out 4 it n throw it @ this stranger wiv mr dreamyz voice...he wud not get a chance 2 even xplain...i wud prob cover my ears n scream at him 2 go away...if he dint leave...i wud prob get up n run away myself...there'd b noway i wud b willing 2 listen...noway wat so eva...
n it wud take me a long tym 2 even cum round 2 thinking about the matter wiv a str8 head...this kind of secret keeping may even b 4givable 2 me...šŸ˜•...
if ur not able 2 share sumink lyk this wiv me...the person u claim 2 luv...
how will u share a relationship n lyf wiv me......
Edited by jani-yeh - 14 years ago
mussy.jamshed thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
DD. meina usko aik jhoota khaich k marunge honestly if I confront such a situation, I wil react angrily n shattered as I m v emotional person. If we love someone, our brain connect thoughts with visual image of that person, when face gets changed. U wil immediately get disconnected , ur feelings does nt cme out so easily for that person. U are with smeone 24x7, he or she does nt stay true to u. I wil b v hurt n might nt stop crying easily. I agree that dutta reaction is justified. If I were in hs place, I would ve felt cheated. I do admit I have soft corner 4 nakusha but she dug hole for herself n nw she has to bear the consequences
Dancingdoll thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: prettywoman

niki.. tune meri muh ki baat ched di hain..i could nver write as beautifully as u have above.. but this was exactly my thoughts when some could not understand POV. it hurt a bit that some could not understand his love and felt his love was weak.. i know i cannot question their POV and i must respect their POV. but this post will maybe help them better in understanding Dutta's pov for sure.

here is my reply from anotehr thread
dutta is not doing wrong here guys.. poor guy has been lied to by everyone and everyone knew the truth except him.. just put urself in his shoes and think.. if the person u married has a new face only cos of their jhooth, whatever the majhboori, for a person like dutta it is inevitable that he will lash out and that is just what he is doing.. and in some respects what he is saying is true na...kaali nakku mar gayi.. she will never come back.. but slowly he will realise the heart in gori nakku is the same.. pls cut him some slack.. usko itna bada sadma laga hain.. a stranger claims to be nakku and he is expected to believe that?! i really feel for him.. i do feel for nakku too, but she knew the outcomes, didn't she when she hid thr truth.. i am not gonna get into why she hid the truth etc, but at the end of the day, dutta has been betrayed again and for a person whose faith on beautiful faces is so fragile, this must have been the last straw..so let him cleanse his mind after venting out all his anger.. then he will sit down and ponder as always! just hope baaj is not penalised too much!
his love for koel nakku is so deep and strong, that he cant even look at this new face..not cos his love is weak.. in fact he is mourning the loss of his koel nakku.. and it will take some time..

I agree Vandu!!...Moreover, this is his inital reaction..Dutta tends to get worked up initially...Thats what he is....He would defn not throw away his love from the window....He is NOW in love, and thats a big thing...Naku's hasnt given so many sacrifices for anything but let the initial phase pass thru....
he loves Naku too much to let her go!!!....He would start missing her and would have no choice but to go to this gal!!
BTW, Tut tut...Vandu, compleet my case study!!...This thread is to gather different reactions and understand each other....so, compleet the scene for me pls!!
I am gng to create a collage over the weekend!!
droopy_asleep thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
I would be devastated and very very angry. Hurt and confusion are part and parcel of that reaction, but I would just walk away. So in that sense, Dutta's reaction is very justified. You cant just blindly accept someone who has just told you - By the way, I am fair now :)
But once I get calm, I am also the type of person, who thinks - why is that everyone is supporting the other person and nobody is backing me up??? Is everybody mistaken or is it just me? That is when I will start asking the right questions - Why? When ? Who ? The answers follow: Men-circumstances-my upbringing in the basti | My own mother.
The real question is what will it take to calm down? Another incident to harm the one you love or just retrospection.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".