I am amazed by DD's and Anu's theories here.. well done girls.. seriously, after watching AS story unfold yesterday, even i was crying for her.. but as they say, you need some time to soak it all in and then the thoughts come to the fore like it did for you all..
there is definitely more to AS's story. i have not watched the show from start, so dont know when it was said his paa dies when he was 10.
Could it be that she swapped the characters around? that SP was evil and DP was not that black as she has painted him to be. Maybe, the scene where they see the man-woman fighting over the dibbi is SP-AS and SP was accidentally killed by AS?! Due to some other majboori DP has to stay away from his son?! And now he has returned to claim back his son?