Naku's secret - Sinister or not? - Page 7

Originally posted by: Dancingdoll

</div>

and we need to be hurt like Dutta!!

GP, you hid this truth for so long? You didnt trust us? This long an association? We opened all our secrets in front of you, and you didnt say a thing?.....why GP...

<div>*puts a phansi ka fanda on gp*....

*roars in Dutta's style*...Isse kuch aur mat samajhnaa, yeh phansi ka fandaa hi hai!! 🤣🤣

@DD--what can I even say? Phansi ka fanda! Would have preferred Dutta to put it on me, truth be told! 😆

Your response made me roar with laughter too. Just awesome!

i see ur point but i also see dutta's view.. if i was betrayed by beauty...and some ugly guy that i fall ofr reveals that he is hott i might forgive him but if someone else does i will be hurt!!

i hope its not the end of tasha..

Originally posted by: brainychild92

i see ur point but i also see dutta's view.. if i was betrayed by beauty...and some ugly guy that i fall ofr reveals that he is hott i might forgive him but if someone else does i will be hurt!!

i hope its not the end of tasha..

Originally posted by: Dancingdoll

I didnt get this part....someone else meaning what?

if nakku reveals herself i feel it might not be okay but remember how anna was trying to plant a seed in his head.. thank god for amma but shes not there forever... im worried about kalavati and gang.. if they do something dutta will hate nakku forever..

now if my ugly man tells me he's handsome i may be able to forgive him over time but if someone else tells me his reality i will be mad and feel betrayed. i hope now i cleared it a bit

Originally posted by: brainychild92

if nakku reveals herself i feel it might not be okay but remember how anna was trying to plant a seed in his head.. thank god for amma but shes not there forever... im worried about kalavati and gang.. if they do something dutta will hate nakku forever..

now if my ugly man tells me he's handsome i may be able to forgive him over time but if someone else tells me his reality i will be mad and feel betrayed. i hope now i cleared it a bit

Originally posted by: Dancingdoll

Nazia, Ho do u always manage to put my thoughts with better clarity!!! awwwwwww 🤗

U r right...Dutta was engrossed in his topic tht he never realized that Naku also has a secret...naku was interetsed in his part bcoz she had feelings or him and she wanted to help him out of it, but Dutta didnt have feelings.... + he didnt see any pain on her face for him to reach out to her even as a friend!

and the moment he believes in the cause tht Naku lived for whole of her life, he wuld stand by her! and I wanna see him standing against Kala n front of the whole family....wuld be awesome to watch!

aww thats so sweet of u DD 🤗
thats true DD..nakku has always understood his pain and has strived to solve his problems whereas dutta was so engrossed in his own sorrowful life that he forgot that even others might have problems in their lives...but soon he will understand this ..so it was actually a one sided friendship where dutta was unaware of nakku's problems and even nakku never minded this[LOL[..she never expected anything from dutta..
i mean even now, its the same thing! dutta has come over his sorrows but nakku is still perplexed regarding the revelation..so as u said , now it is time to support nakku..BINGO!!..he must stand by her and should also go against kala ..that would be worth watching!! 😆

To answer simply it is not a sinister secret compared to Dutta's evil sisters. But it is hurtful because she should now be able to trust him enough to explain the scenario.

Originally posted by: gp00

You don't think it was a betrayal, Nazia? You're right in that betrayal is too strong a word...but the reality is somewhere close I think.

I look at it from the perspective of their relationship. Who is Dutta to Naku? And who is Naku to Dutta?
And who are Naku and Dutta SUPPOSED to be, respectively? Sher and sherni? Principled (Dutta) vs. Loving (Naku)?

So this is the way I look at it. Naku is NOW at the point where she is conveniently confused about Dutta's feelings...although the CVs have not stretched it to the point of disbelief yet. But she loves Dutta...he knows this. Dutta loves Naku...she does not know this.
But, Naku has long been portrayed as Dutta's greatest lover, protector...even when she lied to him about Sups' relationship with Ravi, she betrayed Dutta. No doubt about that. That was wrong, and I wonder if anyone of us could say " oh, that's ok....she did it because she loved him". When it comes to lying, intentions always should be factored in...but these ARE NOT LITTLE WHITE LIES. These are big...like someone not telling their husband "I am not really from xxx, I did not want to tell you because I thought you may hate me". Well, that's not a good enough reason. Yes, the intention is not to hurt the other person, but it is also to protect yourself and the world you have created for yourself. This latter thing is a more subconscious thing.

I know I may be in the minority here--but I think Naku's lying (and I should finally say it, without beating around the bush because I know what people's reactions will be!) IS WRONG. If she is in fact what she is supposed to be on this show, loving, having values, believing in God and all that God stands for, but yet still being human of course---then how can she keep a secret from Dutta like this about herself.

EVEN if Naku does not know he loves her, Naku knows that Dutta trusts her now, treats her with respect, even to some degree thinks of her as his friend again. Isn't that reason enough to tell the truth? To her friend Dutta? To a person who believes in her? Who has chosen to forget the past because of his faith in her now? That would have compelled me to state the truth. It would have killed me on the inside to know I could deceive someone. Some people have said that it is her truth and when he tells her he loves her, then she will say it? WHY WAIT to tell the truth? Why WAIT when you know what the consequences would be if Dutta found out even if he did not love her? That would destroy the friendship again. I'm unconvinced. Yes, it's easier to say Naku should have done this, done that...but given her character Sherni attributes and her faithfulness in people and God, where the hell is the Truth in all of this? Oh, I get it, truth is conditional, situational...if someone loves you, you can tell them the truth then. It's not enough to tell the truth because deep down inside, you feel like a cheat. I know it's a rough assessment of Naku, but I have faith that the CVs will put her honor and honesty on good footing again. This is again, just my opinion.

no gp..i still DON'T think it is betrayal ...or even if betrayal was a a lesser strong word even then i wouldnt have said that it is betrayal. see even if nakku is a sherni..she is a human being..no one is perfect..i wouldnt call her a betrayer as their marriage was never planned..so she never got a chance to reveal her face..she thinks that dutta never loved her...so y should she reveal her face??..so dutta has never been interested in her ..never tried to give their marriage a chance ..wanted to send her back to the city so y should she reveal it?? and if u remember nakku had decided to revel her face before they part...she felt that it is better to reveal her face before she finally goes to the city..so still would u say that she is a betrayer??...she is hiding her face not out of her own wish but she is compelled to do it..so we cant blame her completely

if u refer to the sups matter here then i would say that yes, she loves dutta and didnt want to see him hurt ..but at the same time she also COAXED sups to marry dutta didnt she??she did what she felt was right!...and what nakku had planned must have happened in reality ..but as kala was also involved in the conspiracy , nakku's plan was not accomplished...see its just like how u say..'ache ke liye jo jhoot bolta hai use jhoota nahin kehte" so if jhoot is said for a sensible reason , or too stop something bad from happening then it is not jhoot...not a lie....
in the sups chapter it was not just that dutta would be hurt but also the fact that nakku came to know about this just 2-4 days before the marriage and she did feel that things can se resolved, sups can be asked to marry dutta..abhi bhi chance hai sups ko manane....she will agree to marry dutta snd things will be fine....but alas the last day kala had planned a conspiracy and hence everything was shattered...so i think what nakku did then was reasonable..she is extremely intelligent....had there been a no kala then nakku's plan would have worked!!


gp u my not be in minority..u have justified ur viewpoint clearly!! 😃 ..but after yesterdays epi i think we know why nakku is not revealing her face..she has a a sensible reason to hide her face...she thinks that now if dutta comes to know that nakku was secretive then he would never trust anyone in his life...thats true ...
[B]but its not just that she should reveal it after realizing that dutta TRUSTS her...the question in her mind was that firstly dutta doesnt love her...so whats the use of revealing her face??..taali ek haath se nahin bajti..if dutta is not interested in her then y should she reveal it?? he is just like any other person on earth from whom her beauty is hidden.....OK even if u say that dutta trusts her thats y she should reveal it atleast to prove that she is trustworthy then another probplem would have popped up...people would say that she revealed her face to trap dutta....so thats how she was restricted...

and now at this time she is fearing that if she reveals her face then dutta might not trust anyone anymore in life....its actually a play of LOVE and HUMANITY here...where there are principles and obligation she has to sacrifice love and where there is love she needs to sacrifice the principles of her life....and still she needs to balance the two..which is very difficult!

Originally posted by: kshreya2002

*Ksh notices Aisha getting over friendly with someone in a completely platonic way*

KSH! Meri Janemaan! *Aisha Tackles Ksh in Hug*
God I've been missing you! Kya yaar you don't trust me?
My Other Half of DuJi!
YOU are IRREPLACEABLE
I am ALL yours😳

Aisha xxx☺️

Originally posted by: nazia.icycool

aww thats so sweet of u DD 🤗
thats true DD..nakku has always understood his pain and has strived to solve his problems whereas dutta was so engrossed in his own sorrowful life that he forgot that even others might have problems in their lives...but soon he will understand this ..so it was actually a one sided friendship where dutta was unaware of nakku's problems and even nakku never minded this[LOL[..she never expected anything from dutta..
i mean even now, its the same thing! dutta has come over his sorrows but nakku is still perplexed regarding the revelation..so as u said , now it is time to support nakku..BINGO!!..he must stand by her and should also go against kala ..that would be worth watching!! 😆