why is pragya responsible?

Page

Next Last

ann5

@ann5

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

it is being said that pragya is responsible for raj bhaya staying in jail...I really would like to know how was that her responsibility...when she got to know mitali was the one who wronged raj...she told her to tell the truth and get raj bhaya released...didn't she not...it was and still is mitali doing and responsibility...right after pragya got set up in the mms drama...so why all this blame on her,,,did she sign the papers and got him jailed...

Quote

Frequent Posters

-Nive-

@-Nive-

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

People hold her responsible because she is a good person. A good person wouldn't let another good person suffer for a mistake they didn't do.

P.S. I don't hold her responsible. But just gave reasoning for that point of view.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

nitarata

@nitarata

Achiever

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

No one said she is responsible for Raj Bhaiyya going to jail. But deffo had a part in staying there. She knew he was completely innocent but decided to not tell that truth to anyone. That's irresponsibility. It's a responsibility of a citizen (family member) to speak up against a fraud/crime. It's not like Pragya was threatened to not speak up.

Imagine how would you feel if Abhi knew Pragya is innocent in MMS and still let her suffer the blame? How come Pragya was so happy Abhi helped to prove her innocent but she did not do it for Bhaiyya? She should know better than anyone what it is to take a false blame and the happiness of getting cleared of it.

Edited by -Tia- - 9 years ago

Quote

ShaNchi

@ShaNchi

Voyager

Posted: 9 years ago

Ann, there is a gap after the MMS and the kidnapping track..

In that gap Pragya might have told the truth to Abhi reg Raj Bhaiya, he will certainly believe that and do something for him or atleast she can tell that to Raj.. In that way she is also responsible because only Mithali and Pragya knows about Raj at that time..

Aliya and Tanu no use so I am ignoring them

Quote

Zaalima_5

@Zaalima_5

Sparkler

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: nive_kb
People hold her responsible because she is a good person. A good person wouldn't let another good person suffer for a mistake they didn't do.
P.S. I don't hold her responsible. But just gave reasoning for that point of view.

yes.. but good people also hides truth for some good reason..😆

Edited by kulsum_5 - 9 years ago

Quote

nitarata

@nitarata

Achiever

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

It was Mitali's duty to tell truth. But Mitali is evil. If you say just because Mitali didn't say, Pragya also shoudln't say, then what is the difference between Pragya and Mitali?

Anyways, Pragya was not shown as a person who uses stuff for her benefits before. She fought Abhi/Aakash for Rachna.. a virtuous person she was. Now she didn't spill beans about Raj Bhaiyya's arrest until it came to her lover/husband where he was blaming everything on Abhi.

Quote

Cerealgirl

@Cerealgirl

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

It's not Pragya's responsibility. It's Mitali's and her parents. Pragya does not need to do everyone else's job. Why didn't Raj's own parents help their son? Why not dadi? There are so many elders in the family who could have looked into the case and got a good lawyer. They could have done what Aliya finally did and got Raj out. People change. Priorities change. i'm glad Pragya is changing. I wish she became more selfish!! People wouldn't expect much from her then.

Quote

nitarata

@nitarata

Achiever

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Cerealgirl
It's not Pragya's responsibility. It's Mitali's and her parents. Pragya does not need to do everyone else's job. Why didn't Raj's own parents help their son? Why not dadi? There are so many elders in the family who could have looked into the case and got a good lawyer. They could have done what Aliya finally did and got Raj out. People change. Priorities change. i'm glad Pragya is changing. I wish she became more selfish!! People wouldn't expect much from her then.

None of them know the truth other than Mitali, who herself was the one to put Raj in jail. Pragya is not expected to being Raj out. She owes it to tell the truth to someone, at least police. It's a different matter if Raj can still not be released.

Edited by -Tia- - 9 years ago

Quote

ann5

@ann5

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

yes pragya would go tell the truth to the police as to why raj is in jail because of what mitali did...then mitali would end up in jail and yet still pragya will get the blame for spilling the beans...and making mitali children now suffer without a mother,...and yet again she will be labelled an insensitive...senseless person...it seems no matter what pragya do or don't do she will always get the blame and the fault...

Quote

Raji

@Raji9

Dazzler

Posted: 9 years ago

#10

First of all, Pragya has no evidence to prove Raj is iinocent and Mithali is culprit . "Not to forget Pragya went to police station with suresh and took the complaint back .. So she has done her part ".Every time knowing truth cannot give all the power to help. She needs not to do every one's duty .. She is not responsible ..

And from legal perspective , The signatures were still Raj's signatures .She can send Mithali to jail but cannot save Raj from the case ..