||Aaliya Mehra/Shikha Singh AT#1|| Main rockstar Abhi ki behen hoon! - Page 53

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

140.1k

Users

60

Likes

1.5k

Frequent Posters

-mina- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
I want the AT to be an exclusive space for Aaliya and Shikha fans. Everything you have pointed out is valid; none of those opinions should stop you from posting here. What I would like is for everyone to be an Aaliya/Shikha fan first when you are here. Fan feelings for other characters and actors should not be foregrounded here. But you are right, that is a preference. At the end of the day there is no rule that forbids expressing positive thoughts about other characters or expressing preference for other characters or framing discussion in terms of other characters. My emphasis continues to be that this is an Aaliya/Shikha thread and conversation should be framed in terms of the topic person as much as possible. ATs are supposed to be narrow and strict in scope. That is what differentiates them from open threads.
nitarata thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
I was just checking back my posts here, I have not really posted on Aaliyah as a character after around she threw stones at Abhi (that was my point of giving up on her redemption for now). I did involve a bit on the discussion as in how and when Aalu would redeem that was started by another person. Other than that I have focussed on Shikha and havent tried to initiate discussions on Aalu!
And I have made edits and posted them here and there.

Aalu-Abhi edtis I have made previously too and I see that some of mine and others are used in the first page of this AT too.

Likewise, today in the honor of Raksha bandhan, I made couple of edits, celebrating (mourning) those two. And I find it so hard and sad to believe that a positive comment for another character to encourage positivity for Aaliyah as a reply to one of those edits brings up rules into picture.


Edited by -Tia- - 10 years ago
-mina- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
Rules are always in the picture and they exist for a reason. They form the structure upon which all of our interactions on this site are built on. We have had a lot of informality in this thread and in this forum and created a warm social reality for ourselves. However ultimately by being on India-forums we are actually bound by its rules. In past instances we may have fallen into the habit of collectively ignoring them. I personally have benefitted from the latitude allowed by people not being strict about the rules. But nonetheless I believe it is important to be aware of them and operate within them. I understand this does not create the most welcoming environment. I favour being correct to being welcoming for its own sake.
nitarata thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
Is it mentioned anywhere that talking positive about another character to hope for positivity for the AT character is breaking rules?
..FuggyMehra.. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

can someone tell me whats the issue here ..please

---> dont say Aliya is bad
--->dont say abhi deserve better
--->dont post edits describing her character !

i m so lost😳

-mina- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: I-Told-U-So


can someone tell me whats the issue here ..please

---> dont say Aliya is bad
--->dont say abhi deserve better
--->dont post edits describing her character !

i m so lost😳


You are welcome to read through the last few pages and see exactly what has been discussed. The issue is: this is an Aaliya/Shikha AT, and everything that is said here should emphasize Aaliya/Shikha more than other characters.
-mina- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: jyoti06

Dedicated Appreciation threads (ATs) for celebrities across all Zee TV sub-forums will be subject to specific rules here onwards.

  • The word "Appreciate" it self means to have a highly favorable opinion of someone or something. You are supposed to appraise the value of the work of the actors and express them in positive light. A thread where all the fans of the Actor/Character/Couple gather to discuss what they liked.


  • In an essence Constructive criticism/Positive Outlook towards Actors/Characters/Jodi must prevail in these threads.


  • Members must understand discussions are restricted in ATs. ATs are safe zones for the Actor/Jodi fans to exchange information without being subject to negativity. You have the main forum to present opinions negatively and debate...So Discussion of actors/ characters/ performances and story tracks that do not directly relate to the show or whom the AT is dedicated to should be kept to a minimum, in particular when they imply stating negative opinions. However we are allowing harmless Chit-chat in ATs but the chit-chat should be only limited to ATs only


Quoted from the forum rules, bold/italic/underline emphasis added by me.

No, it does not say specifically "that talking positive about another character to hope for positivity for the AT character is breaking rules". It does say that the point of the AT is to talk in positive ways about its dedicated subject - and conversation on all other points should be minimal. This includes analyzing other characters without direct and positive reference to the dedicated subject.
..FuggyMehra.. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: -mina-


You are welcome to read through the last few pages and see exactly what has been discussed. The issue is: this is an Aaliya/Shikha AT, and everything that is said here should emphasize Aaliya/Shikha more than other characters.



i read last few pages 3 times already 😆 either my english is super bad or i m just sleepy cox u guys make no sense😆
we r talking about Aliya ..who is Aliya Abhi's sister. we talk n care about her cox she is his sister.How is her character... negative.and thats why we love her. what is today rakshabandhan.who wants Aliya as a sister..no one..who successfully made us believe that shikha /Aliya ..
None of those were negative from my POV.those r all appreciation.
by saying ''abhi deserve better'' no one is saying she is any less important then abhi.
If apprenticing means only saying ''OMG I LOVE HER'' 😆 '' whatever she does i blindly support her'' then yaar negative characters should not hv an AT 😕 thats send negative message to kids ..that we r apprenticing negative person 😆
i will join that AT though 🤣

Edited by I-Told-U-So - 10 years ago
-mina- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: I-Told-U-So


i read last few pages 3 times already 😆 its either my english is super bad or i m just sleepy cox u guys make no sense😆
we r talking about Aliya ..who is Aliya Abhi's sister. we talk n care about her cox she is his sister.How is her character... negative.and that why we love her. what is today rakshabandhan.who wants Aliya as a sister..no one..who successfully made us believe that shikha /Aliya ..
None of those were negative from my POV.those r all appreciation.
by saying ''abhi deserve better'' no one is saying she is any less important then abhi.
If apprenticing means only saying ''OMG I LOVE HER'' 😆 '' whatever she does i blindly support her'' then yaar negative characters should not hv an AT 😕 thats send negative message to kids ..that we r apprenticing negative person 😆
i will join that AT though 🤣


No, but you are talking about what Abhi deserves, which is not the point of the Aaliya AT. The point of the Aaliya AT is to talk about what Aaliya deserves.

And in this thread, we do not talk about her because she is someone's sister or granddaughter or whatever. We talk about her because she exists and we are interested in her, prima facie, in and of herself. If you are attached to her or interested in her because of another character that is great, but the point of a dedicated AT is for the people are specifically fans of the dedicated topic to gather and talk specifically and centrally about them.
nitarata thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
-Abhi directly relates to Aaliyah on the rakshabandhan day! Hence I made an edit with a hope that perhaps the biggest relationship in Aalu's life improves. The comment that followed was for that edit, to further emphasize some way to have a better Aalu.

Today is the big day for Aaliyah to pray for Abhi and Abhi to make a promise to protect Aaliyah. And it is celebrated in a big way in the culture that the soap portrays and some parts of the country.

Did this warrant a rule reminder? Because the rules do not state any objection and the rest of the reasoning is subjective judgement/extrapolation.

Let's not forget Aaliyah is an out and out negative character.

Related Topics

Kumkum Bhagya Thumbnail

Posted by: Changers

27 days ago

Abhi Pragya should have bring for final episode - stupid Zee TV 😡

What the hell is wrong with Zee? Kumkum Bhagya is their only show in the last decade which started with 1.4TRP and touched 7.2 TRP in less than...

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".