||Aaliya Mehra/Shikha Singh AT#1|| Main rockstar Abhi ki behen hoon! - Page 54

Hello everybody!
Can I say i understand view points of both sides. I think what Mina is trying to say that the discussion in this AT should be primarily about Aliya and her thoughts and feelings should be given primary importance rather than what other characters feel because of her actions.

And Tia is right too, coz aliya is a negative character with no shades of grey left , and while some may feel ok with her negative traits, many of us can't just appreciate her actions because we cannot relate to her so some criticism may take place

I think criticism and analyses of aliya's actions is bound happen to at this point but may be we can refrain from discussing feelings of other characters as the consequences of her actions.

I accidently peep in here...hot discussion is going on...it's difficult to appreciate a negative character...but I love Shikha as an actor...she has every features for a rockstar sister...she has that aura...I really want her to change for a good...I want to see their genuine bhai behen bonding...not fake one...(its difficult to talk about Aliya without mention Abhi...Its like talking about something without mentioning it)

Originally posted by: Memyself09

Hello everybody!
Can I say i understand view points of both sides. I think what Mina is trying to say that the discussion in this AT should be primarily about Aliya and her thoughts and feelings should be given primary importance rather than what other characters feel because of her actions.

And Tia is right too, coz aliya is a negative character with no shades of grey left , and while some may feel ok with her negative traits, many of us can't just appreciate her actions because we cannot relate to her.

I think criticism and analyses of aliya's actions is bound happen to at this point but may be we can refrain from discussing feelings of other characters as the consequences of her actions.

Originally posted by: nilmi

I accidently peep in here...hot discussion is going on...it's difficult to appreciate a negative character...but I love Shikha as an actor...she has every features for a rockstar sister...she has that aura...I really want her to change for a good...I want to see their genuine bhai behen bonding...not fake one...(its difficult to talk about Aliya without mention Abhi...Its like talking about something without mentioning it)

Originally posted by: nilmi

I accidently peep in here...hot discussion is going on...it's difficult to appreciate a negative character...but I love Shikha as an actor...she has every features for a rockstar sister...she has that aura...I really want her to change for a good...I want to see their genuine bhai behen bonding...not fake one...(its difficult to talk about Aliya without mention Abhi...Its like talking about something without mentioning it)

Originally posted by: -Tia-

This is the thing though right. Bhai is a HUGE part of her life.
Why can't we wish for her to better for her Bhai if she can't better for herself?

Yes it's great to wish she betters for herself, just that some of us see her beyond that point with her having not cared about the lives and deaths of her people.

Originally posted by: -mina-

Because this is not the thread about making wishes for her bhai.

Guys, what about Mina's explanations is not clear? She has spent a good 30 minutes on what the focus of this AT should be.

1. This is not an Abhi thread.
2. This is not a thread for focus on Abhi and what Aaliyah should or should not do for Abhi
3. Aaliyah is the focus of this thread
4. Any subjective discussions are best discussed in an open thread on the forum.
5. An AT has specific focus and specific rules.

She has outlined this a dozen different ways.
You have the whole forum to post anything you want that is subjective and what Aaliyah should or shouldn't do for Abhi falls under that realm.

TINAAA

Does Aliyah even care about Raksha Bandhan at the moment???

Her credit cards are blocked at the moment...she is out of moneyyy 😆

And Aliyah needs some special prayer sessions...Dadi and Daasi sitting in temple for days praying for her redemption 😛

Dee, no one discussed exclusively about Abhi here today.