Dreams Vs. Desires - Page 2

Poll

why are we supporting Nidhi dreams??

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

2.4k

Users

7

Likes

43

Frequent Posters

nandinidavid96 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#11

Yes, she has the right to make her choice and live her dreams and personally even I want her to grow serious on career instead of excitement about profession. But here it is not of her choice alone as marriage is a mutual agreement, As you rightly said onus cannot be on One and one sided but it is in this case...I mean to say the decision is not Mutual..

My only reason behind the post is to know where is this inclination for Nidhi stemming from??? (Professional Interest). Coz, often we tend to mix our personal choices with the characters ignoring the personality traits of the character.

Btw, I think DB has not injected but stirred hidden desires. I personally want both Ashu and Nidhi to fulfill heir desires with a sensible discussion instead of fixing random time period.




Sujatha.rao thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Armu4eva


Thurst upon?? 😆

When did that happen?? She was wondering.. if he will approve or not.. if he will feel bad or not.. n hesitatingly .. she asked him for those 2 years... ! I dun think its thrust upon. n even if it is.. i dun think there is one marriage in this world where.. both partners always discuss things and everything goes as per mutual consent..!

There is always an element where one partner has a bigger say in something than another one..! Eventually both learn to move to common ground n make peace with it!



Come on, Tanu...let us not kid ourselves by imagining his wholehearted consent was obtained...she had him cornered there and he was left with no choice...I am not questioning the legitimacy of her desires...I would never do that...all I am saying, and I maintain it, is that instead of just coming up with a time frame based on whatever Shyama told her, the couple could have had a discussion...even fought over it...and then finally arrived at a solution...that is how it happens in real life...

You may be right in saying that all things don't happen by mutual consent...but wherever they don't, there is resentment and the seeds of dissension are sown...


Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: nandininandu



Yes, she has the right to make her choice and live her dreams and personally even I want her to grow serious on career instead of excitement about profession. But here it is not of her choice alone as marriage is a mutual agreement, As you rightly said onus cannot be on One and one sided but it is in this case...I mean to say the decision is not Mutual..

My only reason behind the post is to know where is this inclination for Nidhi stemming from??? (Professional Interest). Coz, often we tend to mix our personal choices with the characters ignoring the personality traits of the character.

Btw, I think DB has not injected but stirred hidden desires. I personally want both Ashu and Nidhi to fulfill heir desires with a sensible discussion instead of fixing random time period.




Did .. Ashu ask Nidhis consent.. to have Mallu home??? from the Hosp??? No ... it was much after the DB showdown that he so much as bothered to do so... wasnt that THRUST UPON???? 😆

I m intrigued with how much the fact that after ages a show is giving the female lead an upper hand has stirred the resentment in many ... be it FB or IF ..! Women empowerment?? lolz!! Nyways... to each their own..! [N i mean no offense. .so pls..hope u will not tk it personally]😊

DB has injected the idea...!! We all have dormant desires which come to fore on certain stiumulus and that has been provided by DB... never before the party kept after Mallu left did the thot of having a family even cross Ashus head...! 😊

Nidhis characteristic trait is.. she does things on impulse... she will take up career.. do it.. n if something else comes up. totally ignore it... thats her persona..!


Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Sujatha.rao



Come on, Tanu...let us not kid ourselves by imagining his wholehearted consent was obtained...she had him cornered there and he was left with no choice...I am not questioning the legitimacy of her desires...I would never do that...all I am saying, and I maintain it, is that instead of just coming up with a time frame based on whatever Shyama told her, the couple could have had a discussion...even fought over it...and then finally arrived at a solution...that is how it happens in real life...

You may be right in saying that all things don't happen by mutual consent...but wherever they don't, there is resentment and the seeds of dissension are sown...



If whole hearted.. consent was not given.. whole hearted rejection was not given either.. so we interpret situation based on our own assumption ... u have ur set of assumptions .. i have mine..!

May be.. today we can have a follow up to the scene.. maybe.. Nidhi discusses why she wants 2 years.. n not 10 or 1 year.. etc...! Lets see..! For me.. she is right.. n shall support her to the hilt.. thru it!
nandinidavid96 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Armu4eva



He has been supported to the hilt ... till 42 (when he meets Nidhi) he had no desire in life.. no need for love.. etc etc... n in just one year.. he wants the world.. ! Agree.. 'our wants are unending' but his desire is not justifiable.. in my view..!

Further.. its not something that comes from him. .it came from a trigger... it was dormant till this day..despite the fact that he always loved kids.. always loved the childrens ward more. even before Nidhi came in his life.. 😊


Agreed he never had any dreams till 42 and spent a barren life, but it doesn't mean one shouldn't have dreams or desires in the life afterwards. If you take your post in right spirit, even Nidhi never had career dreams or seriousness about profession, she is the one who choose to quit KGH when given the chance way before he has removed her.

Btw, I got my answer, as you're personally career oriented, and see career as an identity you're supporting her dreams. Thank You

Sujatha.rao thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#16





Did .. Ashu ask Nidhis consent.. to have Mallu home??? from the Hosp??? No ... it was much after the DB showdown that he so much as bothered to do so... wasnt that THRUST UPON???? 😆




The answer is there in your own post...don't we know the problems that ensued because of his unilateral decision...does this not underline the need for mutual consent even more...should the couple keep repeating their mistakes...you have done your share and now it is my turn!
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: nandininandu

Agreed he never had any dreams till 42 and spent a barren life, but it doesn't mean one shouldn't have dreams or desires in the life afterwards. If you take your post in right spirit, even Nidhi never had career dreams or seriousness about profession, she is the one who choose to quit KGH when given the chance way before he has removed her.

Nidhis persona has been such.. she is flippant.. n now that she wants to do something with her career.. shuld she be deined that opp ... based on past track?? She quit bcoz she felt she wasnt made for the career... but once she found her calling she stayed on.. till Ashu did the needful..! 😊


Btw, I got my answer, as you're personally career oriented, and see career as an identity you're supporting her dreams. Thank You

Indeed n proud to be so! 😳


Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#18

Did .. Ashu ask Nidhis consent.. to have Mallu home??? from the Hosp??? No ... it was much after the DB showdown that he so much as bothered to do so... wasnt that THRUST UPON???? 😆




The answer is there in your own post...don't we know the problems that ensued because of his unilateral decision...does this not underline the need for mutual consent even more...should the couple keep repeating their mistakes...you have done your share and now it is my turn!

Firstly . its not unilateral decision ... n even if it is.. every decision has its consequences.. it was indeed needed to give Ashu a wake up call .. per say his bestie n this track gave.. his almost blinding belief n faith on Mallu was rudely broken .. ..!

Again as i said.. its how u interpret it..! Glass is either half full or half empty!
Sujatha.rao thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Armu4eva


Did .. Ashu ask Nidhis consent.. to have Mallu home??? from the Hosp??? No ... it was much after the DB showdown that he so much as bothered to do so... wasnt that THRUST UPON???? 😆




The answer is there in your own post...don't we know the problems that ensued because of his unilateral decision...does this not underline the need for mutual consent even more...should the couple keep repeating their mistakes...you have done your share and now it is my turn!

Firstly . its not unilateral decision ... n even if it is.. every decision has its consequences.. it was indeed needed to give Ashu a wake up call .. per say his bestie n this track gave.. his almost blinding belief n faith on Mallu was rudely broken .. ..!

Again as i said.. its how u interpret it..! Glass is either half full or half empty!


Yes Tanu...I too think it is all a matter of perspective 😊
Sujatha.rao thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Armu4eva


If whole hearted.. consent was not given.. whole hearted rejection was not given either.. so we interpret situation based on our own assumption ... u have ur set of assumptions .. i have mine..!

May be.. today we can have a follow up to the scene.. maybe.. Nidhi discusses why she wants 2 years.. n not 10 or 1 year.. etc...! Lets see..! For me.. she is right.. n shall support her to the hilt.. thru it!



For me, I think both of them are wrong...and they will realize it sooner or later!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".