Nidhi's Father is a Selfish Man - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

1.4k

Users

8

Likes

35

Frequent Posters

ritu3kumar thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: mudraswathi



CB clearly said, he is not against love marriage...he is against age-gap marriage..

and he does have all the authority to have his beliefs until he is proved wrong... Unfortunately, neither Mandira's husband nor Ashutosh did that noble work. Never Nidhi revealed why she loves Ashutosh to her father.. of course she didnt even discuss with Ashutosh even ..(for all the reasons that she only knows)


but love is love either age gap or not .
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#12
Disagree with ur post ...

Originally posted by: mudraswathi

No.

When he was young, he married a girl of his choice without her father's consent.. true. But he did go to that father later and BB was the one never reestablished the relation.. to the extent, Ashutosh never knew about Nandini (I guess this is the name)

U come to a girl who is barely studying.. and just say.. one fine day ..lets get hitched and then return to her father expecting acceptance.. lmao.. . WHAT HAPPENED TO SAMAJ ke tane?? Reet Reevaj??? 😆


He had accepted the house ..because it was given to his daughter.. not to him.. no where we have the proof what he would have done, if the house was given to him.. so cannot say he is selfish.


This i agree... 😳 He has kept it as a dharohar.. till his daughter is mature enouf to take a decision on it..


When his daughter wanted to marry a person ( though has got a very high reputation as a doctor) double her age, not only samaj, whatever point DB raised for Mandira were 100% true. No one can deny the age factor or the mental age-gap factor... This Ashutosh never had clarified his stand about their relationship to Col Verma. All that he did was, the confrontation at Kerala... I do agree, he supported Mandira, but in his own case, he has not clarified his POV... Ashutosh and Nidhi also never discussed to each other about their relationship in the family's / samaj's POV

I think... he said WHILE defending Mandy that... 'Mandy is balig n has right to choose her partner.. n samaj cannot force her otherwise' ... infact the Confrontation in Kerala was totally uncharacteristic of the Ashu of earlier times...


Rahi baat believing Mansukhani blindly , such tracks have not come yet, so till the time CVs get time to come out of the current crap, I dont know what to comment.

Not come up?? Erm... thats the point.. CVs ka presentation... n even before that.. has he ever bothered to investigate the supplier of the lower quality material... before the heartattack also ?? 😆

His daughter soldoff Ashu's dream house... She frantically tried to reach him... It was Ashu's turn that time to be stupid... Also, when she sold off the house, Col.Verma had no idea.. remember he was lying on the bed with heart attack.

Its ok.. she sold the house.. all dutiful daughter should do that.. but what about after that?? Wheres the remorse.. or the grief of having made his daughter sell her Nanas amanat (if not Ashus dream)

Edited by Armu4eva - 13 years ago
mudraswathi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Armu4eva

Disagree with ur post ...


U come to a girl who is barely studying.. and just say.. one fine day ..lets get hitched and then return to her father expecting acceptance.. lmao.. . WHAT HAPPENED TO SAMAJ ke tane?? Reet Reevaj??? 😆

CB says, he is not against love marriage... thats because he did the same may be.. but against age-gap marriage .. in which he said about samaj ka reet rivaaz..



Rahi baat believing Mansukhani blindly , such tracks have not come yet, so till the time CVs get time to come out of the current crap, I dont know what to comment.

Not come up?? Erm... thats the point.. CVs ka presentation... n even before that.. has he ever bothered to investigate the supplier of the lower quality material... before the heart attack also ?? 😆

I guess he was worried with the Mark's visit and he suffered heart attack immediately...
Later episodes never covered Mansukhani...as far as I remember... yes.. there could have been some dialogues nevertheless.

Its ok.. she sold the house.. all dutiful daughter should do that.. but what about after that?? Wheres the remorse.. or the grief of having made his daughter sell her Nanas amanat (if not Ashus dream)

If I am sure he said so... some time during the hospital I vaguely remember. But I agree there should have been more such dialogues to show his remorse.

Edited by mudraswathi - 13 years ago
Krrish4You thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#14
Well i dnt think baba is selfish.. He hs done so much for nidhi when she lost her mom..:( he ws nidhi's single parent. He hs given her wat she wanted as a child or when she grew as adult. Remember baba ws in army despite that nidhi-baba relationship as daughter-Dad hs been great... Nidhi took full care of baba when his gt HA, she even went on to sell the house which belonged to ashu & actually wanted to gift him. Its only When nidhi revealed her for ashu to baba.. That's the time baba stopped supporting her rishta only on purpose of nt getting bad name in strict samajh of the city they live in..
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: mudraswathi





CB says, he is not against love marriage... thats because he did the same may be.. but against age-gap marriage .. in which he said about samaj ka reet rivaaz..

In fact Mudra.. u urself had counted.. that CV n Nidhis moms is as good as an age gap marriage with atleast 14 yrs ka gap..!!

Ok leave this aside.. tell me why he din encourage her to finish her studies after marriage 😆




I guess he was worried with the Mark's visit and he suffered heart attack immediately...
Later episodes never covered Mansukhani...as far as I remember... yes.. there could have been some dialogues nevertheless.

Why not.. there was atleast 2-3 minutes ka scene Mansukhani n Baba contemplating what to do... Anjie aware of the material locha... why no sixth sense.. why no contemplation?? 😉



If I am sure he said so... some time during the hospital I vaguely remember. But I agree there should have been more such dialogues to show his remorse.

Yes dialogues of genuine remorse are much needed...

Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: ithasme


That's the time baba stopped supporting her rishta only on purpose of nt getting bad name in strict samajh of the city they live in..



That itself shows how selfish he is... more concerned with the samaj ka khokhla izzat than his daughters real happiness! 😳
mudraswathi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Armu4eva


CB says, he is not against love marriage... thats because he did the same may be.. but against age-gap marriage .. in which he said about samaj ka reet rivaaz..

In fact Mudra.. u urself had counted.. that CV n Nidhis moms is as good as an age gap marriage with atleast 14 yrs ka gap..!!

Ok leave this aside.. tell me why he din encourage her to finish her studies after marriage 😆




@blue
😆 😆 when I pointed out that age-gap of CB's, you quoted ' hum umr... some thing ' dialogue of Baba's.. I simply took it and deleted the tick against his age-gap romance issue mentally...

@black
Was that the issue stopping Nidhi to marry Ashutosh from CB's side?.. I think we can argue at some other post about it.😊

Edited by mudraswathi - 13 years ago
Krrish4You thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#18
@Tanu: he is worried abt his izzazt no doubt.. Bt fears nidhi will hv to will in shame(From samajh's taane) as age gap rishta with dr.ashu..
dkfan thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#19
Thanks to the makers, every character in this show refuses to communicate/ convince/ confront. So, it becomes very convenient for anyone of us to have our own POVs!

Though i'd not term nidhi's father as selfish,I wud however say that he's just being most inconsiderate towards his daughter and has not justified his relationship as a friendly-father.😒




Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: mudraswathi


@blue
😆 😆 when I pointed out that age-gap of CB's, you quoted ' hum umr... some thing ' dialogue of Baba's.. I simply took it and deleted the tick against his age-gap romance issue mentally...

Yeah... me jus saying what u had said earlier.. 😆 ( that hum-umar thing DB had said during the engagement epi.. n Nidhi -family showdown)

@black
Was that the issue stopping Nidhi to marry Ashutosh from CB's side?.. I think we can argue at some other post about it.😊

yes.. that was jus a random diversion...!


nyways for me not only is he selfish.. he is Weak too 😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".