Is Nidhi Betraying Ashutosh's Trust in Her?????

Mehek25 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
Since yestersday's epiosde has been aired almost all of us have been venting our anger at Nidhi and saying to all our friends and to ourselves also how Nidhi could do this to Ashutosh...We have seen that Ashu has kept his promise of supporting her but now it is Nidhi who is chickening out and is not prepared to face the situation...Or should I say she is running away from reality????

I agree that Nidhi did not keep up to her promise/determination to fight for her love...But if we see the turn of events in the story we can empathise with her predicament...Here is a girl who had always been supported by her family (Baba and DB) in all her decisions...and who was confident that because they loved her dearly they would ultimately get round to her way of thinking about the age-gap and would sooner or later support her in this decision...But seeing how adamant DB was in mandira's case and also how her Baba had been powerless in the face od DB's opposition...even though he had wanted to accept Mandira...

Nidhi has two choices left to her...1) She does what Mandira did and marries Ashu against her Bab and DB's wishes and breaks all ties with them...Or ...2) she bows down to their wishes and breaks up with Ashutosh...

If she chooses the first option she will not only be letting down the two people who love her the most...(even though to us they are unreasonable)...But will be leaving them to face the taunts of society all by themselves...Would it be fair of her to have them treated in this way????? If she sees only her happiness she would not bother about them...But by having her do so The Cvs would be turning Nidhi into a selfish and self-centered girl who puts her happiness before that of those who love her...

The second option is harsh not only on Ashu but on herself too...She has now fallen so deep into this abyss (called love) that it would not only be difficult but even impossible for her to find happiness in this life...No doubt she is not the only one who will be suffering...Ashu also will be suffering with her...He has experienced love so late in his life that he is now finding it very difficult to even visualise a life without Nidhi...

So considering these two options what can they do????? Go against the elders and societal norms and get married and live happily ever after????? But if they do this will they be able to 'live happily ever after'? Will Nidhi be happy knowing her Baba is going thru so much at the hands of society? Will Ashu be happy knowing Nidhi is unhappy because of her Baba's unhappiness?

In both the options the end result is unhappiness...In one it is unhappiness because ur family is unhappy and in the other it is unhappiness because of being unable to live with ur loved one...

In yesterday's episode one dialogue which Nidhi told Anjie summed up this whole traumatic turn of events...Nidhi telling Anjie u were against this from the beginning...U knew what would happen...But I did not listen to u...Shows that whatever has happened was not foreseen by her...Ashu on the other hand had foreseen this turn of events but had given into his feelings ultimately...Had he not been pressurised by Arman initially into accepting his love maybe the story would have been different...He would have been reticent in accepting his love and maybe then Nidhi would not have fallen so deeply in love...

But all these are IFs and life always has something else in store for us...which we are totally unaware of...The only solution to this is a change in Baba's outlook towards this whole age-gap thing...Yesterday he said I can force u Nidhi but can't fight society...That is totally wrong thinking on his part...If he truly loves his daughter he should see where her happiness lies and support her...Instead he is willing to see her unhappy but not be brave enough to face society...

One question I would like to ask to society is...Why are people so interested ion other people's lives????? Why can't others live their lives in the way they want????? Why should society force people to live the way it (society) thinks is the correct way?????

In my opinion it is Baba's character that has been butchered...For his false pride and even more false values (what we say ijn Hindi 'khokhle adarsh')...he is condemning his only and beloved daughter to a life time of unhappiness...KLoved Ashu's dialogue to baab...u are only better than the rest of those fathers who resort to honour killing in that u have not sentenced ur daughter to death but to life imprisonment....

Sorry for the long and probably boring post but felt I had to share my views on this...If I am wrong in my thinking then please feel free share ur views also...

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

1.8k

Users

15

Likes

63

Frequent Posters

jayanti_dj thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
gr8 analysis mehek..
agree wid ya..
nidhi should have socho pehle.. how could she be so stupid?
ashu fell in love wid her knowin that he is in for a tuf ride.. he was n is ready 2 face d world for sumthin he wants.. he thought nidhi was 2 ..but he over estimated her ... after d voilin date ,while havin coffee ,he said ur a tuf girl.. she was she said.. but now we n ashu know she is not..
she gave in widout a fight..i would have had sympathy for her ,if she atleast tried.. know its her haar from both the sides but now she is regrettin fallin in love wid ashu...as is obvious from her convo wid anji last night...
as for d samaj, they love 2 adao taang in other ppl lives. for eg, relatives are more interested in matchmakin than the parents themselves...they need to gossip yaar.. otherwise their wont be anythin 2 talk abt ...
mudraswathi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
Mehek,
nice post.. but long ago KTLK story writers have lost the 'logical thinking ' path...
whatever is shown is beyond anybody's imagination and never happens this way...even in the extreme conditions in the present day scenario...

I have lost interest in the seriousness part of the story...KTLK has become a good base for spoofs.
Krrish4You thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
@Mehek: wow! Superb post..yaar, totally agree with ur each word..:) nothing more to add..:)
rabzonedge thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#5

Mehek.Great Analysis and Post...

Nidhi is in dilemma..no doubt..

Torn between Love for family and Ashu No Doubt...

But her dealing with this confusion is not going down well with me...

She is not the Gal..Who loved Ashu...Ashu Asked her to Back Off and she Laughed it out...Even during House track..when Ashu came back realising his undying love for Nidhi and said lets start afresh from where we left..Nidhi said-Aapne choda hoga maine nahi'...This was the Nidhi we knew...

Nidhi's character is loosing sympathy because she is ready to break off with Ashu without even Trying to Convince Baba for once...If then also Baba Disapproved AshNi's relation..she going ahead with Baba's decision is atleast believable..but in that situation also she should be telling Baba that she is breaking off with Ashu but she will not marry any other Guy also..She will be a spinster..That way she will be able to justify both her role of Lover and Daughter...


SwastikAshNi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
I understand Nidhi was very much convinced about getting Family permission after a little fight otherwise if she decided to move ahead with this relation,she would be the first one to escape with Ashu selflessly.But as of now,she has to face it-may be needs some more time to take the decision to go with Ashu.Otherwise it would be unfair.She definitely deserves last chance but what is bothering me that her kid like surrender.It's pathetic.
fiona18 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

Mehek KTLK unpredictable 😆

Edited by fiona18 - 13 years ago
AbhiAni thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
The only problem i have with Nidhi is She has not discussed her promise to her father with Ashu and poor fellow has not been given a chance to understand/discuss/find other alternatives😡 and on the top of it she is expecting the same thing from Ashu😡🤢
chumki... thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
ab to sach me yehi kehna parega jo malliqa kabhi kaha karti the" aajkal ke generetion". woh hur kaam bina soche samjhe ker to lete hai lekin us kaam ko anjaam dene ke liye jo larai larni parti hai woh nahi lar pate, nidhi humesha se janti thi ki unka relation itni asani se accepted nahi hoga... phir what happen now? u r right that she will suffer a lot, either she will face depression, or become a hardstone, lekin phir bhi she will not get any synpatthy from anyone? as per ashu he knows whatever nidhi's dicision is it for her baba, he will stay away from her, he will suffer neither he will get marriad to mallu nor he hate nidhi coz what ever he is doing it's for her only

but d billion dollar question is it's a love-story of ashni... aur aaj nahi to kal woh phir se milenge aur ek dusre ki taraf khicte rahenge kyon ki they both love eachother madly crazyly... phir kya hoga... kyon ki ashu ki ek baat bilqul sahi hai" unke rishte ko zindagi ne chuna hai isiliye woh sath hi jeeyenge" chahe insaan kitni bhi koshish ker le... lekin itna sab kuch hone ke baad kya ashu dobara nidhi pe yaqeen ker payeega? in fact kya nidhi khud ko ashu ke pyaar ke kabil samajh payeegi... then what next?

vyalikaval thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
According to me col. Vermas family is not and ashu has no family at all. They are not any royal family.They should not blow the trumpet of Khandan Ijjat etc .Col. verma should remember that when he had Heart attack by doing rash and negligent act in his business it is Nidhi who came to his resque and lost a beautiful property gifted by her grand father. Whewther he is a father or God he should not forget that he is living today because of Nidhi. Col verma dont do injustice to Dr Ashtosh

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".