Inconsistency or effort at pacification? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

28

Views

1.7k

Users

13

Likes

104

Frequent Posters

Meera_Ka_Mohan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: SandyAquarius

The night before, Dev tells Sona that he cannot see her cry as her tears hurt his heart. And this morning her tears don't give him a pause.

What does it mean?

I have a very strong hunch that the scene between Dev and Sona (in red nightdress) was shot to pacify us, the viewers and it was shot after Erica returned from Xmas break while the rest of the scenes were canned before she left. When the fandom blew up on Sona's reaction to non-pregnancy and infertility news wherein she was completely obsessed with Ishwari's feelings and reactions rather than what a would-be mother would feel or a woman who can never have a child feels, the makers decided to rectify some damage but in the larger picture...how can the one scene salvage bad writing? How can a bandaid stem gushing blood from a deep wound?

So, that beautiful scene between Devakshi was an afterthought and hence the disconnect between what Dev says to Sona the night before and Dev does this morning where Ma-Bhakt Dev is only concerned for his mother and has no time for Sona's tears...

Therefore, I have a question for CVs...do Sona's tears really hurt Dev or was that scene/dialogue meant to pacify the fandom? If he meant it...why the inconsistency in Dev? This is such poor writing. Or has someone amongst you (CVs) ever met a man who simply never ever means anything he says even in the direst of situations?

I guess, I should be really thankful that I know no such people like Dev in real life.

P.S - I came to the conclusion because segments with Erica in white/Yellow dress and the temple segments with Erica were released pre-chirtsmas. But her red dress shoot clearly took place on the same day they received Best Jodi award and it was few days after christmas and by then the infertility episodes began airing and the feedback was bad due to Sona's obvious emotional disconnect with the baby and her only mantra was about her relationship with Ishwari.



Agree with you... felt the same... I mentioned this in another thread that friday's devakshi scenes looks like a dream scene, as Dev today was rude and insensitive towards Sonakshi.😡
Meera_Ka_Mohan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Tinkerfairy

you have pointed out valid point .there is reason Cv's have stopped giving us spoilers that much. right now we don't know what will be happening next. i have feeling they conveniently mould characters and situation according to viewer reactions , i suddenly felt weird how asha and saurabh suddenly started doing jaap about how mahaan their damad is, instead worrying how currently their daughter must be feeling.

Frankly it shows lack of trust they have in their story.

Also i dont know whether it's me only but when dev had planned doing treatment without sona's consent .that episode aired on friday .fans also started uproar about this. and on monday suddenly we have scene about how doctor refused to do any treatment .😕 sab locha hain



Well said... agree with you.

Also, Saurabh suddenly mentioning about the 5 crore help by Dev is a big let down by the CVs. Sonakshi and Saurabh had started this online business to prove themselves that they can achieve success without any one's help or influence. But what happened to the CVs suddenly? At least here we didn't wanted Dev's interference or help.😡 This was just to prove to Bijoy that Dev is a true gentleman??

But, after watching today's episode, Boses' self respect is hurt, so, I want Saurabh to return the money to Dev. They can't live with this burden. Dev is not a gentleman anymore...😡
Pehchaan.Kaun thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#13
Romance in closed doors means nothing when the man is not man enough to save her from the outside world cruelty.

Dev is the sissiest character ever. And literally.
dlavanya thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#14
There is diff -- it is not an after thought to pacify us.. it is just to show that dev always gets carried away when his mother is in pic... cvs know what they r doing...

So far, dev has always broken the promises he made to sona to keep his promises to ishwari.. so now we need to see if history repeats or dev will actually do something about it...

Just imagine... he just told sona that they r enugh for each other and they dont need a baby... now what will he tell her after coming back from temple... will his stand change .. now that his mom asked to make that jhoot sach.:. Will he push sona into treatments - will he announce it to her that they need to make a baby now or will they have a matured discussion and decide the course of action... that is what interests me .:: something tells me he is going to piss sona and bijoy offf to an extent of severe damage ..: wait and watch
HaiMiz thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Pehchaan.Kaun

Romance in closed doors means nothing when the man is not man enough to save her from the outside world cruelty.

Dev is the sissiest character ever. And literally.


I won't call Dev-Sona scene the night before as romance ...I think it is love. But I do agree with you that when you cannot protect your love from the cruelty of the world outside, it doesn't mean anything ultimately.
HaiMiz thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: dlavanya

There is diff -- it is not an after thought to pacify us.. it is just to show that dev always gets carried away when his mother is in pic... cvs know what they r doing...

So far, dev has always broken the promises he made to sona to keep his promises to ishwari.. so now we need to see if history repeats or dev will actually do something about it...

Just imagine... he just told sona that they r enugh for each other and they dont need a baby... now what will he tell her after coming back from temple... will his stand change .. now that his mom asked to make that jhoot sach.:. Will he push sona into treatments - will he announce it to her that they need to make a baby now or will they have a matured discussion and decide the course of action... that is what interests me .:: something tells me he is going to piss sona and bijoy offf to an extent of severe damage ..: wait and watch


I hope you are right...I hope their love wasn't an afterthought, as it is half the foundation on which this story stands. But more often than not, that half is compromised and forgotten and reduced to less than a third of the plot while Ishwari hogs 2/3rds the limelight.

And I also hope that you are right and Dev does piss off Sona. Because, this docile, MIL pleasing Sona is UNBEARABLE. I mean, being a good human being is a great intent. Wanting a good relationship with your in-laws is also a pretty common matter but not to the extent wherein one flushes one's own self-respect down the drain.

Waiting to watch a pissed off Sona...and a pissed off Sona who will not forgive Dev five minutes later just so they could move on to please Ishwari.


HaiMiz thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Meera_Ka_Mohan



Well said... agree with you.

Also, Saurabh suddenly mentioning about the 5 crore help by Dev is a big let down by the CVs. Sonakshi and Saurabh had started this online business to prove themselves that they can achieve success without any one's help or influence. But what happened to the CVs suddenly? At least here we didn't wanted Dev's interference or help.😡 This was just to prove to Bijoy that Dev is a true gentleman??

But, after watching today's episode, Boses' self respect is hurt, so, I want Saurabh to return the money to Dev. They can't live with this burden. Dev is not a gentleman anymore...😡


The whole 5 crore business is another matter that was added in a rushed fashion. If the CVs can manufacture Dev's mahanta with a one-liner dialogue...they can do the same with prenup with a simple flashback scene, where Ishwari would have made Sona sign the papers sneakily.

When writers begin to take their viewers for granted, the loopholes will becomes tear holes.
HaiMiz thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: Shlroy

Aapne ekdum sahi pakad liya hai. That scene was to pacify audience only becoz sona was only worried about ishu and that had disappointed all around among fans.

Also this also always happens that when it comes to ishwari dev tends to forget everything and everyone even right and wrong. So CVS figured that they will go in the same flow. But biggest question is when will it change????? And will it????


Our entire frustration stems for that right. We have waited 75 episodes to see the smallest kind of change in Dev and it is nowhere in sight. Change in Dev proves harder to find than Eid ka Chand.
dbrk thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#19
I also feel that the Devakshi scene was shot after the fandom pointed out.

But if v look into Dev's character, his reaction to Sona was very consistent with it. He loves Sonakshi, he cannot see her in pain but when his mother is in truble same Sona bcums a means of his mother's pain.

This is what he did at the time of breakup and same he did yest.

It is really sad there no growth at all in Dev's character. It is sign of impending doom
HaiMiz thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: siddhi.d123

Dev just looses his senses when his mom is involved 😕 I wish I never meet such a guy in real life 😕 This is fiction and Sharica are beautiful so we root for them , in reality one would run away from this mess.The scenes are shot well before so I don't think it was to pacify the viewers because Friday's episode had a good flow.


Dev loses senses when it comes to mom...this is no flash news.

Dev's wife just learn that she may never be a mother - Dev is aware of this flash news.

And if Devakshi scene was not a afterthought...then Dev is clearly bipolar as he seems to swing between hot and cold with Sona.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".