Created

Last reply

Replies

28

Views

2k

Users

17

Likes

201

Frequent Posters

pkbdas61 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#21
Excellent post. I feel thrilled when I see so many well read people, extremely articulate, in this forum.
The tipping points for me are few... . love, truth, commitment being the top three. If you really love someone, you will go heaven and earth to keep that love. I bashed up Sona during the break up simply because I found it weird to see her accepting that 'creep' (sorry) into her life so quickly when Dev broke up with her. I was in a minority then. Sona did not keep her promises of not leaving him even if he left her!

I bashed up Dev during the time when he was dilly-dallying to inform Ishwari about Sona. He did not show the courage, like Neha, to confess his love for Sona. He did not keep his commitment to Sona - loving her like a man loves a woman! He was not man enough for her then.

I don't agree with what Dev has now done. Telling lies to Sona., blatant ones... the tipping point for me. Again by not telling her the truth he is not being man enough!
Sargesh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#22
Initially my tipping point during separation track was dev's obsesson towards sona and his stalker behaviour. Becoz I have started watching it from there only but when I watched full series on yt. My tipping point changed🤣. I understood his character and his love for sona and I thot all his actions are justified. Now my tipping point is asha maa to asha aunty. Everybody was discussing jhoola and all but I think that is low communication between both which leaf to the situation. Do my point is when u change ur reference point tipping point also changes🤓
gemini54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#23
Thanks to all of you who read and replied on this post.
It is interesting to read people's tolerance levels based on their experiences, situation and what they perceive as right from wrong sometimes their Tipping point vibe with ours sometimes it does not and that is what makes the world interesting.
I want to thank the people in this forum who are open to discussion on varied topics and I am happy to be part of it
pkbdas61 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: gemini54

Thanks to all of you who read and replied on this post.

It is interesting to read people's tolerance levels based on their experiences, situation and what they perceive as right from wrong sometimes their Tipping point vibe with ours sometimes it does not and that is what makes the world interesting.
I want to thank the people in this forum who are open to discussion on varied topics and I am happy to be part of it



always willing to participate in discussions that are objective and open.. i have seen many discussions in this forum that become very personal and the whole subject gets lost in emotions.. and when emotions set in, objective thinking is the victim.
Rithu0203 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#25
For me, first time i felt the tipping point was during patch up, it was way too fast and can't take it. But, after some break for myself i started watching.
Post marriage track i too believed that Dev is taking steps to change for good, but reached the tipping on Dev's character when he admitted that calling Asha as maa was mistake and regretted for that followed by his lies to Sona.

W.r.t Sona, i reached the tipping point when she got emotional when Ishwari included her in discussion of Dev's birthday preparation, for me this is not the Sona whom i know, instead by this time in Dixit's house she should have sensed atleast little bit of insecurity in Ishwari.
Somewhat not convinced with her reaction to removing the swing and that emotional tears in last episode. Rightnow, lost the connection with Sona, so may be here after her pain won't hurt me much i guess(except for serious issues like prenup, infertility etc.)
saumiee thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#26
Such an interesting post to read!👍🏼
For me, the tipping point was when after all the progress in their relationship, Dev right away said to Ishwari without any coaxing that Calling Asha a mother was a mistake. Even when Ishwari later faked that she was okay with calling her mom, he insisted on not doing it.
Not calling her maa is okay but he seriously thought it was a mistake! That was really shocking for me. And then we saw him joyfully relishing the halwa treat with no thoughts on what he promised .
To top it, he actually called Asha aunty. I felt embarrassed and disappointed with his actions that day. Even after that, we did not see him introspecting.
Like Sonakshi said No one forced him to call Asha mom, I did not understand why he said he wants to break societal norms! So all that affection and respect for Asha was because of pressure of the society!? If not he could have easily found other way out to calm Ishwari down but he chose the most brutal solution.
This step simply put him back to square one in a way, whatsoever progress he made for Ishwari was erased and It was very insensitive of him and also cowardly to not even think of Sona and not talk to her about it.
Edited by saumiee - 8 years ago
.Neela. thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#27
Good post Sabita, I have read this book. But I have stopped applying logic from books to TV shows.

I started watching the show because I wanted to see Supriya P. in a show, had never followed any of her shows earlier. But I liked SHaheer's acting and Dev was a good hearted soul, just needed to be polished by Sona, to bring out his best. And ALAS...the CVs failed big time when they degraded both Sona & Dev and made Ishu the Vamp. For me the 1st tipping point was during the break up. I too wondered how he became a BIG business man with that kind of attitude and brain of a 8 year old? 😲

For the rest I agree on the below. For me it's been similar tipping points and the hypocrisy that gets applied differentially - Dev vs Ranveer; Neha vs Sona 🤢🤢

As I have said many times, I can't identify any characters on this show to real life easily as I have never seen any. I know NOW, there are many Iswari's and Dev's that do exist after reading many personal experiences from various women on this forum

You won't believe, but after seeing so many sequences in the serial, I started questioning my husband (after 16 years) what his reactions would be to...for. e.g. if he found my clothes messily lying around like Sona's. I know his closet is so neatly arranged and mine is very messy. But even in the early years after our marriage, when we shared a closet, I never heard any complaints from him - his half of the closet was perfect and he didn't get bothered with my encroachment of his half of the closet. I felt the necessity of asking him what his parent's reaction was the 1st time they heard their favorite son getting married to a neighboring state girl - we speak different languages and just luckily happen to be Brahmins. Some questions that never came to my mind, have started coming after watching KRPKAB and after a few times of questioning I just realized I am taking a daily soap too seriously 😆

I feel much better that I stopped watching. But the healthy discussions on this forum keeps me coming back 😳

Originally posted by: OmNaMaSteOm

Tipping point is the saturation level one has reached while going through something.

I reached mine long back with the show - when Sonakshi's character lost spark. Agreeing to marry Dev knowing everything about his obsession with his Ishwari and Ishwari's obsession with her 8 year old. If I were in her place I would say NO and move on. If the show is about reality then be real - there are many realities then, need to show dont be convenient selective about it. The CV's could have shown half realization of Dev and then get DevAkshi married that would have been a little realistic.

If you start with one stupidity, you need more stupidities to continue with.

Another tipping point : Dev is running such a huge business where he has to communicate clearly! How did he manage all these years without communication in his own home - not understanding his sisters or Ishwari is beyond me. You need to understand psychology to get your work done be it professional or personal.

The CV's are just dragging the "no communication policy" in Ishwari Niwas to run the show.

After these 2 tipping points I lost interest in the show. Now what ever lame plots they show I dont care anymore. It does not affect my that much.

gemini54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#28
Neela yes the book is good. I just wanted to borrow the title of it😉 to kind of pose my question. It is so great to get varied opinions of people's level of Tipping Points! Even though it is just one show. I was not really applying logic of the book here because I think this show is not following understandable logic now but what I do find interesting is that people of different age groups and gender have some similarities and a lot of differences in their interpretation of the same situation and this fascinates me.

Thanks for replying


OmNamasteOm love your dp name tt is awesome thanks for penning your thoughts

Originally posted by: .Neela.

Good post Sabita, I have read this book. But I have stopped applying logic from books to TV shows.

I started watching the show because I wanted to see Supriya P. in a show, had never followed any of her shows earlier. But I liked SHaheer's acting and Dev was a good hearted soul, just needed to be polished by Sona, to bring out his best. And ALAS...the CVs failed big time when they degraded both Sona & Dev and made Ishu the Vamp. For me the 1st tipping point was during the break up. I too wondered how he became a BIG business man with that kind of attitude and brain of a 8 year old? 😲

For the rest I agree on the below. For me it's been similar tipping points and the hypocrisy that gets applied differentially - Dev vs Ranveer; Neha vs Sona 🤢🤢

As I have said many times, I can't identify any characters on this show to real life easily as I have never seen any. I know NOW, there are many Iswari's and Dev's that do exist after reading many personal experiences from various women on this forum

You won't believe, but after seeing so many sequences in the serial, I started questioning my husband (after 16 years) what his reactions would be to...for. e.g. if he found my clothes messily lying around like Sona's. I know his closet is so neatly arranged and mine is very messy. But even in the early years after our marriage, when we shared a closet, I never heard any complaints from him - his half of the closet was perfect and he didn't get bothered with my encroachment of his half of the closet. I felt the necessity of asking him what his parent's reaction was the 1st time they heard their favorite son getting married to a neighboring state girl - we speak different languages and just luckily happen to be Brahmins. Some questions that never came to my mind, have started coming after watching KRPKAB and after a few times of questioning I just realized I am taking a daily soap too seriously 😆

I feel much better that I stopped watching. But the healthy discussions on this forum keeps me coming back 😳

gemini54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#29
Saumiee glad you liked the post. Btw my niece is also called Sowmi

Originally posted by: saumiee

Such an interesting post to read!👍🏼

For me, the tipping point was when after all the progress in their relationship, Dev right away said to Ishwari without any coaxing that Calling Asha a mother was a mistake. Even when Ishwari later faked that she was okay with calling her mom, he insisted on not doing it.
Not calling her maa is okay but he seriously thought it was a mistake! That was really shocking for me. And then we saw him joyfully relishing the halwa treat with no thoughts on what he promised .
To top it, he actually called Asha aunty. I felt embarrassed and disappointed with his actions that day. Even after that, we did not see him introspecting.
Like Sonakshi said No one forced him to call Asha mom, I did not understand why he said he wants to break societal norms! So all that affection and respect for Asha was because of pressure of the society!? If not he could have easily found other way out to calm Ishwari down but he chose the most brutal solution.
This step simply put him back to square one in a way, whatsoever progress he made for Ishwari was erased and It was very insensitive of him and also cowardly to not even think of Sona and not talk to her about it.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".