Created

Last reply

Replies

37

Views

3.8k

Users

17

Likes

231

Frequent Posters

_Payalj_ thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: tia.o

As I mentioned in my previous post, opportunity was limited which she gave Dev. But love and care are unlimited. In exchange for opportunity, she could have given more love and care to Neha.

Or even later when they were rich, she could have compensated for the past.

But she didn't. Usually parents give more love, care and attention to the weak/disadvantaged child not to the strong/advantaged child.

Ishwari was doing what we Bengali call, Tela mathay tel deowa. That means oiling a head that is already oiled too much or in another sense giving to the rich or advantaged hoping for payback instead of the poor and disadvantaged...

a


You are 100% right in this. Parents always oscillate towards the child which needs more support. My parents are literally obsessed with my son as he doesn't have a father. One should see the way they protect him all the time, be it a fight with his cousins or when I am trying to scold him.

They also stay with me instead of their other children who also need support in taking care of their kids. Their straight answer is you are two people earning. She is alone. If we give her support only then she will be able to go and earn peacefully.

Even when we were children and studying I remember them paying more attention to one of my sisters as compared to the balance of us. I used to fight saying that you love her more. My mother used to take it quitely. Several years later she told me that my that sister was a slow learner as compared to us and so needed more support and care.

Her clear dialogue was whichever child needs more support at whatever point of time we will give.

But here when I read some people constantly defending Ishwari I am forced to think are majority parents not like this. Why is it that so many people are incapable of seeing the major flaws in Ishwari's parenting and defending them in the name of majboori

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#32
This is what I wrote on Tinkerfairy's post regarding Dev.

Dev ki saari awaz bahaar walo ke saamne hi nikalta hai. Gharwalon ke saamne woh hamesha hi tye tye phoos...

Today's highlight double standard dialogue:

Dev to Ranveer: Main apne patni ke khilaf kuch nehin sun sakta...

Me: Achcha? Tumhara selective hearing ki bimari gayee nehin abhi tak? Ab tak jab Mami aur tumhari Maata ji bol rahee thi, to kya tumhare Kanpur mein hartal chal raha tha?

Oh no no. Wait. Ab main samjhi.

Dev ka matlab tha ki, "Main apne patni ke khilaf bahaarwalon se kuch nehin sun sakta kyunki izzat ka sawal hai."

"Aur main apni patni ke khilaf gharwalon se kuch nehin sun sakta kyunki main unke saamne deaf or dumb ban jaata hoon."

Statement ek, matlab do.

Waise bhi, dono jagah khamosh raha, to bashers to dhulai kar degi bechare ki. To safe jagah pe bola.

I have said everything there's to say about Ishwari.

Coming to Ranveer, I have never said his anger was wrong. But it was directed to wrong person. If Ranveer was truly upset, he could have called Sona and said the same thing. I won't have said a word.

But while Sona is a Dixit after marriage, there's a vast difference in her attitude towards him from rest of the Dixits. Ranveer has seen it and he has admired her for it enough to wish Neha to be like Sona.

Knowing that, he can't conclude that Sona will come to his house and respectfully ask his Bhabhi to talk to Ranveer to follow up on Dev's threat. There's a vast difference in their approach.

Besides if he truly hates Dixits so much why bother going to their house to warn them? He could warn them over the phone.

Sona was always very respectful towards him. This is not how you treat people who treats you well.

About Sona, I think she has become de-sensitized to insult by now. She no longer reacts. Dev who was prepared to take revenge from Ranveer for insult to his wife under his own roof, don't even care when Radha insults his wife as black shadow, scorpion etc while standing under the same roof.

But then Dev has never stood up for Neha in front of his family and Sona has left her self-respect at Bose house.

What was one saving grace as I said before was the fact that Dev didn't try to feed Sona any bull about how everyone loves her and she is already part of his family. At least today he knew enough to not lie outright.

That's a step in the right direction. You can't move forward without acknowledging the truth to start with. Baby steps hi sahi.

Originally posted by: Pehchaan.Kaun

Totally true about Ishwari. Today's episode was quite quite irritating and I indeed felt I am watching a Star Plus or Colors drama 🤔

To start with my favourite one - Dev. What a way to divert the topic when Ranveer told everyone SECOND time about his dhamki of lawyer 👏. First time I felt why and how he must have been in top position in Business, quite a skill 👍🏼. No doubt Ranveer came down to Dixit Kaalkothri after Sona went to his home, but Ranveer seemed more frustrated about Dev's comments. And he wants to punish Ranveer ? ARE YOU FREAKING KIDDING ME SELFISH Dev ? 😳 For what will you punish Ranveer ? For signing the acknowledgment paper when Postman gave him the Divorce Notice sent by Neha? For cancelling the booking of the flat so that his mother's operation can be done ? Or for being a man in front of Dev and Dixit Clan to show them the reality that Neha was no kid when she got married (like Dev is) ? Oh how did I forget, it doesn't take any reason for Dev to punish people - he did it with Sona before, he did with Rithwik and now Ranveer is his new prey 👍🏼. Because he is mad at Ranveer, he couldn't bear him insulting Sona, but trust him to put a cellotape on his mouth when his Godly mother and GKB do the same and even the younger Neha 👏 Shame on such bedroom-lion 👎🏼.


Now about Ranveer - I don't find his reactions wrong, he has got God-gifted family members who are against this divorce and rather want HIM to move out and are ever ready to adjust the expenses for the sake of the new bride. What shame does it feel for a lower-middle class man to abandon his family to fulfill the unfair demand of his newly wedded bride, even more so when it's a love-marriage. Unlike Dev, Ranveer truly has a reason to feel guilty of giving in to everything his in-laws (including his wife) ask him to do, be it accepting the new job by killing his self-respect and ideologies or now the divorce drama initiated by his better half. Of course any sane man would want to keep his family out of this and would be extremely frustrated if the inlaws come to talk to his family-member. Here we have to keep in mind that Ranveer does NOT want to keep this marriage, he has convinced himself with the idea of separation which is killing him too, he is a man who failed to understand even his wife (Neha proved him wrong in every aspect), so of course the contradicting behaviour of Dev and Sona has truly got him confused and agitated him further. Any sane person will behave likewise. He was furious over Dev's failed attempt and Sona's visit followed by Dev's dhamki indeed can be perceived as Dixit's way of dealing with this matter, how would Ranveer know that Dixits despite living under the same roof, themselves are as scattered entities as Neha and Ranveer are right now. Sona, being wife of a dumb guy like Dev, HAS to bear such insults from time to time since it's a lifetime joint partnership and her actions will be seen as part of Dixits' actions. Like I said yesterday, to people outside Dixits, she IS a Dixit, she can't term her actions from now on as Sonakshi Bose's attempt. So yeah, face it Sona !


And last but not the least - Sona. I am truly disappointed with her actions post marriage 😒. Honestly, I can't fathom her level of tolerance and so-called understanding (which is uncanny). GKB's language triggered no protest in her ? I can understand her silence on Ishwari-Dev-Neha's allegations, but Bichchhoo and Das Liya are like TOOO petty to even mention ! How I wish Baba were there to listen to this and reprimand Sona for allowing Dixits to walk all over her . Honestly people who don't have self-respect, don't get respect from me either 🥱. And about her non-stop tirelessly trying to make Neha-Ranveer's marriage work, honestly this is annoying me as well. Today was the heights of hurls thrown at her. So far Ishwari and Dev have spoken to her privately about not involving herself into this. Today everyone shouted out LOUD in the hall. Still Sona doesn't stop herself. Why God why ! 😡 Every time she is trying, failing and saying sorry. This is testing my patience, since I am MUCH against the TRYING part itself 😡. And what I didn't specifically like is - her considering Neha-Ranveer's decision of separation as an accidental outburst of anger. I want to tell Sona that she disappointed me MUCH when she put her self-respect lower than 'love' and agreed to marry Dev, she disappointed me much when she put the respect of her own parents lower than 'love' and ran away from her own engagement, she disappointed me much when she put the sense of right-wrong aside and wrong-did a guy for the sake of 'love', she is continuing to disappoint me when she takes all the abuses and misbehaviour from Dev and Dixits for the sake of 'love', but this LOVE might not be the MOST important thing in everyone's life, people might have different priorities, everyone doesn't need this romantic fancy world. For Ranveer his self-respect might be more important than Love, for Neha, a girl who was deprived of all her rights in childhood, might put monetary and materialistic pleasures more than Love, she doesn't even have to look far, for her own husband DEV - Mommy, his family and his guilt-trips-along-the-roads-of-the-dreadful-past is FAR MORE important than Love 🥱. So better she stops thinking about Neha-Ranveer and let them decide their priorities. I would not be happy to see Ranveer turning into another Sona. 😵


I don't want to talk about Ishwari since she is beyond criticism. To save herself from the guilt, she is supporting Neha for divorce. Yes, the family is indeed different, a zoo/paagalkhana .

Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#33
Exactly. Same with my grandmother. I am also an only child of a single mother. My mother had to work to raise me, so my Dida (my mother's mother) lived with us and raised me. She also felt that I needed more love because I didn't have a father. Dida has other children (two more girls and even a son who is my Mama). But she didn't live with her son because as your parents, she also felt that her other children has spouses to share the burden. My mother didn't have that. She lived with my mother and I because we needed her more.

I am still her favourite even though she loves all her grandchildren.

As to why people defend Ishwari, I don't know. Even more surprising is that the same people who defend Ishwari also defend Neha. How can you justify the abuser and victim at the same time? If Ishwari did right, then Neha has no right to complain and if Neha has a right to complain, then Ishwari wasn't a good mother.



Originally posted by: _Payalj_


You are 100% right in this. Parents always oscillate towards the child which needs more support. My parents are literally obsessed with my son as he doesn't have a father. One should see the way they protect him all the time, be it a fight with his cousins or when I am trying to scold him.

They also stay with me instead of their other children who also need support in taking care of their kids. Their straight answer is you are two people earning. She is alone. If we give her support only then she will be able to go and earn peacefully.

Even when we were children and studying I remember them paying more attention to one of my sisters as compared to the balance of us. I used to fight saying that you love her more. My mother used to take it quitely. Several years later she told me that my that sister was a slow learner as compared to us and so needed more support and care.

Her clear dialogue was whichever child needs more support at whatever point of time we will give.

But here when I read some people constantly defending Ishwari I am forced to think are majority parents not like this. Why is it that so many people are incapable of seeing the major flaws in Ishwari's parenting and defending them in the name of majboori

Edited by tia.o - 8 years ago
_Payalj_ thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: Pehchaan.Kaun

Totally true about Ishwari. Today's episode was quite quite irritating and I indeed felt I am watching a Star Plus or Colors drama 🤔

To start with my favourite one - Dev. What a way to divert the topic when Ranveer told everyone SECOND time about his dhamki of lawyer 👏. First time I felt why and how he must have been in top position in Business, quite a skill 👍🏼. No doubt Ranveer came down to Dixit Kaalkothri after Sona went to his home, but Ranveer seemed more frustrated about Dev's comments. And he wants to punish Ranveer ? ARE YOU FREAKING KIDDING ME SELFISH Dev ? 😳 For what will you punish Ranveer ? For signing the acknowledgment paper when Postman gave him the Divorce Notice sent by Neha? For cancelling the booking of the flat so that his mother's operation can be done ? Or for being a man in front of Dev and Dixit Clan to show them the reality that Neha was no kid when she got married (like Dev is) ? Oh how did I forget, it doesn't take any reason for Dev to punish people - he did it with Sona before, he did with Rithwik and now Ranveer is his new prey 👍🏼. Because he is mad at Ranveer, he couldn't bear him insulting Sona, but trust him to put a cellotape on his mouth when his Godly mother and GKB do the same and even the younger Neha 👏 Shame on such bedroom-lion 👎🏼.


Now about Ranveer - I don't find his reactions wrong, he has got God-gifted family members who are against this divorce and rather want HIM to move out and are ever ready to adjust the expenses for the sake of the new bride. What shame does it feel for a lower-middle class man to abandon his family to fulfill the unfair demand of his newly wedded bride, even more so when it's a love-marriage. Unlike Dev, Ranveer truly has a reason to feel guilty of giving in to everything his in-laws (including his wife) ask him to do, be it accepting the new job by killing his self-respect and ideologies or now the divorce drama initiated by his better half. Of course any sane man would want to keep his family out of this and would be extremely frustrated if the inlaws come to talk to his family-member. Here we have to keep in mind that Ranveer does NOT want to keep this marriage, he has convinced himself with the idea of separation which is killing him too, he is a man who failed to understand even his wife (Neha proved him wrong in every aspect), so of course the contradicting behaviour of Dev and Sona has truly got him confused and agitated him further. Any sane person will behave likewise. He was furious over Dev's failed attempt and Sona's visit followed by Dev's dhamki indeed can be perceived as Dixit's way of dealing with this matter, how would Ranveer know that Dixits despite living under the same roof, themselves are as scattered entities as Neha and Ranveer are right now. Sona, being wife of a dumb guy like Dev, HAS to bear such insults from time to time since it's a lifetime joint partnership and her actions will be seen as part of Dixits' actions. Like I said yesterday, to people outside Dixits, she IS a Dixit, she can't term her actions from now on as Sonakshi Bose's attempt. So yeah, face it Sona !


And last but not the least - Sona. I am truly disappointed with her actions post marriage 😒. Honestly, I can't fathom her level of tolerance and so-called understanding (which is uncanny). GKB's language triggered no protest in her ? I can understand her silence on Ishwari-Dev-Neha's allegations, but Bichchhoo and Das Liya are like TOOO petty to even mention ! How I wish Baba were there to listen to this and reprimand Sona for allowing Dixits to walk all over her . Honestly people who don't have self-respect, don't get respect from me either 🥱. And about her non-stop tirelessly trying to make Neha-Ranveer's marriage work, honestly this is annoying me as well. Today was the heights of hurls thrown at her. So far Ishwari and Dev have spoken to her privately about not involving herself into this. Today everyone shouted out LOUD in the hall. Still Sona doesn't stop herself. Why God why ! 😡 Every time she is trying, failing and saying sorry. This is testing my patience, since I am MUCH against the TRYING part itself 😡. And what I didn't specifically like is - her considering Neha-Ranveer's decision of separation as an accidental outburst of anger. I want to tell Sona that she disappointed me MUCH when she put her self-respect lower than 'love' and agreed to marry Dev, she disappointed me much when she put the respect of her own parents lower than 'love' and ran away from her own engagement, she disappointed me much when she put the sense of right-wrong aside and wrong-did a guy for the sake of 'love', she is continuing to disappoint me when she takes all the abuses and misbehaviour from Dev and Dixits for the sake of 'love', but this LOVE might not be the MOST important thing in everyone's life, people might have different priorities, everyone doesn't need this romantic fancy world. For Ranveer his self-respect might be more important than Love, for Neha, a girl who was deprived of all her rights in childhood, might put monetary and materialistic pleasures more than Love, she doesn't even have to look far, for her own husband DEV - Mommy, his family and his guilt-trips-along-the-roads-of-the-dreadful-past is FAR MORE important than Love 🥱. So better she stops thinking about Neha-Ranveer and let them decide their priorities. I would not be happy to see Ranveer turning into another Sona. 😵


I don't want to talk about Ishwari since she is beyond criticism. To save herself from the guilt, she is supporting Neha for divorce. Yes, the family is indeed different, a zoo/paagalkhana .


100% agree with your post. Dev babu doesn't have the patience and maturity of a two year old but ranveer should have the patience and maturity of a Saint! Why? Only the Dixits are supposed to be humans?

So Dev again kept quiet when gkb shitted from her mouth. I seriously have always failed to understand what Sonakshi fell for in Dev. She is not a hormonal teenager who got attracted to his looks, money and Swag (note I am not using the word class- as dixits don't have any) . Because besides these qualities he has nothing.

Also someone really needs to shout at Sonakshi mind your own business. Why is she meddling where she is neither wanted nor appreciated. It might look good in theory that two families become one after marriage but in reality it takes years to truly become a part of the family. The way the moment sindoor is put a girl doesn't forget her family, same way she can't understand her husband's family or be accepted as one in one second. It takes time, a lot of it actually.

No one in Dixit family is making an effort is correct. But Sona is also not helping matters by her over eagerness and jumping.
Danseuse thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#35

The scenes being played out now are very realistic. Happens in most families because of the difference in financial status. In some cases, even similar status marital bonds don't last. Here, Ishwari and Dev agreed to Neha-Ranveer match only because she convinced them that she would adjust in a smaller house with minimum amenities and would be able to manage with Ranveer's salary. Now, the reverse has happened. Ranveer has never lied about his status and family. I admire his self-respect. He wants to earn respect and status w/out any favours to be a self-made individual, which is praiseworthy. Any other guy would cling to Dev and get himself all the luxuries of life, w/out breaking a sweat, just like the 'Moronic project head'. 😃

Ishwari is concerned. And worried about Her daughters future. If the divorce happens, what would the society say? She feels Sonakshi is interfering and hence the clear instruction to stay away. It's fair.

Ranveer lost his cool because he tried to reach out to his wife and she is acting as thou he has physically abused her. The outburst was his frustration as he was honest from the beginning. Neha is only looking at comforts given up by her. Then why did she marry Ranveer? Didn't she love him?

Each character is playing the part well. Sonakshi is a modern woman and feels that communication is the key. Postponing it may also create more rift. Ishwari, on the other hand, doesn't want to pressurise her daughter into submission because she feels that time would heal. Both are fair in their approach and the relationships here are also different. It's mother versus daughter-in-law. Ultimately, love must conquer all...



-Rekha
Tia.0 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#36
Oh we all know this happens in a lot of families. But just because it's reality doesn't make it right.

Neha didn't convince Ishwari that she will be happy with Ranveer. Ishwari convinced Neha and Dev both that love is enough. Neha loved Ranveer but she didn't accept his proposal initially because of his financial status. She claims that she knows her daughter, yet she couldn't predict that the same daughter can't live in a middle class family?

Ranveer's self-respect is one of his admirable qualities for sure. That was never a question. In fact the things about him Ishwari admired the most are the things that she is not defending in front of Neha anymore. If Ishwari had spent quality time with Neha and didn't use her grief for her own selfish reasons to stop Dev going to his honeymoon, I'd have agreed with you. But that didn't happen.

Again, Ranveer's anger is justified, but the target is wrong. He was much more respectful to Dev yesterday even after Dev insulted him than to Sonakshi today who has always defended him. That's not done.

Had he blasted Dev yesterday, he would have been completely justified. But not today when he took out his frustration on someone who didn't deserve it.

Sona should just let Neha suffer the consequences of her actions. But when Dev's happiness lies in his family's happiness and her happiness is tied to Dev, she can't stop interfering. Otherwise Ishwari will use Neha forever to come between her and Dev's happiness.

Originally posted by: Danseuse


The scenes being played out now are very realistic. Happens in most families because of the difference in financial status. In some cases, even similar status marital bonds don't last. Here, Ishwari and Dev agreed to Neha-Ranveer match only because she convinced them that she would adjust in a smaller house with minimum amenities and would be able to manage with Ranveer's salary. Now, the reverse has happened. Ranveer has never lied about his status and family. I admire his self-respect. He wants to earn respect and status w/out any favours to be a self-made individual, which is praiseworthy. Any other guy would cling to Dev and get himself all the luxuries of life, w/out breaking a sweat, just like the 'Moronic project head'. 😃

Ishwari is concerned. And worried about Her daughters future. If the divorce happens, what would the society say? She feels Sonakshi is interfering and hence the clear instruction to stay away. It's fair.

Ranveer lost his cool because he tried to reach out to his wife and she is acting as thou he has physically abused her. The outburst was his frustration as he was honest from the beginning. Neha is only looking at comforts given up by her. Then why did she marry Ranveer? Didn't she love him?

Each character is playing the part well. Sonakshi is a modern woman and feels that communication is the key. Postponing it may also create more rift. Ishwari, on the other hand, doesn't want to pressurise her daughter into submission because she feels that time would heal. Both are fair in their approach and the relationships here are also different. It's mother versus daughter-in-law. Ultimately, love must conquer all...



-Rekha

mena_k thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#37
Wonderful analysis like always!
Yesterdays episode I agree to one sentence Ishwari spoke "Why is Neha getting the punishment, why not me" agree, she deserves much much more.

God I cannot take this women's crap any longer, She is sad that what society would say or think with Neha being divorced and on the other hand she wants Neha to get divorced why because she could not give Neha anything she asked for till date so voila give her divorce for she asked for one now. Genius Ishwari. Hey bhagwan aisi maa se bachhe bin maa baap ke hi rahein to behtar.
Her nonsense dialogues, of I know all better than you, no one knows him/her better than me, is bulls. For one I can be sure, even If neha gets divorced, with a mother like Ishwari she won't ever be happy. Ishwari will keep playing her sad music around her always.

Dev can hear any level of insult for his women from insider's but shows what a man he is to outsiders, wait did he just put his sister's husband into the list of outsiders like Sona's boss. This is family of Dixit's. Sona is outsider, never would understand the people or the house, and ranveer too is an outsider. Why even let any of the daughters get married to outsiders If they ever remain be the same for you. Oh but you want those outsiders to treat you like gods and fulfill all your demands, take all your's and your family's insults thrown at them. I still have not understood, what kind of love marriage did Sona had, where from day 1, she is trying to save her marriage by not reacting to Dev's, Mami's, Ishwari's or Neha's insults As If the day she stops doing all that her marriage will break like Neha's, crap.

Sona must immediately stop listening to sad music from Ishwari. As soon as Ishwari starts with it, sona must walk out and show no sympathy to Neha or Ishwari or Dev. It won't be wrong for her to tell Dev that she is not interested in listening to what Neha is going through as everybody including him have said to stay out of it.

Ranveer good decision, just get out of this dixit idiots asap. I wish Sona had the same strength like you do.
Shilky88 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: tia.o

aahh...let me utilize one more reply to elaborate my POV😊
I am still not with Sona entirely on what she is doing.
Having said that she is absolutely right and her intentions are correct but that way she is doing --doesn't differentiate her from stubborn Dixits.

Fair enough. Having a different opinion is totally fine in my post. Here's my take.

I have no doubt in mind that Ranveer is suffering. But when a marriage breaks it's never one person's fault. So it will be wrong to put the entire blame on Neha.
Never did I 😃

I agree with you that Ranveer is receiving mixed messages and he is probably confused. But it will be wrong to say that he did not have interaction with Sona or he only had interaction with Sona through Dev, Ishwari or Neha.
By interaction I meant that he has no personal bonding with Sona and that is why Sona approaching him directly might be misunderstood and could be taken in a wrong sense by anyone.

When Radha accused him of stealing, Sona defended him.
Yes.she did and she did it not because it was Ranveer but because he was not at fault.Had it been Keechu bhaiya, Bhola bhaiya or anyone else for that matter she would have done the same thing.so it isnt enough to justify her bonding or understanding with Ranveer.

He was present at Sona's wedding and Sona was present at his.
yes,thats right.👍🏼
Sona was present at Ranveer's wedding as she was the nutritionist of Ishwari and also an employee of Dev.
Ranveer was present at Sona's wedding as he is husband of Neha.
That is my point.Their interactions are mainly due to Neha/Ishwari/Dev.

When Neha came back and he came to Dixit house with Sona, she was the only one who defended his respect. He admired her so much that he wanted Neha to be like her.


He could not have asked Neha to be like neighbour's aunty whom he has passing acquaintance, could he?
I totally totally agree on that.He admires Sona knowing him as somebody's somebody and not one of his direct friend,relative or even an acquaintance.
We admire lot of people around us distantly but that doesn't mean we are comfortable with them to share our feelings and can easily open up with them w.r.t our personal sensitive issues.
Both Ranveer and Sona --are always shown to admire each other distantly for what kind of individual they are but they were never shown as two people with some mutual understanding of each others's matter.

Having said that I don't mean that Dev has some understanding with Ranveer but if there a channel that Sona must follow then it has go through Dev.

In spite of all that he came to Dixit house to blast on Sona as if she has threatened his family. All Sona tried to do is to fix this marriage. He could have easily called Sona and said exactly what he said. If he really was so against confusing Dixits and paints Sona with the same brush, why bother coming into the same house to say what could be told over the phone.

Well not Sona but Dev did threaten him right.
and how would Ranveer know that these two are not coordinated?
All I could think of being at Ranveer place is -- first Dev threaten him and later sends his wife to say sorry. dint looks like he has slightest of idea as to what is going on between Dixits and they are so not aware of each other's plan of action.
Should we blame Ranveer for this?
In such cases family members will speak to each other and decide before speaking or reacting outside.
Also I don't wanna sound ancient here.
but not sure how would Dev react knowing that Ranveer talking to his wife personally and directly .
Ranveer has clarity of approaching Sona through Dev. There is nothing wrong in that.

And Ranveer can't keep his family out when he lives with them and he is getting a divorce.

When society asks his family questions would he go threaten everyone to keep his family out?
I agree with you that you cannot keep your family outside.
But Ranveer's family has no different take on it so why involve them and create unnecessary confusion.
As a family if you speak one language and agree to a common decision then it totally makes sense to send one person out to speak on everyone's behalf rather than messing up with so many heads speaking one common thing in 10 different ways.It will lead to confusion and nothing else.

No. In my opinion, Ranveer's anger was justified, but his outburst at Sona wasn't.

I still feel that his anger was not just on Sona but on Dixit family as a whole.He might have targeted Sona mostly as she was the recent one causing confusion.

Sona could have gone through Ranveer. But after Dev told her that Ranveer is egotist and stubborn and doesn't care about Neha, who would have gone to him?

If Ranveer and Sona's interaction was that much limited that Ranveer paints Sona with the same brush as Dixits, then how would Sona know Ranveer any better to approach him? Sona met Ranveer exactly the number of time Ranveer met Sona.

Now regarding Sona's interference. Sona could have taken Dev into confidence if Dev hadn't asked her to mind her own business. But it's hard to mind one's own business when a. the said business is crashing down under the same roof affecting one's business and b. all the whining, moping, crying is going on around you affecting your mood.

Sona could have very well minded her own business if she was in her honeymoon. After all that's exactly what she was doing earlier until Ishwari made it her own business.

Well if Neha's matter affecting Sona life and honeymoon cancellation
are the reason for Sona' s conscious step to directly talk to Ranveer then I guess she should be bold and frank enough to let Dixit know this.
If she is stubborn and bold enough to speak to Ranveer's family directly after several warning from Dev/Ishwari then she must have guts to let them know that it is cancellation of her HM which is pushing her to solve Neha's matter.
I am sure Dev and Ishwari can then understand and make sense out of her desperate and stubborn attempts. But one must be honest.

About Neha taking a wrong step, if Neha truly loves Ranveer, then she might take a wrong step if her marriage breaks up. But if she doesn't and just wants to move on with her life, considering how much she loves luxury and material things, she won't take any wrong step.
I hope so 😃

Dev himself made it impossible to take him into confidence. If he had taken Sona into confidence, then that would have encouraged Sona into doing the same. But he first of all never discusses anything with Sona and then ask her to stay out yet expects her to be okay with whatever disruption this causes in her life. He can't have it both ways.

Either continue to live life as if nothing happened or help her fix the issue so that everyone can move on with their life.

if thats the case then I guess Sona must fix her issues with Dev's first and then try to fix Somebody else's issues.
If she cannot convince her husband then how can she convince Neha's husband and even if she can ,she must prioritize her own things first before somebody else's.
She ran to save Neha's life without her husband's knowledge.Dev could have reacted to it very badly and harshly.
In order to fix Neha's life can she afford to upset and anger her husband?




Edited by Shilky88 - 8 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".