Critical Inner voice of Ishwari !! - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

60

Views

5.7k

Users

27

Likes

211

Frequent Posters

Shobhna23 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#41
Just wanted to share something with u guys! My family is also like Dixit family my father died when we were young I was just one year old, we are three sisters and a brother and my brother loves my mom so much and Vice versa! So the point is whenever I watch the show I can always imagine My family's future! N my mom watches it too I always have a fear of my mom turning like ishwari although my mom is not obsessed like her but still ! From my POV when people losses their partner then their life revolves around their kids and they don't want to make space for any another person! My mom is always insecure about my Di 's boyfriend, she always complaints about how my sister is not giving her enough time like she used to, she is changed now and etc.
But people make adjustments! So hope my mom will also adjust...
dikshat thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#42
http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4729461

Ye meri thesis hai ..needs 2-3 days to read 😆
Iss post ka subject shud hv been - Bhawnao mein beh k likhi gayi post 😆

Writing few more on Ishu n devakshi kyuki main dev ki deewani hu
Usse judi har ek baat mujhe likhne pe majboor kar deti hai 😆 😆
sia.krpkab thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: dikshat

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4729461

Ye meri thesis hai ..needs 2-3 days to read 😆
Iss post ka subject shud hv been - Bhawnao mein beh k likhi gayi post 😆

Writing few more on Ishu n devakshi kyuki main dev ki deewani hu
Usse judi har ek baat mujhe likhne pe majboor kar deti hai 😆 😆




We all know that Diksha! I have read your post - By god tumsey zyada crazy Shaheer/ Dev fan koi nahi ho sakta! If I ever got a chance to meet Shaheer, I will happilt pass it along to you 😊
Moony87 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#44
Lovely post 👏. My like button is not working.. Grrr. 😕

But yes I'd like to politely disagree on few points. The slight jealousy is in every person regarding something or the other. But this is on actually a negative level. And very very realistic as well. Though I'll save my applauses depending on how this will be handled but yes the makers deserve an appreciation for bring ing this forth.

Coming to your father, oh that's actually a normal one. He is not trying to sabotage your relationship knowingly or unknowingly😊
To be very Frank, because it's a show and a lot of layers had been shown of Ishwari before, viewers can give a benefit of doubt to her. But this doesn't happen in real life, in most cases. The hatred which is on the forum is what actually develops out of these scenarios. It's not that the daughter in laws start disobeying their MILs in the very beginning itself. No one does that. Specially in single parents, even the Daughter in laws naturally respect them. But there is a difference - to get naturally respected and to force respect out of someone.

These cases are a mix of two things, one forced respect that you have to listen only to what I have been saying in this house all these years and second the toy for the house. That is one of the mentalities which they showed in the promo in lot lot of cases. And ishwari lost my points with that promo actually. That didn't show her insecurity.. That showed her mentality. Sorry no offence. That is what mother in laws are so cursed about - they want a toy.. A maid not a partner to their sons. Someone who can do all the household work and give them a grandchild when demanded.

Coming again to the hatred, well this is a show and at the end everyone will be happy with no love lost for Ishwari.. But the hatred which is on forum is what actually remains by the end of these storms. The relationship is strained for ever, not on the surface but inside. The moment Ishwari told Nikki to ask Sona to sleep with them my mother grunted, just like your grandma. The wounds are deep and they don't heal. The prenup makes it worse to empathize with her. Just my POV. That is pure plotting.

Ishwari made numerous sacrifices for Dev that doesn't give her browny points. Not from me at least. She likes no one near him. Natasha was great. She was not happy. Sona is her son's love, she is not happy. Every mother makes lots of sacrifices for their son but the niceness is just not in that.. It's in how your treat someone else's daughter in your house. Women ill-treat even their own choice of daughter in law.

The makers have taken a wonderful concept. However I never liked ishwari for I hate biased parents. The daughters are sidelined like some furniture. And that brings a bad bad taste in my mouth. Why can't the makers also highlight that daughters can also share your troubles and not just the son? Regarding the message, I hope for once the housewives take a good message out of it. For we are a country where major people want Ram as a kid but won't make an effort to not be like Dashrath and not do injustice to their own kids. Or they'll be blind like Dhritrashtra, but won't open their eyes and stop their kids from being Duryodhan. Wishful thinkings hopefully turn into reality this time.

PS: The show is indeed Path breaking. Hope it is taken as a lesson by the real life mother in laws. Though yes, ishwari makes me shiver due to personal incidents and what I heard from my frenz. They are not beaten or physically tortured but this mental torture is equally hazardous.
Edited by Moony87 - 8 years ago
thedramaqueen thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: WeRockTheWorld



Exactly. I think I am over thinking. Time will tell

deepsel thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: cscs

Thank for the post. Its good to hear a different perspective for Ishwari. She never did anything intentionally (apart from pre nup fiasco). She was always clear that she is bringing sonakshi for dev's happiness. And if you look at everything she is not plotting and planning anything against devakshi. She has been insecure from the start only and resistance to changes. Remember she said, its too difficult for her to accept new things when dev asked her to permit nikki for night out. She has never seen dev behaving like that and hence she is bound to get shocked. She will take her time to come up with everything.


She never knew that Devakshi hasn't consummated so delaying it purposely is out of question. This is what i was saying from last two episodes. Her reactions are normal ans she is not pushing sona into anything forcefully. She had tried to protect sona for whatever reasons may be. Yes she is insecure because she has always been an important part of dev's life and now she has to share that position with sona.

I really hope cvs dnt make ishwari some psychotic person, who did all this intentionally to separate dev and sonakshi. She is capable of doing many things even without any mental illness. And supriya is doing full justice to the character. She is just perfect.


Thank you 😊 You have pointed it all exactly the way I look it !! There is a thin line between extreme insecurity and mental instability and Ishwari is on the max borderline now. So far whatever she have done is in the spur of moment and I hope CVs maintain the same in future too without making her look like a evil vamp😆 I am definite this character shade wouldn't have been justified by any other actress other than Supriyaji after watching her !!
deepsel thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: sona_naksh

amazing post
agree wid u
ishwari is not evil ...but she knows t use circumstances in her favour ...


Thank you😊 I really hope the makers maintain this borderline !
deepsel thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: Maya_Dutt

Thank you so much for the post Deepa. I was so waiting to read your analysis of yesterdays episode and how u read Ishwaris character. I am also married and completely understand human jealousy part and its quite natural. Dont siblings feel it , infact I keep hearing all the time..mum loves u more and dad loves u more in all families I know of; parents feel it..when kids share some secret with one parent and not the other etc., but they are all mini versions of jealousy.

In case of Ishwari its an extreme and the CVs are running on a very thin line where it can be misunderstood by the audience. But like you said Kudos to them to show this. I just hope Dev and Sona stay together to overcome this situation rather than another separation track.

Please keep writing and making us see postives in every action.


Thank you for your kind words😊 Yes insecurity and jealousy is a part of every human nature , for some its glaringly visible and for some its subtle😳 In Ishwari's case it just shoots up high at an alarmingly rapid rate to the point of clouding her senses and her actions. I really really hope we don't need to see another separation track to deal this issue but for serial longevity we might never know what the makers have in their hood😆 More the Devakshi and KRPKAB, more the happier me ...no complaints! 😛
deepsel thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: Soumya23

NYC post Deepsal

Very true Ishwari is never bad...but as u were saying
Whenever her inner demons chase her she's overtly insecure and that's what is pushing her to these levels...
Hoping to see that Sona soon realizes this and along with Dev try sorting things in a right manner
Ignoring her or distancing her from her son would makes things only worse...Hope CVs show how to deal with such type of things...it might be the reason why they even showed Sona as a doc...maybe she would be able to deal this with more patience...


Thank you😊 yes the more Devakshi is blind towards Ishwari's feelings , the more messy their relationship would become.. As you said, Sona is the DIL for Ishwari for a reason and she might be the first one to know about her problem and fear and hope she doesn't need to struggle alone to resolve this but Dev stand by her side to support and care as well !
deepsel thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: Nehz

Quoting something from your post - kids but they are never surfaced because they are compromised by one or the other way with the situations and relationships around them

I believe it is not a compromise but understanding of relationship and accepting that with time relationships change/ grow and as we meet people we form new relationships.
In your case(i am not judging) daughters are special for papa always and your dad felt a normal emotion but I am sure he was equally proud of you being a carinf wife ... that s an understanding ... he knows you love him and he wants you to be successful in your relationships and that s what normal parents want...

There are MIL who cause trouble for control or who struggle with the decision making power they are going to lose or control over their son who listens to them ...

But there are those like Ish who are selfish and clingy... who have some kind of obsession and it is not healthy ...


it is unhealthy jealousy Ishwari feels
Yes, ish has issues and Dev needs to realize it .. she needs to see a shrink ...


Thanks for your input😊 Agree new relationships and their understanding with an amicable situations avoid normal people from being insecure and express those traits. My dad always wants me to be addressed as his daughter first than his SIL's wife even today and I very well know about his insecure feeling of him being replaced in my heart in this matter but that doesn't make him mentally unstable as I know how much he values me in his life and how possessive he is about me. My life has its own complications for him to believe so 😆 and thats one reason I always connected with Bijoy. Thanks for the lovely family surrounding my dad , he is saved from becoming a male version of Ishwari😆

Ishwari's clingy nature came from the sole survival past with Dev who stood beside her as more of a partner than a Son and shoulderd her responsibility. She will need some time to let anyone into that territory of oneness and that doesn't need a shrink but a supportive Devakshi to open up her insecurities and make her look the reality strictly IMO of course 😳..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".