proposal was tacky,emotionless and there was a disconnect!! - Page 10

Created

Last reply

Replies

107

Views

8.8k

Users

48

Likes

434

Frequent Posters

tinken thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#91

Originally posted by: LiveLoveLife


I made a post too abt this. And this is what I mentioned:

What was the significance of the Proposal in today'e episode or the storyline? --> NONE
Yes it was TACKY (never ever thought or used this word for KRPKAB and hopefully wouldnt need to in future). I thought KRPKAB is so above all this. Could not see any Passion or Romance bwteen the 2. Like a big piece of the Puzzle missing. Felt like a big DISCONNECT. Like as if, even the Main Leads had no clue why was the Proposal happening. May be Proposal could have been saved for after Dev's redemption Assuming the so called infertility track is to show Dev's redemption by standing up for Sona and supporting her in all situations. But then why all this on Sona...she is always at the recieving end in all these tracks or so called twists. But anyways lets not go there.

After Sona's baba agreed for the proposal, what was the rush to show Saurav calling Dev. It looked like Saurav is Dev's best buddy and all thru the break up was updating Dev on every move. It was so unrealistic. Would have loved to see Asha maa informing Ishwari abt Sona and her baba approving the proposal. And then probably Dev and Sona have a phone convo or meeting with a little bit of awkwardness initially. But then their emotions, feelings and passion for each other which was building up all through the break up phase would break that awkwardness into a passionate hug. May be a nice adult convo between the two after that hug would be so welcomed.
But again breaking all KRPKAB rules, Dev reaches Sona's house within a minute of Saurav calling him. And then follows it with a proposal at a total different location. The makers have always expected and have been successful in getting a clever audience to watching this show. But were they expecting us to keep our BRAIN aside today? I mean SERIOUSLY!!!



i know suddenly they moved at a rocket speed with the proposal>
Jade0001 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#92
In my opinion nothing was tacky , I'm not sure if it's more important to reunite with your love or set the atmosphere to a romantic sphere
I know if I was separated from my love I can always organize a romantic dinner but reuniting the words the emotions the love is much more important.
sia.krpkab thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#93
The problem is the order of the events, right?

Dev is meeting Sona's family today - will apologize of course - sorted, right?
He is redeeming himself today with her parents - sorted, right?
Its all happening - and please understand it takes time!
I feel your post is more dramatic than this whole saga - how will YOU redeem yourself with such harsh and non-objective feedback, if the CVs chance upon delivering well now?

Instead of jumping guns, think and act! (learn from Dev's blunder 😉)
tinken thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#94

Originally posted by: sia.krpkab

The problem is the order of the events, right?

Dev is meeting Sona's family today - will apologize of course - sorted, right?
He is redeeming himself today with her parents - sorted, right?
Its all happening - and please understand it takes time!
I feel your post is more dramatic than this whole saga - how will YOU redeem yourself with such harsh and non-objective feedback, if the CVs chance upon delivering well now?

Instead of jumping guns, think and act! (learn from Dev's blunder 😉)


Order of events were a problem, yes!

Someone who loves his family so much was expected to seek blessings from Sona's parents first. Did you notice Sona looking at her mother and silently asking permission to meet Dev who waited outside?

ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#95

Originally posted by: sajinifaby



What according to you is magic n passion ?
Would u try to explain that better so that I can connect to ur statement ?

Dev did it that way.. As Sona is like most of us .. Who believes this is how a proposal - it's stereotyped.. N full of fantasy
But Dev did it his way .. N not keeping aside their emotional state ...
There is time for passion ...
Special day n moment is when I make mistake - I want to let the person know That am aware I hurt u a lot - I donno how to make it up - but u mean the world to me
All of this Sona understood from Dev

I really donno what exactly TM or supporters of the thought expects

Yes I support TM because I felt the same way. I think we have different ways of looking at the scenes. What looks magical to you may not appeal to me at all. That doesn't mean our view points need to be changed. For instance the dance of the leads when they were still not in love with each other made me drool over them. But yesterday I just could not find the sparks flying.I wish we should respect each other's point of view without trying to mend our stand. Hence I feel I don't need to explain what according to me is magic. Seriously I can not define it as it is a feeling an emotion. So with due respect to your point I hold my views intact.
Moony87 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#96
I agree.
So much was missing yesterday. God, it was jet speed episode. Asha and Bijoy being the most consistent and rest the most inconsistent. Sonakshi's siblings are so unpredictable. 😆 They just go with the flow. They can intensely bash Dev and then tease him almost simultaneously. 👏😆

Coming to the leads. The whole patch up looked fake. The way Sonakshi said yes totally nullified her outburst in her office. Dev was no where. It seemed Ishwari was more in love with Sonakshi.. 😆 The passion she had for her to become her daughter-in-law was more intense and steely than Dev😆

I don't know how people will here take this but I have always disliked that flying hug. I apologize but it looks funny actually. I would have rather wanted a long emotional hug, where none would want to let go of each other for zillion minutes.

Yesterday should not have been about lights and music (That was a traumatic violin piece 😆 ) and children with placards. I have personally found children and cards idea highly unromantic. It just doesn't click with me at least even though it is used in so many movies. It is all the more unbearable when it is done in real life proposal videos. 😆

I have seen few soft conversations of Dev with Sonakshi. His subtle voice, the longing eyes and slightly high breathing. I wanted that actually. I wanted him to apologize. I wanted him to talk. The way he did while gifting the saree to her. To top it with, that going down on one knee.. I don't know why people like it, that is the most mechanical stuff ever. It looks darn filmy. 😡

Oh apart from Asha and Bijoy, another consistent one is Vicky. I'd like to applaud Sonakshi for going to a family where a leech like him openly roams and has the audacity to talk creepily to every woman entering the house. 😛👏 But thik hai .. Kuch rang devar ke aise bhi .. 😆
Edited by Moony87 - 8 years ago
tinken thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#97

Originally posted by: Moony87

I agree.

So much was missing yesterday. God, it was jet speed episode. Asha and Bijoy being the most consistent and rest the most inconsistent. Sonakshi's siblings are so unpredictable. 😆 They just go with the flow. They can intensely bash Dev and then tease him almost simultaneously. 👏😆

Coming to the leads. The whole patch up looked fake. The way Sonakshi said yes totally nullified her outburst in her office. Dev was no where. It seemed Ishwari was more in love with Sonakshi.. 😆 The passion she had for her to become her daughter-in-law was more intense and steely than Dev😆

I don't know how people will here take this but I have always disliked that flying hug. I apologize but it looks funny actually. I would have rather wanted a long emotional hug, where none would want to let go of each other for zillion minutes.

Yesterday should not have been about lights and music (That was a traumatic violin piece 😆 ) and children with placards. I have personally found children and cards idea highly unromantic. It just doesn't click with me at least even though it is used in so many movies. It is all the more unbearable when it is done in real life proposal videos. 😆

I have seen few soft conversations of Dev with Sonakshi. His subtle voice, the longing eyes and slightly high breathing. I wanted that actually. I wanted him to apologize. I wanted him to talk. The way he did while gifting the saree to her. To top it with, that going down on one knee.. I don't know why people like it, that is the most mechanical stuff ever. It looks darn filmy. 😡

Oh apart from Asha and Bijoy, another consistent one is Vicky. I'd like to applaud Sonakshi for going to a family where a leech like him openly roams and has the audacity to talk creepily to every woman entering the house. 😛👏 But thik hai .. Kuch rang devar ke aise bhi .. 😆


All you wrote make absolute sense to me!
I wanted them to connect emotionaly, Sona to communicate her resentment,angst and Dev to seek forgiveness,show regrets. That would have been enough. I did not anticipate proposal straight away. Hence it looked like a masala film to me
Moony87 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#98

Originally posted by: tinken


All you wrote make absolute sense to me!
I wanted them to connect emotionaly, Sona to communicate her resentment,angst and Dev to seek forgiveness,show regrets. That would have been enough. I did not anticipate proposal straight away. Hence it looked like a masala film to me


Thanks for agreeing. 😊 Yep it looked masala movie.. Those roses coming out from his shirt was the last nail.. 😆

Sorry for going off the topic but can someone give Dev a royal haircut?

"Dukh bhare din beete re Devaa ab sukh aayo re.. Haircut jeevan mein naya laayo re.. 😆"
Edited by Moony87 - 8 years ago
Krpkab_meg thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#99

Great post! Completely agree that the proposal lacked KRPKAB magic! I can't believe this is the same team that gave us the most amazing confession. The confession was so beautiful and we connected with it because it was so personal, he took her to places that were significant to him and he shared a part of himself with her. The proposal was so clichd and impersonal other than reference to Ms. Bose and Mr. Obhodro. The only part i liked was when he wiped away her tears and said Bas.

And that Violin music😡. They have a bagful of beautiful BG music they could have used, it would have been so much more impactful.

xxZaaraxx thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
So true! It was indeed emotionless!
Pls cv's bring back the old magic of krpab and sharica chemistry! Pls don't mess the lead pair and this fantastic show up!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".