No redemption track for Dev??? Updated *DT Note PG-26* - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

201

Views

14.3k

Users

47

Likes

615

Frequent Posters

FreeBird03 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#11
I think whatever Sonakshi said today was the result of seeing the man she loves in such a vulnerable and disturbed state...we are all human beings and we all have our weak moments...this was sonakshi's..I won't think of it as anything else..

the scene was brilliant, shaheer and erica performed it well!
Edited by FreeBird03 - 8 years ago
bookworm123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Pehchaan.Kaun

I feel cheated too. This is SO not done.

I knew Sona's character is going to be destroyed here it comes 👏. At least whatever Dev is doing, it's for his family. Sona has no loyalty towards his family 👎🏼 She has taken the whole Bose family for granted. 👎🏼


After the brutal break up, he did not say "sorry" even once to her. Yes, he did acknowledge that he was acting crazy, stalking etc. Once again he was focused on himself and had to be shown the reality by Sona and Ritvik.

Fine, if his characterization is such that he needs Sona to "take care" of him..I will go with that...

Does she not even deserve a sorry? Do the CVS not feel he had a responsibility to find a middle path before giving up? So he never needs to apologize for not trying, for hurting her? It has become about - we are now in this together...

Their acting was very touching and this scene would have been very very lovely if the break up was amicable. By making the breaking up somewhat brutal I thought the CVs were planning a track in which he would redeem himself and win her over, was I wrong??
bookworm123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: OmNaMaSteOm

I have been cheated by a serial before. - IPKKND - 1

Oh no! That was the worst redemption track ever Actually there was none because it was dealt with in 1 episode!

But this one is unfair, promos mein kuch aur dikhaya kuch.

Sonakshi melts too fast, in reality who reacts like that ? A concept called self respect ? Bose family reacts close to reality in comparison to Sonakshi! Rather the leads of the show are displaying unreal stuff, the leads families are displaying real stuff.

Redemption ka chance is gone from Dev and Ishwari - only their transformation we may get to see, thanks to Sonakshi being so DILDAAR!!

The show is about Ishwari more parallel is Sonakshi and Dev unke parallel baaki kirdhaar.
I want the strong Sonakshi back!


@ bold - yes, that is what I am saying. She may be a great soul but I would not mind if she were more real and felt so hurt that she would not melt so fast!!
bookworm123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: tina59

I agree too

He gets away with everything . First when Sonakshi had to hide to her parents abt her love for Dev , now she has to be again the person who has to give up completely forgetting her parents wishes for their daughter.

she is going to be that sona again who was like a highly paid maid doing all the work, listening to all the taunts and when the time comes, dev will do the same tantrum and again side with mommy dearest...

This is ridiculous. They could have a shown a little bit of redemption from his side but no, its sonakshi who has to be the lamb here



Will we get redemption now? Even if she said what she said when her heart melted seeing him like this, why did the CVs write this scene already? Could it not have been sequenced after a redemption track?
rose4ever thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Malvika07

Someone once said - Maybe being in love and being stupid is the exact same thing. Somehow, this rings true for both Dev and Sona. They both are doing things that can only be called stupid, but they're doing it out of love. I'm not entirely sure if I approve.

You're right. I felt cheated too, when I realized that Dev may never have to work to win her over once all this mess clears up.
Having said that, the scene did make me misty eyed. It was heart touching if I ignore the part about Dev never having to apologize for the way he broke up. I did feel bad for him today, after ages. I'm not saying I approve of his tactics or that all is forgiven. I'm just saying I do understand now what he must be going through. Him admitting to behaving like a pyscho stalker is a step in the right direction.
Maybe, just maybe we can attribute Sonakshi's words as having a weak moment seeing the man she loves in this state. If there's no redemption track, then I really see no point in continuing to sit through all the crazy Dev pulls out of his hat in the coming episodes.
Also, I know probably noone paid attention to this, but I liked R and Sonakshi's scene today. It mature and sweet.
Confused is a good word to potray my state of mind right now.
The romantic in me felt for Dev-Sona but the woman in me did feel cheated.
Like you said, it was a good scene if we look at it with a stand-alone view. But alas, it isn't stand alone is it?

You wrote exactly how I am feeling right now. Confused.Dev-Sonakshi scene was so heart touching. Dev himself admits that he feels like a dirty stalker. I felt bad for him in that scene epecially when he says tumhe khud se kaise alag karun jab hum ek hain. So much so that I was expecting a gut wrenching, crying hug between them.
But, as a woman, I feel cheated too. So many thoughtless actions , crazy and demeaning acts, disrespect and disregard for Sonakshi and her family, such blind devotion towards his mother that he never even questions her. and no redemption?Not even a simple Sorry?That's just not acceptable.
You are not the only one to pay attention to Ritik's scene. His maturity and sweetness deserves a mention and applaud. At that moment I really agreed with what Sona said, that she is lucky to have him in her life.I just hope she doesn't end up hurting him
Edited by rose4ever - 8 years ago
bookworm123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: dlavanya

i think there will be redemption track...a small one may be ... after the journalist fisco Sona will be super mad at dev as they both promised to each other to not intefere like adults in todays episode... and Sona will surely think Dev did all this on purpose.
but again ... may be the redemption track will be in parallel to Ishwari manofy track.. lets wait and watch... it is very dfficult to guess any thing in this show


Could not agree more with the last line.





dikshat thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: bookworm123

Dev has already got Sona
understanding him and forgiving him for the break up without him even asking
her to forgive him! After the way she acted so understanding today how can she
display anger at a future date for the manner of break up?


He does not even have
to work to win her over in the future. She is herself telling him that she
would marry him in an instant!! She is herself telling him - if you try to
bring me into your life, your mom will be unhappy. She is not even saying you
did not try!!


Furthermore, she told him
- I will even manage my parents which means he does not need to work for that
as well!!


I feel cheated. I really
really wanted him to work towards winning her and her family over like a gentleman. It's like she got all the bitterness out of her system in the
restaurant and became zen like in the office conversation.


As a standalone conversation
it was very heart touching but it would have been more appropriate if the break
up was amicable and mutual not thrust upon her by him in such a callous
fashion!


Should I be reading the
subtext (i.e what the CVS are thinking) that they too did not think he had a
responsibility to try and find a middle ground before taking an impulsive
decision? Is that how they see relationships? So all the pages and pages of analysis
on the forum have no meaning if this is what the CVs think. Then it becomes all
about "exposing Ishwari" and fixing/healing/redeeming her and
completely disregarding the fixing that Dev himself needs!




I totally understand ur point bt I wanna say...thand rakho 😆

I am very very very sure that all will happen bt it cannot in a single episode or a single conversation...aftr break up this was their first talk n not fight or anythibg else...this was a serious deep rooted coversation dat they had tday...once dev wil get to knw of his mother's actions and wid some self introspection etc he wil do all this...
Pls hv patience
bookworm123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: ARCH21

I haven't seen the episode yet. Will only get to see tomm. but reading this doesn't surprise me.
With the way things are going, Sona has just been living her hurt. This move on business that's moving into marriage with someone else is just rebound. She is simply hurt bad. But one honest call from Dev and she will be willing to go to him.

Yes, that is so true. One honest call, but was this that? Should the honest call not include an apology for the callous manner of breakup, for not even trying to find a middle path?

Sona's move on thing distracted Dev from feeling regret for his actions. He hasn't had time to reflect on what wrong he did and was hit with this whammy of Sona going away with someone else. Guess this has also confused him if she loves/ever loved him - that's why all those 'how can you do this to me n all'... and he's just become more n more desperate. She has been pushing him away. But if they had one sane conversation, the result would have been, 'v both love each other but can't do anything because Mommy doesn't approve' - initial promo...
They took a convoluted way but looks like the initial promos is where they will head.

Like we discussed earlier, if that is where they wanted to head, why did they need to humiliate Sona in the process? I wish they had given is an amicable break up and events that lead to it.

If Dev comes to know that Ishwari sent the rishta by tomm and still on Monday, the engagement drama happens so this Son knows but the lover does nothing... Absorbing more pain in the process...

Anyways, as they bring this drama to head and Ritwik track ends, Sona will manage her parents, Dev will clearly not be able to live without her and Sona will be understanding... More I read the spoilers and what's happening, am getting the feeling that all this crazy drama is taking us to the initial promo stage ... and like I said earlier & seconding what u just said - I feel cheated.



Maybe I should wait and see but why did they sequence this heart touching scene now? Why not after his redemption??
bookworm123 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Malvika07

Someone once said - Maybe being in love and being stupid is the exact same thing. Somehow, this rings true for both Dev and Sona. They both are doing things that can only be called stupid, but they're doing it out of love. I'm not entirely sure if I approve.

You're right. I felt cheated too, when I realized that Dev may never have to work to win her over once all this mess clears up.
Having said that, the scene did make me misty eyed. It was heart touching if I ignore the part about Dev never having to apologize for the way he broke up. I did feel bad for him today, after ages. I'm not saying I approve of his tactics or that all is forgiven. I'm just saying I do understand now what he must be going through. Him admitting to behaving like a pyscho stalker is a step in the right direction.

Everything you said about Dev is all true. It was a very very touching scene and it would have fit in very very well if the break up was amicable. That way the romantic and the woman in me would be in harmony!

Maybe, just maybe we can attribute Sonakshi's words as having a weak moment seeing the man she loves in this state

And the scene was so good as a stand alone scene that even we had a weak moment. Why did the CVs sequence this scene now such that Sona had no option but to melt??

. If there's no redemption track, then I really see no point in continuing to sit through all the crazy Dev pulls out of his hat in the coming episodes.
Also, I know probably noone paid attention to this, but I liked R and Sonakshi's scene today. It mature and sweet.

This was actually the best scene they have had till date. It had the necessary therav.

Confused is a good word to potray my state of mind right now.
The romantic in me felt for Dev-Sona but the woman in me did feel cheated.
Like you said, it was a good scene if we look at it with a stand-alone view. But alas, it isn't stand alone is it?


P.S -loved your post above
Edited by bookworm123 - 8 years ago
Hari73 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#20
Some how I had expected this. This is just like how in MB happened. There RK never tried to understand madhubala's pain.. It was always RK & RK. Self centered. Here also DEV self centered. But here toned down craziness. After all its same writer Raghuveer shikavat. Now I will certify him as poor writer in redemption track. He is excellent in proposal and breakup track. But when it comes to redemption, he does not value female emotions. . It's just about male character and female character bear understanding and sacrificing.
Keeping aside this redemption track.. sharica were phenomenal today.. just loved their acting.. how I wished to see one tight hug from them..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".