Sonakshi ....too good to be true. Has to be more natural. - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

98

Views

8.3k

Users

32

Likes

258

Frequent Posters

..BhUvaNa thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: pyaaribehna



<font color="#ff0000" face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif">I understand that . Bade ghar ki betiyaan chote ghar mein jaati hain to problemz hi hota hain.</font>

<font color="#ff0000" face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif">I know a girl who married like that that she had no privacy in her sasuraal. No room of her own. The sasuraal people used all her things. There was nothing to call her own.</font>

<font color="#ff0000" face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif">The children were bad mannered badly brought up just like Ranveer's brother's kids who barge into the suhaag raat room . Didn't their parents not teach them any manners? they look grown up enought to understand these things.</font>

<font color="#ff0000" face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif">I miss a point here. Does not Neha and Ranveeer have the right to live on their own?Rent a house or something?

In this where is Ranveer's self respect? Neha leaves her parent's house and comforts to be with him. Why cannot he leave his parent's house to be with her?

After all it is a "love marriage" as opposed to "arranged marriage" where in love marriage one has more 'love" and a girl has more "rights' towards her husband.</font>




If Ranveer's brother also stays with them all year long , sure Ranveer can rent an other house and move out with Neha. Unfortunately his brother doesn't stay , so I think its unfair to move and leave his mother , bhabi and 2kids alone . The only option left here is they all should move in to a bigger house that gives some space to breathe.
pyaaribehna thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: fanktlk

My 2 cents worth... It is not about taking gift from parent's house it is more of independence of the child itself.

I am against parasite children... who cling on to once source or another for their own comfort.

How is Vicky any different than Neha... My only point is Dev has worked hard to provide for his family. Is it fair to expect him to provide for Ranveer and his family too...

It is not a random gift that is expected... that could be limited to what she needs more... But to expect that all the appliances should be provided is a bit far fetched...

Cut your cloth according to the cloth it is said. Today all the appliances come.. then the maintenance expenses will also come... who will bear that!!

Like I said... the parasite mentality is a problem... A gift isn't!!


You spoke my mind. Hats off. Neha should go about earning money for her own things. She should have worked before her marriage. But no. In Indian soaps in Indian set ups the girl does not "work" .She should stay home cook clean serve food serve others badiya se chaai banaao etc. These things do not earn money . Not much anyway. Otherwise stay home enjoy the comforts create problems live off parents get spoit etc.

Then get married. Marry someone of your whims and fancies. Not very realistic. Do not speak or discuss about how one should live after marraige. Again it is a girl she is only as rich as her husband is. If he is poor so is she. If her sasuraal is without comforts she should go without comforts. And bear it to "adjust" in her sasural. that is considered being a good bahu.

Again no control over your own finances. You hubby provides for everything. He cannot live without his bhaiyya bhabhi or his mom. But you bade ghar ki beti has to live wihtout your parents or brothers and sisters. and wait for him to provide all the comforts of life at his own pace. Therein lies your khushi. After all how would you show you are not a "spoilt" bade ghar ki beti? only by waking up before your husband. bathing before everyone in the house (in cold water if need be) towel around your head go wake hubby with coffee/tea.(He can drink bed coffee/tea you cannot) And flirt a bit with your husband feel shy. At best he can bring gajra in the evening only for you (that is not bad manners) and put it in your hair (sick) that is your happiness. Not AC or car or a good house even.

No money to call your own not allowed to work ( how can you be typical bahu if you work? Who will cook clean massage sasumaa's legs? make papads, sweep mop wash etc? If you don't do all these you are considered spoilt rich.

If you want to study more (this is not done) and earn money for your own expenses you are not "allowed" . You are rich you need to be poor. and be satisfied with stuff around you . and play up to your husband's whims and fancies.

As for Sona she makes a good living by giving free advice. She works she earns her own money. She does not give advice to Neha to do the same. She will marry rich and live in comfort.

But Neha should live poor. After all she made her own "bed" literally so . She should lie on it.
pyaaribehna thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: chholabhatoora

Neha was well aware of ranveer's financial status if she was so used to all the luxuries then why the hell did she marry him!Why didn't she listen to gkb that sirf pyaar se pet nahi bharta tab to she was like mere liye sirf unka pyaar hi kaafi hai and all ab kya hua? she should have married a rich guy then.I am completely with sona and about the lehenga thing If someone gifts you something you should respect that just the way dev was hurt when ishwari didn't wear the saree gifted by him ranveer's family would have felt very insulted if she wouldn't have wear that lehenga


Who is gkb? and they gave advice about Ranveer's status?

As for lehenga does not matter if lehenga is mehenga or not but buy a lehenga that Neha chooses. Take her shopping. if Ranveer bhaiyya can give ten thousand to his saali for jhoota can can spend a bit more on lehenga of Neha's liking.

It is all about talking and discussing. Not about feeling shy or sad . Discuss openly take Neha shopping and buy her what she chooses. Let it be mehenga.How costly would it be? thirty thousand? It is once time occasion in your life. Ask man ask. Find what your wife thinks . Don't decide on your own.

Love is about thinking of the other person too. Not deciding on your own or thinking on your own.
pyaaribehna thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#14
]
Love or arranged, the society is such the day you get married believe me... you are on the same playing field...

Ranveer is saying no... while his mom and Bhabhi are asking him to move out... Here he really needs to be more practical... there is absolutely nothing wrong in finding a place close by, maybe even the neighboring apartment just for some privacy or space... They can spend the entire day together while retire to their own apartment when ever they need to be alone.

That's the best of both the worlds.



Thanks for saying that. I have been trying to convey this. I just got sarcastic. they make it out that "Love marriage" as opposed to "arranged marriage" and "love marriages" are "better" as there is more "love" and they make the girl wear "gajra" and they flirt more and they go out etc. The rest remains the same. There should be love in every marriage no matter your marriage is of your choice or arranged by someone. And each other's rights remain the same.

What I mean is Neha has had a chance to discuss and talk about so many things. And they have right to their privacy. Whether to take a bigger place or rent another apartment. Ranveer needs a wake up call. He only thinks of himself. Not of Neha.
Edited by pyaaribehna - 9 years ago
chholabhatoora thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: pyaaribehna


<font face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif" color="#ff0000">Who is gkb? and they gave advice about Ranveer's status?</font>

<font face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif" color="#ff0000">As for lehenga does not matter if lehenga is mehenga or not but buy a lehenga that Neha chooses. Take her shopping. if Ranveer bhaiyya can give ten thousand to his saali for jhoota can can spend a bit more on lehenga of Neha's liking.</font>

<font face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif" color="#ff0000">It is all about talking and discussing. Not about feeling shy or sad . Discuss openly take Neha shopping and buy her what she chooses. Let it be mehenga.How costly would it be? thirty thousand? It is once time occasion in your life. Ask man ask. Find what your wife thinks . Don't decide on your own.</font>

<font face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif" color="#ff0000">Love is about thinking of the other person too. Not deciding on your own or thinking on your own.</font>

Do you even watch the show? GKB is none other than our money minded Mamiji And kal dev AC bhejega uska lamba chaura bill aega wo bhi kya dev dega? And about taking her with him to shopping I guess their marriage was done in so much hurry that there was no time for that And a lehenga worth 30,000 is worthless and only wastage of money and I have problem with Neha calling that lehenga cheap if she would have said that she didn't like the colour I wouldn't be so offended but she is like this is not expensive and I only wear expensive dresses because I am THE DEV DIXIT's sister
aban1 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#16

You spoke my mind. Hats off. Neha should go about earning money for her own things. She should have worked before her marriage. But no. In Indian soaps in Indian set ups the girl does not "work" .She should stay home cook clean serve food serve others badiya se chaai banaao etc. These things do not earn money . Not much anyway. Otherwise stay home enjoy the comforts create problems live off parents get spoit etc.

No one ask Neha to stay at home, cook and clean.

Then get married. Marry someone of your whims and fancies. Not very realistic. Do not speak or discuss about how one should live after marraige. Again it is a girl she is only as rich as her husband is. If he is poor so is she. If her sasuraal is without comforts she should go without comforts. And bear it to "adjust" in her sasural. that is considered being a good bahu.

If you love someone you should love that person and not try to change him/her. If you need to change someone then don't love her/him. she knows Ranvir self respect issue, still she does that job things. she knows Ranvir doesn't want to take something from in-laws so she should wait a little so Ranvir can arrange things for her(As ranvir can gift her gold earring for her vhaia's engagement and 10,000 to her sisters in Juta churau rasam then it's shows that he knows her demand and wish). If you can't tolerate middle class life for a single month then don't marry a middle class man.

Again no control over your own finances. You hubby provides for everything. He cannot live without his bhaiyya bhabhi or his mom. But you bade ghar ki beti has to live wihtout your parents or brothers and sisters. and wait for him to provide all the comforts of life at his own pace. Therein lies your khushi. After all how would you show you are not a "spoilt" bade ghar ki beti? only by waking up before your husband. bathing before everyone in the house (in cold water if need be) towel around your head go wake hubby with coffee/tea.(He can drink bed coffee/tea you cannot) And flirt a bit with your husband feel shy. At best he can bring gajra in the evening only for you (that is not bad manners) and put it in your hair (sick) that is your happiness. Not AC or car or a good house even.

So basically forget you parent and relatives just because you love someone. Really? what is the guarantee if someone can leave his house and family for me today will not leave me for someone else in future.

No money to call your own not allowed to work ( how can you be typical bahu if you work? Who will cook clean massage sasumaa's legs? make papads, sweep mop wash etc? If you don't do all these you are considered spoilt rich.

is that Ranvir's family said that to her. No. In fact they are trying to convince Ranvir to shift a new house. Don't you think if some one is thinking about you, you should think about them as well.


As for Sona she makes a good living by giving free advice. She works she earns her own money. She does not give advice to Neha to do the same. She will marry rich and live in comfort.

if you all the time ask you parent to send everything then why living in your sasural. stay in your maika. and make Ranvir gar jamai. isn't that will be more convincing.

But Neha should live poor. After all she made her own "bed" literally so . She should lie on it.

She is not saying Neha should live poor. she is saying live to live what you have and try to make yourself capable to achieve what you want. don't just being a parasite and live in your brother's money.
pyaaribehna thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#17

[quote]Do you even watch the show? GKB is none other than our money minded Mamiji And kal dev AC bhejega uska lamba chaura bill aega wo bhi kya dev dega? And about taking her with him to shopping I guess their marriage was done in so much hurry that there was no time for that And a lehenga worth 30,000 is worthless and only wastage of money and I have problem with Neha calling that lehenga cheap if she would have said that she didn't like the colour I wouldn't be so offended but she is like this is not expensive and I only wear expensive dresses because I am THE DEV DIXIT's sister

Oh yeah mamiji I thought her name was Radha rani. True who will pay AC bill? I understand 30000 Rs worth lehenga is worthless. May be you like a lehenga for 100000 Rs. Wastage it is . Because you do not get to wear it that often. Still wedding dress is special.Everyone spends on the occasion.

As for Neha yes I would have borne it if is for the color. But she says it is cheap and she is Dev Dikshit's sister. That is not correct . But the cvs paint any character as they want. They make vamps out of good people and good people out of vamps. and they stereotype everything.

Instead of Sonakshi giving free advice to stop presents being sent to Neha from Dev she should make Neha understand that she has no right in Dev's hard earned money. What he gives her is his charity. not her right.
She is nothing on her own.No money no property no education nothing to call her own except her own mother.

Then she would have woken up and done something in her life. married rich at least. so that she does not come back to her bhaiyaa's house with demands like these.

Neha does not have a father . she has no right in what Dev earns. It is his hard earned money.

She could have worked. But she does not. She was living on borrowed comforts. They are not her own. She is not even rich to begin with . Now too she is not rich.

She should have thought about it before marrying Ranveer. not now.
Edited by pyaaribehna - 9 years ago
Jade0001 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#18
For me its simple if a girl marries then first and foremost she needs to communicate with her husband ask if he is comfortable with her getting help or gifts from her family if indeed he is comfortable with that then there is no problem but if he wants to take that responsibility and care and provide for his wife then she should allow him to do so .
Neha knew that Ranveer is not rich guy yet she felt he is the only guy that would love her for herself so now she needs to do everything that will make her marriage work and she needs to understand that her life now has changed .

vibg thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#19
Sorry... I disagree.

Neha is a needy, spoilt brat who feels just because she suffered in childhood.. her mom and bro and everyone else need to indulge her every nakhra and tantrum. Its about time, she grew up😡she wants her love and wants her money too... then either go EARN it, or wait for hubby dearest to provide it. she is trying to mold him to suit her needs and wants. she fell in love with the man Ranveer is.. and is now trying to change him. She is a very typical girl and there are far too many of her kind in this world. and there are far too many boys of her kind in this world too.. like Vicky. both feel a sense of entitlement cause they resent others😲 but don't want to lift a finger to get the luxuries they desire.. fast money on easy track😉


Sona is a smart, independent, caring, strong girl. she is someone who now considers Dev her partner, as evidenced by their bond, their love, their relationship growth shown in the serial. It's Dev who has given her these rights through their friendship, bonding and love. She cares for people who matter to him. That's all! She is not "too good to be true" either. Girls like her exist too. And I really don't think... she is trying to save a few Rs. of her would be husband. Sona has not been shown to be a gold digger by any means.

Edited by vibg - 9 years ago
pyaaribehna thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: aban1


You spoke my mind. Hats off. Neha should go about earning money for her own things. She should have worked before her marriage. But no. In Indian soaps in Indian set ups the girl does not "work" .She should stay home cook clean serve food serve others badiya se chaai banaao etc. These things do not earn money . Not much anyway. Otherwise stay home enjoy the comforts create problems live off parents get spoit etc.

No one ask Neha to stay at home, cook and clean.

Then get married. Marry someone of your whims and fancies. Not very realistic. Do not speak or discuss about how one should live after marraige. Again it is a girl she is only as rich as her husband is. If he is poor so is she. If her sasuraal is without comforts she should go without comforts. And bear it to "adjust" in her sasural. that is considered being a good bahu.

If you love someone you should love that person and not try to change him/her. If you need to change someone then don't love her/him. she knows Ranvir self respect issue, still she does that job things. she knows Ranvir doesn't want to take something from in-laws so she should wait a little so Ranvir can arrange things for her(As ranvir can gift her gold earring for her vhaia's engagement and 10,000 to her sisters in Juta churau rasam then it's shows that he knows her demand and wish). If you can't tolerate middle class life for a single month then don't marry a middle class man.

Again no control over your own finances. You hubby provides for everything. He cannot live without his bhaiyya bhabhi or his mom. But you bade ghar ki beti has to live wihtout your parents or brothers and sisters. and wait for him to provide all the comforts of life at his own pace. Therein lies your khushi. After all how would you show you are not a "spoilt" bade ghar ki beti? only by waking up before your husband. bathing before everyone in the house (in cold water if need be) towel around your head go wake hubby with coffee/tea.(He can drink bed coffee/tea you cannot) And flirt a bit with your husband feel shy. At best he can bring gajra in the evening only for you (that is not bad manners) and put it in your hair (sick) that is your happiness. Not AC or car or a good house even.

So basically forget you parent and relatives just because you love someone. Really? what is the guarantee if someone can leave his house and family for me today will not leave me for someone else in future.

No money to call your own not allowed to work ( how can you be typical bahu if you work? Who will cook clean massage sasumaa's legs? make papads, sweep mop wash etc? If you don't do all these you are considered spoilt rich.

is that Ranvir's family said that to her. No. In fact they are trying to convince Ranvir to shift a new house. Don't you think if some one is thinking about you, you should think about them as well.


As for Sona she makes a good living by giving free advice. She works she earns her own money. She does not give advice to Neha to do the same. She will marry rich and live in comfort.

if you all the time ask you parent to send everything then why living in your sasural. stay in your maika. and make Ranvir gar jamai. isn't that will be more convincing.

But Neha should live poor. After all she made her own "bed" literally so . She should lie on it.

She is not saying Neha should live poor. she is saying live to live what you have and try to make yourself capable to achieve what you want. don't just being a parasite and live in your brother's money.


In blue I do not understand what you mean. Again I am saying the sasuraal people or hubby is being selfish and thinks only of themselves. They expect bahu to forget her parents but they do not want to go away from even their brother's family. That is what I am talking about. The state of the girl in her sasuraal as made out by cvs . That is what I am talking about . Neha is expected to be in her sasuraal with no control over her finances. and expected to forget her parents. I am not asking her forget her parents. I am saying they story is such they expect her to be away from her parents but hubby cannot be away from his brother's family.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".