Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Dev Dixit's focus is always on the present moment; what does he need, what does his family need, materially speaking, in the here and now? This attitude is of course, largely shaped by the circumstances of his upbringing and the emphasis that was placed on financial security. His responsibility is to provide every material comfort at any cost, and he takes it for granted that the women in his household will deal with the consequences. This equation allows Dev to maintain the idea that he is all-powerful and can do anything for his family's happiness. But every so often there comes a moment so overpowering that Dev sees an honest reflection of himself, with all his flaws, and he struggles and fights, without the tools to handle these revelations and channel them positively.

He didn't actually think about what Neha's wedding entailed until he saw the car pulling out of his drive way. Suddenly, he was hit with the realisation that he had lost a precious part of his life, not just in the person of Neha, but in all the unackknowledged time, all the neglected chances that could gone into building a more meaningful relationship between them. He was so caught up in providing her every physical need, that he forgot how much he needed her, as a sister, friend, and fellow struggler, and for the first time he acknowledged Neha's real problem, of being ignored. Shedding all his bluster of being Neha's "protector and provider," Dev had a rare moment of complete clarity on their relationship. It is only in times of extreme vulnerability that we can see the whole truth of our feelings, and were it not for Sona, this momentous realisation would have gone unexpressed, and eventially would have been lost once Dev's ego came to the fore again.

However, thanks to the unburdening of his feelings and a little redirection from Sona, Dev's negative emotions were translated into such a beatiful, positive outcome! Instead of wallowing in guilt and self-loathing about what he couldn't do with Neha, Dev turned his attention to what he could do with the sisters who still live under the same roof: form a real bond, based in love and mutual confidence. The most beautiful part? In doing that, he showed that he truly understood and acknowledged what Neha's presence meant in their family, what she had done all these years, especially for these two younger sisters. In the end, isn't that all Neha ever wanted from him?
Edited by Samanalyse - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

1.9k

Users

7

Likes

64

Frequent Posters

adoremevirgo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
very nice...
yes dev has always seen the comforts of his family that he never realized that his time and company r equally desired by them...

some incidents can be turning points in our lives...with neha going away dev has realized wat he has not done for her that overshadows all that he has done for her...but he still has 2 more sisters to rectify himself...wat he cud not do for neha he will make sure he can do those things with rhea and niki...loved their moment and their hug...

beautiful episode...

btw i love reading ur and maham's posts...i may not hv replied much but i do wait for ur posts :)
gemini54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
I always eagerly wait for your posts keep writing
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: adoremevirgo

very nice...

yes dev has always seen the comforts of his family that he never realized that his time and company r equally desired by them...

some incidents can be turning points in our lives...with neha going away dev has realized wat he has not done for her that overshadows all that he has done for her...but he still has 2 more sisters to rectify himself...wat he cud not do for neha he will make sure he can do those things with rhea and niki...loved their moment and their hug...

beautiful episode...

btw i love reading ur and maham's posts...i may not hv replied much but i do wait for ur posts :)


Thanks so much for reading and responding! I love reading your responses as well 🤗

I so agree about this being a turning point in Dev's life, and I think the fact that it took Neha's leaving for him to understand her importnace it is also interesting foreshadowing for Dev and Sona's relationship. It's true Dev doesn't take Sona for granted nearly to the same degree, but there is no denying that he expects a lot from her on a day to day basis, especially with regards to hiding their relationship. On the one hand, he keeps pursuing those intimate moments in his own house, without much subtlety, and on the other doesn't want anyone to suspect them. Sona is also the kind of person who is happy to help and oblige, so it is not apparent to Dev yet how much responsibility he is putting on her shoulders. It's not that he's doing this purposely, but he is used to not being questioned and has no idea how obvious he is being. His reaction to Neha suggests that he won't realise how badly he handled this whole situation with Sona entering his life, and his family, until she is no longer around every day. Then only will he find a way to rectify it the way he did with his younger sisters today.
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: 1234bar12

Beautiful analysis! :)


Thank you! 😃
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: gemini54

I always eagerly wait for your posts keep writing


That's so kind of you to say, thanks! Please keep reading and responding! 😃
spacenoxx thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Samanalyse

Dev's negative emotions were translated into such a beatiful, positive outcome! Instead of wallowing in guilt and self-loathing about what he couldn't do with Neha, Dev turned his attention to what he could do with the sisters who still live under the same roof: form a real bond, based in love and mutual confidence.


Sadness at the departure of his sister is not at all a negative emotion. Its a perfectly normal human emotion. While Shaheer and Erica did a fabulous job the scene felt a bit too dramatic. Dev shares the feeling of loss (without crying like a baby) with Sona and also himself suggests that may be his younger sisters need him now that their elder sister is gone.

A partner or spouse need not always be a crutch, which is what I felt about about the above scene. (Dev always depending on Sonas wisdom will forever keep him immature. Atleast by now he should have been able to handle this with just sharing his feelings not depending on her wisdom to show his emotional maturity). There need not always be agyan/updesh between them . Just being a sounding board is all that is needed between a couple that understand each other very well.


I just felt the "not spending enough time with Neha" wala guilt was a bit contrived. Feeling guilty all the time for every imaginary issue is a more a sign of immaturity than otherwise.
Edited by spacenoxx - 9 years ago
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: spacenoxx

Sadness at the departure of his sister is not at all a negative emotion. Its a perfectly normal human emotion. While Shaheer and Erica did a fabulous job the scene felt a bit too dramatic. Dev shares the feeling of loss (without crying like a baby) with Sona and also himself suggests that may be his younger sisters need him now that their elder sister is gone.

Sadness at the departure of his sister wasn't the negative emotion I was referring to; it was his guilt and self-reproach. I completely agree that sadness is perfectly natural and healthy, but as we saw him, Dev was trying to repress his sadness instead of letting it out. Had he not found an outlet in Sona, who reassured him that he was indeed a good brother and had done all he could for Neha, those thoughts would have festered inside him, creating an angrier and more emotionally distant Dev. I liked that he cried like a baby and she just listened... I think he just needed to vent his emotions completely in order to have a fresh start and new energy to go forward. 😊

A partner or spouse need not always be a crutch, which is what I felt about about the above scene. (Dev always depending on Sonas wisdom will forever keep him immature. Atleast by now he should have been able to handle this with just sharing his feelings not depending on her wisdom to show his emotional maturity). There need not always be agyan/updesh between them . Just being a sounding board is all that is needed between a couple that understand each other very well.
I completely agree with you on this too -- that Sona is becoming an emotional crutch for Dev-- but I am quite happy with the way they are showing this dependence because it paves the way for some interesting character development. One of Dev's primary traits as a character is his emotional immaturity. He was never given a chance to cultivate a strong EQ, and was even given the impression that it wasn't necessary for him at all! As long as he brought home the money, the women of the house took it upon themselves to take care of the emotional side of the household and make him feel like its king. Only with Sona's arrival and her higher expectations of him are we understanding how lacking he is in this department, and only with her is he getting the space and guidance to see things differently. I think this will play out in really interesting ways when he is forced to break up with Sona. She will no longer be there for him to lean on, and he will have to develop his own emotional strength to heal the rifts he's unconsciously brought into being.


I just felt the "not spending enough time with Neha" wala guilt was a bit contrived. Feeling guilty all the time for every imaginary issue is a more a sign of immaturity than otherwise.
Ishwari and Dev have always brushed Neha's opnion aside and treated her like she's nothing more than a stubborn child. Today I saw Dev acknowledging that, acknowledging all the opportunities he had missed to really get to know Neha and have a meaningful sibling relationship with her. And @bold: I just think you outlined Dev's characterisation perfectly! He feels guilty for "imaginary issues" because he thinks he is responsible for everyone's happiness, so if they are not happy, he is directly to blame. This is certainly his immaturity, his failure to understand that he doesn't possess that kind of power. What remains to be seen is how he grows to understand that.

mayu1982 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
@ Sam ( even @ Maham ) loved your writing skill. Whenever there is some negative post. I really want that persona to come , and read your (@MAHAM ) post once. Although I do understand ppl do have different POV and I respect their POV as well.

Anyway coming to Post - Well See what Sona has done to Dev.. Sona and Dev phone conversation brought bit sense to him that all these years he was looking after their needs and don't know anything about their liking at all.

Earlier he used to share everything with Mom Ishwari .. Why Ishwari never knocked down some sense in him that he needs to spend sometime with his sisters as well? One more point to question Ishwari upbringing?

P.S> Bug Hug to @ SAM and want to say so many things am bit busy as usual 🤔
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: mayu1982

@ Sam ( even @ Maham ) loved your writing skill. Whenever there is some negative post. I really want that persona to come , and read your (@MAHAM ) post once. Although I do understand ppl do have different POV and I respect their POV as well.

Anyway coming to Post - Well See what Sona has done to Dev.. Sona and Dev phone conversation brought bit sense to him that all these years he was looking after their needs and don't know anything about their liking at all.

Earlier he used to share everything with Mom Ishwari .. Why Ishwari never knocked down some sense in him that he needs to spend sometime with his sisters as well? One more point to question Ishwari upbringing?

P.S> Bug Hug to @ SAM and want to say so many things am bit busy as usual 🤔


Thanks Mayu! 😃 Like you said, everyone is entitled to their opinion. Mine is heavily informed by a great love for the way they are developing the show and characters, so I might be a bit biased.


Sona has indeed introduced so many new perspectives into Dev's life. She holds a mirror up to him like nobody has before. As I have mentioned in previous posts, Ishwari was mainly interested in getting the family solvent and so she gave Dev a lot of rights which she didn't afford her daughters, because she saw him as the hope for that. This has unfortunately created a false divide between Dev and his sisters, where Dev is the "bade" of the family with Ishwari and the sisters are just bacchas. With this divide, neither did Dev get space to make mistakes, nor does Neha get taken seriously... two things which have caused major problems in their family dynamic. 😒

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".