Weekend Rambles: Stories of Committment

...Maham... thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#1

Hello people,

I'm sorry I haven't been able to reply to anyone on the last thread, working on a VM that's been giving me sleepless nights, so I have generally been too disoriented to write anything sensible here. I planned on making a post earlier but since we still have more than 12 hours since the new episode I figured I might as well write on the last three.

I love how the show touched upon the subject of commitment this week. Love and commitment are two very different things and I have seen very few shows depict that. Usually the presence of the former automatically confirms that of the latter but that doesn't have to be the case everytime and I'm glad we saw that being tested for both Dev Sona and Neha Ranveer this week.

However, since I have nothing more to add to Sam's take on Neha-Ranveer (Beautiful post once again Sam!), I'll stick to Dev Sona.

I'll be honest. I did not expect their conversation about Neha Ranveer to turn into a disagreement with a disappointed Sona leaving for home but the how and why of it made sense. All said and done, Dev and Sona have led very different lives and so they are bound to have contrasting opinions about relationships, money and happiness. Dev has only ever interpreted a lack of money as complete misery. I don't think he even remembers the time when his Father was still alive and while they were probably far from rich they must have been still been somewhat happy in their lives. That period of his life was naturally eclipsed with all the tragedy and hardship that followed and this part is firmly etched into his mind. Sona on the other hand - while she has never known the same kind of hardship as Dev in terms of money, she has still known enough happiness to be able to tell the difference between the peace of mind that money can bring from the joy that only comes from the immaterial things in life. Their backgrounds and upbringing were especially distinctive in this scene.

Sona getting upset by Dev's statement made sense to me. She was patient and understanding about what he was trying to say until he utters the words Yeh rishta barabari ka nai hai.' Time and again we have seen Sona feel that same gap between her and Dev. That was always her primary reasoning as to why Dev and Natasha make more sense as a couple. When Dev chose to follow his heart, he proved her wrong so today when she sees him affirm her initial fears/insecurities she was bound to feel hurt. Granted that Dev hadn't even thought of his relationship with Sona in the same context but it was bound to pinch. Is money really that important to be equals in a relationship? The main reason why Neha-Ranveer and Dev-Sona work tells us that it isn't. There's a genuine connect, understanding, friendship and acceptance there. And ofcourse love. You don't fall in love with someone's bank account afterall. You fall in love with their mind, their heart, even their flaws and shortcomings. Both relationships are like puzzle pieces. Each person adds something to other, thereby giving a sense of being whole and complete.

That rain sequence - Beautiful beautiful. You know, the general norm of Indian TV is that the men (Atleast those having a similar description as Dev, read - a business tycoon) play the part of being the head in the relationship and the women (Some girl whose only apparent goal in life is to make sure the hero experiences love) are the heart. As you see more and more of Dev and Sona's relationship you understand that in their case, Sona's the one with a head while Dev is all heart. Its not new, ofcourse. If Sona weren't as strong and practical, she would have never survived working for the Dixits whilst experiencing almost constant heartbreak. Dev too has always been a very emotional man and as a lover we have only seen that escalate.

I liked how Sona calmly told Dev that she needs some time to herself. Our lover boy had a different idea in mind ofcourse. And so came the important question - Are you ready to be in this relationship? Ready to be with me? Ofcourse she is, you doofus. I love how Sona's answer really wasn't a spur-of-the-moment thing. Granted that earlier her love was one-sided (well to her anyway) but even then she's known what it's like to lose Dev and now that he does love her, she wouldn't trade it for the world. Any fight or disagreement is okay as long as they are together in it. That back hug was so beautiful BTW. I loved how she smiles as she sees the relief and happiness on Dev's face... There was so much love and adoration in her eyes there. Dev is such a delicate man that way... it's sad how he was more prepared for being abandoned than being accepted by Sona. If Sona didn't know how much Dev loves her before their encounter in the rain, then Dev doesn't know how much Sona loves him either.

I loved loved loved how Dev made her promise that she would never go home like that again. I like how he understands the importance of not letting a fight fester for too long and talking things out. Also how he clarifies why he is so worried about this match, making Sona see her own fault in understanding him, was wonderful.

Their conversation about her driving was so sweet! There was something very aesthetic about that final shot where they are holding hands and laughing. And I am the only one who finds the idea of both Dev and Sona nursing a cold totally adorable? 😆

A final note about Ishwari - she is about the most confusing character on this show for me. One second she makes perfect sense and the very next she leaves you face-palming. Most of what she said about Neha to Dev did make sense to me. Her thinking that a woman should only ever please her husband and bend accordingly is disappointing though. Yes Neha was wrong, but only in the way she used Dev for what she wanted instead of talking directly to Ranveer. What irked me the most about this conversation was how she constantly refers to Neha as a child while she and Dev are the 'bade buzurg' of the house. Geez! Neha is certainly not a child. It's just easier to label her as one instead of trying to understand what drove her to this point. It's ironic really how in her head, Ishwari doesn't let Neha grow up while insisting that Dev, who is only 27 afterall, think and act like her equal. Dev is not her equal at all and Ishwari has perhaps replaced her husband with Dev in terms of an emotional support. It happens ofcourse. A mother in her position would most likely expect her son to assume the position of the head of the house but when you are required to grow up so fast, its bound to have consequences. Perhaps if Ishwari had allowed Neha to share that burden more openly, this family wouldn't be such a mess. Dev is such an emotionally handicapped person because of the same, having grown up with the single minded focus of fulfilling the needs of his family, leaving room for little else. No wonder he doesn't think much about how he's going to do that and just does it. It's why he got Sona fired from her job and also why he tried to get a better one for Ranveer.

Oh and one more thing - the whole issue with Neha and Ranveer, I'm glad the writers didn't necessarily make it too much about Dev and let the focus remain on them. Its annoyingly mandatory otherwise for every issue to become about the lead pair instead. I'll give it to Dev though... His genuine worry, love and sense of responsibility towards Neha was very touching to watch. The man's a little messed up but he nearly always means well. On a different note: It was good to see Dev having some fun on his own too... That scene with Tina was pure gold! 😆

And this has gotten long enough... I'll end my ramble now. Happy Monday guys!

p.s: What is this absurd spoiler I read about Ranveer's character taking a very K-Ektaish turn? 😕 Assuming it's false though. 🤔

Edited by ...Maham... - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.5k

Users

10

Likes

55

Frequent Posters

independent thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Nice post👏 beautiful analysis 👏
EJF_FAN thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
What a start to Monday !! Thank you for this beautiful analysis... Waiting for the episode now! :-)
Ferdous_69 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
As always superb Maham
Brilliant analysis...

Nd ha... Madly missed ur post...
Waiting for ur VM
mayu1982 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Well whenever I see your post , my excitement increase, knowing I will be reading something worthwhile and interesting : My reaction to your post



After reading your post : wow no words .. Too good



And

finally @ MAHAM And even @ SAM - am sure very soon she will write something interesting over here




P.S.. Is your VM ready ? Greedy me 🤔
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Beautiful post, Maham! It's so great to have you back 😃 And thanks so much for the shout out! I really hope this phantom rumour about Ranveer turning negative is rubbish.😕 It doesn't fit the trajectory the story has taken so far, and it makes so much more sense for them to explore Neha and Ranveer's complex relationship, where Neha's demons and Ranveer's pride are the primary antagonists. Much more in the vein we've seen so far.

Your central theme of commitment is so spot on! The way the show is justifying the title is pretty amazing. Instead of portraying love as a monolithic entity that answers all questions and solves all problems once it enters your life, they are truly showing us the different shades of the emotion, and how it can also bring problems of its own. In such a short time, they have so beautifully illustrated so many of these shades: unrealised love, unrequited love, friendship, laughter, conversation and confidence, the bliss of the first union, the rude interruption of reality, disagreements, reconciliations... and of course, the big one, commitment.

Part of what has defined Dev's character from the very beginning is that he doesn't really take the time to question his own actions and their motivations. Once he wants something, he dives headlong into it and doesn't look back. This is a luxury that Ishwari, who didn't hold him accountable for anything other than financial success, has afforded him. You need the blind self-assurance Dev has to be as successful as he is in business, and she made sure he got it. I completely agree that had Ishwari not skewed the balance so much, their family would have been, perhaps nowhere near as wealthy, but much, much happier and more balanced (I actually made a whole post about that sometime last week, so I won't get repetitive here 😛). The irony now is that the way Ishwari has treated Dev all this time is backfiring in the way Dev is pursuing his relationship with Sona. He doesn't feel accountable to anyone, and goes where he wants when he pleases. It was one thing to support his decision to break the engagement with Natasha, but he should have had to deal with the consequences as well. When his Mami tried to tell him this, he brushed her off and told her he didn't want to talk about it anymore. I'm no fan of Radharani, but his response was downright disrespectful. It was a similar thing with the haldi-dood. Dev's mind thought, I'm running late, and don't want my mom to leave her breakfast for me, and Sona is giving me milk that is pre-prepared so no one has to take the trouble. He had no idea how that act could be read in a totally different way with an emotional spin on it! As Sona would say, "kardiya na typical ladkowali baat!" 😉

Okay, so before I go off on too much of a tangent 😆, my point is that Dev has gotten used to people seeing him as a demigod, capable of solving all problems, and beyond questioning... and I think he likes it; I mean, who wouldn't? But he sees himself that way because he has been taught to, never given the tools of introspection and self-reflection. There's no, "is what I am doing right?" but rather "I'm doing it so it must be right." Sona is the first person who is holding him to a higher emotional standard, and it is both thrilling and terrifying for him. I know we read that car scene when Sona is telling him he isn't god totally differently that day, but when I rewatched it I thought: maybe his silence was really him sulking because she questioned his ability to make her happy, and the rain was a lucky coincidence that smoothed the tension over and made him feel in control again.

And I kind of like how they aren't addressing this flaw in one go. Even with the Ranveer/middle-class thing, they never showed him fully understanding where Sona's concerns lay, but he understood that he had done something to dissapoint her, and took the first step of accepting that he was a difficult person because of his past. That kind of vulnerability is a huge and brave step for Dev, offering Sona not the all-powerful "Hi, I'm Dev Dixit," but the broken, emotionally-stunted Dev, and asking of she would still accept him. I loved that moment just before the hug when Sona didn't quite know what to say. Poor Dev probably thought admitting his flaws was a "big reveal" moment, and Sona was just thinking, "I KNOW, you doofus (excellent word-choice, btw), that's why I fell in love with you!" 🤣

EDIT
@Mayu: You know the drill! 😉😆 This one's for you! 🤗
Edited by Samanalyse - 9 years ago
WeRockTheWorld thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
I really like way you analyse and enjoy reading ur write up 😊
-AditiS thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
take a bow Maham. excellent write up! 👏
While i am so caught up on drooling over 2 kids dancing in rain and 2 lovers reconciling on a rainy night, u come up with this 😲 and compel me to take another look at whole of last week wrt love n commitment. too good.

adding to that, way you have tried analysing Dev's character is so interesting- why he does what he does, the way he does; linking it to his upbringing n how Ishwari has raised n treated him. it's great analysis n adds so much to my KRP experience.

@Sam- I loved your comment too much. was a pleasure reading it. u write so clearly about Dev- he is business tycoon but with a heart; he is a solution seeker but without thinking of overall consequences. i see what u want to say!

ur reading of Sona's mind when she responded after couple of seconds to Dev's Q ... that's 👏👏⭐️
gemini54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
I was waiting for this write up I am glad I did not miss reading it. I am confused by Easwari behaviour and now about Why Dev who loves Sona's does not fight for her...any thoughts?
adoremevirgo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
as usual i am always late latif in reading ur brilliant posts...i totally agree with u that ishwari is a very complicated character...the stand that she takes for neha actually surprises me...she is always insisting that ranveer is a very precious man and neha shud overlook the financial constraints whereas she knows that her eldest daughter fears poverty...as a mother she shud hv gvn her more practical advice that even if she loves ranveer she cannot expect him to change overnite and promise her riches of life...instead she is eager to get neha married to a family who r practically lower middle class...
dont get me wrong i hv no issue about money but neha has...i wud hv loved a scene where ishwari is sitting with her daughter and telling her that her fear of lack of money in life will bound to happen if she marries ranveer and so she shud think properly before making marriage decision...i am not saying ishwari shud discourage neha but shud show her the practical picture like all mothers do...

wat concerns me is that the way ishwari is kind of taking a "love is all and everything else is secondary" kind of approach in the case of neha,,,,dev is actually starting to believe that his mom wud take a similar approach in his and sona's case...therefore i really feel so bad for dev wen he will come face to face with reality which is that ishwari will not actually ake a completely different approach in his context...

the constantly smiling glowing and hving fun that dev is now after falling in love is a treat to watch...i only wish ishwari as a mother wont want to snatch this happiness from dev for her selfish desire that she shud be the focal point of his life...noone can take the place of a mother but similarly a mother cant fulfill a lover or wife's position in a man's life...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".