June 16: Of Love & Secrecy - A Web of Emotions

...Maham... thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#1

Hello people,

Another great episode. As Neets said in her post, I'm glad they toned down the romance a bit today and let other things come in to focus. That balance needs to be maintained because let's face it, this show is more than a love story and that's what sets it apart.

Dev and Sona's silent exchanges infront of Ishwari were amusing on their own but they also got me thinking a bit about the main conflict in this show. I'll get to that in a bit. I found it funny how Dev actually held onto the carrot while heading out. Reminded me of the million times he has left halfway through breakfast and rushed to work. That's a very special little carrot for Dev though. 😆

Nikki was so sweet on finding out about Sona's break-up'. Even Sona felt a combination of amusement and affection for the way Nikki was concerned for her. It lasted two seconds though... Sharp girl that she is, she immediately asks why is she so happy these days when she has just broken up. Normally those kinds of things leave you devastated you know? 😆

Sona grumbling about Dev saying one thing and doing the opposite - 😆 Can't blame her either.

It's so sweet how these two alternate between depth and intensity and all things romantic to acting like two lost kids who don't have the slightest clue about love or relationships. This bit of their conversation in the car was so so adorable,

"Ab main kya ghussa bhi nai karsakti? Mujhe kya pata tha ke pyar aisa hota hai?"

"Aap mujhse kya pooch rai hai, mujhe kya pata? Mujhe tou pyar ke baare mein jitna bhi pata hai woh aapse hi pata hai."

Their expressions here... You gotta appreciate how Shaheer and Erica bring forth such varying shades in Dev-Sona's relationship with equal conviction. Dev's statement also brings your attention towards the fact that as intense and romantic our lover is, Sona is ultimately his guiding light. Whatever knowledge or understanding he has come to have about love is through Sona and in that sense they have a long road ahead of them. It's great though. I'd really like to see these two grow and explore their relationship together, discover more about each other and themselves along the way and ultimately fall more and more in love. Can that possibly happen on Indian TV? Does it? 😆

Dev stalking Sona on the web didn't surprise me in the least. He has always been like this and I was immediately reminded of all the times he has called Tina up to research on some xyz person and send him all their details. The only difference here perhaps is that this time he endeavored to carry out the task himself. I suppose even Tina would have a thing or two to say if she were asked to go through Dr. Bose's social media profiles. 😆 I love that little detail they showcased today about Dev being too busy in going through Sona's old status updates/tweet etc. to ignore her text messages to him. Dev has always been methodical about everything he does; he is such a businessman that way. He knows how to deal with people in his line of work, we have seen how he does just enough research to know how to impress them or how to get rid of them. Even when he was first introduced to Sonakshi, he ran a background check there and then. Now as well, you see how he employs some of the same methods and in his eagerness to to find out every little detail of her life, he fails to understand the importance of the present moment. Naturally Sona steps in to guide his hand, both literally and figuratively, and helps him understand that to know a person all you have to do is spend time with them, talk to them and just be with them. Relationships don't operate under the same rules as business. Business requires a certain detachment. Relationships need companionship and conversation. You have to really give yourself on an emotional level. Sona loves the fact that Dev wants to know so much about her and so do I. What Dev needs to understand however is that he won't know her heart through a Facebook profile. He'll know it by simply spending every day with her. Even them sitting down and talking late into night as she makes her way through all those questions he had would be enough :)

I loved the little skip in Sona's step as she came down the stairs to sit with her family. They really don't miss a detail. Poor Elena and Dada. They were there for Sona everyday, worrying constantly for her and yet she deprived them of this bit of happy news! Bohat nainsafi hai baba 😆 Their scenes are so naturally sweet and full of warmth BTW. Love the natural camaraderie between them.

Coming to the scene between Dev and his family. I love how everything Sona tells Dev stays permanently with him. The ease with which he gave Nikki permission over the trip was such a great throwback to the time Nikki wanted to go for a sleepover with her friends. Everything he said to Ishwari about letting Nikki grow up and experience new things echoed so strongly of the advice he had gotten from Sona on the subject.

Ishwari feeling so happy and at peace over Dev's happiness was very touching. I felt bad for her today. You might label her as an overly-possessive mother but she does love her son with all her heart and really does seem to want what's best for him. The way they keep emphasizing on Ishwari's continued assertions that Dev needs to live for himself a bit really makes you wonder why she will react negatively to Dev and Sona's relationship. My current theory is that we aren't just dealing with her fear of losing Dev once he gets married. I think how Dev is keeping her in the dark about all of this will also be a contributing factor to her disapproval. I understand Dev ofcourse... when you experience happiness and love like this for the first time then some part of you gets selfish with it. You just want to revel in the feeling on your own for a while and that's probably why Dev is being so secretive. He loves the idea that no one else is privy to what he has with Sona. It's exciting and romantic and new and he wants it stay that way for now. He's just so happy with how things are you know? Besides his family isn't exactly like Sona's. They would most definitely not approve, especially since he chose to break up with Natasha to be with Sona - especially a particular gharib ki beti. You can't blame Dev for wanting to escape the inevitable drama for as long as he can.

But but but... It is still going to hurt Ishwari very badly. Especially if she finds out about their relationship accidentally without them telling her first. It's a betrayal of sorts. Ishwari and Dev are one unit in a way. Today as well, if you noticed, she fully expected Dev to agree with her about Nikki's trip because that is how it has always been. For Dev to keep something so huge from her is going to shake Ishwari up and she is naturally going to question if Sona is taking her son away from her. Dev isn't even aware how his Mother feels about him getting married one day, he is oblivious to her insecurities to some extent so he doesn't realize the damage he is going to cause by keeping all this from his Mother. Remember that Dev and Ishwari's bond isn't a normal one. Sometimes he is the parent and she is the child, sometimes vice versa. Then he also sees her as his God and to top it all there is a deep friendship and understanding between them. Dev is assuming that Ishwari would just be happy when he finally tells her but it's not as simple as that. I felt a little sad for Dev too.. The conviction he has that Ishwari will always support his decisions is so absolute. It's going to shake Dev up when the opposite happens. It's necessary ofcourse.. He needs to see that his Mother is really just a normal human being with her own set of flaws and insecurities. All in all, it's such a complex yet fascinating web of relationships in this show. Before Sona, the Dixits had found a kind of routine in their dysfunctional lives. I hope to see Ishwari understand that sometimes change is good. It's healthy and it helps you heal. Everything won't be perfect immediately but Sona entering their lives is ultimately for the better and while her son falling in love does change everything, it will not break what she has with Dev, only strengthen it.

Edited by ...Maham... - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

41

Views

4.5k

Users

17

Likes

175

Frequent Posters

KambakthIshq thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Oh Maham! I absolutely love the way you interpret each character👏
Dev is going to land himself into misery along with Ishwari and Sona with this Luka chupi game. Poor fellow being totally unaware of his Moms insecuries, just wanted to experience this new Rang in his life is going to lead to a big misunderstanding.
Well Isn't this what we were waiting for? Bring it on CV's but please wait for a week or two.. Let the love birds spend some quality time with each other 😆

I'm curious to see how the makers are going to handle this story.

Thank you so much for this post🤗
Edited by KambakthIshq - 9 years ago
LiveLoveLaugh96 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Loved the analysis!!
Really well written :))
Nothing more to add 😆

And yayy my comment on the first pg atleast 😆
Adi_Ki_Zoya thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
I already feel sad for Dev
The poor guy will be confused to be more sad for what? For staying away from sona? Or for finding out that his mother isn't there with him in taking the happiest decision of his life!
😭
TheRowdiest thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
As usual beautiful written Maham 👏

Another thing which will make ishwari so insecure that Dev is totally into Sona, always ready to say sorry , do things the way she wants and In past Ishwari got angry with Sona when she called him Dumb. she will feel Dev has totally changed for Sona , like juro ka ghulam and she will hate it .
aaliah3108 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Hi Maham.

AS always your post is just sooo good and a worthwhile read into this complexity of emotions that we sell get to see in sometime.
I have a different view point over why Dev and Sona are hiding it from Ishwari or Sona from her parents for that matter.
Well any new couple takes time to settle in their relationship... No one believe me no one goes to their parents on the 2/3 Rd day of their courtship to disclose that they are seeing someone.
Everyone needs time to know the other person and then since we know how our respective families are... The couple tries to present each other in their families.. And everyone tries to present themselves as if they r perfect to mingle in a new household. What different r these souls doing! Dev knows Sona has been coming to his house and she is on good terms with all except of course the one... GKB! I don't find his approach wrong as such as of now... No one decides to get married in a week after proposing... It's V natural. The poor chap is trying to enjoy and buy some personal time for himself like his mom keeps saying.. Personal time is personal... It does not include anyone...
After so many reassurances and her standing along with him in his every decision and declaring it vocally all the time... I don't see any reason for it to strike him that his mom will not accept Sona. What can the reason be after all? Why will it bother him just now... He feels he will go and tell his Mom and she will agree... She shd agree if she really loves Dev.
I just hope she sees that it shall be Sona who will understand how important. ISHWARI is for Dev which is why in the earlier promos she said... You think /feel she will not agree... So I'm not saying anything either you understand yourself... Sona is not the kind of person who will ever step in their equation... She has seen them... I just hope ishwari realises this that Change at times brings out the good in a person too... If her son has changed its his wish which is so imp. for her... Ain't he a robot if he does not change at all... I m just not ready to accept any reason why there will be opposition from her end if she claims to say she feels she has been to a pilgrimage when she sees Dev happy... It's heartbreaking that a mom would not value what her son wanted most in his life... That's not a mom's love... Well let's see how this all plays out. It's not going to b an easy ride..it is said a mom's love is unconditional but is it really so? This plot is test of a mother's love for her son and also how Dev and sona deal with this situation. My eyes r on Ishwari really Coz the children will bear the brunt of her decision what so ever it is
Someone who loves with a lot of passion... The heartbreak is equally painful... The deeper the love... Deeper is the pain!
I'm sad already.
Edited by aaliah3108 - 9 years ago
Ferdous_69 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
As always beautiful written Maham...
Great analysis...I also felt bad for dev...I think he should tell his mom ASAP about sona
Anyway.. Amazing post dear
Thanks for sharing it with us...
ZumSrK. thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
What an amazing analysis yet again !! 👏

Hehe and I wanted to use these hugs for you 🤗🤗🤗
Edited by ZumSrK. - 9 years ago
Samanalyse thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
Thanks for pointing me in the direction of your post, Maham! This forum is really on fire, and it's getting harder and harder to keep up!

I, of course, loved your entire post (like, what's even new? 😆) but there were a few things that really stood out.

Your observation that Dev is trying to approach love like he approaches business is spot on, and I love the little irony you noticed that in trying to learn all about Sona through social media, he missed the messages of the present-Sona who is really the only one who matters. In many ways, our nadaan Dev was much better at this whole love thing before he realised he was in love! He was so confident in his knowledge of Sona when pitted against Neel, for example, and rightly so - he probably knows more about her than anyone except her own family. Now that he is formally in love, he feels like he should really be deliberate and proactive about it. But like our wise heroine advised, it's better to let these things happen organically instead of forcing their hand.

I really look forward to Sona-Elena-Sourabh moments now! Their camaraderie is so easy and natural and it sets up such a stark contrast between Dev and Sona's families, giving you an idea of why Sona is so much more prepared for a relationship than Dev, despite neither having ever been in one. Sona is surrounded by laughter and happiness in her family, the biggest problem at the moment being that her mother doesn't know what to write her book about! Sourabh and Elena especially have been so supportive of her throughout this phase. It breaks my heart that Dev doesn't have anyone to share his joy with who would just be happy for him and join him in jumping around, no strings attached. The very fact that he didn't go running to Ishwari with the news that he had fallen in love speaks to the complexity of their relationship, despite its innocent facade.

And that brings us to the central issue... the growing concern of Ishwari's insecurities. But, as I mentioned on Neets' post, the promos seem to hint that the problem is as much Dev's as it is Ishwari's. And I think something that is going to factor in in a major way which we haven't considered is Dev's guilt. For those who have always thought about others, and have been pretty much brainwashed into doing so, thinking about oneself doesn't come that easily. Dev may be floating on cloud nine now, but it's only going to take one untoward result of concentrating on himself to bring him crashing down. Even today, I loved his little flinch when he realised he was more interested in Sona's response than what Ishwari was telling him she told her, and he seemed to quickly refocus. Imagine when he forgets something major that has to do with Ishwari. His guilt is going to be monumental, and I wouldn't be surprised if his reading of Ishwari's disapproval is partly the projection of his own guilt onto her.

So... this got long and rambly! 😛
Edited by Samanalyse - 9 years ago
JyotiBThakur thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
As always... Bang on Analysis Maham...👏 I am loving this new Dev and how the makers are handling DevAkshi love story... It seems so natural... 2 People who have never been in love before are trying to build their relationship and trying to learn what to do when in love is beautifully portrayed.
DevAkshi are cute and ShaRica makes them perfect onscreen with their performance.👏

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".