@Ria: Wow, it touched me deep inside Superb analysis.. so we are at same wavelength emotionally today... wat i like most about ur analysis is simplicity.. u explain all their emotions, their feelings, their actions in such a simple words n yet u cover them all beautifully.. especially when it comes to Arjun.. i know u r always biased towards Arjun n tend to overlook his flaws!! i know its hard 2 find faults with such n ideal character..but u know wat i like Arjun from ur perspective more than what actually he is..
Ok so coming back 2 u analysis, i was engrossed completely reading it first time and had to read it twice b4 replying..
he has these shades in him that pull you towards him...He has flaws but still has this beauty deep down inside him which attracts you towards him👏...and it could only be Arjun who has the ability of earning back his love with dignity even after he stooped so low in the eyes of his love....
--Well said, it was that beauty of his heart, the purity of his soul which made Aro fall in luv with him.. both of them cud c the purity of soul n beauty of heart which lied under their outer mask...u know creatives have depicted that tangible feeling of luv that weave them together so beautifully.. those epis where they gradually realize their feelings n starts falling in luv with each other inspite of flaws r my all time favorites..wat a beautiful luv story...
In his opinion Arohi was acting all the way...and if one is in the acting mode you overact in situations like this where you are humiliated...just to make a bigger fuss out of it...she could have screamed at him, slapped him, run away, cried, sobbed....questioned holding on to his collar...called him names...Did she do anything like that...No...Why? Cuz her emotions had died...so there was no more room for her to say anything..and it was this SILENCE that haunted Arjun...that gave him the same odd feeling yet once again of something being very wrong!
--Well well, he is slowly realizing that something is wrong.. oh i wud luv this track.. Arohi's continued silence prompts him to realize that something is wrong somewhere.. that his heart is right.. n seeing his pitiful plight DK finally admits his mistake n tells him the truth... ah wat n interesting plot isnt it..
I asked this question yesterday as to whether he pushed her to the limits or he just could not stop her from saying all that...I get the answer today...He did not push her to limits yesterday...infact he did not expect her to confess her love at that point in time AND in this way (yet again there is a difference in confessing when you are acting)...
--yesterday he didnt push her but he definitely encouraged her wrong assumption that he believes her.. his constant reassurance that he believes her n will fight with his Dad 4 her prompted her confession..n obviously he did not expect her confession n i m definitely not mad at him at what he did bcoz he had 2 do it..it takes story forward..but i m STILL mad at the way he tried 2 kiss Aro..that definitely is a big no-no from Arjun's part 4 me..
BUT today he pushed her...he said everything that will make her break the silence...the silence which was deafening for him...But what she does in response only deepens his wounds...her "aur kuch sir" was enough of a scream so loud that it was enough to tore him apart...her tears were as real as the fact that he was alive at that point in time...
--Yeah..ruthless words.. pricking taunts.. ah.. damage done to perfection!!
Arjun with Dad:
--as i said in my analysis i did find it that effective.. now that i have read ur analysis i will now definitely find it interesting.. but Satyajit is definitely good actor.. i cud only c DK on screen n not satyajit n he really make me hate DK 4 wat he is doing Creatives better have a gud explanation 4 his acts..
Arjun is in shock and denial (Thanks Anjana for making us understand and analyze this)..."I am perfectly fine Dad"...I just could not hold back my emotions when he says "main nai kia tora hai Dad"...yet again symbolic but so apparent...his internal guilt reflected so beautifully in these 4-5 words...He is guilty and the natural reaction is that one becomes defensive...and in doing so cannot listen to anything negative about him...his defense reflex was fully active during this initial part of the their talk....So for me it was Denial and Defense that he was going through....
--"main kya toda hai dad" yeah that dialogue touched me most.. just one dialogue expresses all his luv, pain, n guilt..
But than he knows himself deep down that he has done it all wrong...he has broken that single thread that held the relationship with Arohi...The colors of the elevator would never be the same again! he knows that....and the eyes that were rock solid in front of the redness in Arohi's eyes a few minutes ago...were now filled with a pain more than hers....cuz they not only reflected Arohi's pain but also his own! Where Arohi will only have to cry on her fate.....her humiliation...Arjun has to cry for the pain he gave and the pain he feels! he deserves that....but than is it his fault?
--Yeah though he has that doubled his grief n no one is to blame 4 it.. yet i m all with Aro.. Arjun has 2 bear his guilt where as Aro has 2 bear his mistrust on her luv.. inspite of knowing that he is not wrong n he is not 2 blame she has 2 bear all the his hatredness n pain that he inflicts on her.. Arjun can at least hate her.. do those ugly things n bring out his frustration..Aro cannot even do that.. she can never hate him.. it is not her Arjun who is doing all this..n yet she cannot change him.. she cannot bring him back in to her life.. there is helplessness, there is frustration n yet she cant vent it out on him like he does..is there any greater pain than wat she feels..
and the irony of the situation is as I always say both of them know the depth of their feelings but fail to realise the depth of feelings the other has for them! The "Haalaath".....
--well said.. well will it be that "ek pal" when they finally realize this?
He does not hate her......He hates himself! and that is because they are not any more two different entities at the emotional level...
--well said..
Manisha
p.s: I m posting this twice now.. my IE bugger has betrayed me twice.. so please bear with formatting.. go to catch up with my work..