That was inappropriate!

dhoopkinarey thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

Okay, so I admit that Balaji shows aren't an authority on religion, but today I found myself wondering what the director was thinking, and how much does he really know about the Islamic culture.

My sister has constantly pointed that AA marriage is considered illegal Islamically because Afreen didn't observe her iddat (the time to wait after your husband passes- In islam, if a woman finds out she is pregnant after her husband's passing, she cannot marry till the baby is born). I let that pass because, after all, this is a serial and you can only expect so much. There was no other excuse they could find to make AA marry each other.

However, today's episode was a bit much. In no Islamic prayer will the men and women ever be facing each other. While I loved the AA romance, it was highly inappropriate. They were praying for God's sakes! They shouldn't have been staring at each other.

I love this show, and I know that Ekta misportrays Indian culture as well (how many girls really have sex before marriage, or get married to four different people), but I guess this just bothered me and I thought I would put it out there, and see if it annoyed anyone else?

PS- I loved how Afreen prayed for God to show her the way to unite two people who love each other--she didn't say Saniya and Azaan, only two people who love each other. I think the two people are AA, not SA, so I hope Afreen is shown the way, and stops sacrificing and falling for Saniya's traps!

So this topic has generated a lot of interest 😊, but there are many people who are still confused about iddat. Iddat is the time a woman must wait after the death of her husband to marry. This time is four months and 10 days (not 40 days, which is a common misconception). If the woman finds out she is pregnant during this time, her iddat extends, and she must wait till the baby is born before she remarries.

As far as Hinduism is concerned, I know that Ekta inaccurately portrays Hinduism as well as Indian culture. Often times, she will show the actors/actresses walking in with shoes into a temple, which is most definitely inappropriate. She also shows girls having sex before marriage, which is not acceptable by any standards, Hinduism or Indian. Nobody here is saying she accurately portrays Hinduism and Indian culture- I was merely pointing out she is also not portraying Islam properly.

Last thought: I know it is a serial, but I just wanted to see who else notices this stuff, and how much of what Ekta shows is taken at face value and what is researched by the average viewer to confirm what they see. I am an Indian as well as a Muslim, so Ekta pretty much angers me on all fronts at times 😆, but I still love this show 😳!

Edited by dhoopkinarey - 18 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

35

Views

3k

Users

25

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

shafaqali thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
oh my GOD u r so rite that a pregnant women can't get married after the child is born that really is inappropraite if they want to show a soap based on isamic religion they should show it rite this way they are misguiding people
shafaqali thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
oh my GOD u r so rite that a pregnant women can't get married after the child is born that really is inappropraite if they want to show a soap based on isamic religion they should show it rite this way they are misguiding people
chituku thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: dhoopkinarey

PS- I loved how Afreen prayed for God to show her the way to unite two people who love each other--she didn't say Saniya and Azaan, only two people who love each other. I think the two people are AA, not SA, so I hope Afreen is shown the way, and stops sacrificing and falling for Saniya's traps!

i thought the same she said two people not sania & azzan😆
m_khusi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: dhoopkinarey

Okay, so I admit that Balaji shows aren't an authority on religion, but today I found myself wondering what the director was thinking, and how much does he really know about the Islamic culture.

My sister has constantly pointed that AA marriage is considered illegal Islamically because Afreen didn't observe her iddat (the time to wait after your husband passes- In islam, if a woman finds out she is pregnant after her husband's passing, she cannot marry till the baby is born). I let that pass because, after all, this is a serial and you can only expect so much. There was no other excuse they could find to make AA marry each other.

However, today's episode was a bit much. In no Islamic prayer will the men and women ever be facing each other. While I loved the AA romance, it was highly inappropriate. They were praying for God's sakes! They shouldn't have been staring at each other.

I love this show, and I know that Ekta misportrays Indian culture as well (how many girls really have sex before marriage, or get married to four different people), but I guess this just bothered me and I thought I would put it out there, and see if it annoyed anyone else?

PS- I loved how Afreen prayed for God to show her the way to unite two people who love each other--she didn't say Saniya and Azaan, only two people who love each other. I think the two people are AA, not SA, so I hope Afreen is shown the way, and stops sacrificing and falling for Saniya's traps!

I agree with you she cant marry another person till the baby is born but as you said its a serial, and i was also womdering why men and women where sitting together during the quran khani that never happens, but what can you its a serial and a kekta serial that says it all. I dont pay much attention to these things coz its a serial but they are misguiding ppl.

I hope afreens prayer gets heard and AA reunite

Edited by m_khusi - 18 years ago
anumra thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
dhoopkinaray...u took my words outta my mouth and sed them soo well...seriously i was thinking the same frm the beginning...isnt azaan frm pak...then he must know the full culture..why didnt he guide any1...
Dark Love thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
Yasir isn't Ekta Kapoor, he just acts as he is told😳 Afreen-Azaan marriage issue has been discussed before too. True, they shouldn't have been staring at each other. I think you all should put this in your feedback to Balaji.
UnKnown:) thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: sajibabe

no about afreen marrying azaan is not appropriate, my brother who is totally religious & breathes & lives for religion, said the waiting period is 40 days, pregnant or not pregnant. but men & women sitting together is totally inappropriate, but then ekta seems to have very little knowledge of any religion, including her own. don't stress yaar just enjoy the show, as in ekta land logic has no room, if she is really struggling with islaam, she doesn't need to go far to seek knowledge. i am sure our hotty handsome hunk yaasir can give her some tips for sure

ya iddat is 40 days
but if u preg dunt u have to wait for the baby to be bornn??
medzs thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
😳 wow this is something new i am learning about the muslim religion, that why i find khwaish so interested 😳
dhoopkinarey thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: amrita rao fan

ya iddat is 40 days
but if u preg dunt u have to wait for the baby to be bornn??

Iddat is actually 4 months and 10 days after the husband's death, not 40 days. This extended time is to allow the woman to mourn, and to ascertain whether the woman is pregnant or not; and if she is, then she has to wait till the child is born.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".