karan does not desesrve criticism - Page 2

well i believe in a forum both criticism AND appreciation shud be welcum..i do agree with wht pg17 wrote its all the same story lines whereas with these new non-ekta serials its better storylines and they dont need all those clothing and loud music to make them run..for eg left right left..but im not saying that means v dont watch ekta serial cuz every1 wacthes ekta serials cuz there is just sumthing in them that u have to watch them!

in reply to the main topic about karan patel...well no doubt he's a gud actor and like all other actors given a chance he has the possibility to improve more..however...i think he wud suit more in the side roles...a main lead wud be sum1 who puts the screen on fir with the very first presence..now every1's not iqbal or eijaz...but i think this present robby is an avg guy...not those HEARTTHROBS type as it is the way he is presented..and noman i think currently has far more fanz than robby...but lets c how the story line proceeds now that they HAVE given the main lead to him..

members can be diff in their opinions but plz dont get going personal.

my POV,
i dont think karan did justice to rockstar role..but this may be bez, the whole set is same as KYPH and i started expecting IQBAL's magic rockstar..everyone cant carry it off 😳 . lets see how this character shapes up. its just one epi, we cant come into conclusions. 😳


amu~

come on donot compare iqbal and karan!
iqbal is good in his own ways
but i really dont understand how iqbal did justice to a rockstar role???
juat having an attitude does not make you a rockstar the guy can barely dance!!1
and karan was soo good in his dance performance

Originally posted by: adonis

come on donot compare iqbal and karan!
iqbal is good in his own ways
but i really dont understand how iqbal did justice to a rockstar role???
juat having an attitude does not make you a rockstar the guy can barely dance!!1
and karan was soo good in his dance performance

i dint saw iqbal dancing and karans so i cant judge ......but i will definetly like to watch karan as a rock star .........common guys it is hardly 1 episode so lets give him a chance ......ektha is not a fool to select him for her serial......so lets watch him ......hope he does justice to his character.....

yeah i agree karan justmade his entry and critism is on..

i think we should wait and let the story unfold and watch him how he does justice to the character of robbie..

the little role he did in ka as soham's friend was good and in kaa also as shiv's cousin bro ...

i think we must give him a chance but i did like how he was perfect guy with the media and next a carefree and attitude guy ..