5/12 - Prerna Sharma might just be the most infuriating Balaji FL - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

55

Views

6.1k

Users

15

Likes

195

Frequent Posters

gravshrav23 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: AnuPre

I don't understand why she has to marry Naveen and work In London to repay the amount given by him? Instead they can sell the house and live in a rented house. She can do part time job. Both Prerna and Shivani can take tuitions for children and pay the rent.His brother will also help her


Because they're the female leads. If they start getting into part-time work and actually SHOW WOMEN WORKING, what will happen to the kitchen-politics telly shows are so used to showing?

So they must crib about their fate in life, but not lift a finger to actually address those issues!
gravshrav23 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#42
😆

Originally posted by: Ayesha1980


Yes kasauti lacks good creatives and director ...if u see kuch rang you wont believe it was her first show when she even did not knew that much hindi ...but still she did her best ..so instead of doing masti on sets ...i think her co actors also need to guide her ...also this director he is not doing good job ..Ekta shud hire Noel Smith from kuch rang ...first thing he will do he may throw script of the show...only that can be a lifesaver for the show 😆


@red😆😆

Oh yes! I'm sure he's sitting horrified watching his first protege/starlet look like such a disinterested chick in her so-called hit show.
gravshrav23 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: -Doppelganger-

Exactly 😆 when I said bland I meant that one shocked expression she has for every scene. I have not seen her previous show so my judgement is based on what I have seen of her in kasauti. She probably needs a good director and a good script to bring out the best in her. Kasauti sadly lacks both


Yeah. She needs to stop looking so shocked all the time. That's such a lazy excuse to portray a HOST of other emotions yaar!😆
gravshrav23 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: jasw

I understand the frustration and anger of the viewers about Prerna's decision. As we are all financially independent, this decision seems stupid. But for a financially dependent poor person, the outlook can be different. I do not live in India, but I know a considerable percentage live under poverty lines. For money, they have to compromise on their life, sacrifice their desire even today.

We are infuriated because it is not a simple marriage to an older guy. If that was the case, Prerna in Season1 married an older guy BAjaj and was happy with him. Here we know Naveen babu has a wife and is into S** racket, which Pre does not know or does not believe.

However I would not wish the serial to be over. We have not yet seen the love story between Anu and Pre. Even without much encouragement from Prerna, Anu has managed to fall head over heels in love with Prerna, but Prerna has so far checked herself. We just got a glimpse of her love in the haldi imagination scene yesterday. Once she starts adoring Anu openly, and Anu reads that in her eyes, the story will be beautiful. So lets us just give our self a little more time .. a pause before the judgement!😊


@red - As much as I want to consider that justification, I find it hard to disagree. Not because the reasoning doesn't make sense, but because the portrayal of the Sharma family is so.

For viewers to understand and empathize with Prerna's situation, it is also necessary to see their STRUGGLE. All I see is flashy dresses, opulent homes (Sharmas too), generally great standard of living, jewellery and shopping - a standard most middle class families will find it difficult to maintain.

Either the makers could've scripted a different reason for Prerna's decision to marry an older man or taken care to portray the setup as such that it is BELIEVABLE.

At the moment, it is not!

@ blue - I disagree. None of us knew Madhuri was his first wife or that they run a sex racket together, until much later. All we knew and could see was Naveen's creepiness from day one. That was one of the key reasons behind viewers' objection to the marriage.

Secondly, but MORE IMPORTANT than the first one...this is a reboot of the original show and we expect the female lead will not succumb to regressive attitudes and circumstances as happened in the original. To see Prerna LITERALLY SURRENDER herself to this creep, when she couldv'e thought of alternatives - taking a bank loan, or from a friend, tell her parents, discuss it with Anurag, start working part-time or well, loads of other ways to go about this

She chose to simply give up, sit and dream about Anurag, ditch his well-meaning advice and even the PROOF he has attempted to show her, hate on Naveen but not lift a finger to actually get herself out of this mess. Which thinking woman even does this???

Had I seen NO OTHER RECOURSE, I may have swallowed this bitter pill - of her marrying a certified creep like Naveen, but not now. Just too hard to do so.

@maroon - that's what I'm wondering - How? And why?

@pink - You see it as love? I don't see it as such. I see her as extremely weak, quite resolute (and incorrectly so, considering someone like Anu is trying to make her see sense) and deep down somewhere I feel it's a one-sided love story...with Anu pining for her and Prerna falling into traps because she refuses to see sense and would rather be a symbol of maryrdom!

Judgment is called for, because we are, after all, the viewers..we invest our time and money, and to have the makers insult our intelligence every day, despite promising us sensible entertainment, is no less than manipulation. We're not asking for all the cards to be laid out in the beginning itself, the least we can ask for is a story and characters that fit in with the world we're living in with today!

gravshrav23 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#45
😆😆😆

Originally posted by: RollingStones

I have said earlier too , Erica needs a solid BTS team , she herself can't bring that depth through her acting . She needs a Guidance who can help her understand the emotions , her own interpretation levels are Low .

Yes She was BLANK in the Thappad scene , and so many more . I remember I had mentioned this somewhere in the forum that Shivam looked more concerned for Anurag then Prerna . Prerna was like a fool standing there and watching Drama , there was not a leg movement even from her side to go towards Anurag .
That guy is freaking taking that a slap feat for you , and you look so DISINTERESTED. I really feel thsi lovestory is One-Sided .
And Sorry but she lacks screen presence also big time . In many moments I have seen her blending in the background.


@blue 😆😆😆

and somehow, Anu could see how HURT she was

I was like, hum tum sab ko dekh rahe hain from this side of the screen, humein kyun nai dikha phir??

@red - it could be because ek toh she is petite, small face, small frame, and then the setting is always too grand ...in fact, given the setting, only Mohini and Nivi stand out!

She had amazing screen presence in her previous show, but that was a different setting altogether. It was a regular , chic home, but not too overbearing
TheSupergirl thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#46
Kudos to u @gravity for addressing this issue. I have been very excited for kasautii but right from the promo a day before the launch i have been consistently disappointed. Seeing that promo only i came to know that this is going to be nothing but just a goodlooking OTT senseless drama. Still gathering all hope watched it for eri's sake and wasn't at all impressed by the first episode. This show is lavish n grand n NOTHING else. Such lazy writing where they are just copy pasting scenes from all their shows, wth was ekta thinking this to be her dream project?
Promising audiences this is some heart touching epic love story and then basically just copying scenes n tracks ditto from ur other shows is a disservice to audiences. But as i type this i look like a fool myself because the trps have increased with this senseless track n plot. This is the root cause of the problem, we as audiences support such BS and thats exactly what we get. Look at kdb, the quality of that show is utter BS and its no. 2 on trp charts. The problem is in us as audiences. If ppl stop supporting sch shows which take audience' intelligence for granted, its only then that we will have quality shows which will launch and which will sustain.
mily_mathew thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: gravity23


@red - As much as I want to consider that justification, I find it hard to disagree. Not because the reasoning doesn't make sense, but because the portrayal of the Sharma family is so.

For viewers to understand and empathize with Prerna's situation, it is also necessary to see their STRUGGLE. All I see is flashy dresses, opulent homes (Sharmas too), generally great standard of living, jewellery and shopping - a standard most middle class families will find it difficult to maintain.

Either the makers could've scripted a different reason for Prerna's decision to marry an older man or taken care to portray the setup as such that it is BELIEVABLE.

At the moment, it is not!

@ blue - I disagree. None of us knew Madhuri was his first wife or that they run a sex racket together, until much later. All we knew and could see was Naveen's creepiness from day one. That was one of the key reasons behind viewers' objection to the marriage.

Secondly, but MORE IMPORTANT than the first one...this is a reboot of the original show and we expect the female lead will not succumb to regressive attitudes and circumstances as happened in the original. To see Prerna LITERALLY SURRENDER herself to this creep, when she couldv'e thought of alternatives - taking a bank loan, or from a friend, tell her parents, discuss it with Anurag, start working part-time or well, loads of other ways to go about this

She chose to simply give up, sit and dream about Anurag, ditch his well-meaning advice and even the PROOF he has attempted to show her, hate on Naveen but not lift a finger to actually get herself out of this mess. Which thinking woman even does this???

Had I seen NO OTHER RECOURSE, I may have swallowed this bitter pill - of her marrying a certified creep like Naveen, but not now. Just too hard to do so.

@maroon - that's what I'm wondering - How? And why?

@pink - You see it as love? I don't see it as such. I see her as extremely weak, quite resolute (and incorrectly so, considering someone like Anu is trying to make her see sense) and deep down somewhere I feel it's a one-sided love story...with Anu pining for her and Prerna falling into traps because she refuses to see sense and would rather be a symbol of maryrdom!

Judgment is called for, because we are, after all, the viewers..we invest our time and money, and to have the makers insult our intelligence every day, despite promising us sensible entertainment, is no less than manipulation. We're not asking for all the cards to be laid out in the beginning itself, the least we can ask for is a story and characters that fit in with the world we're living in with today!

Totally agree with you,the premise of the show does not justify Prernas sacrifice.Actually,I find it irtitirrit when Prenatal callsAnurag irritating,when seriously it's her and her stupidity and bipolar attitude that I find irritating .I actually want Anurag to ignore her.
KumbhkarnKiNani thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#48
Ms.Gravity- Beautiful, hard-hitting post :) You've put forth all the relevant points, in a very logical manner. This show is a disaster in it's entirety. I for one, cannot bring myself to accept that this is the same Erica who had played the firebrand nutritionist in her previous show. There is such a MASSIVE gulf in the quality of characterization and writing, when one analyses her two characters/shows.
Lively2000 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#49
I expected this show to be like Anurag will be serious and hardworking Business man and Prerna also working in company like self respected woman ..but their idea of showing them as college going students was too stupid ...neither Parth or Erica look as college going students we can make out from looks of an actor.
aur ab tu college bhi na jaane kahan chala gaya
KumbhkarnKiNani thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#50
I know this isn't the perfect co-relation but I'd like to say it.
It all started with Prerna not having enough financial resources to rebut Navvu's evil advances. The amount here is in lakhs.

In Erica's previous show, there was a stage where the FL's i.e her character's family had to face some humiliation owing to their middle-class status. That family too was a regular middle-class family (but they looked absolutely relatable, unlike the Sharma family here). She had to return Rs.5 Crore. Yeah, she was a very strong, independent and successful nutritionist in the show, but 5 Crore was still WAY beyond her family's financial reach. It is a HUGE sum for a middle-class family. They didn't have a deadline to return the money, but that girl was upright and very self-respecting. She returned the money within a very short period of time. And how did she do that? She and her family mortgaged their house. It was a tough decision, but they stood firm and went ahead with it. When your self-respect is assaulted, people DO TAKE such decisions. That is how people deal with testing circumstances in life. Contrary to that, what Prerna has done here is outright illogical and pathetic.

I'll share my own personal experiences. I'm someone who's been brought up by a single mother. My Mom was not the most highly-educated woman out there, but she slogged tirelessly to give me and my sister a good life. We purchased a house via a bank loan. Yes, a loan. The option which SO MANY middle-class families take in testing situations. We WERE middle-class and we ARE still middle-class. The Sharma family, based on how they've been portrayed, are financially MUCH more stable. Heck, I've done part-time jobs, I'm still doing one, all while pursuing my education. Even we have high expenditures, often running into lakhs, but we've always found a way. Through our hardwork, not by bending in front of anyone.

And here, Prerna is bending in front of that disgusting creep for a house! Seriously?

The writers better not use the middle-class card to justify Prerna's stupidity. DO NOT insult the intelligence and integrity of so many middle class families out there who do not resort to such idiocy, even in the toughest of situations.
Edited by KumbhkarnKiNani - 6 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".