My perspective!! - Page 12

Created

Last reply

Replies

140

Views

10.8k

Users

41

Likes

422

Frequent Posters

Beba17 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: nneeiill

^ so that means if Parth supposedly does not return we dont want MaNan HEA...hmm interesting...that sums it up 😆

i would rather have a replacement than nandini with some other guy coz even if i dont watch S2 i atleast I will know nandini got a happy ending with her man ...if parth comes back good for all of us...anyways

as of now am not watching..may not watch even if parth returns LOL


Good point
Even If Parth does not come back, Manan should not be a sad story

Manan should be given happy ending
moonlite131 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: -KP-


The reason MaNan has been unique is because it included PaNi + Richa in a package. The story telling + the actors did justice to their role, so yes, I would rather they don't replace any of the actors.

We saw what happened once Richa left to MaNan.

I guess we can see what will happen if they decide to bring a replacement for Parth as Manik.


do u think if Parth comes back it will be same? without Richa it just can't be same and we already saw tht. so at this point for me if there is anything tht I want from s2 is MaNan's HEA. even though it requires actor's replacement.
Beba17 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: LovesToBeLoved

@Genie Fans don't get paid but still we watch the show for our entertainment and emotions right? I can not agree that fans are selfless.. They are fighting for what they WANT to quench their emotional thirst. It's for themselves.. And how anything which is done for their own sake becomes a selfless act?

We buy a product by paying for it, we use it, test it, like or dislike it, give ratings, and switch on to a different brand if we find it worthless isn't it? I do agree that people have the right to criticise(I still believe there is way to do it) the product because ultimately they r the one who are paying for it. But why is it wrong if the maker try to give a justification which off course is different from what u feel? Or try to sell the same product to the other customers?? Who knows others may like it.. It's their duty to convince people to buy their product in the competitive world. So people who dislike the product should not hold the grudge against makers for hamesha and ppl who like it just because it did not satisfy their needs I believe.. But that's what I feel about the whole scenario and others are entitled to have different POV. Having said that I do not understand the need of people to bash continuously, throw so much shit, hurt everyone around just because they are hurt!!

It's all about perception and RIGHT's and WRONG's are subjective.. But if everyone keeps saying I will do whatever I want and In a WAY I want then there is no point in talking or giving explanations.

When people say they were tricked by the Writers, Karan or whoever I remember same people(Not u) wanting to slap our Nandu for taking things at FACE-VALUE. But my feelings remain consistent. Neither did I blame Nandini then nor would I blame fans now!! Anyway I can't really talk much about it as m not one of those who got manipulated or believed in whatever people said(Including cast).

The Bottom line is I just want people to live and let live just like u.. But this is not possible when everyone does whatever they want to.. Because In a way to get what we want we r trying to snatch away others right to have what they want!! It's all interrelated in such a messy way.. SIGH!!

And It's been a long time 🤗🤗


👏

Amazing post
The explanations are brilliant and factual


charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: moonlite131

do u think if Parth comes back it will be same? without Richa it just can't be same and we already saw tht. so at this point for me if there is anything tht I want from s2 is MaNan's HEA. even though it requires actor's replacement.


It won't be same either ways because MaNan story be done and over, should have finished with S2. But greed. Anyway.. yes it matters to her and me that PaNi be the faces because I like to re-watch the show . For you , it might be different matter/opinion . Doesn't make ether of us right or wrong.

If we just want MaNan HEA then whats the purpose of S2 .. should have ended back then na. Probably what the trenders also say. 😆

One scene , if cannot be managed , make her go , use phone and send her to the place where her Manik is. But till that point, let the story be solely about Nandini..not some stupid joke they are playing at right now.


-KP- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: moonlite131


do u think if Parth comes back it will be same? without Richa it just can't be same and we already saw tht. so at this point for me if there is anything tht I want from s2 is MaNan's HEA. even though it requires actor's replacement.



If parth isn't willing to come back, I would rather they show manik being alright and in touch with nandini while abroad. This is what I wished they had shown instead of this stupid bomb blast in the first place!

I cannot accept a replacement simply for MaNan's HEA! For me, MaNan's journey was special because of PaNi and if they can't give me a proper HEA, keep Nandu alone for S2.
moonlite131 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: charminggenie


It won't be same either ways because MaNan story be done and over, should have finished with S2. But greed. Anyway.. yes it matters to her and me that PaNi be the faces because I like to re-watch the show . For you , it might be different matter/opinion . Doesn't make ether of us right or wrong.

If we just want MaNan HEA then whats the purpose of S2 .. should have ended back then na. Probably what the trenders also say. 😆

One scene , if cannot be managed , make her go , use phone and send her to the place where her Manik is. But till that point, let the story be solely about Nandini..not some stupid joke they are playing at right now.



Even I want tht Genie. I'll be more than happy if they show somehow tht Manik(even if they don;t show his face or by just a call) is alive and takes Nandu with him at the end of the show. but believe me they cant sale a show just by showing FL is living only for herself, only working on her dreams. do u think people will sit n watch a youth show without a luv story for long? they will be bored within few weeks it self. I don't know if they will show her falling for someone or not. but definitely there will be guy who will be fall for her and this very thought is also very disturbing for me . thts the reason I want Manik if really they need any luv story for Nandu.
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
@Moons- See thats the flaw of S2 - you cannot go and sell a love story ever again. let her go investigate the bomb, Nyo and whatever. Focus on her music- because thats what he wanted. Beyond a point, I don't care for S2, if they cannot focus on Nandini this much . Why will I sit through a love story again after the brilliance of MaNan. Let that HEA be for final curve. You are not watching anyway, so do we really care how boring S2 is or not.
Niti sold me MaNan on her own when parth was in hospital , I trust her talent and Nandini for that. Sadly makers don't , so , let opinions be.
moonlite131 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: -KP-



If parth isn't willing to come back, I would rather they show manik being alright and in touch with nandini while abroad. This is what I wished they had shown instead of this stupid bomb blast in the first place!

I cannot accept a replacement simply for MaNan's HEA! For me, MaNan's journey was special because of PaNi and if they can't give me a proper HEA, keep Nandu alone for S2.


KP, FL can't be alone 😆. its against indian telly soap rule 😉. From business point of view it wont work for long run. so best option is to bring Manik back. In any way u wont watch the show I guess n even I will not. so why not try with new Manik rather than introducing new guy 😆. I'll be hapy with WU then 😉. btw this HEA becomes joke to me now a days. don't know why we r even fighting for this 😆
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
Moon- Works for you to say new guy for Manik, doesn't for me. I don't care how they run it but not something, agree with it. So there is that. Different perspective indeed.
LovesToBeLoved thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: charminggenie


🤗 Happy Hugs.


Nope for me MaNan HEA with paNI , if he is not available , let Nandu run the house ON HER OWN , not through contriving relationships and in the end scene, one phone call to wherever Manik is and girl leaving for that place be enough. For me personally, PaNi be MaNan.

I'm not sure about I want with MaNan anymore.. All I know is I miss them terribly and I hate seeing my Nandini in misery.. and let alone replacement It won't be same even if Parth comes back(atleast for me)


We live in a world of brand association, customer rentention- you and i both know , non maker will ever want the customer to leave it's services or products. People pan Apple , they can switch to others but they still wait for it's products with hopes. Thats how it works.

I know, But I see people expecting company to shut if it can't run on their terms.. So I don't see any HOPE.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".