My perspective!! - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

140

Views

10.8k

Users

41

Likes

422

Frequent Posters

EXOL thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Love Couple India Season 2 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
@genie : all i would say abt believing sources is "fool me once shame on you..fool me twice shame on ME"...
and i repeat bashing a channel is different than bashing a person...channel did wrong so bash them if at all u have to..
Edited by nneeiill - 10 years ago
-KP- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: moonlite131


its sad tht no one is actually fighting for Manik/MaNan. its only for Parth. for all of us Parth is only Manik. It will be very difficult and even impossible for few of us to take someone else as Manik. but wht if Parth doesn't return? then wht is the next step? shut down the show. in tht way will we get MaNan HEA? how come actor becomes greater than character? is it the first time tht we need a replacement?


Manik and Nandini are two characters who cannot be played by anyone else except Parth and Niti at this point.
Parth and Niti brought these characters to life through their individual nuances. It was Parth that made us fall in love with Monster Manik and Majnu Manik.
For me, PaNi = MaNan, so yes, I cannot see anyone else taking their place as Manik/Nandini.
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: nneeiill

@genie : all i would say abt believing sources is "fool me once shame on you..fool me twice shame on ME"...


I get that and i feel the same about the cast too. They fooled me nicely - from saying last day of the show, crying , to talking about the whole cast in S2 ..I believe them just as much as these sources.


In the end we are all fools if for this silliness we end up calling each other names and stuff.
EXOL thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Love Couple India Season 2 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
^ so that means if Parth supposedly does not return we dont want MaNan HEA...hmm interesting...that sums it up 😆
i would rather have a replacement than nandini with some other guy coz even if i dont watch S2 i atleast I will know nandini got a happy ending with her man ...if parth comes back good for all of us...anyways

as of now am not watching..may not watch even if parth returns LOL

LovesToBeLoved thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
@Genie Fans don't get paid but still we watch the show for our entertainment and emotions right? I can not agree that fans are selfless.. They are fighting for what they WANT to quench their emotional thirst. It's for themselves.. And how anything which is done for their own sake becomes a selfless act?
We buy a product by paying for it, we use it, test it, like or dislike it, give ratings, and switch on to a different brand if we find it worthless isn't it? I do agree that people have the right to criticise(I still believe there is way to do it) the product because ultimately they r the one who are paying for it. But why is it wrong if the maker try to give a justification which off course is different from what u feel? Or try to sell the same product to the other customers?? Who knows others may like it.. It's their duty to convince people to buy their product in the competitive world. So people who dislike the product should not hold the grudge against makers for hamesha and ppl who like it just because it did not satisfy their needs I believe.. But that's what I feel about the whole scenario and others are entitled to have different POV. Having said that I do not understand the need of people to bash continuously, throw so much shit, hurt everyone around just because they are hurt!!

It's all about perception and RIGHT's and WRONG's are subjective.. But if everyone keeps saying I will do whatever I want and In a WAY I want then there is no point in talking or giving explanations.

When people say they were tricked by the Writers, Karan or whoever I remember same people(Not u) wanting to slap our Nandu for taking things at FACE-VALUE. But my feelings remain consistent. Neither did I blame Nandini then nor would I blame fans now!! Anyway I can't really talk much about it as m not one of those who got manipulated or believed in whatever people said(Including cast).

The Bottom line is I just want people to live and let live just like u.. But this is not possible when everyone does whatever they want to.. Because In a way to get what we want we r trying to snatch away others right to have what they want!! It's all interrelated in such a messy way.. SIGH!!

And It's been a long time 🤗🤗
EXOL thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Love Couple India Season 2 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: charminggenie


I get that and i feel the same about the cast too. They fooled me nicely - from saying last day of the show, crying , to talking about the whole cast in S2 ..I believe them just as much as these sources.


In the end we are all fools if for this silliness we end up calling each other names and stuff.


Cast got last minute info may be..may be it was a last minute decision coz someone might have ditched at last moment ??? possinle..isnt it ??? may be mtv had no option but to continue coz of contracts with the sponsors...atleast we saw the changes in front of us unlike the so called sources jo kaha se bol rahe hai ye bhi nahi pata..anyways gtg

@bold : that is what i said all i see is hatred everyhwere...
Edited by nneeiill - 10 years ago
-KP- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: nneeiill

^ so that means if Parth supposedly does not return we dont want MaNan HEA...hmm interesting...that sums it up 😆

i would rather have a replacement than nandini with some other guy coz even if i dont watch S2 i atleast I will know nandini got a happy ending with her man ...if parth comes back good for all of us...anyways

as of now am not watching..may not watch even if parth returns LOL


The reason MaNan has been unique is because it included PaNi + Richa in a package. The story telling + the actors did justice to their role, so yes, I would rather they don't replace any of the actors.

We saw what happened once Richa left to MaNan.

I guess we can see what will happen if they decide to bring a replacement for Parth as Manik.

moonlite131 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: charminggenie

Moon- I have a problem with Nandini moving on- because 3-4 months, 2 tragedy , how the heck is anyone normal .Obviously fans be pissed coz lacks of semblance to the story of 1 year and letting Nandu be .Let her have some space.

She would be devastated given the story narration all year. By moving on - give her time for herself, why force her through a circle - of Arya-Maddy being new Dhruv-Manik. Please, watch the show , because I did , hence I know what I am speaking about Nandini and why I understand the anger.

I [protested then too about Arya- hated him, unnecessary and yes Nandu was compromised at times- never liked it but this is complete destruction for me , her basic traits are compromised which never were. Arya was introduced by Lalsa and well I don't buy his crush for Nandu because last visual was him taking selfie with Alya and having a thing for her. But S2, nope I am told he is her bff and has a thing for her WOAH. Nice.


Show is sold on yaariyaan and that is isolating Nandini again. Should have been about feb3 and her building it up together- THEY LOST 2 FRIENDS to whatever, and these guys should be tight in real sense.

I don't want Manik, my opinion, if it's not Parth , give me Nandini ..moving on without the support of contriving friendships and tashans. Or hashtags.




Sorry, I just can't watch Nandini in this state. its really painful seeing her without her monster. so yep my opinion is mostly after reading wu or GIFs. But I agree we should criticize show specially if they butcher main character. but frankly Nandini is still stuck in the same place. she is not moving on. let fall hundred guys for her but I don't think they will show her fall for anyone or at-least not so soon. and abt yaariyaan thing,they can say wht ever they want to promote but the truth is no show will be successful without a love story. so they have to build one and do u think Aliya, Mukti or Navya's luv story can sale the show?nah its just not possible. so ultimately they hav to build a luv story for Nandu if Manik doesn't retrun. thts why I want Manik's character rather than Nandu falling for some random guy, even though I'm not sure if I'll watch then also. and frankly speaking I don't know if I'll start watching the shown even if Parth returns. because the MaNan will never be same. its just giv me peace tht their humesas r not false after all. sorry I guess the discussion is going to another direction. so back to trending 😆. this bashing/trending is just creating problems between fandoms only. show will continue as long as TRP is good otherwise it will shut down automatically. so there is no point of this extreme bashing. and if its help to vent out ur frustration, then I'll say it is fine as long as others r not hurt in this process.
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: LovesToBeLoved

@Genie Fans don't get paid but still we watch the show for our entertainment and emotions right? I can not agree that fans are selfless.. They are fighting for what they WANT to quench their emotional thirst. It's for themselves.. And how anything which is done for their own sake becomes a selfless act?

Personally I don't believe there is anything selfless . But do find fans more honest then actors/makers.

We buy a product by paying for it, we use it, test it, like or dislike it, give ratings, and switch on to a different brand if we find it worthless isn't it?
Customer feedback- Products are recalled. Toyota recalled the entire batch of it's products because of customer dissatisfaction . They apologized and worked on it . Customers could have switched on to the different brand, won't have bothered at all wth feedback, investment emotionally , if it was so easy to switch on. NO MAKER wants it's customers to switch on or we won't have Customer relationship programs . So , no I don't buy this analogy.
Like I said, i don't judge cast or makers for selling or marketing the product , thats their duty. But we have boards and censors who object to such adverts if sells content that is not present in the product or services. Maggie case, court summoned the actors too who were just selling the advert. Thats how the world works, accountability on both sides should be there and everyone must be careful. Yet each to their own.
I do agree that people have the right to criticise(I still believe there is way to do it) the product because ultimately they r the one who are paying for it. But why is it wrong if the maker try to give a justification which off course is different from what u feel? Or try to sell the same product to the other customers?? Who knows others may like it.. It's their duty to convince people to buy their product in the competitive world. So people who dislike the product should not hold the grudge against makers for hamesha and ppl who like it just because it did not satisfy their needs I believe.. But that's what I feel about the whole scenario and others are entitled to have different POV. Having said that I do not understand the need of people to bash continuously, throw so much shit, hurt everyone around just because they are hurt!!

It's all about perception and RIGHT's and WRONG's are subjective.. But if everyone keeps saying I will do whatever I want and In a WAY I want then there is no point in talking or giving explanations.
But they don't have the power of getting the things their way rght. If that be the case, all this nonsense won't be happenng.

When people say they were tricked by the Writers, Karan or whoever I remember same people(Not u) wanting to slap our Nandu for taking things at FACE-VALUE. But my feelings remain consistent. Neither did I blame Nandini then nor would I blame fans now!! Anyway I can't really talk much about it as m not one of those who got manipulated or believed in whatever people said(Including cast).
Each be different in how they react to the characters and actors. Why should I be bothered by then, heck i know makers/actors don't give a damn
The Bottom line is I just want people to live and let live just like u.. But this is not possible when everyone does whatever they want to.. Because In a way to get what we want we r trying to snatch away others right to have what they want!! It's all interrelated in such a messy way.. SIGH!!
See, we are judging others by doing what we want.😆 It's a circle and for me believers and cynics are same, let all voices be heard.
And It's been a long time 🤗🤗


🤗 Happy Hugs.


Nope for me MaNan HEA with paNI , if he is not available , let Nandu run the house ON HER OWN , not through contriving relationships and in the end scene, one phone call to wherever Manik is and girl leaving for that place be enough. For me personally, PaNi be MaNan.


We live in a world of brand association, customer rentention- you and i both know , non maker will ever want the customer to leave it's services or products. People pan Apple , they can switch to others but they still wait for it's products with hopes. Thats how it works.



@Saamya- Last minute replacement? But cast said they knew aobut Parth not being in S2 since a while back? So how can YuVi be replacement when he says makers told him it\s a new character? 😕
I am going by what cast is SAYING.

I would have loved this calling out fans if t wasn't for hypocrisy. Disha ko bash karo coz of sources , Parth ko karo, Niti etc..nobody ever cared. 😆
Edited by charminggenie - 10 years ago
Beba17 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: moonlite131


I believe None of us know wht exactly happen behind the screen.

Arya was there during Richa's time too. all lame track related to Arya was introduced during tht time only. Vishal was there tht time. rt? so butchering Arya's character is not Karishma's fault. but tht time no one raise their voice or rather I will say didnt bother to protest in the way thing is going on now as MaNan was there. even though Nandini's character was butchered in tht process. not only this time, Nandini's character suffered many time before also n we know tht very well. but everything was covered up just because they kept giving up MaNan scene however those r silly or sa kind of just fillers at time. but in all these scenario we never bully or did name calling RY or the cast. we criticize a lot though and which was definitely required. and we all know how they took our criticism n tried to work on those.
Now coming to new creative team.first let me tell u I watched only one epi in S2 and can't continue as I really need Manik's character to return in the show. other wise its really difficult for me to watch Nandu in this state. now the creative team.. they r new. their way of handling each character and the show will be different. its foolishness in our part if we think tht everything will be same as it was before. we can suggest them the changes required, we can criticize them. but lets be honest, did we giv them the time to work on these things. wht we r doing is tht we r just bashing them. n again the main reason of bashing is P aka Manik is not there. they hav problem why Nandini is moving on which is not true at all. she is still leaving for Manik's dream only.
do u think this bashing will help them to fix the show? wht if the impact is just the reverse? for last week of s1, r u sure Karishma was there tht time? because few of from same source says tht she was not involve in s1. and there was tweet from her tht she was traveling tht time. so my guess s1 was orphan tht time 😆.

now abt S2, I believe it was finalized just few day's before s1 ends. so casts must know tht there is a possibility of s2 and no one was sure of it. because Abhishek/ Krish told tht they were called for s2 while they were busy for auditioning or already sign other show.
I don't expect anything from Parth so I'm not saying anything against or for him 😆

finally cyberbullying. yes it happens before also. casts did react tht time also. sometime we supported the cast n sometime we supported the fan depending upon our own perspective and we r doing the same now also.


what a post
Summed up everything
I have highlighted main takeaways

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".