Why can't Nandini love again?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

...Doctor...

@...Doctor...

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 10 years ago

#31

Originally posted by: divansree
I never reply to a post.. but this post questioned something that I admire a lot and that is manan
Nandini cant love someone again coz her fireflies shined only wid manik... He promised her humesha, he guided her through the dark part of their life and coz he can even kill somebody for her and that her monster can even fight death to be wid her.
Watch from epi 1 ... Their whole journey and if u can still say this then may be ur ri8 and we all are wrong.
some stories are forever and manan are one of them.
PS: totally my opinion, sorry if I hurt you.

I've seen it from the beginning. I'm not saying that their love has to die or they were not meant to be. No. What I'm saying is that if an unfortunate incident takes away the love of your life then you do have the right to love again. Nandini can't live her whole life without Manik or maybe she can, it's upto her. But she's very young, we should consider that, right? She should have the opportunity to fall in love, now if she wants that or not, it's totally upto her.

Thanks for replying :) No need to apologise, I guess we are having a healthy discussion here.

Quote

...Doctor...

@...Doctor...

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 10 years ago

#32

Originally posted by: Smita17
Why can't we have a happy ending?

Season 1 ended with Manan together, so much in love & happier than they'd ever been. What is happier than that? Now they needed something to get rid of Manik & make way for season 2 so they took the best route they could. What else do you want?

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

...Doctor...

@...Doctor...

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 10 years ago

#33

Originally posted by: tanyadeora19
Hahahaha!Wow!So,she should fall in love again because Manik is dead?!What if it was the other way round.If there was no Nandini?I can never see Manik(the way his character is portrayed)falling for anyone else!can you?Then why Nandini!Love can happen twice,thrice whatever but true love happens only once!And If it was True,it never dies,you can move on,but,you can't love someone else!Season 2 is sheer crap. #NoOffence. 🤢

If Nandini would have died then this post would have read 'Why can't Manik love again?'

Okay true love happens once according to you. But that's your opinion. There are people who think true love can happen twice, thrice & many more times. To each his own.

And if you judge something so early then season 1 must have been crappier than season 2 for you, initially because in the beginning they showed Manik bullying Nandini which was not COOL at all #NoOffence

Thanks for replying :)

Quote

-Aarya-

@-Aarya-

Dazzler

Posted: 10 years ago

#34

The problem is when you sell stories like "fireflies (true love), stars (forever shining), and "hamesha" love (eternity), it's hard for anyone to imagine that she would find love again with anyone else but Manik. If only they never sold those stories to us...

Your question is not wrong, it's just not for Nandini...

Quote

...Doctor...

@...Doctor...

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 10 years ago

#35

Originally posted by: ParthForeverRia
no true love doesn't end so soon,and if Manik was alive,how could Nandini fall in love?if now he isn't present in her life,so what?their connection is from soul not body.Manik resides in Nandini's heart..so it's not possible any soon for Nandini to move on.if not believe,then watch Ashiqui 2❤️

I've seen it.

You watch kuch kuch hota hai.

Thanks for replying :)

Quote

...Doctor...

@...Doctor...

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 10 years ago

#36

Originally posted by: Felicity1234
There's no issue with nandini falling in love again, but juSt think:
An 18 year old girl mentally exhausted after all the hurdles to be with the one she fell in love with, she gave everything she had to him, her love, her heart n her soul!
Now you ask me why she can't love again? That too in 3 months?!
Simple, true love never dies, at least never in 3 months!
If it's so easy for nandini to forget manik and fall for another guy in '3 months' then I'm sorry to say that nandini never really loved manik!

She hasn't forgotten Manik. She remembers him every moment. She hasn't even fell in love yet. She's not even looking at people that way. Then how can you say that she has fallen for another guy in just 3 months? Judgemental much?

Thanks for replying :)

Quote

...Doctor...

@...Doctor...

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 10 years ago

#37

Originally posted by: -Aarya-
The problem is when you sell stories like "fireflies (true love), stars (forever shining), and "hamesha" love (eternity), it's hard for anyone to imagine that she would find love again with anyone else but Manik. If only they never sold those stories to us...

Your question is not wrong, it's just not for Nandini...

Now that is true. After making us believe in such things, they shouldn't take it away but I don't think they had an option. Parth decided to quit & they had to cover his absence somehow. They just did that.

Thanks for replying :)

Quote

Mruganka and Anushka

@Arshalicious

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#38

It's nice to find a post with a different point of view...quite refreshing

Honestly like most others, I find it hard to picture Nandini with anyone other than Manik...Yes realistically speaking, it's possible for a 17 year old to fall in love more than once...there are very few people who actually stay with their first college sweetheart forever...but the beauty of MaNan is that they are not just one of the usual college pair...Their love isn't some teenage infatuation...It was real unconditional love...The kind of love which states that once u are in you're in...there's no backing out...Yes it sounds highly unrealistic in the current times but it does happen once in a blue moon...It's like Romeo and Juliet who were two teenagers barely aware of their own identities and their own lives but the kind of love they had was beyond all the boundaries of age and maturity...and that's MaNan

I am of the opinion that currently more focus should be given on Nandu's own life and her own journey in music...After all she's more than just a Fab5 groupie so it's high time that she rediscovers her dreams and falls in love with her own self before loving someone else

Edited by Arshalicious - 10 years ago

Quote

Felicity_Khushi

@Felicity_Khushi

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#39

Originally posted by: ...Doctor...

She hasn't forgotten Manik. She remembers him every moment. She hasn't even fell in love yet. She's not even looking at people that way. Then how can you say that she has fallen for another guy in just 3 months? Judgemental much?

Thanks for replying :)

Judgemental! Not really, because this is what will be given in a few days or weeks!

A new romantic track for nandini.

Quote

shibz

@shibz

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#40

Originally posted by: ...Doctor...

Now that is true. After making us believe in such things, they shouldn't take it away but I don't think they had an option. Parth decided to quit & they had to cover his absence somehow. They just did that.

Thanks for replying :)

Parth quit the show doesn't mean they have to kill Manik.

Quote

1 2 3 4 5

Why can't Nandini love again? - Page 4

Related Topics

Explore Topics