A glimpse into Musicmaniac Ams Mind - Cabir and Ams Convo - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

2.2k

Users

10

Likes

59

Frequent Posters

kany thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: Noorie30



I don't mean to argue to you, but it is not about asking Mangoes, Navya is flawed, Cabir has even more flaws, it is not the point. It is about ignoring everything around her, and focusing only on herself! She doesnot make any effort to understand anyone. Like i said she can't think beyond herself. She is so one- dimensional



Every pregnant woman is sensitive and vulnerable and looking for support in their environment, maybe you're young to understand this situation, but once when you're pregnant as Navya, you'll understand the.



Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#12
Look, If you feel so passionately about how 'wrong' Cabir was for not being sensitive enough in the mental state he was, well move on to the DT and discuss.
In case you still didn't notice -the real topic is for Ams and her psyche.
Not how everyone is so insensitive to the highly sensitive Naveli.

In fact, the logic that when Cabir is not wrong when he is being rude to her without reasons is alright but he is wrong when he is being rude after going through an emotionally taxing experience?
Um,Really?

Fab5 (except Dhruv) all have sacrificed for each other-They are selfish but never when it comes to each other. Naveli is just all about Me, I,Mera,Mine,Myself.
-Sara. thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#13
Navya was also a badly written character from the beginning, from her stupidity in Ep 1 to her Harshad obsessiveness. I feel like it's too late for her character to grow up. Unless when she has her child she realizes how stupid she's been this whole time.
sherma thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Medha.S

And you totally missed the actual point of the post and zoned in on the P.S. part? Wow!

You are entitled to your opinions as I am to mine.Tada! You are trying to find parallels between two relationships that don't really have any parallels. Cabir knows Raghav loves him. Navya knows Harshad used her. Navya-Harshad's relationship was never real from Harshad's side.
Raghav never hurt or planned anything devious against Cabir's friends.
Well, I personally feel that Cabir is more depressed and resigned than anyone else since Musicana and has been suppressing it for over 118+ episodes! Well, my personal belief, obviously!

Now, do you have anything to add to the actual matter of the topic? Ams, her psyche? No? Its fine. Have a good night. 😊

Atleast cabirknows raghav loved him,navya was madly in luv with harshd-she was cheated n used-so its okay to taunt her with h name cause she knows he dint love her---wat sense does that make
hnestly cabir wasnt shown depressed fr Raghav until d article came abt his renetry,so u cnt really tell dat he waas upset frm 118 episodes etc

i guess we wont agree to one point -so jst peace

and abt ams???i dont have anything to say cause -i cn comment only aftr few episodes
i really dint get wat she meant to tell cabir?dis women really confused me.n i actually felt dere is all peace betwwn manik n ams but still she was so bitchy with him.she really hates manik,




Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#15
But that is the problem with her Kany, or more like with the writing. She never behaves like she is an economically insecure teenage girl who is pregnant. She is all about frolicking around living her cool life.She has always been like this, pregnant or not *shrugs*
In fact pregnancy has mellowed down that for her to some extent, but it flares up now and then.
That isn't even a flaw, it is just a personality trait which makes up most of her character.
Riya-111 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#16
First impression of amms on Manik was not good.Because she met him in a different place and different situation.But amms recognised Cabeer as a teacher from music point of view.So she saw pain of Cabeer.And Navya she is very childish.She should not be sad.From my point of view she should comeback to Cabeer to confront him that is something wrong with him.Little maturity and sincerity will make things better for both Cabeer and Navya.
1012214 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: kany



Every pregnant woman is sensitive and vulnerable and looking for support in their environment, maybe you're young to understand this situation, but once when you're pregnant as Navya, you'll understand the.



Honey, i am not that young but i will take it as a compliment. Not been pregnant yet, i agree i can't completely understand the mindset of pregnant women but being pregnant doesn't give you the automatic right to be delusional. I agree that pregnant women are hyper, sensitive, vulnerable, require supports and everything, but here i am talking about Naveli's core character trait which was and has always been present, even before she was pregnant. She was lame, one-dimensional and selfish and she is still. SHE CAN'T THINK BEYOND HERSELF! if someone is so inconsiderate, how can you expect people to be considerate to them?!

Be nice to people and people would response nicely to you, but be inconsiderate, and people would lash at you, that's human nature!

Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#18
Yeah I can say he has been depressed since even before Musicana - Because Cabir's life isn't just about his love life, there were other things he was dealing with which made him want to kill himself? Raghav was a major factor but he has many other important things in his life that suffered due to it.

You are right though, lets agree to disagree. - Navya as a character is so flat and just lacking since the start, she comes off as completely self-centered. Don't know how writers expect her to pull these heavy tracks.She is a major let down mostly.
In the rare moments she is not being self centered, she shines. That is just sad writing.

Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Butterfly242

First impression of amms on Manik was not good.Because she met him in a different place and different situation.But amms recognised Cabeer as a teacher from music point of view.So she saw pain of Cabeer.And Navya she is very childish.She should not be sad.From my point of view she should comeback to Cabeer to confront him that is something wrong with him.Little maturity and sincerity will make things better for both Cabeer and Navya.


Ams is still just holding on to past impression of Manik like it is set in stoned even though she was literally completely off the mark about her impression of Pandit. She should see it.She didn't even acknowledge it.
Even now she is all Nandini and Music, Music of Nandini, Nandini with Music -- It is kinda sad really.

My expectations from Naveli are always the lowest. So in moments she is actually good, I can actually feel excited. Or else she is just ..😆

piyu008 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#20
agree.. ams character shown initially and now is very much different ...
the mangalore track is already too much..uper se ams is behaving impossible..
her behaviour with manik can be understood but cabir😕 usne kya bigada hai!!!
today her convo wid cabir was not good..i mean emotions are nothing,just music music music ..shit now nandu taking science track is much needed!!
N i toh don't understand one thing she is strict ok understood but why she needs to behave so frustrated all the time..always hyper without a reason!!
its all jz my POV no offence to anyone.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".