|firefliesHaven|MaNanAT#101|To New Beginnings and Old Love|Note pg 2

First Previous

Page

115

Next Last

Frequent Posters

charminggenie

@charminggenie

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#451

@Aliya - But did Alya knew about the progress in MaNan equation? She clearly thought that her ex was obsessed , she had no idea about their closeness or emotional connect. Manik never revealed it. So she thought if Dhruv-Nandini can be together , who were friends then whats the harm, maybe Manik's obsession will wean off and he will be with her. She didn't "plot" to separate MaNan because she had no clue how and what they were doing. The same obsession that even Dhruv himself was aware of , he was vocal about it too. So it's not that Dhruv was unaware of Manik's obsession . Both Dhruv and Aliya had same idea about MaNan equation. Nothing more.

DHruv has to own up everything on his own. Aliya was the sounding board who kept reminding him about his own goodness and how Nandini can never say no to him .

Quote

shefni

@shefni

Navigator

Posted: 10 years ago

#452

Originally posted by: AnomanderRake

Shef all this is understandable, my problem with Harshad doesnt stem from his fight with Fab5 though, it stems from him using Nandini and Navya. Say if Nandu knew Harshad's real face, would she ever have agreed? I don't think so. Let him fight Fab5 and do whatever with them but don't use innocents with no stake in this war for your own dirty means. Don't pretend to be good when you are actually bad. The choice should have been Nandini's and Navya's to make when presented with the reality but by pretending to be good, he took away their choice and used them as pawns and made things worse for them. And while its all fine because MaNan fell in love, what if they didnt?

I do not disagree one bit, let me put it this way, it was a battleground with fab5 and harshad at the ends.Navya and nandini were caught unaware and rubbed off at the wrong end of fab 5.Harshad seeks the oppurtunity and uses them as his weapons in his battle.Wrong in all forms, but it was always the fab5 world and their nemesis.Navya and nandini treaded on wrong lines and got caught in the whirlwind.

Harshad did seem like a shining knight in armour when he saved nandini's brother or even the moment where he stepped up to drop the girls home after the friendship day party.Had his own intentions, but for the girls it was saving at the moment. Manik did remove nandini off college, if not for harshad , she would have had to get back home to a disappointed ams and chachi.My point is fab5 were wrong, but they changed ways

BTW, you have no idea how much am enjoying your writing...😃

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Aliyagogoi

@Aliyagogoi

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#453

Originally posted by: AnomanderRake

I think it needs to come in separately without tying in to the Dhruv redemption. As much as Alya encouraged, Dhruv was responsible for his own actions. Dhruv knew Nandini better than Alya did and probably knew what Alya was upto but chose to ignore it, because it made him feel good.
And no matter what Alya did by trying to pair up Dhruni, Dhruv kissed, made out and slept with Alya after all that. Dhruv not only hurt Alya, but also Nandini and most importantly he treated them with no respect.
Alya's acceptance of her mistake cannot be tied to Dhruv's because it will undermine Dhruv's repentance.

ok i agree no redemption and no link with dhruv track but we cant deny it that she did it all because of one motive to get back manik,more than she wanted to help her friend...can you assure me if she knew manan thing,she would not have do it?

i am not against her but i just wanna see her growth completely flawless as she is one character after cabir,who improved tremendously

Quote

geet.a

@geet.a

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 10 years ago

#454

all she has to do is apologize for the goon thing.

i do not think aur kuch chahiye..her insecurity was valid, and honestly, while the goon thing took it far, her reactions were valid too..i mean, 7 years..i get it. the goon thing i don't.

dhruv on the other hand, while saying he's in love with nandini, made out with his best friend's ex-girlfriend..i always found it a bit weird..for me, dhruv went from being good to grey right then when that first kiss led to the second.

That scene in the forest was very telling and foreshadowing again..when the KKHH thing happened.

manik PULLED nandini from dhruv

while dhruv left alya's hand...

Quote

Cat.

@Cat.

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 10 years ago

#455

Originally posted by: -Aarya-

Adhi it's wrong to bring MaNan love into this equation, the crawl between Fab5 and Harshad is before Nandini coming into Manik's life. But then why blame Harshad only, didn't everyone play a game here to win. Nandini played Harshad to teach him a lesson, Manik played Harshad using Ross to trap him, Cabir played by exposing Harshad and Sahid's video. In short no one is a saint here, doesn't matter what intentions are behind your actions, but what matter is the role your playing and that's evil; which everyone has played to some extend..

And all that was a reaction to Harshad playing games with them, wasnt it, he set the ball rolling. Maybe its personal bias but I hate people who are not straight-forward. I have a lot of respect for people who tell me to my face they hate me, I may not like them but I respect them while I don't like or respect people who say one thing to my face and then talk behind my back.

Quote

charminggenie

@charminggenie

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#456

Also Dhruv knew about Alya's motive- he kept giving her false hopes about Manik too. Remember the Musicana night when he dropped her home and Manik calls Alya , Dhruv told her how she will get Manik back too.

Quote

Cat.

@Cat.

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 10 years ago

#457

Originally posted by: Aliyagogoi

ok i agree no redemption and no link with dhruv track but we cant deny it that she did it all because of one motive to get back manik,more than she wanted to help her friend...can you assure me if she knew manan thing,she would not have do it?

i am not against her but i just wanna see her growth completely flawless as she is one character after cabir,who improved tremendously

No human being is completely flawless Aliya. Yes she did it to get back Manik but lets take the case of a married couple in the place of Manik and Alya, will we say its wrong?Human beings are selfish, we want the best for ourselves😆

Quote

Aliyagogoi

@Aliyagogoi

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#458

Originally posted by: -Aarya-

I believe the final cut to Aliya's redemption track was over today, she finally accepting MaNan love in front of her very own eyes! And some where I feel Nandini will help Dhruv and Aliya unite, which will build Nandini and Aliya's friendship...

yes i so wish this to happen..

alya was awesome today,even mukti could not believe it or could think she will react like that..

Quote

geet.a

@geet.a

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 10 years ago

#459

Originally posted by: charminggenie
Also Dhruv knew about Alya's motive- he kept giving her false hopes about Manik too. Remember the Musicana night when he dropped her home and Manik calls Alya , Dhruv told her how she will get Manik back too.

dhruv's ghonchuness level kept rising and rising after musicana😆😆😆

Quote

charminggenie

@charminggenie

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#460

See Alya only wished to be with Manik and she thought in her head that if Dhruv and Nandini clicks, everything will be sorted. We cannot blame her for thinking like that, it took her a while and harsh lessons to believe her own thing with Manik and it's reality. Her thing, intention was all in her head... She didnt meant harm to anyone. Because she was unaware of what Nandini wanted . Anybody would have guesed at that point that Dhruv and Nandini had better chance to be with each other coa they were friends and that Dhruv broke from fab5 for her. Navya thought it was them. So not much wrong she did in assumping that Nandu wanted Dhruv too.

Quote

1 ... 44 45 46 47 48 ... 115

|firefliesHaven|MaNanAT#101|To New Beginnings and Old Love|Note pg 2 - Page 46

Related Topics

Explore Topics