|firefliesHaven|MaNanAT#101|To New Beginnings and Old Love|Note pg 2

First Previous

Page

115

Next Last

Frequent Posters

shefni

@shefni

Navigator

Posted: 10 years ago

#441

adhi,yeah right.I just doubt if harshad is made of the same cloth as the fab5...Let me say the band of brothers was quite a thing, harshad did revel in it, but with him broken off it ,he needed a way to get back at the fab5.The only way- play the good card when fab5 were the given bad..I remember mukti pulling a similar stunt( it is miniscule) the good mask to earn confidence of shahid in exposing harshad.

Saying that, i know harshad is way evil , it is just my mind is trying all creative ways to make harshad even more interesting.Fab 5 have grown beautifully ,and they always had the guiding source in manik. Harshad was a lost kid, who apparently did a mistake, instead of repenting , took to hatred which magnified with age and clouded his moralities.I am gonna try finding substance with navya.is it the acting or writing which has disappointed is something i am trying to find

Quote

Aliyagogoi

@Aliyagogoi

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#442

Sorry to butt in but my special question to genie,adhi and all present...

don't you guys think Alya redemption track should also be there with dhruv as it was alya who insisted dhruv to take nandini seriously and it was her selfishness to get back manik back into her life so she planned to paired up dhruni as she somehow knew that if manik ever get to know dhruv is in love,he will definitely back out..alya's growth is commendable as a character,but unless and until cvs show this acceptance from Alya,i can't connect with her by any means...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

charminggenie

@charminggenie

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#443

Originally posted by: AnomanderRake
I detest MukShad, its unhealthy as hell. Any relationship that shatters the girl so much , that she is a shell of the person she was earlier is unhealthy. All the passion and love in the world is not enough for this relationship to work. They are actually toxic for each other.

This!! I hate that relationship so much. No pity story. Harshad enjoyed , enabled the shattering of Mukti-that girl has lost all her zing towards life because of him- they cannot ever be together, such a wrong signal. Toxic is the word.

@KP - Can you be sorry about being formal here. We like asses butting in always.

Yes that scene had parallels, also the time Manik touched her feel after musicana night removing those ropes. I mean seriously a night before he was chiding and calling Nandu names and here he was willingly removing ropes from her feet. Mixed signals galore.

Quote

Cat.

@Cat.

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 10 years ago

#444

Originally posted by: shefni
adhi,yeah right.I just doubt if harshad is made of the same cloth as the fab5...Let me say the band of brothers was quite a thing, harshad did revel in it, but with him broken off it ,he needed a way to get back at the fab5.The only way- play the good card when fab5 were the given bad..I remember mukti pulling a similar stunt( it is miniscule) the good mask to earn confidence of shahid in exposing harshad.
Saying that, i know harshad is way evil , it is just my mind is trying all creative ways to make harshad even more interesting.Fab 5 have grown beautifully ,and they always had the guiding source in manik. Harshad was a lost kid, who apparently did a mistake, instead of repenting , took to hatred which magnified with age and clouded his moralities.I am gonna try finding substance with navya.is it the acting or writing which has disappointed is something i am trying to find

Shef all this is understandable, my problem with Harshad doesnt stem from his fight with Fab5 though, it stems from him using Nandini and Navya. Say if Nandu knew Harshad's real face, would she ever have agreed? I don't think so. Let him fight Fab5 and do whatever with them but don't use innocents with no stake in this war for your own dirty means. Don't pretend to be good when you are actually bad. The choice should have been Nandini's and Navya's to make when presented with the reality but by pretending to be good, he took away their choice and used them as pawns and made things worse for them. And while its all fine because MaNan fell in love, what if they didnt?

Quote

charminggenie

@charminggenie

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#445

Originally posted by: Aliyagogoi
Sorry to butt in but my special question to genie,adhi and all present...
don't you guys think Alya redemption track should also be there with dhruv as it was alya who insisted dhruv to take nandini seriously and it was her selfishness to get back manik back into her life so she planned to paired up dhruni as she somehow knew that if manik ever get to know dhruv is in love,he will definitely back out..alya's growth is commendable as a character,but unless and until cvs show this acceptance from Alya,i can't connect with her by any means...

I don;t think she did anything wrong tbh. She never plotted or set up in traps for Nandini or Dhruv. She just encouraged her friend , Dhruv to talk it out with the girl he loved .We all do that. Yes she had a different motive but she didn't harm Nandini or gave Dhruv false hopes , she had no clue about MaNan's increasing closeness or even what Nandu thought of Dhruv. So pretty unfair to blame her for Dhruv heartbreak, she just kept giving him hope which Nandini sells these days.

The only thing that she needs to do now is to apologise to Nandini about goons. bas.

Quote

Cat.

@Cat.

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 10 years ago

#446

Originally posted by: Aliyagogoi
Sorry to butt in but my special question to genie,adhi and all present...
don't you guys think Alya redemption track should also be there with dhruv as it was alya who insisted dhruv to take nandini seriously and it was her selfishness to get back manik back into her life so she planned to paired up dhruni as she somehow knew that if manik ever get to know dhruv is in love,he will definitely back out..alya's growth is commendable as a character,but unless and until cvs show this acceptance from Alya,i can't connect with her by any means...

I think it needs to come in separately without tying in to the Dhruv redemption. As much as Alya encouraged, Dhruv was responsible for his own actions. Dhruv knew Nandini better than Alya did and probably knew what Alya was upto but chose to ignore it, because it made him feel good.

And no matter what Alya did by trying to pair up Dhruni, Dhruv kissed, made out and slept with Alya after all that. Dhruv not only hurt Alya, but also Nandini and most importantly he treated them with no respect.

Alya's acceptance of her mistake cannot be tied to Dhruv's because it will undermine Dhruv's repentance.

Quote

shefni

@shefni

Navigator

Posted: 10 years ago

#447

Originally posted by: Aliyagogoi
Sorry to butt in but my special question to genie,adhi and all present...
don't you guys think Alya redemption track should also be there with dhruv as it was alya who insisted dhruv to take nandini seriously and it was her selfishness to get back manik back into her life so she planned to paired up dhruni as she somehow knew that if manik ever get to know dhruv is in love,he will definitely back out..alya's growth is commendable as a character,but unless and until cvs show this acceptance from Alya,i can't connect with her by any means...

hey there, dropping my cents- i dont think alya needs a redemption track.She can acknowledge her mistake and apologize to nandhini regarding the goons incident.( it could have had serious repercussions if not for the boys so for that yes) .Regarding the dhruv bit, who isn;t selfish? A 7 year relationship and the girl tried her best to get it back!So i dont see a redemption track.

Her growth has amazed me and am a little biased .genie, adhi shall put it better

Quote

-Aarya-

@-Aarya-

Dazzler

Posted: 10 years ago

#448

Originally posted by: AnomanderRake

Shef all this is understandable, my problem with Harshad doesnt stem from his fight with Fab5 though, it stems from him using Nandini and Navya. Say if Nandu knew Harshad's real face, would she ever have agreed? I don't think so. Let him fight Fab5 and do whatever with them but don't use innocents with no stake in this war for your own dirty means. Don't pretend to be good when you are actually bad. The choice should have been Nandini's and Navya's to make when presented with the reality but by pretending to be good, he took away their choice and used them as pawns and made things worse for them. And while its all fine because MaNan fell in love, what if they didnt?

Adhi it's wrong to bring MaNan love into this equation, the crawl between Fab5 and Harshad is before Nandini coming into Manik's life. But then why blame Harshad only, didn't everyone play a game here to win. Nandini played Harshad to teach him a lesson, Manik played Harshad using Ross to trap him, Cabir played by exposing Harshad and Sahid's video. In short no one is a saint here, doesn't matter what intentions are behind your actions, but what matter is the role your playing and that's evil; which everyone has played to some extend..

Edited by -Aarya- - 10 years ago

Quote

Aliyagogoi

@Aliyagogoi

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#449

Originally posted by: charminggenie

I don;t think she did anything wrong tbh. She never plotted or set up in traps for Nandini or Dhruv. She just encouraged her friend , Dhruv to talk it out with the girl he loved .We all do that. Yes she had a different motive but she didn't harm Nandini or gave Dhruv false hopes , she had no clue about MaNan's increasing closeness or even what Nandu thought of Dhruv. So pretty unfair to blame her for Dhruv heartbreak, she just kept giving him hope which Nandini sells these days.

The only thing that she needs to do now is to apologise to Nandini about goons. bas.

i agree to it partially,as it was clearly shown in manan's first hug episode when alya and harshad was talking in the pool and she call dhruv..after disconnecting the phone she clearly confessed it as her own motive,her last chance to get manik back..

Quote

-Aarya-

@-Aarya-

Dazzler

Posted: 10 years ago

#450

Originally posted by: Aliyagogoi
Sorry to butt in but my special question to genie,adhi and all present...
don't you guys think Alya redemption track should also be there with dhruv as it was alya who insisted dhruv to take nandini seriously and it was her selfishness to get back manik back into her life so she planned to paired up dhruni as she somehow knew that if manik ever get to know dhruv is in love,he will definitely back out..alya's growth is commendable as a character,but unless and until cvs show this acceptance from Alya,i can't connect with her by any means...

I believe the final cut to Aliya's redemption track was over today, she finally accepting MaNan love in front of her very own eyes! And some where I feel Nandini will help Dhruv and Aliya unite, which will build Nandini and Aliya's friendship...

Quote

1 ... 43 44 45 46 47 ... 115

|firefliesHaven|MaNanAT#101|To New Beginnings and Old Love|Note pg 2 - Page 45

Related Topics

Explore Topics