My take on Parth Samthaan leaving Ky2

Serendipity2015 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
My reaction...
Parth quitting kyy ...Good for him!

For some strange reason I was not a least bit shocked, surprised or sad, probably because I already knew or expected this. Parth will be the 1st one to quit Ky2 ...I had this uncanny feeling even before the telechakkar article appeared...I had started feeling this somewhere around the time when this so called interview of Parth was published it was conducted by email by school girl.

Am somehow very I unaffected with this Parth quitting drama, not because I don't like this guy...well, I actually do like him..Like him a lot. However, somewhere down the line am kinda tired with all the frequent drama surrounding him.

He wants to move on to some other show...his wish, choice or should I say his prerogative . Right or wrong am not even gonna go there, it's not upto me to decide that. But yes, I believe which ever Field we come from we all hv certain responsibilities that comes with them..& we are expected to act/behave accordingly. Somehow I get the feeling this guy is highly influenced by Lostboy ...more like a puppet to him. So, wish him the very best there, hope this decision of his is a good one.

Before Coming to the Manan or ky2 bit: I would like to say a few things that I personally believe in & go by-
1) as Parth himself pointed out recently- Change is the only constant thing in life- well then I am geared for the changes with respect to Ky2 ...be it replacement, new season , twist or end.

2) Show must go on- well hell yes! no one & I say it again no one is indispensable. So, Ky2 going off air because one bloke wants to quit at its peak...find some other way to deal with it rather stopping the show.

3) Memory is short lived & being able to adapt to different situation - we as humans hv an in built system where we can automatically adapt to what is thrown at us. So, Ky2 changes hardly seem that diificult to cope with & adapt to.

4) No one is perfect...there is always room for improvement- no matter how well Parth can act as Manik ...there is always room for improvement...

5) Taking things for granted- well actually, it's more like when u get anything easily, we tend it for granted...but in this case I can't say Parth got all this Fan adulation easily...he definetly, slogged for it & he absolutely deserves all the appreciation. But yes, with the amount of adulation pouring in his judgement is definetly getting blurred.

Now as fans would it help feeling bad, begging or pleading him, Lostboy or asking the makers to Stop Ky2 after his exit ...well no, if anything it will only making his decision to quit firm, reason being the person in question pretty much knows, no matter what he does his fan base will follow him everywhere (there is nothing wrong in that)
But guys maybe we should try reversed psychology, maybe sudden withdrawal & silence from his fans can get him to rethink his decision. As nothing else seems to be working & we really want him to continue with ky2.


On a parting note,YES I am ready for a Manik replacement & before some of u start questioning my loyalty for Manan...so be it. but yes, I am proving my loyalty for Ky2 ( other half of Manan is still there in Ky2 ;-) )

Hope this helps...my Guyan session. Please feel free to write with ur views be it in agreement or disagreement. Beauty of this forum is the flow of views/ideas ...challenging each other, love those discussions...only, let's keep in healthy & not make it a mud slinging fest.

Cheers,S

Let peace prevail😉

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

5.4k

Users

15

Likes

66

Frequent Posters

Mimi2609 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
lovely post👏
i have no idea if i can watch this show without Manik or with a replaced Manik
but i'm gonna try for Niti, Ayaz, Kris, Utkarsh and Veebha and those awesome writers who gave us this show
for all those people who worked day and night to give us KY2
i'll try my best, and if after a few episodes i cant bring myself to watch it, i will slowly go away😊
but i will try😊
Jiyagulabi_26 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Well said
MaNan :( my love.
My suggestion they come with season 2
Edited by addictedlove - 10 years ago
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
The USP for this show has been it;s consistent writing which always forced me to pick an old episode and watch it see relating to the present. This is exactly why I cannot deal with replacements because it destroys that recall value for me. Simple.
There isn't much left to explore interms of MaNan relationship. It was always about them realizing their love and how it is above everything. The journey is about it. Conclude it with the fusion concert and give me the closure on the tale that was suppose to be all about fated lovers.

Best solutions- Season 2
I will watch it for the writers and the cast(who manage to actually work with no drama).

On him leaving - No comments.
priyanka3677 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
The best solution is Season 2 and I agree with Genie here
And yes I agree to us fans not reacting to his leaving rumors now

Let him do what he wishes and we just ignore and take what is given to us
anz11 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
For me
MANAN CANT BE REREACTED... NO PANI NO MANAN.

CABIR MANIK CANT BE RECREATED.

FAB 5 CANT BE RECREATED.

SORRY WITH DUE RESPECT TO ALL OTHER CHARACTERS.

END THE SHOW...GIVE THEM A BREAK... START FRESH ky2 SEASON 2.
WITH ALL THE ACTORS AND REST WHO DOESNOT WANT TO JOIN= THERE CHOICE

SORRY I BEEN HONEST.
ek_nai_paheli thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
You are so bang on S. My thoughts exactly, I couldn't have put it better. To each his own. As you say no one is indispensable and too much has been going on about this already. There are a lot of other people involved in this show. And those folks should not lose their jobs because of one person (I sometimes wonder. Is all the adulation being taken with the right attitude?). Yes, of course it has to end one day but should not be because of someone wanting to leave. We have seen that happen and we know what happened after that. (Disappearance). Khair. What is is,
As far as a replacement goes. My only hope is that they find someone appropriate. Some one with the right attitude and height (Manan purrfect chemistry). AND one who looks 19. Personally, if they are thinking of Arijit, don't think he would work. Cannot see him as MMM, and for sure does not look to be even 20 never mind 19. Wouldn't be a good match for Nandini. But this is purely my opinion.


livelytanu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Its so good to hear that some can really continue to watch.
But my loyalty towards this show will end with the end of Manan. Manan for me is Manik & nandu together. And thus I do want a proper closure with Parth & Niti as Manan. And I want a happy ending.
Now if they go for a replacement or new character, I will definitely not watch.
But I can watch if they come with another season with fresh characters. I love the writers of this show & I will definitely give it a shot.
As for Parth leaving whether he will succeed or not that or good or bad decision or whatever I dont care. I am not one who will watch his each & every show even if he is not good. But yes he definitely has the right to choose.
Serendipity2015 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: charminggenie

The USP for this show has been it;s consistent writing which always forced me to pick an old episode and watch it see relating to the present. This is exactly why I cannot deal with replacements because it destroys that recall value for me. Simple.

There isn't much left to explore interms of MaNan relationship. It was always about them realizing their love and how it is above everything. The journey is about it. Conclude it with the fusion concert and give me the closure on the tale that was suppose to be all about fated lovers.

Best solutions- Season 2
I will watch it for the writers and the cast(who manage to actually work with no drama).

On him leaving - No comments.


True, agree with u! What I trying to get at was...we just need to keep an open mind, give the writers & makers of Ky2 a chance...maybe they don't gets replacement at all ...they might just twik the story a little or get a replacement who shares a fabulous relation with Niti on & off screen 😆 We all know how these off screen dramas also help in connecting with on screen stuff for a few fans...if not all. See, it can only go two ways either we love what they offer or reject it, but let's atleast welcome with open mind ...means give it fair chance.

Rutu01 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
lovely post !!!
Agree to most of your points

The makers wont shut down the show just because one actor is leaving. They know the fans will be upset , they will get a backlash but after a point everything will die down and new set of fans will join in for the replacement actor. So the show will go on ...i guess most of us have accepted it.

Manan / Pani are the reason most of us are attached to the show so is it too much to expect that if one is leaving can the makers just give a proper closure in terms of confession atleast !!!! After confession those who want to leave can leave peacefully with some beautiful memories rather than being disillusioned.



Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".