Originally posted by: Sabdabhala
SO I AM BACK WITH DETAILED COMMENTS, AFTER A COUPLE OF THOROUGH READINGS, AND HERE THEY ARE -
THERE ARE ACTUALLY TWO SETS OF COMMENTS, FIRST ONES ABOUT YOUR WRITING STYLE, AND THE SECOND ONES ABOUT THE STORY, THE PLOT AND THE CHARACTERS
REGARDING THE FORMER, I MUST SAY THAT I AM TOTALLY BLOWN WITH THIS CHAPTER... EACH WORD IS USED PERFECTLY, AND IS SCENE IS EXPLAINED SO VIVIDLY AND BEAUTIFULLY THAT I CAN IMAGINE EACH ONE IN MY MIND CLEARLY - RIGHT FROM THE 'DISTURBED' AAYAT THAT THE SHEHZAADE RECITES TILL HEERA RUNS TO THE WINDOW WITH HER PRAYERS AND WISHES FOR THE SAHIB. 👏
THIS IS AN EMOTIONALLY CHARGED CHAPTER, TO PUT IT MILDLY 😉 BUT THE FINESSE WITH WHICH YOU HAVE HANDLED THE MYRIAD EMOTIONS IS ABSOLUTELY ASTOUNDING 👏 FROM SHEHZAADE'S VEILED AND CONTROLLED ANGER, TO FAROOQ SAHIB'S HIDDEN DECEIT AND TWO FACEDNESS, TO KHALIL'S MANIC EUPHORIA, TO KHAN SAHIB'S OPTIMISM REGARDING THE CANAL, HIS SHOCK AT THE DEATH OF HIS MEN, HIS SILENT LAMENT FOR NOT APPRECIATING THEM ENOUGH WHILE THEY WERE ALIVE, HIS GENTLE HANDLING OF SAYYID, HIS GRATITUDE ON SEEING HIM ALIVE, HIS DEJECTION AT THE NEWS RECEIVED FROM THE SPY, HIS EMBARASSMENT FOR HIS MOMENTARY LOSS OF CONTROL, HIS TENDER TETE A TETE WITH HIS WIFE, HIS VULNERABILITY WHEN HE MAKES HER SEE REALITY, HIS INDECISION REGARDING WHAT TO DIVULGE TO HIS HUZOOR, HIS STEADFASTNESS TOWARDS HIS GOAL, HEERA'S BATTLE WITH HER EMOTIONS, HER RESOLVE TO NOT TEAR UP, HER SENSITIVE UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT THE SAHIB WANTS...EACH AND EVERY EMOTION IS BEAUTIFULLY EXPRESSED...WITH NOT A SINGLE SYLLABLE OUT OF PLACE
ANOTHER SUPERB ASPECT OF YOUR WRITING SKILLS, AND I HAVE MENTIONED THIS POINT SEVERAL TIMES, IS HOW WELL YOUR STORY FLOWS THROUGH THE CHAPTERS...MUCH LIKE THE JOURNEY OF THE CANAL THAT SAHIB IS ENVISAGING...
I LOVE THE WAY YOU HAVE CHARACTERIZED THE NEW MAN, FAROOQ SAHIB - SUPERBLY DETAILING HIS PHYSICAL APPEARANCE, AND JUST A BIT LATER, HIS CHARACTER...👏
NOW TO THE STORY AND CHARACTERS
I THINK THE SHEHZAADE IS RIGHT IN HIS PLACE TO BE SO DISTURBED, TO A LARGE EXTENT. IF SUCH NEWS ABOUT THE PERSON WHOM HE RESPECTS THE MOST REACHES HIM, HE WOULD CERTAINLY BE WISE TO HAVE IT INVESTIGATED. AND THE KIND OF ERA THAT IT WAS, TRUST WAS THE ONE THING THAT WAS DIFFICULT TO FIND...
FAROOQ SAHIB TURNED OUT TO BE QUITE A TWO FACED MONSTER, I MUST SAY. IT WAS A SHOCK FOR ME TO SEE HIM RUSH WITH THE NEWS TO KHALIL, OF ALL PEOPLE. BUT AGAIN WITH BROTHERS KILLING EACH OTHER, THIS WAS OK TO DIGEST, I GUESS...HIS SPIES HAVE CERTAINLY GIVEN HIM ACCURATE INFORMATION. AND HE SERIOUSLY IS QUITE SHARP AND THE SHROUD OF CONFIDENTIALITY IS SERVING HIM WELL...
KHALIL, OF COURSE, IS CONSISTENTLY EVIL...NO CHANGE THERE... AND I AM QUITE HOPEFUL THAT, UNLESS KHALIL HAS AQUIRED SOME EXCEPTIONAL CEREBRAL PROWESS 😆 THAT HE WILL CERTAINLY DIG HIS OWN GRAVE IN THE FRENZY OF BRNGING THE SAHIB DOWN...
THE WHOLE SCENE AT SAYYID'S HOUSE WAS EXTREMELY POIGNANT...SAHIB'S THOUGHTS AND ACTIONS ARE SO SUBTLE, SO SUITABLE...AND JUST PERFECT...
ALL OF SAHIB'S MEN ARE HEROES...AZEEZ, SAYYID...😳 AND THE SNIPPET ABOUT SAYYID'S PAST LIFE IS ENDEARING TO READ...HOW, WITH A LITTLE TENDER NURTURING, A MAN UNDERGOES A SEA CHANGE IN HIS THOUGHTS AND DEEDS...👏 AND IT WAS AWWW MOMENT FOR ME TO SEE HIM FEEL SORRY...WHEN, IN REALITY, ALLOF US AND HIS SAHIB KNOW THAT HE DID THE VERY BEST...SHOWING SO MUCH GRIT AFTER HAVING BEEN SO GRAVELY INJURED...
THE RUSH OF ACTIVITY IN THE HAVELI IS WONDERFULLY DESCRIBED... LIKE ALL SCENES WHIRRRING PAST AND HEERA AT THE CENTRE OF IT ALL, WONDERING WHAT SHE MUST DO... AND THE CRASH OF THE LANTERN...SYMBOLIC AT SO MANY LEVELS...SUPERB!!!
AZEEZ AGAIN 😆 HAVE TO REALLY HAND IT TO THE GUY...THE WAY HE SENDS HEERA INSIDE SPEAKS VOLUMES ABOUT HIS FINE SENSIBILITIES...
AND THE SCENE INSIDE HIS CHAMBER... GOD, I DONT HAVE WORDS TO DESCRIBE IT... BUT THE ONE NOTICEABLE THING FOR ME WAS THAT THE SAHIB TELLS HEERA EVERYTHING POINT BLANK... HIS TRUST IN HER AS HIS COMPANION HAS GROWN MANIFOLD, AND WHY NOT? HEERA TOO IS BECOMING HIS TRUE SAATHI AT BREAKNECK SPEED...SHE DOES NOT SHED EVEN A SINGLE TEAR...AND REMAINS A HUGE SUPPORT TO HIM BY UNDERSTANDING HIM PERFECTLY...AND REMINDS HIM OF HIS PROMISE IN THE MOST SUBTLE WAY...
THE FLASHBACK ABOUT THE MOONLIT NIGHT WAS ETHREAL, LASHY!!!
AND THE FOCUS ON THE TAAVEEZ POUCH WAS...UFFF...THEIR BRIEF TOUCH SEEMED HEAVENLY AND THEIR PARTING...WAS JUST TENDER AND SAD...MOSTLY SAD!!!
THE WHOLE CHAPTER WAS A MASTERPIECE, MY DEAR...BUT FOR ME, THE MASTERSTROKE WAS THE POEM AT THE END...THAT SUITABLY CONVEYED WHAT THE SAHIB MEANT TO HER, AND HER PEOPLE; AND THE DANGERS THAT THEY WERE NOW EXPOSED TO, IN HIS ABSENCE...
AND WHAT DO WE HAVE TO LOOK FORWARD TO... SAHIB'S HOPE...
'THIS COULD BE THE BEGINNING'
671