TS: The Third Person~ completed - Page 35

Created

Last reply

Replies

386

Views

24.9k

Users

39

Likes

788

Frequent Posters

Durgeshnandini thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
Bhalo achho Stuti di ???

A lot of things happened in this last-but-not-the-least chapter. It was emotionally exhausting, to feel it happening as a reader, to let it happen as an author and to brave it all , letting the storm take over as the characters justly did...

Yet I shall stick to the rule : I will begin at the beginning, go on till the end, and then stop.
So I begin by telling that I really liked all that's happened the way you let them happen. Such lives can't culminate in to happy ending of sorts...👏👏for your bold efforts.

Your Jalal doesn't have much to do...he acts on his conscience and is toyed along by master play of Fate.Sadly, he doesn't emerge as a heroic martyr, and even though he has not poisoned his dying wife, he is no better than a murderer...for he had poisoned a life, rather lives with his oscillating conflicts of conscience and emotions . He could never man up and come to terms with the twist and turns of his life.
It's a difficult character, and even more difficult to imagine oneself as a man like Jalal...first he's given rosogollas (read love), overwhelmed with sweetness, then plunged into depths of bitterness...Jodha remains like an unachievable mirage of sorts whose hope he never loses...but bitterness strangulates the best of his dreams, and when he is all about to submit himself to fate's mercy, he's baited again with hopes of sweetness...and Jalal being a man of flesh and blood eagerly grabs it as his lifeline...

Ruquaiya is wrong and wronged all the way. She gets her share and learns, it's was some one else's, so to make her importance felt she chooses her path,which definitely does her no good. Her intentions weren't negative, but the path she pursued, surely was. You can't health a wound by making another one. In life and in death she remains an unanswered question to Jalal.

If anyone is really punished without any fault...that's definitely Jodha, and she manages to really look strong and supporting...but then again she had never been in the position of Jalal...yet her unwavering faith, her love for Jalal , her unselfish attitude towards Ruquaiya, her optimism creates a convincing appeal altogether...

It was a pleasure reading your story. Would love to read more such works from you...

Till then, bhalo theko, kemon? 😳
Edited by durgeshnandini - 9 years ago
Shinning_Stuti thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
Adwitiwa,
Don't know how to react after reading your review! I mean, till date I think this one is the best I got among lots and lots of beautiful reviews from my buddies, and I am feeling really overwhelmingly honoured! I cherished reading every words and your deep character analysises. honoured to get you as my reader!😳

Tumio khub bhalo theko...😳
Kavya_P thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Shinning_Stuti

Adwitiwa,

Don't know how to react after reading your review! I mean, till date I think this one is the best I got among lots and lots of beautiful reviews from my buddies, and I am feeling really overwhelmingly honoured! I cherished reading every words and your deep character analysises. honoured to get you as my reader!😳

Tumio khub bhalo theko...😳


KYA COMMENT HAI 👏
Edited by Kavya_P - 9 years ago
Kavya_P thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Shinning_Stuti


Okay, I will try my best to make your souls happy. 😆


Try to make us happy in imagination itself 😆
o know in reality it wont be happy ending
but in imagination anything is possible 😉
natashathakur thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
Fantastic chapter n thnxx for pm
Durgeshnandini thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Shinning_Stuti

Adwitiwa,

Don't know how to react after reading your review! I mean, till date I think this one is the best I got among lots and lots of beautiful reviews from my buddies, and I am feeling really overwhelmingly honoured! I cherished reading every words and your deep character analysises. honoured to get you as my reader!😳

Tumio khub bhalo theko...😳


OMG
jasminegrewal98 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
So this was last update dear, well must say you did a fabulous job dear it was such a different story and i admire that you stuck to what you wanted to do and didnt give us happy ending for Jodha and Jalal (even if we really wanted it haha) rather left it open to us to wonder what happened in their life! Unless you give epilogue then we will get a glimpse of what happened to the two after!
But thanks for pms for this story really enjoyed it keep up the great writing👏😃
1357raksha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
Wonderful update stuti...
Jalal confession was much needed...
Jodha was shocked by his confession nd had lost 90% of faith on him but other 10% did nt want to believe that...
Even I couldn't believe that jalal could have done that ya he had made everything ready for ruks peace full sleep but will nt give her ...
But ruks got what he wanted nd did d need full...
But nw she is nt there physically but did what she wanted...
Jodha on other sites dont knw what to do...
But time is there to heal all d pain...
Thanks for pm dear...
alffim thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
Dear Stuti!

Only my opinion. 😊

You wrote with great talent; very painfully...

In this chapter I don't like the behavior of Jodha. She acts as a hypocrite (goody-goody), and not as a loving woman. There is a saying: "To be holier than the Pope". She judges Jalal of intention (!) in a moment of despair and an act that he didn't. She completely ignores the hell in which he lived - not because Rukaya was sick and the disease ravaged of him. This hell was herself Rukaya.

Perhaps I have a different opinion, because a different mentality ...😊

But loving a woman should not recoil. Jalal - not a killer. Yes, his action is worthy of condemnation. But relatives of sick people - is a group of risk of psychological disorders affect. Even if Jalal would gave her this pills, they would have to discuss it, to decide how voluntary a confession ... a lot that could be done, but Jodha should not become a judge.

This is my opinion, not because I'm on the side of Jalal. I just know that is a very sick person, and how it affects the family. And if it's such a nasty person like Rukaya? The psychological state of families is terrible, they will lose the strength of mind
and understanding. Not for an justification, but for a clear understanding.


Edited by alffim - 9 years ago
vjctpt378 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
Is this an end??? R else one more update there?? Poor souls life long suffered? ? Ppl wil move on with life na... pls make them happy sear n ya one of best story
.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".