Jodha Akbar 16th March 2015 ...Page-12 - Page 6

abhay watched the epi despite the warnings in ff mode..and i will just say that one more line should be added to the disclaimer in the beginning...'kripeya kamzor dil waale ye bhayanak natkiye rupanter na dekhein dil ka dora pad sakta hai aur dekhne ke baad icu main bhi jana pad sakta hai..!

Originally posted by: Sandhya.A

To even imagine that we screamed 'foul' when Abul Mali captured Jalal. When we think that the writers have hit the rock bottom they surprise us by plunging deeper.

They say that the script is the real backbone/base of any story/show. Without it even the best talents fail to achieve. JA is the best example of immense potential and insipid script.

I particularly did not like the scene when he was lying down on earth after the whipping,if anyone noticed here. That sight was not good in my opinion. It was even bad compared to the beating by Abu'l Maali. I think now i will prefer that Maali scene as being better compared to this one.

Originally posted by: Rashmi81

Abhay ,

I saw just that Lep scene ,it was beautifully enacted by all three .I liked the emotions portrayed by all of them.I don't know much about whipping scene but I believe one thing that in the court of Almighty everybody is same whether you are a King or an ordinary person.And I think Jalal might be taking it as decree of god .

Rashmi,
As per NR your reasoning is fine . They all acted that scene well in the episode. Performance wise, the episode was good. BUT, the whole situation was very illogical, i can't think of reason for this, as i said my update. So, just reading the views. :)

Originally posted by: vinitaj27

Abhay in keeping NR in mind reg ruqqaiyas n jalals punishment i just want to say one thing.. jalal could have avoided his punishment by walking away or declaring his identity but he chose to stick wirh his punishment for his conscience whereas ruqqaiya doesnt have one and finds ways n means to avoid them...

Vini,
That is the difference between the thought process of Jalal and Ruqayya. Jalal faces every thing. But still, i did not like the whipping. The issue is not whipping also, but the issue is the "extreme" portrayal. He was shown lying on Earth, completely red, and almost lifeless ; to raise the emotional quotient, i guess.

On lighter note, it reminded me of Sholay, when Dharam Paaji was shackled by Gabbar / tied both hands. :-P

Originally posted by: neeshaa16

Hi Abhay,

What to say.. Until yesterdays episode all seemed fine and OK to me but yesterdays epi again left a bitter taste . A king can become a common man if he wishes to and also do community service but tolerating injustice is the biggest crime.. and then it was his rule that may be 100 criminals are left scot free .. but innocent person should not be punished??? So what happened.He takes the blame to himself and gets punished by Jodha?? Jodha keeps quiet.. Why?? This was something which was not at all acceptable to me.. Though I must say Rajat and Paridi and even Lavina displayed their emotions and enacted their roles very well. But I fail to understand the logic of CVS showing Akbar in a helpless condition.. clueless.. ?? Again the CVS have proved yet again how unpredictable they are... At one moment they will raise your hopes and then next moment they will shatter ALL YOUR HOPES OF ja REVIVAL.. The only good part was Mansinghs escape .. Baaki bakwaas.. What to say.. I hope next week atleast they show something worthwhile..

Neeshaa,
That is the moral of the story. One day they give such awesome episodes, and then they throw off all logics and dignity in a split second. What to say . Our CV's are like this only. Lets see, what they plan to do now. Along with Man Singh's escape, the divine experience scene was also good.

Originally posted by: Suganya.S

Abhay ,

Ur analysis cracked me up 😆😆 .. Yeah , the whole debacle must be viewed with surjan- Now dakku for villagers n Radha- sarpanj for villagers 😊 In their disguise , they have to follow the ethics related to their role !!!

Though I felt , after watching epi .. CVS are back to their usual self 😆 punishing every innocent instead of REAL culprits And only thing I loved was , parijat expressions n their strong relationship 😳 Precap was some thing to look for 😉 as JD- cheapu 2 was near dagger throw ( ofc jallu's fiery eyes 😉) 😆

Last thing tat I would like to convey is , NR should be viewed for entertainment .. Not for spoiling our moods with extreme negativity Hope CVS n makers understand this some day !!!

Suganya,
It seems you enjoyed the episode. :D
Hope for the best in future. I agree with your concluding lines.

Originally posted by: ghalibmirza

abhay watched the epi despite the warnings in ff mode..and i will just say that one more line should be added to the disclaimer in the beginning...'kripeya kamzor dil waale ye bhayanak natkiye rupanter na dekhein dil ka dora pad sakta hai aur dekhne ke baad icu main bhi jana pad sakta hai..!

Mandy,

I was expecting more from you. :-P

I think in an attempt to raise the emotional quotient and the "sympathy" factor of audience, they went this way. :-P

But, this line of "kamzor Dil" is not applicable now, as we ALL are immune to see any NR watching JA for long, they can do anything. There seems to be no FULL STOP..

Originally posted by: ayushimehra

Thanks Abhay, for update,

I was accepting you will give title Mee tumahari Ruh hoo,

But My acception flopped.😆 comment will later.

Welcome Ayushi.
First part of that kid/soul was really good, but i had to contend with giving "statutory notices" in my update for J and A fans. :-P So, did not give any tagline today.

abhay, the trps tell that this track is already a super flop..no one will tolerate akabr lying in mud..falling at jodha's feet..and getting himself whipped..! although the idea of this whole track was that akbar at one point thought himself as god on earth after conquering most of hindustan and then wanted to have one religion rather than many which divide humans..and that is when i guess all religious discussions started and then it led to din-e-illahi which not many people follwed and there might have been a stir in hindus and muslims at that time..and then there was famine in gujarat..one such incident i can remember..and then there was a tree inder which akbar sat and got some enlightenment..but smith calls it to be an epileptic shock where people can be haunted with such illusions, bur this whole thing was presented in the most bhayanak NR! even the aarti scene looked pathetic..imagine the real akbar ever doing all this!

if the whole incidents or incidents would have been shown in such a way by keeping akabr still royal and majestic then it would have not looked so bad but instead they showed him next to nothing! only saving grace was rajat's acting the rest was not worth watching and if they want to show anything to do with muz why akabr is shown falling at her feet instead can't they show akbar giving her the responsibilities and she doing them with perfection and authority and then akabr not shown doing majnugiri but something substantial either preparing for war or dealing with administrative issues..why show them both like servants serving the awaam and when did such things ever happened in the barbaric era