ANARKALI :* - Page 10

Originally posted by: ---Mehak---

few scholars say , that it was just a fictional story made for salim n anarkali ..

Originally posted by: myviewprem

I

May be CVs thought hen Archana Manav were accepted as grandparents and parents JA would be also. And arcahna manav actors were also 20 something not 70 something as they played to Arjun Purvi's grown up kids and so were these two also. But that time problem did not arise and every show 20-25 year olds are playing 60-70 year olds after leaps and has worked too, So CV thought same for this show too must be.

I am wondering how fan reaction would have been if Rajat was only Salim and Paridhi anarkali would it be so vicious? The viewers have objections of showing Salim anarkali in show named JA. The biggest blooper is if CVs wanted to shown aged JA then show should never have been named Jodha Akbar instead naming it as something common like a "Siyasat" serial has been named. Maybe they were not clever enough to think of all these future issues.

Originally posted by: myviewprem

What is seriously lacking on this show is a good script and good dialogues. If that only fails no cast can lift it up. JA has been going down from Benazir track in quality and worst was the baby sharing track. If same script writer continues with awful direction and dialogues then it will sink further no matter what great acting. Initial 3 months JA was not that popular and only later it picked up after JA wedding etc. I think amer track and ajmer sharif trip was best track till date. Rest all the lesser said the better.

Originally posted by: J2lover

well pavitra rishta was a family drama!!! it didn't had only manav archana love story...it had other tracks too which they focused though THE highlight WAS THE LOVESTORY...but yet...people did accept them...soo the audience watching it were of all age groups!!! when it comes to a lovestory...a specific age group has a majority...N when the main pair itself is being shown AGED...the audience who ahd signed up for love story..lost interest!!!...ALSO it PR...THE TITLE did not SUGGEST THE STORY of a SPECIFIC couple...but "JODHA AKBAR" itself suggests THE STORY OF JODHA AND AKBAR!!! maybe THESE were the FACTORS THAT WORKED FOR OTHER SHOWS but not for JA!!!😕😕

That is what I am also saying why name some show after a couple of you want to show other couples too- CVs never thought of that a common name would suffice

Originally posted by: myviewprem

What is seriously lacking on this show is a good script and good dialogues. If that only fails no cast can lift it up. JA has been going down from Benazir track in quality and worst was the baby sharing track. If same script writer continues with awful direction and dialogues then it will sink further no matter what great acting. Initial 3 months JA was not that popular and only later it picked up after JA wedding etc. I think amer track and ajmer sharif trip was best track till date. Rest all the lesser said the better.

Originally posted by: myviewprem

That is what I am also saying why name some show after a couple of you want to show other couples too- CVs never thought of that a common name would suffice

The story of JA is pathetic so its downfall started in june-july only salim anarkali has nothing to do with it actually they are here only for past 7 days

JA is actually seen by majority family audience - I started watching because my family watched it but the family audience do not want to see too much negativity in form of Ruqaiah, child swapping etc anyone watches it for some peace of mind not to lose their peace of mind

Originally posted by: J2lover

well...i feel the chaos on the forum is not about WHICH pair is SUPERIOR or INFERIOR!!! its more about WHICH PAIR is given more IMPORTANCE at this stage!!! in my view EVERY LOVE STORY has its own SHARE of UNIQUENESS...EVERY love story has its own share of SACRIFICES...which itself makes it EPIC!!! as far as both the LOVE STORIES are concerned...they both have their different backgrounds...JODHA-AKBAR was more of STRUGGLE to find LOVE IN BETWEEN the SEA of hatred between two people...IT was a MARRIAGE OF CONTROVERSIES... BUT FINALLY THEY CREATE THEIR OWN HISTORY...WHEREAS salim-anarkali( no idea if its fiction or not)...but as far as i have heard and seen...its a STRUGGLE FOR LOVE...two people from EXTREMELY different socities...TRYING to FIGHT for their LOVE!!!! AND FINALLY EVEN THEY CREATE THEIR OWN HISTORY!!! THIS WAS REGARDING HISTORY!!

Now here the main problem lies IN the potrayal of these COUPLES!!!! FANS aren't against SA..they are AGAINST "SA IN JA"!!!! If the creatives wanted to show SA..they should have done JUST a simple thing...START FRESH!!!! start a new show..name it SALIM-ANARKALI...n MAKE the SHOW a hit!!! if this would have happened...people would had ENJOYED N ACCEPTED SA WHOLEHEARTEDLY!!! who knows even JA fans would also have joined IN the SHIPPING!!!

but now the case is...SHOW'S name is JA...n love story shown is of SA..."SIDELINING JA"!!! THAT'S the main issue with fans of the show!!! as its but natural...LOGICALLY..if the show's name is JODHA-AKBAR...THEIR STORY should be SHOWN...the SERIAL SHOULD START N END WITH JODHA-AKBAR!!!! the other way round...also if THE name woudn't had been JODHA-AKBAR...even then..fans would have accepted SALIM-ANARKALI...coz that time fans mindset would have been different!!! but now AS the name GOES...isn't it mandatory to show THE STORY OF JODHA AND AKBAR till the END of the show??!!! AGREED salim was there SON HE was a APRT of JA...so just show him...HIS relationship with HIS parents...THAT'S IT!!! potraying SALIM'S life...his wives HIS STUGGLE for love...doesn't make sense...again i would say..it doesn't make any IN JODHA-AKBAR!!! THAT'S THE MAIN ISSUE WITH THE FANS IN MY VIEW!!!! correct me if a wrong!!!

AND lastly...the issue is with AGE FACTOR(okk here its maybe JUST "MY" ISSUE..😛😛)...COUPLE in THEIR 20s playing PARENTS to a 20yr. old!!! i cant somehow digest it...its difficult for me!!! maybe that's because OF the IMMENSE LOVE we have FOR RAJAT AND PARIDHI!!!😃...I get it THEY had to be shown OLD at some point of time...BUT is it the right TIME??!!!...isn't it too early to show them OLD??!!!😕😕...isn't it injustice WITH the characters..to skip the important EVENTS of THEIR lives in THEIR MID AGES..n JUMPING DIRECTLY to THIE OLD age??!!( okk...here am not soo good at HISTORY..soo can't name the events!!😆)...but its there!! correct me if am wrong!!

SOO DUE TO ALL THIS MESS-UP...THE SOUL SUFFERERS ARE THE SHOW N ITS ARDENT LOYAL FANS...WHICH COULD BE SEEN ON TRP CHARTS NOW-A-DAYS!!!

P.S: THIS IS EXCLUSIVELY MY VIEW..NO OFFENSE TO ANYBODY!!!😳😳...N DUSHI...MY APOLOGIES FOR WRITING THIS BORING ESSAY HERE ON YOUR THREAD!!!😛...just thought its a right PLACE to XPRESS MYSELF!!!😳😳