JA Oct 7 2014 | Elegy for Hasan, Oct10 Abhay Updt P18, Call to Zee P24 - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

209

Views

17k

Users

31

Likes

1.2k

Frequent Posters

Charu.S thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#11
Very very beautifully written Radhika . Your lines about not to judge a grieving person is so ... TRUE . I loved your writeup .

I watched today's episode only because Sindhu asked me to , just to see the talented pair of Paridhi and Rajat . Hats off to them . They were awesome as the grief-stricken parents .Thank you Sindhu 😛. It was hard for me to watch , I too cried along with Jodha and Jalal.

To lose a child , is the worst pain a parent can endure . The mother especially , she has cocooned the infant in the protective warmth of her womb , felt his every movement inside and then brought him into this world , forgetting the pain of childbirth , just to enjoy his presence and see him grow .When this happiness is cut short permanently , the sorrow of that mother is immeasurable and unimaginable . She can never forget him and move on , she will just mundanely carry on with her life .
Today the grief-stricken Jodha lamented that in spite of only doing good for others why did she have to undergo something so tragic . I have the same question too ... She who readily understood the feelings of a motherless fellow queen and magnanimously agreed to give her a twin , should be punished in such a horrible way ... call it a cruel game of destiny , taking the form of Zeenat .'Mera ansh , meta bachcha ', she wailed, the truth is ... both Jalal and Jodha have lost a part of themselves by losing their babies . Jodha and Jalal had just started enjoying parenthood , having to say a final goodbye to their beloved firstborns would never ever have crossed their minds .

The Shehnshah trying to console his grief-stricken wife was touching . He was desperately trying to be strong for her, breaking down with silent tears that she could not see . It was a heart wrenching sight to see Jalal carrying his baby wrapped in white to his final resting place .

Henceforth , we will witness a new phase in the lives of Jodha and Jalal . The grief of losing their babies will strengthen their bond . From now on begins their journey of survival . It is going to be one where both of them will derive strength from each other and endure all kinds of hardships coming their way .

I did not want to write about Rukaiyya at all , however I could not help myself from noticing how she grabbed baby Hussein from Jodha's arms . I think we will see her full blown insecurity tomorrow when Jalal asks her to hand over baby Hussein to Jodha for comfort . This will also trigger anger and she may end up doing something stupid and bring about her own ruin . Cannot wait for this to happen .
Edited by JAfanCharu - 10 years ago
SindhuMenon thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: JAfanCharu

Very very beautifully written Radhika . Your lines about not to judge a grieving person is so ... TRUE . I loved your writeup .


I watched today's episode only because Sindhu asked me to , just to see the talented pair of Paridhi and Rajat . Hats off to them . They were awesome as the grief-stricken parents .Thank you Sindhu 😛. It was hard for me to watch , I too cried along with Jodha and Jalal.

To lose a child , is the worst pain a parent can endure . The mother especially , she has cocooned the infant in the protective warmth of her womb , felt his every movement inside and then brought him into this world , forgetting the pain of childbirth , just to enjoy his presence and see him grow .When this happiness is cut short permanently , the sorrow of that mother is immeasurable and unimaginable . She can never forget him and move on , she will just mundanely carry on with her life .
Today the grief-stricken Jodha lamented that in spite of only doing good for others why did she have to undergo something so tragic . I have the same question too ... She who readily understood the feelings of a motherless fellow queen and magnanimously agreed to give her a twin , should be punished in such a horrible way ... call it a cruel game of destiny , taking the form of Zeenat .'Mera ansh , meta bachcha ', she wailed, the truth is ... both Jalal and Jodha have lost a part of themselves by losing their babies . Jodha and Jalal had just started enjoying parenthood , having to say a final goodbye to their beloved firstborns would never ever have crossed their minds .

The Shehnshah trying to console his grief-stricken wife was touching . He was desperately trying to be strong for her, breaking down with silent tears that she could not see . It was a heart wrenching sight to see Jalal carrying his baby wrapped in white to his final resting place .

Henceforth , we will witness a new phase in the lives of Jodha and Jalal . The grief of losing their babies will strengthen their bond . From now on begins their journey of survival . It is going to be one where both of them will derive strength from each other and endure all kinds of hardships coming their way .

I did not want to write about Rukaiyya at all , however I could not help myself from noticing how she grabbed baby Hussein from Jodha's arms . I think we will see her full blown insecurity tomorrow when Jalal asks her to hand over baby Hussein to Jodha for comfort . This will also trigger anger and she may end up doing something stupid and bring about her own ruin . Cannot wait for this to happen .



lovely post Charu. very touching
Charu.S thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: SindhuMenon



lovely post Charu. very touching


Thank you Sindhu .
-ambrosia- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: history_geek

---UNRES---

Radhika,

This post of yours is a masterpiece. I do not possess the audacity to match your words.
Absolutely Phenomenal Performance by the Leads.!!!.
What an Episode it was.. I would recommend to all the friends here, watch the episode..

Tell me what was Missing.?. >>

Memories
Broken hearts
Tear-stained faces
Grief
Sadness
Regret
Guilt
Depression
Heart-Break
Rage
Sadness
Despair
Collapse
Console
Lost
Drifting
Helplessness
Vulnerability
Anger
Resent
Fraught
Denial
And what not.?.


Watch it NOT ONLY for RT and PS..

Today watch the episode for Jodha Akbar.

Amidst all the NR which we are fed up of, i am pretty sure, the scenes we saw today must have been replicated in the Fort of Agra .!!!

Didn't we all feel a Tsunami of Humanistic Feelings.?.
Didn't we all get all those emotionS one could think of, in such a setting.?.


" The rush of arrows and the clash of swords,
Tore the marrow of elephants and the entrails of tigers. "

^^^^^^ These lines "be-jewel" the capability of Shahenshah-e-Hind Jalal-ud-din Mohammed Akbar...Can we think of the man who had the ENTIRE Hindustan at HIS Feet, but was helpless.?. The Man who Proclaimed that he can write(and he DID) the destiny with HIS Sword, was a spectator before the Decree of God..!!!.


Coming to Jodha. She was so much broken today, that she even said, why God took Hasan and why not her.?. I can not think of better lines by Ghalib , to describe this moment :>

Urdu

Koi ummid bar nahin aati
Koi surat nazar nahin aati

Maut ka ek din mu'ayyana hai
Nind kyon raat bhar nahin aati

Aage aati thi hal-e-dil pe hansi
Ab kisi baat par nahin aati

Jaanata hun savab-e-ta'at-o-zahad
Par tabiyat idhar nahin aati

Hai kuch aisi hi bat jo chup hun
Varna kya baat kar nahin aati

Kyon na chikhun ki yad karate hain
Merii aavaaz gar nahin aati

Daag-e-dilagarnazar nahin aata
Bu bhi ai chaaraagar nahin aati

Ham vahan hain jahan se ham ko bhi
Kuch hamari Khabar nahin aati

Marte hain aarazuu mein marne ki
Maut aati hai par nahin aati


English Translation

I am left with no hope at all,
No possibility to reach my goal,

The Day of my death is fixed,
I can not sleep all night.

Then, the state(s) of my heart which used to make me laugh
Now it (laughter) doesn't come for anything.

Though I know the reward of obedience and worship,
But I have no tendency for it.

I am silent for a certain reason,
Otherwise I can convince you with my words,

Why I shouldn't cry,
For when I don't, she asks about me,

My heart is burning, though you cannot see the spot,
But O my doctor, can't you smell my heart burn?

I have reached to a certain state,
From where even I cannot find myself.

I am dying (Waiting anxiously) for my death,
I don't know where my death has gone.



Can we imagine the plight of Akbar - HK.?.
How it feels for a father to carry his "ANSH" {as Jodha says it}, to the graveyard.?.
The face of Jodha and Akbar displayed a 1000 shades today, each more subtle than the other.

Only people who are capable of loving strongly can suffer great sorrow, but this same necessity of loving serves to counteract their grief and heals them. Today Jalal was playing the same role for Jodha. Having said this, i also want to add that, the grief always remains there.. It has been said time heals all wounds. I differ a bit here.. The wounds remain. In time, the mind protecting it's sanity covers them and the pain lessens, but it's never gone."

"Agar kuch hota hai to woh yeh ki, Waqt ke saath us dukh ki "Kashish" "kam" ho jaati hai, par wo "kashish" kabhi "khatm" nahi hoti, woh kayamat tak aapke saath rehti hai.". We can wipe the tears from our eyes, but we can not wipe the pain from our heart.

I admit that i do not shed tears easily, but this episode brought me "almost on the verge" of shedding them. The scene looked so original. It was "saddingly ethereal" . I agree with you that neither can we compare the grief of the parents nor can we say who suffered more..When your fear touches someone's pain, it becomes pity, when your love touches someone's pain, it become compassion..

Did we notice this today.?. Did we notice Jalal's Love being converting into compassion for Jodha. He was very much present with her so that she no longer wrestles with the grief, but could sit down with it as a lasting companion(Jalal) and make it a sharer in her thoughts.

They say that the darkest night produces the brightest stars. In my view, the story becomes EPIC by such poignant display of emotions. I have heard that even a hundredfold grief is divisible by love.

Your partner complements you. While Jodha was with Jalal as his pillar, after he was broken hearing MA's crude words to THEIR unborn sons. Today, it was Jalal who played the same role for Jodha. Tears shed for someone are not a sign of weakness. They are a sign of a pure heart. Jalal and Jodha BOTH have went through the phase.

What can i say about Jalal. The "MAN" in him was very much present there, as a shield for Jodha. Apart from this i would request all not to judge the bereaved mother today. She lost the most beautiful thing she could keep in her heart.

NOW,

She is breathing, but she is dying.
She may look young, but inside she has turned old.
She may smile, but her heart sobs.
She may walk, may talk, may work. She is, but she is not, all at once.
She is here, but part of her is elsewhere for 'eternity' ."



RIP -||- Akbar and Harka Bai..

You both were NOT supposed to meet, but you MET..And,
You scripted the "UNscriptable script"...!!!..!!!...I can't ADD more here.!. TODAY, I feel short of words..



wonderful post abhay👏...
Bilkul sahi likha hai ...kal PS or RT ne sach mein kamal kar diya especially paridhi ne jis tarah se usne jodha ke dukh ko dikhaya...vo expressions sach mein kabil e tareef they...or akbar ne jaise support kiya kal 👏...
U r right main same baat bolne waali thi ki aaj tak jodha support karti aayi akbar ko uski taqt bani jab jab akbar toota usko sahara bani...lekin aaj ulta tha aaj wahi kaam akbar ne kiya jodha ke liye...

Yes bohot dukhi they dono or shehensha hokar bhi jalal helpless tha kuch nahi kar paya...kyunki vo shehensha hai god nahi...
Or zindagi maut bhagwan ke haath hoti hai...or ye to hona hi tha ho gaya honi ko koi nahi rok sakta.....
Ab toofan to koi nahi rok sakta lekin ek dusre ka sahara banke khadey reh saktey hain iska saamna karne ke liye...
Aaj wahi sahara bana jalal jodha ke liye...

Ab ye hona tha aaj hassan gaya hai kal hussain bhi chala jaayega...yehi sach hai or ye hoga...lekin jodha jalal ka rishta humesha rahega...
Or jaldi hi dono ko hasne ki jeeney ki ek nayi wajah milegi ...salim😊...yes😊...kyunki raat kitni hi kali or gehri kyun na ho sawera hone se nahi rok sakti
Edited by -ambrosia- - 10 years ago
Donjas thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#15
Thank you Radhika and Abhay for bringing to life with your writings, a tear inducing episode.

There are some moments in life when you wonder if it is worth going on, but those moments are also a gauge of your true strength. Yesterday we saw that in abundance as Akbar and Hira Kunwari, gave us a glimpse of the depths of despair and hopelessness but also the strength they gave each other with their presence.

Did I say Akbar and Hira Kunwari, Sorry! I should say Rajat and Paridhi, but that is how good they were yesterday. A masterly performance that will be remembered. Both are ready for the big stage. After this serial ends I expect both to make a try at movies and succeed.

As for the serial, we can expect Ruqaiya to show her colours now. I expect more smirks from Ruqs and more insults and torture for Jodha ahead, culminating in the horror of another death. This phase could take a week or two. We will have to endure.
Edited by Donjas - 10 years ago
Jais1 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#16
Wonderful post Radhika. You have written so beautifully that i have short of word. Thanks for this post.
DearZindagi12 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#17
Radhika Fabulous Post... What a wonderful painful episode especially RT & PS nailed their scenes.. Both were so real and the love of Jodha and Jalal was shining brightly in the midst of this tragedy . we were transported to 450 yrs to see how these two had gone thru the pain..i still feel that these are real jodha and akbar who took rebirth to show thr love and pain to the whole world and how they became others strength .. thr is a saying kuch gaav itna gehra hota hai ki saamay ke saath dard kum hosakta hai..par is gaav ko kabi nahi bhool payenge ...chahe kitna bache bi aye unke zindagi main par Hassan aur hussain ko khone ka dard kabi nahi bhool payenge.
Paridhi as a distraught mother was a picture of grief and Jalal was her rock strength . The way he held her ,swallowed his pain to support her was beautifully shot it was not ott but very natural and real... The most emotional episode of JA and the soul connection of JJ was very touching
Its more painful for parents to loose thr kids...how real jodha akbar tolerated the agony of seeing their youthful sons's Daniyal n Murad's death.Its so painful to see jodha cursing her fate...? Liked jalaal telling to remove the palana and telling her firmly if she dies he will also die along with her ...There is so much warmth & love and the way Jalal consoled and stood by JO is superb... When HB came JO pleaded Jalaal she want to see her son last time, why can't she the way Jalaal said NO you won't get through the pain and Jo saying kanha she will not pray from now on is so heart touching... Can't even begin to imagine the pain real Akbar and Hk must have gone through.. next will be Hussain after few days..now this will make JoJa's love even stronger. They both have and will need only each other to come out of this pain. I loved the scene where Jalal was holding Jodha in his arms giving her the support she needed. Worrying for her. He was shocked and hurt even more than he already was when Jodha said she wished to die..
Y god was so cruel to them..y he punished them so severely..wat was thr mistake..since they both were born in a royal family ... was it the price they paid for being what they were?? did Abar and jodha really deserve such grave punishment in life?? Why god punished them again and again..for any parent to see one kid dying infront of thr eyes literally kills them..here thr 3 sons who were infants and one daughter and later on murad and daniyal who were grownup's...how they survived thru this pain again and again.. None can understand a mother's pain on having lost her child. Same goes for a father..
Today's episode is dedicated to only jodha and akbar..dont want to talk about precap and spoil my mood..all thanks to maddy..coz of her I dared to watch this beautiful episode.. Coming to rukku's bandaphod... they il show exactly opposite to wat we wanted to see..so I don't want to keep any false hopes on this or rukku's bandaphod...I was the one who was so confident that this time for sure rukku il get caught..but now I hv lost all hopes and not expecting any thing but want to see my jodha jalal happy..
dushi123 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#18
radhika and abhay... u both have written it beautifully ... indeed m not a good writer. so m not gonna say anything . but i feel how beautiful that the way u described this whole episode. 👏 👏 ... ...
this is for u both ❤️ ❤️😳😊
MaddyO thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: RadhikaS0


Full many a gem of purest ray serene,
The dark unfathomed caves of ocean bear:
Full many a flower is born to blush unseen,
And waste its sweetness on the desert air.



Today, the entire episode was dedicated to little Hasan, who lived for barely a few days but what memories he left behind! Oh! how many broken hearts and tear-stained faces did he leave behind without a backward glance.

Did he not miss his mother's gentle caress as she hugged him to her bosom and sang sweet lullabies?
Did he not miss his father's strong hands that promised to protect him in their embrace forever?
Did he not miss his brother who had been snatched from him but who still remembered Hasan with every breath he took?

It was painful to watch Jodha and Jalal today. There are no words that can describe what they felt, what they went through, how they embraced each other through the night, struggling to come to terms with a loss whose magnitude cannot be measured or understood by anyone else.

Coping with loss is a deeply personal experience. Nobody can help one go through it more easily or understand all the emotions that one is going through. But others can help comfort one through this process. The best thing we can do is to allow ourselves to feel the grief as it comes over us. Resisting it only prolongs the natural process of healing.

Jodha especially went through so many different stages of grief today, as she tried to come to terms with the reality that Hasan was no more a part of her life.

She tried hard to deny that Hasan had gone away. She tried to convince a broken Jalal that their Hasan was alright, that he would soon wake up upon hearing her voice. This was her mind trying to rationalize overwhelming emotions and to protect her from the immediate shock. Almost all of us go through this stage of denial, to tide through the first wave of pain.

As Man Singh took away the baby for final rites, she and Jalal remained, holding on to each other, as if afraid that if they let go, the other would disappear too. They spent the long, dark night remembering Hasan, trying to understand what had happened and why, if they could have prevented it, why God had punished them for being good, how God could have spared the child and taken them instead, and how they now had only each other to live for and how they had to live on for each other.

Sadness and regret predominated the mood. Jodha kept wondering why God had not taken her instead of Hasan. Jalal was stricken with guilt that despite being the Shahenshah, he could not save his own child. The grief and depression they exhibited was subtle and private. It was their way of quietly preparing to bid Hasan farewell. No one could have consoled them at this time. Except each other. It was so heart-breaking to watch them cradled together in a helpless, - sometimes raging, sometimes sad - despair, trying to find and offer succor, even as their hearts and minds seemed ready to collapse.

Jalal was magnificent, as the man struggling to control his own bursting grief, so that he could protect and console Jodha, who had completely melted. This was a strong man, if ever there was one. Not the one who fought tigers bare-handed or waged war on enemies. But this one who could subdue his own tormenting soul so that he could soothe the broken soul of his beloved. If only I had done this...If only this had happened...If only ...There was no end to these Ifs...

Jodha and Jalal, who had always been so strong, so independent, so much in control of their lives, were today unashamedly lost and drifting in the seas of helplessness and vulnerability. They tried hard to regain control of the situation by thinking of ways in which they could have prevented the tragedy from occurring.

Towards the end of the episode, Jodha's tumultuous feelings gave way to anger, as the masking effects of denial began to wear and reality re-emerged. She was not yet ready to accept the ultimate truth. And so the intense emotions swirling within her deflected from her vulnerable soul and expressed themselves instead as anger directed towards her beloved Kanha. In her heart, she knew that Kanha could not go against Destiny. Emotionally, however, she felt resentful with Kanha for causing her pain by taking away the light in her life. Ironically, this is a vicious cycle Jodha is caught in. The more Jodha stays away from Kanha, the more guilty she will feel, which would make her more angry.

One day, both Jodha and Jalal will have to accept the inevitable. Of course, it is a difficult journey fraught with emotional pitholes. Hasan's demise was so sudden and unexpected, that Jodha may continue to live in denial or anger against God for ever. But I hope that Jalal will be able to accept and help Jodha accept the truth. This is crucial for their peace of mind.

The days ahead are far from being happy ones. But I wish to see JJ at most withdrawn and calm rather than depressed or angry still. I wish to see them remember Hasan ultimately with fondness as God's gift to them, if only for a few days.


@All: Remember, grieving is a personal process that has no time limit, nor one "right" way to do it. Please do not judge how JJ grieved or should have grieved.


Precap:

Jodha has apparently nursed Hussein and is rocking him in her arms to make him sleep. Ruq is hovering around like a stricken hen and ultimately almost snatches Hussein from Jodha's arms and puts him in his cradle. Jodha is stunned at Hussein being taken away. Salima Begum is looking on in helpless silence.

Has Jalal managed to convince Ruq to share Hussein with Jodha?





Wonderful post Radhika, I cannot add anything more.

I was mesmerized by the acting of Paridhi and Rajat yesterday. Actually acting is not the correct word, they were not acting they WERE the characters.

I cried with them and we are lucky to have such magnificent leads for JA depicting HK and Akbar.

Paridhi never gets enough praise here, this entire month she has been super, the MA track and now this track. I just want to say Paridhi's Jodha is the reason I started watching, I love Rajat too but still for me it is all about Jodha. The way I see it, I LOVE Jodha's Jalal and not Ruk's. I hope soon there won't be anybody's Jalal but ONLY Jodha's. There already is ONLY Jodha's Jalal but the formalities remain which hope we will get to see with adequate justice to Jodha and Jalal.

It should be ONLY about them - I don't even want to take name of other cos not worth it.

ann2012 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#20
Wonderful and Amazing piece of writing Radhika! I can't find words to describe this beautiful post. I am speechless 👏👏👏

You have described their agony so impeccably. It never ceases to amaze me, the way you write. Right from your heart but it never spills over completely. It remains restrained and focused even in face of so much emotion that must have gone in typing those words.

Your post made me emotional all over again 😭 Never stop making posts. Love them and you!
Edited by ann2012 - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".