Will Jalal Ever Stop Playing Around with Jodha's Love? Updated 20/8 - Page 6

Originally posted by: rishitabeladia

I m not justifying his anger either m jst saying jst coz of dos harsh wrds 1 cn not say he dnt love jodha...or he is confused abt his feelings thts y he smtimes loves hr nd smtimes ABUSE hr as sm people feel...nd abt suicide usse suicide ka khayal hi well ko khula dekh ke aaya tha jst a weak moment...agar wo waha jati hi nai nd well ko khula dekhti hi nai to shayad suicide ka khayal hi nai aata...yes his plan hv sm loop holes...i cn not justify tht...he wil himself justify tht bt i wud always stand fo his love wenever it wud b questioned...nd wud stand fo jodha also wen hr love wud b question bt tht never happens nd wud never happen i guess...bd abt him using d same wrds to atifa which he used fo jodha well i wud say he dnt any other way to express love...hes not a player who wud knw hundreds of pickup lines...agar koi aur tarike se atifa ko pyar ke bare me bolta to sab kehte ke aesa usne jodha ko to kabhi nai boli...u see people find fault in him regardless of any situation or circumstances...

@sindhumenon

Originally posted by: myviewprem

There are two aspects

Thanks for posting! I think this is the first time you have posted on my thread. Welcome!!! 😊

My views inline in blue. 😊

Fictional jalal

Fictional jalal was a ruqaiah loyalist husband till jodha came along. He may have had 20-30 wives but he was emotionally bond with ruqaiah. then came jodha and he became emotionally attached to her and more than that only as jodha is not assertive and possessive like ruqaiah of jalal and her audha. She is typical people pleasing person.

Now whether jalal loved Benazir, atifa or was using them I do not know. But all I know is that he does not truly love them he does not have emotional bonding like he has with ruqaiah or soul bonding like jodha

Yes. I agree, Jalal can never truly love anyone except Jodha. He cannot even bond like a friend with anyone else like he bonds with Ruq and Salima.

History jalal

In those days king married to expand kingdom and to keep people loyal. that is what Akbar did but on a large scale basis.

Whether he treated muz badly- not really but he is king with 300 wives he must have had a few favourites among whom muz was one and so was ruqaiah and salima.

Did he only love muz and ignore others- not really he treated all wives nicely but had favourites

That's the whole point. Akbar may have a harem. But he treated all queens with respect. He didn't humiliate them in the DEK like being shown in the serial.

Can we compare that 16th century Akbar to serial Akbar- not really, love had different meaning in those times

Men were not single woman husbands in those times especially kings. They had many wives and few of them were his favourites simple

In those days men married for loyalty, property and kids

Very few married only for love like a jehangir to widow nur jahan, shah jahan to mumtaz, baz bahadur to roopmati etc

The two Mughal examples you have quoted here are highly debatable in my humble personal opinion. But I do vouch for Baz Bahadur - Roopmati. We cannot say that Akbar didn't love Jodha just because he had a harem. Even Shah Jahan married even after Mumtaz died. Jahangir was more of a puppet than the kind of strong emperor Akbar was and the kind of TE we expect Jalal to be. I will quote the example of Khusrau - there was a man devoted to his wife if ever there was one. 😊

On a lighter note, seeing how much you love the Jahangir-Nur Jahan story, I am sure, you will be happy with the proposed 15-year leap. 😊

Originally posted by: Donjas

Wow, two fantastic posts in one thread, yours and Abhay. I am sorry to say, you are hindering my de-addiction efforts from Jodha Akbar. With such beautiful posts to ponder and comment upon, how can anyone think of leaving.

As for the depiction of Jodha and Akbar, like most I think it is a problem of Ability. These CV's simply don't have the creative horsepower to present events from Akbar's long and eventful life, things like Sati abolition, like Akbar's war with Rajputana states, like Todar Mal's rehaul of the revenue system, like Akbar's pilgrimage to the many saints of that era etc.

They are so many things one can show, instead the CV's take the easy way out, they introduce imaginary characters and ridiculous situations, which have absolutely nothing to do with history. When the depiction of a character needs a subtle approach, they go the sledgehammer way totally destroying the essence of the character.

Maybe, that is the problem. Maybe Ekta and the CV's have no understanding of history, of the sacredness of certain aspects of depiction.

Maybe a big leap is not a bad idea, these CV's will never do justice to Akbar and Jodha. Perhaps after the leap, these two will escape their attentions, and Salim will get the full treatment.

Originally posted by: Birdiee

I am sorry but I disagree. We can reverse the question too. This track has been executed so poorly . I don't agree with the treatment of Jodha either, but I do not think Jalal is playing with Jodha's love. He still loves her . Atifa is just part of his plan.It just that things went beyond Jalal's control . Even though , I am not a big fan of Jodha's treatment on some level, but Jodha does a tight whack. It's one thing to spare life, but another to run to rescue a foreign man in the middle of night . Does the Jodha realize the repercussions of her spending night with Khyber. It's one thing to be kind but the extreme measure Jodha has taken is too far.Jalal will defend her publicly and trusts her no doubt. On top of it, she was running after him holding his hand. She is a queen not an ordinary woman.

Originally posted by: baldevfan

how conveniently meaning of bashing changes for u when it comes for jalal

on other hand u people complains of bashing jodha saying she too is human no matter what she does

frankly speaking she has done nothing to be considered as queen

a man enters he hojra at night

she continuously does attempt to suicide

but when it comes the question of her child she shows bravery and says cowards does suicide

she is on verge of doing suicide becoz of MU with jalal

but considers ruku suicide wrong wgen her husband is captured👏

she runs holding hand in hand with paraya mard in night in huts changes clothes

ask for forgiveness of the paraya mard still she loves jalal and deserves love

Originally posted by: RadhikaS0