--- The LOST Symbol --- - Page 20

Originally posted by: ann2012

This thread proves that Abhay's threads were the life of the forum. Practically it's very soul and the main attraction. Now I am really confused by MODs claims about people reporting Abhay's thread. If so many members have liked and commented here, then who reported? Obviously a very small percentage of people. Infact Abhay's threads were one the rare regular threads on the forum which had no DT note. Still silently there were closed.

For a few people and there appeasement, they unanimously decided to punish us all. History based discussions will always be a norm here. But just to meet their goals they made a rule to curb our discussions on history. The rule isn't exactly against history but specifically directed against Abhay's threads, why?

I wouldn't like to discuss about freedom of discussion of this forum because since past few months, threads have been closed and reported left right and center. Sadly it has now taken it's toll on the most famous threads on JA forum.

But administrators instead of resolving disputes, prefer to close the threads as an easy way out.

Originally posted by: MaddyO

Lines in bold exactly! I NEVER saw Mods note on Abhay's thread, so how can there be fan wars?!
When other threads who openly discuss anything and everything, claim with confidence REAL Akbar would never have done this, was not this - btw HOW IS THIS NOT DISCUSSING HISTORY?!! - are allowed to go on merrily!

So the threads getting Mods Note are ok but not Abhay's threads!

Originally posted by: MaddyO

Lines in bold exactly! I NEVER saw Mods note on Abhay's thread, so how can there be fan wars?!
When other threads who openly discuss anything and everything, claim with confidence REAL Akbar would never have done this, was not this - btw HOW IS THIS NOT DISCUSSING HISTORY?!! - are allowed to go on merrily!

So the threads getting Mods Note are ok but not Abhay's threads!

Originally posted by: history_geek

@All

Sharing a PM here, read just now, sent by a member 2 days back , who does NOT wants to post this herself on the Forum disclosing her ID(?), but wants me to post it.

I am posting a ''part'' of the PM.
She has asked the same questions raised by many of us. Though her PM was 'touching' and perhaps an ''answer'' also. 😊


''
Hey bruh...'tis a devoted follower of your threads...read every comment posted by u on 'dis forum...appreciate the respect ur threads give to Sufis and saints and hold every creed in high honors...ur outlook at deducing the things in most logical manner with proof is unparalleled...i like tis, being from a scientific field, i appreciate proofs...Me too stay in Delhi...Meself a scholar at Faculty of Eng. And Tech., Jamia Milia Islamia University, Delhi...Belong to a very conservative family of sunnis in faizabad district, uttar pradesh...first girl to get higher education from my clan in the village...mughals fascinate me due to a special bond we have with them...we are the descendants of the weavers who made the finishings for the royal suits of mughal emperors and empresses...the last suit was sent 3 generations ago...now many of our area have migrated to bhadohi carpet zone, after akhilesh yadav govt. new schemes for skilled weavers...coming to point...the complete belt of our area know about akbar and his hindu rani for generations...i wanted to know more about them...there were no libraries in faizabad...no big bookstores...the clerics in our area call akbar a kaafir...blaming his hindu rani for turning him a infidel...they dislike akbar and his hindu rani in our area...came the movie jodha akbar and i became more involved in the quest to discover them...searched wikipedia and many websites...but tis made me hate akbar...raw and obsolete text was written about him...i stopped searching as i never got any source to read on them...atlast came to know abt you from my friends in St. Stephen's College who started watching the show for rajat and paridhi since august and found your posts on this forum...they all follow your posts like any other brand in Delhi Univ.- ask'd me to google 'history_geek jodha akbar' to get to you. With underscore character in ur id... i discovered reality of real akbar...thanks to you...i read the persian munthakhab by badaouni given in ur thread...i wanted to verify the marrying once statement of akbar and ruqayya which you said is wrong..not that i suspect you but wanted to read from my own eyes...took me 4 months to read the said book...understood what efforts it takes to search the truth...tis was more tough than drafting a research paper for Nature ! I have procured gulshan i ibrahimi from the source in your thread and reading it now..if you visit zakir hussain library again then inform me..like to meet you..along with me my cousins back in Faizabad follow you every weekend from the nearby cyber cafe...we don't have a computer at home...thank you for providing these valuable and priceless gems from the annals of our past...my heart bleeds to see such dazzling work being targeted by some people out of jeolosy and the moderation team acting on complains against you.. Any person can sense the truth of tis work . It is pretty easy for me to make out why you were targeted. I have a first hand experience in my hometown because i've seen some elements speaking against akbar. You stood against those beliefs about akbar and fell prey. all of us are suffering due to prejudice of some . it is a mirage that indiaforums boasts of calling itself number 1 discussion forum and acts in such an ostracizing manner against a member. After tis serial, the forum will shut down but your efforts will be remembered forever. It is clear because tis forum stands by you in unison. jodha akbar in heaven must be smiling this day...someone stood for them, after 400 years despite all odds...unka aks tumhari posts mein dikhta hai...shukriya hamein sach se mukhatib karane ke liye...kehte hain aaftab ka noor chupaye nahi chipta ... Waise hi jodha akbar ki dastaan nahi mit sakti...chahe koi kitni bhi koshish karle...hum dua karenge..
Eid Mubarak...

Iqra khan
''

Originally posted by: al_pal

Hi, abhay I have been silent reader of ur post . Though my background is medical I am avid fan of reading which gives me knowledge and different views to see things rather than go by traditional way . We take education to improve ourself not just to get good job . U were doing fabulous job of giving knowledge not just some fiction or not what u thought abut akbar but pure knowledge with facts . I was hoping to see FSikri just becoz of ur writing , hoping to pass this wast history to my son & showing him how to see things with different prospective ( though he still is 14 month ) . I was devastated to see closing of ur post just becoz some one doesn't think it true or not matching with their view. We call ourself secular country but we don't act on it. If u can't tolerate others view or opinion than how we are secular ? . Just becoz ur educated doesn't make u know legible . Hoping mods will consider others view as they did with others by closing ur treads.

Originally posted by: MaddyO

I wish more silent readers like you come forward.

Abhay's threads are the reason many joined IF.

I wish those who want to read Abhay's posts, threads - their voice is also heard!

Originally posted by: history_geek

@All

Sharing a PM here, read just now, sent by a member 2 days back , who does NOT wants to post this herself on the Forum disclosing her ID(?), but wants me to post it.

I am posting a ''part'' of the PM.
She has asked the same questions raised by many of us. Though her PM was 'touching' and perhaps an ''answer'' also. 😊


''
Hey bruh...'tis a devoted follower of your threads...read every comment posted by u on 'dis forum...appreciate the respect ur threads give to Sufis and saints and hold every creed in high honors...ur outlook at deducing the things in most logical manner with proof is unparalleled...i like tis, being from a scientific field, i appreciate proofs...Me too stay in Delhi...Meself a scholar at Faculty of Eng. And Tech., Jamia Milia Islamia University, Delhi...Belong to a very conservative family of sunnis in faizabad district, uttar pradesh...first girl to get higher education from my clan in the village...mughals fascinate me due to a special bond we have with them...we are the descendants of the weavers who made the finishings for the royal suits of mughal emperors and empresses...the last suit was sent 3 generations ago...now many of our area have migrated to bhadohi carpet zone, after akhilesh yadav govt. new schemes for skilled weavers...coming to point...the complete belt of our area know about akbar and his hindu rani for generations...i wanted to know more about them...there were no libraries in faizabad...no big bookstores...the clerics in our area call akbar a kaafir...blaming his hindu rani for turning him a infidel...they dislike akbar and his hindu rani in our area...came the movie jodha akbar and i became more involved in the quest to discover them...searched wikipedia and many websites...but tis made me hate akbar...raw and obsolete text was written about him...i stopped searching as i never got any source to read on them...atlast came to know abt you from my friends in St. Stephen's College who started watching the show for rajat and paridhi since august and found your posts on this forum...they all follow your posts like any other brand in Delhi Univ.- ask'd me to google 'history_geek jodha akbar' to get to you. With underscore character in ur id... i discovered reality of real akbar...thanks to you...i read the persian munthakhab by badaouni given in ur thread...i wanted to verify the marrying once statement of akbar and ruqayya which you said is wrong..not that i suspect you but wanted to read from my own eyes...took me 4 months to read the said book...understood what efforts it takes to search the truth...tis was more tough than drafting a research paper for Nature ! I have procured gulshan i ibrahimi from the source in your thread and reading it now..if you visit zakir hussain library again then inform me..like to meet you..along with me my cousins back in Faizabad follow you every weekend from the nearby cyber cafe...we don't have a computer at home...thank you for providing these valuable and priceless gems from the annals of our past...my heart bleeds to see such dazzling work being targeted by some people out of jeolosy and the moderation team acting on complains against you.. Any person can sense the truth of tis work . It is pretty easy for me to make out why you were targeted. I have a first hand experience in my hometown because i've seen some elements speaking against akbar. You stood against those beliefs about akbar and fell prey. all of us are suffering due to prejudice of some . it is a mirage that indiaforums boasts of calling itself number 1 discussion forum and acts in such an ostracizing manner against a member. After tis serial, the forum will shut down but your efforts will be remembered forever. It is clear because tis forum stands by you in unison. jodha akbar in heaven must be smiling this day...someone stood for them, after 400 years despite all odds...unka aks tumhari posts mein dikhta hai...shukriya hamein sach se mukhatib karane ke liye...kehte hain aaftab ka noor chupaye nahi chipta ... Waise hi jodha akbar ki dastaan nahi mit sakti...chahe koi kitni bhi koshish karle...hum dua karenge..
Eid Mubarak...

Iqra khan
''