Take 5: Top 5 countdown for June 12th - Page 11

Originally posted by: mandyg

divi, i am satisfied with the episode, jodha did what a woman..a home maker is supposed to do in the time of crisis when relations are at stake..and that is what hamida did in maham's case and salima has also been doing the same time and again..!..and what worst punishment can ruk get other than a silent slap on her face and the guilt that she has to live in for betraying and hurting her own husband!

Originally posted by: Akdhaparijatluv

Divya u made take 5 for this episode n actually ur last one abt Maham is only giving me hope or else This show is no more jodha akbar... I hv no hopes on zee as im sure they lied to all of us...

We all know Jo mahanta of forgiving so not to think abt her... It's Jallu who doesn't hv decision taking capability by seeing which is correct or wrong... It's jalal character which is butchered more than Jo... I loved wen Jallu dint listen to Jo in Maham case...I'm actually feeling pity for Maham and adham bcz just bcz they r from bandhi family rules n punishment r different wer as ppl lik rukayya and abulmali from royal families r forgiven... As per spoiler Jo wil cme to know that adham is behind this attack so Jallu wil also know... So wil Jallu punish adham?? Y shud adham b punished wen abulmali who attacked Jallu was forgiven in mathura just bcz he is behanoyi???Is this justice fair?? It's definitely not mistake it's gunah according to jalal...bakshi gunah itni hi bada nahi thi ki he called in DEK n stopped talking to her n rukayya gunah itni chitin nahi thi ki he shud forgive her immediately...

As Jo told him to forgive by making saugandh on kanha he has forgiven rukayya... If he had not met Jo on the way we all know wat punishment he wud hv given to rukayya... As shehenshah how can he keep saugandh for ppl n make justice? Dint he say to jodha during bakshi matter and Maham matter that all relations r to kept aside while giving judgement???

I seriously dnt hv hopes on Maham also... But I want her to tel evrythng abt rukayya infront of evryone wen she n her son gets punishment... I sound lik sadist but I really want Maham to insult Jallu n question him that y was rukayya matter hidden n not given punishment n y she deserves punishment?? JJ thinks no one knows this matter even HB Salima doesn't know... Little they know that this news is known to bomb which may explode at anytime... I really wish this happens n I'm waiting what wil Jallu answer her as it's insult to him to hide matter lik this...

Originally posted by: ---Khushi---

"Om Jai Jodha Hare,

Maiya Jai Jodha Hare

AGRA Jano Ke Sankat,

GUNEHGAAR Jano ke Sankat,

Kshan Mein Dur Kare ... "

Most bakwaas epi of JA to date...being loving, forgiving & large hearted is one thing, & being outright foolish in an attempt to be MAHAAN is another. Jo is the most self righteous foolish person I have ever encountered as a viewer till date.

A king ought to punish all those who have been guilty. Jalal had been right when he banished Jo during Sujamal fiasco(the way he saw it)...Ruqu was guilty, n she ought to have been punished by Jalal. Period.

If Jo tried to stop the king from meting out punishment to the guilty, Jo should have issued a warning by the king. A big fat period.

A king ought to have a personality of his own, & should NOT be influenced to this extent by anyone...not even his favourite queen. This Jalal is a very, very weak emperor who has always been used as a puppet by MA, Ruqu, etc & now, Jo, as per their whims & fancy.

Not acceptable to me. Sorry.

Originally posted by: munnirony

Well when gave it a 2nd thought I realised whtever jalal nd jodha did was not their "mahanta" but out of love. Jodha didn't do anything for ruku but for jalal. She knows tht if jalal punishes ruku he himself wont be happy. He himself will break down. He is not tht person who will forget evrything just bcoz jodha is there. Nd jodha understood if jalal breaks down, even she cant heal it. Whtever maybe the issue jalal loves ruku nd jodha understood tht. She gave lectures to jalal bcoz she knows jalal will understand but ruku wont. People may argue tht why jalal listened jodha but thts bcoz he is feeling guilty nd thts jalal for u who always takes the blame even though others r also equally at fault. He did the same during the MU track as well.

Originally posted by: PAPS71

Personally I am not totally disappointed with yesterday's episode. ... never expected a public insult ... becoz the issue is sensitive enough. ... even I liked Jodha's reasoning also ... liked Jalal Jodha scene. ... now at least Jalal manage to controls his anger which indicates his maturity level... but ... if he confronted Ruq with the FP issue privately then it would have been justified. ... becoz she needs to understand the magnitude of the crime... yes it was a crime ... and jalal knows it... may be later...

Sorry. .. I m sure I m a minority here .:)... thanks for the beautiful post...

My dearest girl,

You spoil me, but I am used to taking such lavish compliments with a spoonful of salt! 😉This said, I am very glad that you liked this one so much, for I liked it a lot too.

Re: @ blue.Logic and beauty need not go together. Last night, the script, the screenplay, and the acting all reinforced each other for all the 3 lead players, and that, to my mind, was the most important. There is rarely any logic in this story, the issue is only whether the take of any one or more characters moves you or not. So there is very little to be gained from defending the screenplay for any one episode, when it can so easily be stood on its head the next time around.

Plus, by the time you have answered all possible objections, you are ready to wind up, so you cannot put down what you did like a lot and why, or vice versa.

But I forget that yours is not a critical episode analysis; it is a listing of positives. But even so, I regret that you missed out the single most important one last night: the performances and then the script.

I would love to read a proper episode analysis of yours. Do try your hand at one; you will not regret it, and I will have so much fun reading it!

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: divyavm

Originally posted by: sunshine_sun

Di , i was very much sure that u wud come up with take 5 rather dejectedly .must admit 😆
Thanx a lot for this much needed post ..🤗👏
Comin to the episode , ahhh alas als alas ,it must have hurted jodha supporters badly ...the reason is all we know 😕
But i as a viewer was highly surprised ..i dont know how to react 😲
Yes yes m blabbering too much ..cutting things short if jalal kept things under wraps without having jodha in his way i wud have appreciated but cvs is a biggg let down .. A Shehenshah who vision to have whole of hindustan under his wraps is easily dictated by others , hw he ruled hindustan,m not sure 👎🏼..If he was angry then damn it ,be it be it ! but y easily led by others ...Jodha gave him a seriies of saugandhs (which reminds me of sujamal fiasco ) How jalal n jodha r different here ?? Actually jodha is consistent to her character ..n yesterday she was at her best behaviour ...👍🏼..Everything is becoming unrealistic ...u know here ppl r saying if jodha is in rukaiyah place things wud be different ,may be i agree with them bcz there is no another jodha .. N on that fateful he was asking her innumerable times who is he ??(physical abuse is not needed) A man who sees his wife n another man doin eye talking cant think normal even in 21st century ...So i think we shud just stop comparing these two incidents ... Now that everything has ended in a bad taste in our mouth for several reason i just hope rulkaiya redeemed herself to be really with jalal 😳. Taht menancing ,threathening lok of jalal wen he was pressing her head was☺️..(was scary indeed but m mad too)😆. Nothing wud be same for these two buddy bcz they both held responsible for that ...
Jalal intead of pacifying her , making her c reason he was endearing her with statements like i also didnt like(jaan ,hug pe hug audience dont want such scenes right ?)👎🏼 jalal must have chid her , he ought to wen alone 😡. I m very sure n i want also Maham to raise this question bcz both betrayed mughal sultanate...😡😡.. Jalal has no sense of justice in this show 👎🏼

Originally posted by: PutijaChalhov

Like your positive posts though I dont comment much here is something which the posted in couple of other threads

Hope you dont mind

Originally in Mandyg's thread

Mandyg a very rational post and it miss what happens in many families the concept which very few new age people can digest. I can say it maybe because of the nuclear family we in current age live in No body wants to clean their dirty linen in public and burying skeletons in cupboards all the proverbs have come all because of such incidents.

How can Akbar tell all that he has been made a fool of by his main queen though in private he may be angry and mad what if all try and do such things as once he has been made a fool.

This is a private matter and that is why he has to deal in private . Besides having so many external and internal enemies he does not need to make more enemies within and he being a mighty ruler he needs many friends may be his revenge with Ruq would have made her his no 1 foe as she knows about him his nature what ticks him more then even Jodha as they are together since childhood. Remember what Salima told about them to Jo both being childhood friends

Long long time back I remember reading a book on Harem politics and surprised and shocked at the type of happenings.

Jodha and her behaviour reminds me of the sanskrist shlok

Karyeshu Dasi, Karaneshu Manthri;
Bhojeshu Mata, Shayaneshu Rambha;
Roopeshu lakshmi, Kshamayeshu Dharitri;
Satkarma Nari, Kuladharma Patni

According to the Hindu Mythology, the six criteria of an ideal wife:

Works like a servant, Advises like a minister, Feeds like a mother, makes love like a nymph, is as beautiful as Lakshmi, and forgiving like the earth.

She is following these qualites to the T with her husband Akbar and also teaching him the goodness of forgiving. No doubt guilt is a very hard feeling to overcome and will Ruq have the same bullying attitude over Akbar like before now she will be much subdued and wont be able to have a haq over Jalal.

In the long run this will certainly help unless Ruq is so pigheaded and does not take the hint and canges herself have to W&W and see.

My POV

Liked to read your positive post and could identify this feeling that you have expressed.

Originally posted by: TheIronLady

Nice post Divi.😃

And as for me, well I liked the episode.

Originally posted by: Mallika-E-Bhais

I predict-

Ruqaiyya will plot to kill Jodha.

Jalal will become FURIOUS & kick her out of his Life.

I wonder how anyone can be angry with Jodha. 😆 😆

The woman is a SAINT. 😆