Fateh pur sikari and Jo's tomb - Page 32

I am sorry but I am starting to lose faith in Abhay's historical ability. Every time anything unsual happens in the serial, Abhay is there to give corroborating evidence usually from books that I have never heard of and neither has any serious historian and records that no one can access.

I believe that most of the evidence that he presents is true, but sometimes I wonder, like in this Surjamal case.

@ Donjas

I am posting what i get . I do NOT know if someone else has also read this and can support me. Some events do appear too much over the top. But, if they happened then...?... 😊



Edit:
Bikaner House in Rajasthan is the BEST place for research. All Books i say are present there.😊

Originally posted by: Donjas

I am sorry but I am starting to lose faith in Abhay's historical ability. Every time anything unsual happens in the serial, Abhay is there to give corroborating evidence usually from books that I have never heard of and neither has any serious historian and records that no one can access.

I believe that most of the evidence that he presents is true, but sometimes I wonder, like in this Surjamal case.

Originally posted by: history_geek

@ Donjas

I am posting what i get . I do NOT know if someone else has also read this and can support me. Some events do appear too much over the top. But, if they happened then...?... 😊



Edit:
Bikaner House in Rajasthan is the BEST place for research. All Books i say are present there.😊

I am not doubting your ability, you have spent many hours and a lot of effort to ferret facts lost in history for the enjoyment of all in this forum. I respect you and thank you for that.

But, you are starting to depend too much on unreliable sources. A "tattered book written in Persian" is being used too many times as a source in your writings. So, to ensure that people continue to hold as the gospel all the other wonderful historical facts that you have found out, you must be absolutely sure that what you write comes from impeccable sources, before you make any claims.

Originally posted by: Donjas

I am not doubting your ability, you have spent many hours and a lot of effort to ferret facts lost in history for the enjoyment of all in this forum. I respect you and thank you for that.

But, you are starting to depend too much on unreliable sources. A "tattered book written in Persian" is being used too many times as a source in your writings. So, to ensure that people continue to hold as the gospel all the other wonderful historical facts that you have found out, you must be absolutely sure that what you write comes from impeccable sources, before you make any claims.

This is absolutely strange information that suja had entered in jalal's harem genuinely!!
I m not definitely questioning on the credibility of the source of Abhay where as i have quite little learning abt the mughal history before him but phir vi ajeeb lagra rahai to know suja showed gut to enter in jalal's harem that also in hidden way just for meeting with jodha!? Guilelessly, was it happened?

There are many records available in private hands ,archives, libraries and many places that only some researchers or writers of books access so I don't disbelieve anything myself being from a research background and seen many rare and historical documents and also when something we see or someone asks we try and find that information I read lot of Abhay's posts and don't find anything wrong. I am from Hyderabad and sometimes some unexpected persons try to bring very rare handwritten documents in private hands who want to sell them but don't relieve their source

Originally posted by: nabiii

This is absolutely strange information that suja had entered in jalal's harem genuinely!!
I m not definitely questioning on the credibility of the source of Abhay where as i have quite little learning abt the mughal history before him but phir vi ajeeb lagra rahai to know suja showed gut to enter in jalal's harem that also in hidden way just for meeting with jodha!? Guilelessly, was it happened?

I am sure this information about Sujamal can be available in Rajasthan records archives specially all the royal families who stay on the right side of people in power their records were not spoiled or snatched away whether they were Moghuls britishers etc.