should ruqayia be given second chance? - Page 19

Created

Last reply

Replies

292

Views

19.3k

Users

51

Likes

981

Frequent Posters

ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: FairGuy

nice post 👏

women of those days knew from childhood that d men practiced polygamy so ruku never should have felt a sudden unexpected stab so this reason can not be an excuse of her sinful acts.a persons own deeds makes her desirable non desirable.what ruku is doing would not further her cause.if she is so blind in fury n jealousy that she fails to differentiate between just n unjust then she cannot expect 2nd chance.also jthere are many women in that palace rukus anger is not directed towards them but only on jo.it proves she is not feeling hurt angry as a wife but she is feeling insecured fearing jo gaining more importance in d kingdom n in d ppls heart she is insecured seeing jo being heralded as a befitting queen to jalal not ruku herself.
d day ruku starts feeling jealous as a woman not as a power monger that day i might consider giving her 2nd chance.😊



thx😊..u r rt an honest approach from her is needed!
greeshma014 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Priya_nv

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">There are some inconsistencies in Ruk's character but she is redeemable.
She is in denial right now abt the growing closeness between Jodha n Jalal. She
will definitely make some mistakes in the time required for her to understand
that people can't help whom they fall in love with. Each character in this
serial had a phase where their actions were questioned to extreme, be it Jalal
during MC track or Jodha during Sukanya's wedding. The learning curve for Ruk
has started and she has to reach to a height first from where the fall can result
in max impact on her character makeover. And I think Jalal will be there for
her at that time. Even though there are predictions n history proofs that Jalal
might stop taking to her, I think he might provide her with emotional support required.
He is not the character to easily let go of his loved ones even when they go
against him. Example is the BK case where he publicly goes against Jalal, but
when BK stood in front of the Shahi Gate Jalal was ready to forget everything n
asked him to take his place back. </font>


<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif"> As for the shouting of
Ruk for Krishna Murti issue, I think Jalal was hurt because Ruk acted against his
view of his BEK. For Jalal, Ruk has always been 'Insaaf Pasand' (as shown in
the case where she gives her gift of tax money to Salima n Rahim). So when she
has done something that goes entirelyagainst the Mugal
Law, it was the breaking point for him. See he mentions something like "I
thought you will play fair for the elections but you have lost hope at the
starting itself". I think he is not mostly mad that the trick was played
against Jodha (maybe in some part of his now existing heart) but the idea that
his childhood friend and BEK whom he regarded as the 'INSAAF PASAND"
individual in his life has done something so mean and played with the other
begums and bandhis feelings, has hurt him the most n resulted in his lashing.</font>


<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif"> As for his saying to
not give him unasked advise at the harem meeting, we should look at the scene
completely. In the previous dialogue he clearly says that whoever has done this
can come to me and accept it privately otherwise I will consider it as
'Sehanshah ko lalrkarna aur sehanshah ko lalrkarne ka anjam aap sab jante hai'.
He already knew that Ruk was the culprit and he was indirectly telling her to
come to him and confess he may even pardon her. But the stupid girl what does
she do..she goes on saying that it is a taab on mugal saltanat. So what should
a sheheshah/friend/husband should do when she is not even interested in
listening to the chance he gave her ? So he replied her to shut up. But even at
this stage he was not ready to degrade her infront of everyone. This shows that
he cares or even loves her in his own different way. And I think that she will
be given more n more chances where he goes along with her tantrums n chaals
given he can relate to her pain/changing conditions.</font><font face="Arial, sans-serif"></font>


priya, u said it all...especially d last paragraph..she was really acted like a stupid girl..k, don't admit ur mistak in public, par chup toh reh sakti thi na?? but no...dat made him angry...aftr dis all I expected a sorry scene b/w dem..Ruq saying sorry and jalal make her understand her mistakes and a talk b/w dem regarding dat...But dat scene never came...*sigh*
greeshma014 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: mandyg



i had no issue during the murti kand as ruq was at fault! but in yesterday's episode i felt a bit at unease after watching ruqlal scene..i did not like it..it left a bitter taste in my mouth!..jalal's reactions were like whatever and ruq was throwing herself forcefully on him..it was a sad situation..being the first wife she had to stoop so low to grab attention..i do not like tracks like this where to raise one the cvz blacken the other person completely..balance is missing and inconsistencies in characters exist!


mandy dat was the worse RukLal scene till d date..I think more dis types of scenes is coming in our way..Let's not talk abt balance and consistencies...iss show mein aisa kuch bhi nai hai.
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
i agree! i seriously do not want to see another sad scene of ruqlal i am not used to it and would hate to see my jalal behaving indifferently with her..i cannot take it yaar!
Edited by mandyg - 11 years ago
greeshma014 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: mandyg

i agree! i seriously do not want to see another sad scene of ruqlal i am not used to it and would hate to see my jalal behaving indifferently with her..i cannot take it yaar!


me too...why his expression changed when she hugged him?? don't knw why I remembered dat scene wher jalal felt disguested by Benazir 's touch..I knw dis scene was not like dat..but phir bhi...some people r happy becoz he hated Rukku's touch, becoz nw he is in love with jo, and he doesn't like any other woman's physical proximity..I don't knw it's like dat way or not...if so I hate dat fact..After his love confession to jo, is he goin to keep a 3 foot distance frm Ruq..can't he hug her?? seriously I don't want jalal turn into Ramji...it wil reduce his charm as a person..
greeshma014 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: mandyg

i agree! i seriously do not want to see another sad scene of ruqlal i am not used to it and would hate to see my jalal behaving indifferently with her..i cannot take it yaar!


mandy u r making me emotional..I don't want any sad scene b/w RukLal and AkDha..I cried a lot during dat letter which Rukku wrote and their furthur conv. regarding dat..
Edited by greeshma014 - 11 years ago
Muggle_Diaries thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
Hi Mandy,
Just read your post. It is very beautifully written and quite insightful.👏

So agree with your analysis on Ruq.
But, now is the time for her to grow up. I just want Jalal to help her to understand the new dynamics and also help her to become the person she can be. This can be her second chance. Till now Jalal has acted very patiently with her. But, unless she realizes that she needs to change, she will not be getting more chances.
But first she needs to come out of MAs influence.

Love
Kshithi


greeshma014 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

sorry...double post..
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: greeshma014


me too...why his expression changed when she hugged him?? don't knw why I remembered dat scene wher jalal felt disguested by Benazir 's touch..I knw dis scene was not like dat..but phir bhi...some people r happy becoz he hated Rukku's touch, becoz nw he is in love with jo, and he doesn't like any other woman's physical proximity..I don't knw it's like dat way or not...if so I hate dat fact..After his love confession to jo, is he goin to keep a 3 foot distance frm Ruq..can't he hug her?? seriously I don't want jalal turn into Ramji...it wil reduce his charm as a person..



i would hate to see that! i want him to be fair..now that will reduce his respect in my eyes!
ghalibmirza thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: kmmdesai

Hi Mandy,

Just read your post. It is very beautifully written and quite insightful.👏

So agree with your analysis on Ruq.
But, now is the time for her to grow up. I just want Jalal to help her to understand the new dynamics and also help her to become the person she can be. This can be her second chance. Till now Jalal has acted very patiently with her. But, unless she realizes that she needs to change, she will not be getting more chances.
But first she needs to come out of MAs influence.

Love
Kshithi




thanks dear😊..coming from u i will take it as a compliment since you yourself write so beautifully! till now i did not feel the need to support ruq or her behavior but after watching friday's episode i did not like his reaction when she wanted to spend some time with him..! i agree that only jalal can help her out of all this if he really cares for her..and i also hope that the cvz do not make her a vamp..the real ruq might not have been that bad..after all she was akbar's first wife, she does deserve that care and love from akbar be it as a friend or first wife!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".