Jodha Akbar 55: In the vale of tears - Page 5

No, Ila, this is a capital crime, and not at all like the one in the film, which was merely a case of suspected indiscreet behaviour.

Do also see my posts above about this, and also about I feel that it cannot be Hamida Banu; this is far too difficult a task for her.

As for Mahaam Anga, she has by now hardly used any of her 9 lives!

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: ila_tanwar

My dear shayamla Aunty

iagree with your point of view... i think by the scenario what has shown i think jodha has to be sent back to amer for the crime that she hasnt done and may be jalal's mother prrove that jodha is innocent and jalal will go to manofying and bring the amer's shezaadi back as like the movie jodha akbar... bcoz in movie also begam hamida bano has told the truth about the mahaam anga... and the downfall of her begins but as the story proceeds it might not possible bcoz his son has to die first according to the fact...

as your verdict on mansingh he is really having a great potential his thinking is just awsome when adham insulted them his father is going to lose his temper he signal him to pacify and when the time came he nailed it... and i was awstruck to that this what has to be done... as per the saying samay aane par hi kuch krna chaahiye..

looking forward to upcoming epis how they goanna proove jodha innocent and the question still remain wiil begum ruqaiya consider her innocent after jodha comes clean hand

Dear Shyamala (Vanilla-e-mint)

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Yes, Suvi dear, your comment about Mahaam and Jalal is spot on, and I am again glad that the nuanced performances by Rajat and Ashwini are being appreciated. One should not confuse the character and the acting, and you never do that..

Thanks you aunty...

As for Sharifuddin, I do not see how he could have done it; do see both my responses to Mansi above. Plus, he simply does not have the kind of brilliant, devious mind this sort of plot needs.

@bold- that's correct...he is not at all a bright chap...

Jodha's problems are manifold...I don't see maham's ill intention getting exposed so soon...it's an uphill task for jodha...Jodha, is not a typical heroine with super power (thus, more relatable)..most of the times she has talked herself out of sticky situations...by basic logic and reasoning...But, it's different this time...she will require solid proof to back her claims...as of now all evidence are against her...

Thank you aunty for your lovely post as it really helps to clear many doubts and also for highlighting the most vital point that puts jalal aka Rajat's superb acting skill in high.. He was very convincing as a distraught father,no doubt, Maham anga's empathy was also bit to bit convincing.. Ruqaiyaa's happiness while jalal was tending her was also genuinly of an upcoming motherhood..And also her grief after losing her baby was genuine, for the first time she behaved like a true mother and not like a power hungry selfish woman..
your comparison between jalal 1 and jalal 2 is very intense and I agree with every point of it..

As for why hamida bano did not come to pacify jalal,well aunty though ruqaiyaa screamed but I think none heared it, It might be hosiyaar who informed only jalal and maham anga and maham anga summoned the khwaja sera ,otherwise Jodha at least would have come to see what happened,and the news did not reach to everyone till then..

Now lets see who is the culprit and if mansingh this time be the savior of jodha,then how he performs his task..

Thank you so much, my dear Ela, and you have hit on the exact point as to why it cannot be Sharifuddin, he does not have the kind of subtle, brilliant, devious mind needed here.

As for Ruqaiya, we need to have something on which we differ, don't we, whether it is Jalandhar or someone else?😉 And my comment on Ruqaiya was only for the day in question. I think she really believes, after being briefed by the eavesdropping Hoshiyaar, that Jodha is guilty.

Shyamala

Originally posted by: elasingh

Fantastic post.

I am dead sure it is Maham's doing...Sharif doesn't have that kind of mind...

I disagree abt Rukaiya...She did look in pain but I think it was more physical and less emotional...

She didn't miss an opportunity to accuse Jodha and get revenge from her even in this state...Her mind even in this moment of great loss is working to derive maximum benefits from this situation...She was very calculating.

Precisely, my dear.

Shyamala

Originally posted by: sun29

haan the film wala track will come later when both of them would have developed stronger feelings for each other...MA will use sujamal to create MU since jalal has never met him or knows about him ...

Oh Lord, you wretched, mischievous, fey creature,

Do you have to show up my flat-footed, prosaic, non-poetic nature like this? Get thee behind me, masala girl!

Shyamala

Originally posted by: Moontide

Dear Shyamala (Vanilla-e-mint)

Grasping this opportunity,

To express my heartfelt to thee,

By turning the humble tides of mine

To stone, thou hast made me shine

With pride too real and a tsunami swell,

She mentioneth me, in her Magic spell!

Arak-stoned yet beaming with glee

Forever a Moonstone, just for thee 😳

Another thing which I didn't like abt episode is Jalal's closeness with Ruku...I gives me an uneasy feeling...His show of concern and happiness for being father of Rukaiya's child...I know I should be logical and all that but I can't...

Thank you so much, Mythili. Yes, Rajat was superb.

I myself am waiting to see how Jodha is cleared of the charge, and then I am also sure that Mahaam will not be exposed, not for a good while yet.

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: mythili2

Wonderful analysis aunty.. loved reading it..😊

It was really jalal's episode..rajat just out does himself. .he s too good in potraying emotions..

Even I feel its MA's deed.. she s a very sharp woman n very good player too.. bt i dnt kw if she ll b caught so soon..even if she s caught also she ll frame someone else easily..

As you pointed out aunty dnt kw y hameeda s mysteriously absent in the whole scene..

I love ur prediction of maan singh as savior. .I hope they show something like tat..

Bt right nw I cant think hw jodha ll get out of this.. may b hameeda may save her fr nw n jodha ll prove herself innocent later r maan singh ll do tat fr her..

Loved the way u explained jalal1 n jalal 2 actually some part of jalal still doesn't want to believe its jodha who did this bt what can he do if all the evidence s against her..

Thank you so much, Eris, and yes, that is the key question. I am still putting my money on Mansingh; he has the kind of mind needed now.. Let us see,

Shyamala B.Cowsik

Originally posted by: -Eris-

Fantastic post madam :) i dont know why i keep thinking the mystery lies in the spoon with which the kesar was mixed. If that is tested she will get a clean chit . . . There s no way the ark was in the kesar milk it might have been adminstred before /after . . . Am waiting to see the mystery unfold