Is Farah fit to be a judge? - Page 2

i like farah as a judge..shez good n straight forward..

someone said what she knws nothing abt music..well..u think a choreographer doesnt know abt music?? how to dance when u dont know the beats, the sargam? its impossible actually! 😛

Last week after Ishmeet sang Sekar and Visha said that his Sur was out. Farah - with her great music knowledge - says that there was nothing wrong in his siging. Who is better to judge if Sur is gone - Farah or Vishal-Sekar?

Originally posted by: ManaliS

i like farah as a judge..shez good n straight forward..

someone said what she knws nothing abt music..well..u think a choreographer doesnt know abt music?? how to dance when u dont know the beats, the sargam? its impossible actually! 😛

yup...and shes a director as well....she sat with anu malik and VS in the making of the music...im sure she mite have picked up on sumthing....and not just as a director, even as a choreographer...as u said itz impossible not to noe about the beats, the sargam, the feel of teh song while choreographing it...

shes a good judge, very frank and says wat she feels....shes actually become better in this show than she was in ii1 and ii2 lol...there she actually used to comment about the clothes and the closed eyes part....she doesnt comment on that much now, sumtimes here and there saying u are looking nice, but she has started to comment on the song as well...especially the emotion of the song...she noes about the higher and lower notes as well, and she talks about the scale too sumtimes...😆😆 shes improving loll

Originally posted by: ~Indian Doll~

well so wat if shez a good director etc..u can hav all those qualities n stilll be good at judging pplz voice! why cant she hav all the qualities?
i think she iz a good judge, n i actually agree with wat she sayz most of the time, its not important to be a singer to judge one

i agreee.. she dosent have to be a singer to judge one, shes a choreography and a director.. she knows enuff bout singin..
and i think shes a relli good judge.. shes so much like rakhi.. stright up...

She is a good judge on the whole, just that she cud be a lil less biased towards her favorite... Else she is good...

lol. farah aint fit enuff to be a judge. and she sure aint fit enuff otherwise. 😆

Originally posted by: angelsgurl

i agreee.. she dosent have to be a singer to judge one, shes a choreography and a director.. she knows enuff bout singin..
and i think shes a relli good judge.. shes so much like rakhi.. stright up...

arre yaar, whatever happened to getting guni judges like pandit jasraj? or do we just parade out te good pandit when we want to say that he picked debo in some early competition?😉

as for farah being like rakhi, do u mean rakhi sawant? ab usko bhee musical show ka judge banana baki hai?😆

Outrageous??? Are you kidding me...
I thank Farah for standing up for the truth...

Mind games cannot be played by Himani...
I would want Himani to be eliminated.

Originally posted by: chatbuster

as for farah being like rakhi, do u mean rakhi sawant? ab usko bhee musical show ka judge banana baki hai?😆

haha. i wonder...if you think farah is not fit to be a judge, what would happen if rakhi came as a judge?? i think they meant that like rakhi, farah also speaks her mind openly