Is Farah fit to be a judge?

I find some of the comments made by Farah are outrageous.

First, she questions the champs on how can they vote for a particular challenger. The champs have been given the voting rights and I do not think they need to justify. If they play politics, it is their business. It is same as the way the judges gave marks to Prajakta when she could not evensing. Because of their marks Aishwarya got out even after a terrific performance.

This week she kept telling that Himani should not be there among champs. A few weeks back she asked the champs not to vote for Himani because the compettition would lose the last female. In spite of that the champs voted for her.Is it because of this that she is taking it out on Himani?

Himani has been giving terrific performances consistently and she deserves to be among champs.

Rock

I think Farah is a very good judge. I loved the way she exposed Rahul and Debo on their double standard voting, even though she seems to like them. I think the only reason she was angry with Himani was cuz she made the champions look bad and wasted one entry into the champions side. This was unfair to Amey and Toshi who now just have one chance to become a champion.
I think she is very fair and honest. Not scared to tell the truth. 😊

I personally think that Farah is an awesome judge....
She is very straight-forward so due to that she tells all the contestant whatever she feels without any fear..I adore Farah for being frank..😛

but what music background she has ? she is choregrapher and director ,not music rt ? she is a bit rude to himani .everyone shud be encouraged in this compitition ,some times good singers sing bad ,when luck is bad or song selection is not good . himanui is good singer ,same time fara too is good judge .

Originally posted by: docnalini

but what music background she has ? she is choregrapher and director ,not music rt ? she is a bit rude to himani .everyone shud be encouraged in this compitition ,some times good singers sing bad ,when luck is bad or song selection is not good . himanui is good singer ,same time fara too is good judge .

i agree - how can a judge of a music competion EVER say - sur wur gaya bhaad mein???

that statement itself shows whats her take on this show. she goes by her favourites - Vinit and rahul- everyone else gaya bhaad mein

Shes a g00d judge :)
she's frank and not scared to say what she feels.
and as far as her experience in music is concerned i think she does a good job at judging so she must know what she's doing.

She is the worst judge in the history of reality shows?? 😡

naheen yaar, she's not fit to be a judge. otherwise too, seriously needs to hit the gym. total misfit 😛 😆

Originally posted by: docnalini

but what music background she has ? she is choregrapher and director ,not music rt ? she is a bit rude to himani .everyone shud be encouraged in this compitition ,some times good singers sing bad ,when luck is bad or song selection is not good . himanui is good singer ,same time fara too is good judge .

to be a choreographer, you need at least some musical sense. farah is a phenomenal choreographer, so i'm sure she knows a bit about music. but more than that, it's another point of the show: public voting. not every voter has musical experience (as you can see when many times the most deserving are not voted to be the winner), so farah can act just like a common person giving her feedback on the contestants' singing

Farah says what she feels. I feel she is a good judge and love her for her frankness. She makes the show more interesting.