are judges being too harsh on toshi

Page

melonheads

@melonheads

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

just my thoughts. week after week, toshi sings well and sometimes very well. but still the judges keep finding faults and giving him lower marks.

as against this ----------->the champs are being marked very leniently- they go off sur often but still get good marks and reasonable comments.

are the judges being harsh on Toshi?

Quote

Frequent Posters

amitanamika

@amitanamika

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

totaly agree with you ,judges have been too harsh to toshi compare to others. dont know the reason why though?
we dont like any more these judges honestly
😡

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Anisha

@Cuhrazy.Anisha

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

oh well i dunt agree i am a big toshi fan myself but currently he is nt performing d way he can or the way he shud ...judges r just being fair if hes nt good he is nt n if he is thn ders no stopping him ...n if d judges r beinga bit harsh its bcuz they wnat him to sing better...the judges wont gain anything out of it...they r just doing their job n they know all abt it better than us

ders no reason to hate the judges just bcoz ur fav contestant is nt performing good enough!!!

Quote

361344

Suspended

Posted: 17 years ago

yaa iam with u they are too harsh to Toshi and they always criticism Toshi 😕

Quote

Aysha

@-Aysha-

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 17 years ago

i agree they are being too harsh to toshi, he sings better than some of the other contestants and still gets marked low.

Quote

msti

@msti

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

I seriously dont think they are being too harsh on Toshi.
I actually appreciate the faults they are finding in him, as should he, too. He needs to know the things he's not doing well in, specially the kind of dip in form he's got right now.
Plus, giving him 9, 9, 10 or 9, 9, 9, is not harsh, y'know :)

Quote

Atlee

@Atlee99

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

I dont agree...if u think judges r being harsh to Toshi.
Judges have been even more harsh with Harshit in 2 episodes, one being in the comedy but he had taken the critisism very positively and came back with a bang of 30s. Toshi is not able to do that ....Judges werent very nice to Amey on his first episode and either to Rahul after his first performance but they have all taken it as a challenge and worked on the problems...I think becos u r a Toshi fan u r being biased to him
PS I am not a diehard fan of anyone and my views r restricted to their performances in JJWS only

Quote

srk_kadz

@srk_kadz

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

his voice sounds very tired and strained... and I wonder wat the reason is... probably he is putting too much strain to his voice...

Quote

Sana

@fudge_brownie0

Navigator

Posted: 17 years ago

OMG! THANK YOU FOR POSTIG THIS TOPIC!!!! I was just about to. I TOTALLY agreee. Judges are REALLY unfair with him. God, i could go on about this...but im gonna boil up. So i wont!